8 ms·
There is also another issue why Apple is restricting "part harvesting": theft. iCloud locks or Samsung's KNOX lock entered the field because the manufacturers w
by mschuster91 3y ago
There is also another issue why Apple is restricting "part harvesting": theft. iCloud locks or Samsung's KNOX lock entered the field because the manufacturers were pretty pissed that customers using their devices in public became a target for "enterprising" robbers who'd factory-wipe the devices and flip them to a pawn shop or second-hand store in a matter of half an hour. When people are afraid to use your products because it paints a phone-sized target on them, they won't buy your product.
That cut down on a lot of the robbery bullshit, but then criminals simply found new buyer classes - they'd simply part stolen devices out and resell everything but the iCloud/Knox/whatever locked mainboard. Displays, cameras, speakers, batteries, flex cables, cases, everything.
So now, at least Apple is tagging the most "valuable" parts in new phones, simply to make stealing them unattractive for thieves, which frankly sucks but is necessary because it's a public safety issue.
(If anyone at Apple is reading this: ffs, allow the legitimate owner of a device to "unpair" all components in their phone in iCloud so that legitimate second-hand shops can strip a broken device at least for its parts)
- tantalor 3y agoSpeculation. If that were true, Apple would only require the replacement part to be verified, but they also require the device receiving the part to be verified. That's the "pair" in "pairing".
- Kirby64 3y agoNot speculation at all. I can tell you for certain this is what they're trying to combat. The "require the device receiving the part to be verified" is just a consequence of how it's currently implemented. There are ways to implement this without the need to do per-device pairing, but doing so in a secure way is quite difficult. I suspect they'll eventually remove the requirement to pair devices using system configurator, if only because this removes the need to have chat assistance with pairing. That's costing them money to have a call center, and they want to avoid it I suspect.
- drtz 3y ago> I can tell you for certain this is what they're trying to combat. > There are ways to implement this without the need to do per-device pairing, but doing so in a secure way is quite difficult. Is this based on first-hand knowledge? I'm skeptical on both fronts because I neither see any evidence this is what's being combatted, nor do I see the technical difficulty of being able to self-authorize your phone's parts to be used in repairs. Sure it takes some engineering effort to get there, but I wouldn't expect it to be particularly challenging from a technical point of view. The phone is already linked to a user account, and the phone's parts are apparently already linked to the phone that's currently using them.
- Kirby64 3y agoSo, the technical challenge is related to managing the following things (all simultaneously): * Apple wants to make sure components in an authentic phone are not capable of being stolen and resold (this is a problem today, even with the pairing, although it is less valuable due to pairing) * Apple wants to make sure that if you change components, that the replacement component is authentic * Apple wants to make sure that if you change components, that the replacement component is not stolen I can't comment on specific implementations, but allowing users to just re-pair devices in the current state would not allow the above 3 goals to be met. By restricting who has access to the pairing tools, they can achieve those 3 with the downside being obviously it leads to a crappy user experience for repair.
- Dylan16807 3y agoIf you send a permanent unlock code for parts being re-used in a repair, then that fully accomplishes 2 and 3 and almost entirely accomplishes 1. With no need to know anything about the host device. And brand new parts could lock themselves to the first device they're put into. It wouldn't be ideal for repair but it would be much better.
- Kirby64 3y agoMy point is that Apple currently does not appear to have tight control over the serial numbering or whatever on the external components (display, etc) in a truly secure way. If you let anyone re-pair devices, then that opens the floodgates to 3rd party vendors being able to make devices that appear as 'authentic' components, which does not accomplish #2. As it stands today, you can already use any random components, you'll just get a pop-up telling you it can't be authenticated.
- eddythompson80 3y agoThis was an interesting listen on the iPhone theft industry https://youtu.be/3Ws3YptLmLQ?si=KuVt1DBvxiBXa3Vl https://youtu.be/3Ws3YptLmLQ?si=KuVt1DBvxiBXa3Vl
- toxik 3y agoWhile anti-consumerist practices such as this authentication mechanism sometimes accidentally protect the consumer, it is not the reason why companies do it. If it were, they would also allow you to say “yes this replacement is desired.” Similarly, if it was about security and preventing backdoored parts, they could allow you to authorize the replacement. But no, it is of course about money grabbing, and then the consumer is the opponent.
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoYes. I could see a better system being made. Perhaps alerting you that the screen was marked as stolen and refusing to have it operate. Hell, for screens in particular you could display a “please return to <original owner>” message and nothing else.
- circuit10 3y agoI think this is being downvoted as it initially reads as a snarky way to say "the way it works now is fine", but reading closer I think they are saying it should only happen when the screen is marked as stolen which seems reasonable
- Brian_K_White 3y agoThis. The proof is in the actions. No need to try to defend them based on unsupportable benefit of the doubt possibilities. If their motivations were actually for the users benefit, then the user would have these options and be benefitting.
- misnome 3y ago> If it were, they would also allow you to say “yes this replacement is desired.” How does that not completely bypass any of the reasons for wanting to do this? And it is “anti-consumerist” to make my property a less desirable target for theft?
- picture 3y ago> How does that not completely bypass any of the reasons for wanting to do this? Do it from your iCloud account. Presumably thieves will not hold you at gun point to log in to iCloud and allow pairing of your phone's components to a ready recipient iPhone
- amartya916 3y agoI would be surprised if Apple does what you suggested, but I do think it's an excellent suggestion, thank you. It just won't be a priority unless some sort of legislation forces their hand.
- jchw 3y agoI do not accept this as a reasonable answer. I've lived in not even very good areas, with very lax physical security (often not locking my car) and have never had this issue, ever. Nobody has ever stolen my phone. Not in downtown Detroit, not in not-downtown-Detroit, not in SF, not in Chicago. If crime really is this bad, it's not an Apple or Samsung problem. It's a societal problem that extremely badly needs to be addressed seriously and not just worked around with convenient anti-consumer garbage. Sell me the phone that can be stolen please.
- vineyardmike 3y ago“No one has stolen my phone so I don’t believe that actions to stop phone theft is necessary” I’ve heard plenty of stories of people getting their phones stolen in public. Especially when I was in school, we’d hear of plots like kids coming up to students and asking to call their parents because they’re scared and alone only to run over to a car waiting around the corner and drive away. You can argue it’s unnecessary, but it certainly chilled the market for stolen phones. They’re pretty obvious targets and they’re very personal. Not worrying about it as much is a big win, but some people have other priorities and that’s ok too.
- MenhirMike 3y agoI have never been murdered, and none of my friends have been either, so I don't believe that actions to stop murder are necessary. (We _do_ need laws to allow customers that can prove their purchase to unlock their parts though.)
- ArtemZ 3y agoLet's lock you up in your house, it will ensure that you are safe
- Spivak 3y agoThat's not what this is and you know it. The equivalent would imagining a fictional world where we could say just raise the dead or Borderland's style instantly print you a new body at the phone-booth down the street. In that world there's no point to murdering you, they get no benefit it's only an inconvenience to the person being murdered. In that world you need very little actual protection against murder because there's no incentive to do it. That's the current state of iPhones, you don't need to lock them up, use those chest pickpocket proof bags, or strap them to your wrist because no one wants to steal them.
- awesomeMilou 3y agoThe rationale of putting engineering time into developing sophisticated anti-repair schemes instead of selling spare parts directly under some threat of a part black market is completely bonkers to me. Sorry, I'm not buying it, this is Apple protecting their exclusive repair turf and nothing else.
- junofan 3y agoThe execs are actually focused on a giant, sophisticated fraud ring in China doing several bn $. The repairs lose money.
- TheKarateKid 3y agoInteresting. Where can I read more about this?
- notanormalnerd 3y agoI don't know why iFixit doesn't even touch on that point. I live in Barcelona and phones are being pickpocketed every day here. Not being able to wipe or unlock or else is a mayor deterrent for the pickpockets, because noone will take the phone off of them, so it's not worth it. Phones are still being stolen but imagine if they could sell to a global market of repair shops. You couldn't go to any tourist location without having your phone stolen if it wasn't bolted to your person. I get the iFixit point as well but if I have a 1500€ phone, I don't want to think about it being stolen, when I am on vacation, because someone needs some parts (oh the human trafficing/organ harvesting similarity...) Apple should offer a better repair program and offer the ability to "unlock and relock" it in a apple store with proper proof of ownership. Or anything else in that direction.
- flanked-evergl 3y ago> I get the iFixit point as well but if I have a 1500€ phone, I don't want to think about it being stolen, when I am on vacation, because someone needs some parts (oh the human trafficing/organ harvesting similarity...) Do you think thieves are that descending? I know someone whos iPhone 14 was stolen in London. If this helped protect against theft, then why did they steal the phone anyway?
- zaroth 3y agoOf course thieves are discerning. They are running a profitable criminal enterprise. They are in it for big money and are extremely sophisticated and not going to risk stealing worthless junk. An example of one theft is not evidence that the policy doesn’t reduce theft, or that the purpose of the policy isn’t to reduce theft.
- flanked-evergl 3y ago> Of course thieves are discerning. They are running a profitable criminal enterprise. I can promise you the person who stole this iPhone doesn't run a profitable criminal enterprise. But I am also not disputing that someone along the theft value chain, someone will likely be discerning. However, your claim seems to conflate a criminal enterprise and the theft value chain with an individual thief. Also, I find the notion that it is very risky to steal something in London hard to believe, but if you have some data to back that up I would be happy to change my mind.
- Macha 3y agoI have to think that if replacement parts were more widely available, it would reduce the market for parted out stolen phones.
- dmitrygr 3y agoCar parts are available. Cars still get jacked and chopped up.
- hedora 3y agoIt seems pretty easy to implement the "unpair" functionality you ask for. If "Find My iPhone" (the anti-theft subsystem) is disabled, then the serial numbers for all the parts could be sent to an Apple database, and/or the components could have a "ready to be re-used" bit set that caused them to factory reset themselves if the phone they're plugged into changes (so any state on the re-used thing wouldn't somehow leak into the other phone). I'm not sure how to define "phone they're plugged into" though. Whatever board has the NAND + security coprocessor on it, maybe?
- mrweasel 3y agoThat does sound like a pretty good solution, if it can be done for a broken phone. The major issue I see is that refurbish companies are already complaining about "bricked" MacBooks, because nobody actually cared enough to ensure that those laptops where reset before being sold. I don't see the same industry being capable of guiding users through resetting permissions for spare parts. A better solutions is to take the direction FairPhone has chosen and make the things that break user-serviceable and offer the parts for sale on Apples own website. If the issue is that phones are being stolen and sold for parts, just flood the market with cheap parts. The new iPhones are absolutely massive, so I'm not buying that you can't make them a bit thicker and allow a user to take them apart. How many people use their phone without a cover anyway? If Apple is serious about being more environmentally friendly, then make a user serviceable phone. Not replacing your phone because fixing it is either impossible or impossibly expensive is going to have a much bigger impact than buying carbon credits for people who charge their watch. My best guess is that Apple is so obsessed with just-in-time production and so hostile to the idea of stocking parts, that they can even see the potential benefits.
- hedora 3y agoAccording to iFixit, they've solved the "this is physically hard to repair" problem. Also, Apple aggressively recycles components, and is making bold claims about carbon neutrality of manufacturing this release cycle. On top of that, the cost of repairs is dramatically lower for the new models (again, according to the iFixit article). So, I think those issues are mostly fixed, or at least best-in-class. The problem of "I bought your laptop, but you didn't disable anti-theft" is questionable. Here's how to sell a macbook so that it can be used by the purchaser and so that your data is wiped: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212749 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212749 It takes 4 clicks (and probably a password entry), and it's easy for the purchaser to confirm it was done before forking over cash (assuming they turn on the machine to confirm it can POST). If the seller forgets to do this, they can initiate the wipe + unlock remotely via iCloud. Apple parts are pretty cheap already, so that's not the issue either. As far as I can tell, all the complaints boil down to people wanting to fix phones without Apple's authorization. Its a valid complaint, but it only really impacts independent repair shops at this point. I'd also like to see better support for third-party replacement parts (like with PC's), but I don't think there is any realistic market demand for that, and it is not what people are asking for.
- Eduard 3y ago> When people are afraid to use your products because it paints a phone-sized target on them, they won't buy your product. "iPhone's have become too mainstream to steal, I rather get a crappy phone nobody wants“ – nobody said.
- ejstronge 3y ago> (If anyone at Apple is reading this: ffs, allow the legitimate owner of a device to "unpair" all components in their phone in iCloud so that legitimate second-hand shops can strip a broken device at least for its parts) I was robbed at gunpoint (but not in a 'problematic' part of town) and the thief outlined all the steps he needed me to take to remove my phone from Find My and from iCloud. I think a lot of these mitigation measures could make sense but there's no perfect solution.
- shortcake27 3y agoI’m sorry that happened to you. IMHO this is a huge problem. A thief just wants to steal your phone. To ensure the value of the device, it’s now common to force you to provide your passcode. This gives access to all your data, can be used to reset your Apple ID password, lock you out of your account, and erase and lock all your other devices. This problem never existed before, and it’s significantly worse! Like, way way way worse. It’s so bad I wonder if I should really be signed into my Apple ID on my phone at all. Because I don’t give the slightest care of someone stealing my phone. But I do care if they have access to all my data, erase and lock me out of all my other devices. I really care about that. And this problem only exists because Apple locks down the device and all parts.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoIt sounds like the solution for your problem is not to use an Apple phone. Use an Android rom that gives you significantly more power and granularity.
- TheHappyOddish 3y agoI'm unsure how your device being Android means you won't hand over the keys when prompted at gunpoint. Can you explain your line of thought?
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoIt's much easier on Android to setup all kinds of alternatives. You could setup a 'dummy' key that if entered would alert the police, for example. Failing that, you can setup different keys for different services with different levels of access, as well as have third party equivalents to 'Find my iPhone'. Not being in the walled garden provides a lot of freedom and flexibility to setup contingencies.
- gchamonlive 3y agoYou can try to push that as a marketing strategy, but I would say the share of the market that looks for smartphones specifically because they are less of a target for theft is minuscule, the reason being because nobody shop for phones thinking about getting robbed. They shop mainly guided by ecosystem (android Vs ios) brand perception (how good their aftersales support is), budget and cost-effectiveness. In this sense, device lockdown is clearly a anti-consumer practice, not pro-consumer.
- spinningarrow 3y ago> nobody shop for phones thinking about getting robbed I don’t know the safety situation of where you live but I literally had this conversation with friends two weeks ago where we loved the idea that the iPhone is a better purchase because it’s less prone to theft (because of the reasons GP mentioned).
- gchamonlive 3y agoEnough for non-anecdotal people to shift their entire ecosystem to a diffent brand? People in general won't just switch from Android to iPhone because "filthy criminals are after my brand new phone for parts". If apple wasn't going to lock their parts and Samsung would, people would still keep buying iPhones.
- layer8 3y agoIf iPhones didn’t have that protection, but Android phones did, would you and your friends switch to Android and love the idea that Android phones are the better purchase?
- Pet_Ant 3y agoYou can do a search and you'll find many articles and comments about how back in the day people were warned not to wear the white iPod ear buds as not to be a target for thefts. > West Midlands police have issued a stark warning to iPod users: ditch the white headphones or pay the price. https://www.theregister.com/2004/03/30/ipod_this_seasons_musthave/ https://www.theregister.com/2004/03/30/ipod_this_seasons_mus... Apple could be very well front-running this and trying to prevent it before it becomes a problem. This is clearly a possibility.
- MostlyStable 3y agoWhat is the relative rates of occurrence of phone theft vs. phones breaking in a way that requires repair? I'm going to go out on a limb and say that far far far more people have a phone that needs to be repaired than have a phone that gets stolen. So making repair worse to make theft "better" seems like a bad tradeoff to me. And that's even presuming that this stated goal actually works. I would expect that a very non-trivial amount of phone theft happens without knowing the model. Assuming that's the case, having 1 manufacturer make selling parts non-viable doesn't really help that much. So A) even if it was 100% effective that seems like a bad tradeoff to me and B) I'm skeptical of how much difference this actually makes in theft rates. I know that I personally, if choosing between a phone that I knew for a fact would 100% never be stolen, but also couldn't be repaired, vs. a phone that could easily be repaired but was subject to theft, I would choose the repairable phone every time. It's an anecdote, but I've never had a phone stolen and literally every single phone I've ever had has needed repair at one point or another.
- weaksauce 3y ago> What is the relative rates of occurrence of phone theft vs. phones breaking in a way that requires repair? i would think having a permanently useless phone would stop the first rate from ever increasing much. you are walking around with a grand in your pocket everywhere you go so to lower the risk of violent robbery is good.
- hbn 3y ago> I'm going to go out on a limb and say that far far far more people have a phone that needs to be repaired than have a phone that gets stolen. Perhaps because it's known to many thieves that iPhones are a useless thing to steal due to Apple's tight account-tied software locks?
- MostlyStable 3y agoGo back five years and I'd guess this is still true. I do not think Apple's policy has changed this.
- 3y ago
- pierat 3y agoHow much were you paid to shill Apple for this top post? If this were a real issue, then I as the device owner should be able to toggle this on and off as needed. But that hits deeper, since this is a device that's being sold as "purchase" when I don't have real control - Apple does. At best, this is a rental being mis-advertised as a purchase.
- jameshart 3y agoJust put a big sticker on the back of your phone case that says ‘no parts left in phone overnight’
- mschuster91 3y ago> How much were you paid to shill Apple for this top post? Unfortunately, I don't get paid by anyone except my employer lol. 16k HN and 160k Reddit karma points in about a decade isn't exactly influencer-worthy. > If this were a real issue, then I as the device owner should be able to toggle this on and off as needed. Phone theft is a real issue, even in places not suffering from open street markets with people fencing stolen shit, like London [1]. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-65105199 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-65105199
- Kirby64 3y agoThe problem, as I see it, with having a method to 'pair' and 'unpair' components right now... is that I don't think Apple is really doing anything too special to 'pair' devices. My guess is they're just using a serial number of the device (display, camera, whatever) and making sure that serial matches the what is programmed into the mainboard. If you allow any random person to change the paired serial number for say, the display, then you no longer have any guarantee that the new display is actually an authentic device. Maybe someone aftermarket makes a bunch of devices with 0xDEADBEEF as the serial number so you just always pair that. If Apple knows that serial number 0x12345678 was sold to you, and that it is the component you want to install, then they have a guarantee that this part is authentic and should work properly. So, Apple needs a way for you to pair a serial number, but also that the serial number you're pairing is authentic. I'm not sure they have the second piece today.
- accrual 3y agoPhone theft is also a big deal at music festivals. Last year an entire backpack full of phones was recovered. People who lose them either never hear from them again, or see them in Find My as a brief blip somewhere hundreds or thousands of miles away. Sometimes they're shucked on site and all you find is your empty phone case on the ground. It's already awful to lose your phone, but even more so when you're at a multi-day event you paid hundreds to attend. https://www.wftv.com/news/local/lost-your-cell-edc-backpack-full-stolen-phones-recovered-orlando-police-say/7LSY73T5JBFO5KPIHWHEZ3K32Q/ https://www.wftv.com/news/local/lost-your-cell-edc-backpack-...
- crazygringo 3y ago> (If anyone at Apple is reading this: ffs, allow the legitimate owner of a device to "unpair" all components in their phone in iCloud so that legitimate second-hand shops can strip a broken device at least for its parts) If you've lived in certain places, you'd know this isn't a solution at all. Thieves will start holding people at gunpoint forcing you to unpair it all while they wait.
- mmastrac 3y agoAre thieves currently forcing people at gunpoint to iCloud-unpair/unlock their devices right now?
- crazygringo 3y agoOh absolutely. Happened to a friend of mine, and there's another commenter here who had it happen to them. Crime is real. Obviously its frequency is going to depend on where you live/travel.
- circuit10 3y agoSo if they can already do that, they'll just sell the whole unlocked phone and not worry about parts? Unless it's broken to the point of being unsellable, I guess
- crazygringo 3y agoThat's a good point. You're right -- since you can already force someone to unpair, being able to unlock the individual parts isn't going to make a difference. Thanks.
- r0m4n0 3y agoWell I think you hit the nail on the head. They aren’t working on the most important aspect of the puzzle (your last point), not because they aren’t reading HN comments, but because that would have a very negative effect on their bottom line.
- brundolf 3y agoWhat if they locked the parts individually, but not until an iCloud lock happened?
- exabrial 3y agoI'm sorry, but I think this is Bullshit. Litreally _exactly_ how many people were robbed and please point us to a source?
- mschuster91 3y agoIn 2022, there was a phone theft every six minutes in London [1], for example. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-65105199 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-65105199
- cameldrv 3y agoThey can already "unpair" the phone by removing it from iCloud, as you say. The phone could simply check whether the serial number on a part is already associated with an iCloud registered device and if not, allow it to pair. Fairly obviously, they don't do this because it would reduce the demand for their parts, which is a multibillion dollar business.
- mvdtnz 3y agoDoesn't this "logic" apply to literally every product ever? That's not a world I want to live in.
- apexalpha 3y ago>That cut down on a lot of the robbery bullshit, but then criminals simply found new buyer classes - they'd simply part stolen devices out and resell everything but the iCloud/Knox/whatever locked mainboard. Displays, cameras, speakers, batteries, flex cables, cases, everything. This would be way less valueble to do if the companies just sold the parts are reasonable prices. The extreme ways fixers have to go to to source parts for legitimate repairs concerns is insane. The entire reason there even is a whole ecosystem of people picking apart phones in Shenzen is because it's so darn difficult to source it any other way!
- fortran77 3y agoI agree, and I think there's a compromise. Allow the pairing of harvested parts, but also allow users to report their unit as "stolen" so the parts can't be paired. However, this is probably fraught with problems that Apple doesn't want to deal with. Users will want to know if someone tried to pair their parts and they'll be hit with a large number of subpoenas daily from people who want to know which repair shops had their stolen phones.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tzs 3y ago> iCloud locks or Samsung's KNOX lock entered the field because the manufacturers were pretty pissed that customers using their devices in public became a target for "enterprising" robbers who'd factory-wipe the devices and flip them to a pawn shop or second-hand store in a matter of half an hour. It wasn't just the manufacturers who were pretty pissed at that. Minnesota passed a law requiring smartphones to have a kill switch that would allow the owner to remotely render the phone inoperable [1]. Then California did, with the California law also making kill switch support be turned on by default. Those laws have been in effect since mid 2015 and were quickly followed by a huge drop in smartphone thefts. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smartphone_kill_switch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smartphone_kill_switch
- Kretinsky 3y agoWhat is the resell value of the parts for a whole phone? It can't be more than 1/10th, even less when factoring the time spent dismounting the phone. Another solution would be to have a database of parts, and a repair using a stolen part wouldn't work.
- gandalfian 3y agoOr they could just sell official replacement screens for $50. The price of an entire budget smartphone. Thefts of iPhones would plummet. The phones would be worth more to consumers. A small drop in sales perhaps due to more repairs.
- callalex 3y agoCan you link me to any public communication from Apple making this claim?
- raxxorraxor 3y ago> it's a public safety issue. Absolutely not. The cases for repairs vastly outnumber the cases for theft to a degree it isn't comparable in the slightest. This should be the basis for any honest discussion. Not putting that in perspective cannot lead to sensible considerations.
- justinclift 3y agoIf Apple has a record of the individual serial numbers on parts contained in each phone, that seems like a wonderful way of backtracking stolen phone parts to the thieves. "Oh you're trying to replace your phone screen with one from a stolen item. Please provide your contact details so we can pass that on to the police." Doesn't seem like a bad idea at all. ;)
- stjohnswarts 3y agoIt's really stupid. How many people get their devices not stolen vs stolen. I would bet 99% is conservative? sounds like an excuse to just make it harder to repair and make the product useless much earlier.
- JohnFen 3y agoEven if that's their motivation, doing that is still a terrible practice at least in the way they're doing it. It's certainly one of the big reasons why I won't buy these devices.