6 ms·
MGM losing up to $8.4M a day due to cyberattack, analyist says
- anonymousiam 3y agoI never like it when writers use the word "lose" to describe money not earned. Yeah, MGM is not earning as much as it could because of this attack. They are under pressure to settle with the attackers. Articles like this can increase that pressure. I'm glad that they aren't settling, and I'm certain that they will survive this attack.
- slashdev 3y agoMoney not earned is equivalent to money lost in this case. It will affect their quarterly results the same way.
- NegativeK 3y agoThere's an implied "losing $X [in comparison to expected revenue]" every time they say it. It's a reasonable perspective from accounting and, in my mind, a reasonable shorthand. For a more literal version of losing, people would be saying misplacing or stealing.
- SeanAnderson 3y agoHuh? Google says MGM Resorts opex for 2022 11.6B or 31M/day, net income 1.4B or 3.8M/day. It doesn't seem unreasonable to say they are, in fact, losing 8.4M/day to opex.
- kube-system 3y agoIt's a loss of income. This is a common use of the word.
- bqmjjx0kac 3y agoWell, it's a loss of projected income, which in many ways is not real.
- CamelCaseName 3y agoIt's not even that, it's revenue. > MGM Resorts International could be losing between $4.2 million and $8.4 million in daily revenue
- kube-system 3y agoRevenue is a measure of income. Unless speaking about specific types of revenue or specific types of income, they are synonymous.
- hollerith 3y agoAccounts don't think revenue and income are synomymous: income is revenue minus expenses. Now if you were to say that profit and income are synonymous, that I might be okay with.
- kube-system 3y agoRevenue minus expenses is "net income". "income" is ambiguous.
- hollerith 3y agoOK. I believe it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kube-system 3y agoIt is just plain normal language to refer to a loss as a comparison against a current trajectory or current state. It is reasonable to assume that the reader/listener knows that the future cannot be predicted exactly, because this is generally true. This is why it isn't said explicitly. It would be silly to correct someone who said "I just accepted a $120,000/yr job" with "you don't really know for sure, you could get fired or die". The colloquial presumption is that the rate of future income cited is dependent on a steady trajectory without confounding variables.
- libraryatnight 3y agoThere's lots of instances where I'd agree, but this one seems like a tried and true business with years of revenue to gauge how much they are in fact "losing" on average. I also wonder how much pressure it puts on MGM - who are no doubt very much aware of the loss (every major outage I've been on eventually comes down to how much did this cost us - whether it's money, customer attrition, customer trust etc) vs how much pressure it puts on executives following along to maybe pay attention to their IT and security teams. Pipe dream.
- paulddraper 3y ago> I never like it when writers use the word "lose" to describe money not earned. What the difference between not earning $8M and earning $8M and losing it? Bank account looks pretty similar.
- SoftTalker 3y agoIf your salary was cut 20% next year, would you think you were not losing money because you had not yet earned it?
- JetSpiegel 3y agoI have a contract that requires my employer to pay up. Not the same think as avoiding shopping somewhere.
- RandallBrown 3y agoYou're getting a lot of comments to the contrary, but I agree with you. There is a difference between losing money (like someone is actually stealing the money) and not getting money you were hoping/expecting to get. In this context it can even be a little bit confusing since there are criminals involved that could actually be stealing money. Language has lots of ambiguities and despite this being a common way of describing this situation, I don't like it. Some people don't like the word "moist" either and that's just fine. It's an opinion.
- rahimnathwani 3y agoIf your employer gives you 2 weeks notice of employment termination, did you lose your job? After all, it only applies to future payroll periods.
- eddieroger 3y agoYes you lost your job, and will not receive money in the future. Money from a job is in exchange for services rendered to company. It's reasonable to say you can't lose something you haven't yet received, but it is also normal to say they're losing money given they had an incredibly high likelihood of actually receiving it.
- PopAlongKid 3y agoThe revenue may be going down, but that doesn't mean they have to operate at a loss (they could always cut their variable expenses to match the cut in revenue). It would be more accurate, but not as click-baity, to describe it as "MGM getting up to $8.4M less revenue a day". A slightly more misleading use of "losing money" is for example when movie or music companies claim they are "losing" billions of dollars to piracy, when there is no reason to believe that every pirated copy would instead be purchased at full price, if only piracy were eliminated.
- jiofj 3y agoImagine being one of the guys in charge of cybersecurity of MGM. I would dig a hole and hide.
- ComputerGuru 3y agoI think those heads are on the chopping block no matter which hole they’re hiding in.
- NegativeK 3y agoI'd say that responsible organizations know that a hack is inevitable and you evaluate based on the response, but I've heard from people who've worked at MGM in the past that the place is disgustingly cutthroat.
- Sytten 3y agoBold of you to assume there was one (before the incident) /s
- graton 3y agoOr they have been telling management for years that security needs to be improved and more spending is needed to do that but management declined to provide funding.
- Freedom2 3y agoIt's still on the onus of the employee to properly state their viewpoint and deliver a proper business document, outlining the risks and benefits. Too many times I've seen security been increased and upgraded, at the cost of the entire business shutting down, or even worse, layoffs.
- jszymborski 3y agoThe cybersecurity team will probably take the fall for it, but if I had to take a guess, their budget was probably no where near where it should be for a team that is responsible for protecting $8.4M of revenue a day.
- zephyrus76 3y agoThis really feels like 1650's nautical piracy. Someone outside the reach of the law of the targeted country's merchants, making tons of money by theft and ransom. And like the pirates of old, often supported by the host nation so long as their attacks disrupt the activities of rivals nations' merchants.
- willis936 3y agoMerchants provide a value to society and pirates harm that. The thieves are providing a value to society in this case by damaging casinos, which provide no value to society and only harm citizens.
- kube-system 3y agoCasinos provide leisure and entertainment. If what you're actually trying to say is that they are overall a net harm, then I'd point out that imperial mercantilism was also quite harmful to many people. At least MGM hasn't overthrown any countries.
- mrguyorama 3y agoIn exactly the same way a heroin dealer provides leisure and entertainment. Selling access to an inherently addictive substance should not be a for profit endeavor. The incentives are inherently biased towards harming people for profit.
- kube-system 3y agoYou say this as if "addictive" and "harmful" are boolean concepts. These concepts have a wide spectrum in reality. People die every day from addictions to all kinds of socially acceptable products and services, whether it be the dopamine rush from an unhealthy or dangerous activity, a buzz from their favorite beverage, or the sugar rush from an unhealthy snack.
- 3y ago
- irtefa 3y agoI'm curious if MGM fully understood their cyber risks. Many companies underestimate threats until something like this happens. After seeing MGM, if other hotels beef up security too (very likely), will overall costs for consumers go up?
- xfitm3 3y agoSecurity is a SG&A line item, I am sure they are far more fixated on physical security due to their business vertical and had a gap. There will be many cyber companies chomping at the bit to get a piece of the inevitable (I made this number up) 100m MGM will spend on Cybersecurity over the next 5 years. They won't make the same mistake twice and will build a comprehensive cybersecurity program, and it will succeed. Up until someone questions this cost and they forgot what they are paying for because everything was so smooth and repeat the cycle. The objective of security is risk identification and management, not creating an impervious barrier for potential adversaries.
- thefourthchime 3y ago“ They won't make the same mistake twice and will build a comprehensive cybersecurity program, and it will succeed. Up until someone questions this cost and they forgot what they are paying for because everything was so smooth and repeat the cycle.” You couldn’t have said it better.
- Veserv 3y agoHa, that is funny. I have literally never met a CISO who shares your confidence. Not a single one of the companies chomping at the bit can protect MGM against a multi-million dollar ransomware attack. Companies get hacked because commercial cybersecurity by the big names is useless against the modern, prevailing threat landscape of organized crime. The sum total of their ability is stopping unskilled children, and even then only sometimes. Just ask any CISO if they would bet their job on surviving a $1M unrestricted red team exercise with a year-long timeframe. They would all be scared shitless by the thought. I bet if you asked the CISO of MGM three days before the attack: "How much would it cost to hack MGM and cripple operations?" they would answer like every other CISO I have heard answer that question and say something on the order of $100K. They know it does not work; they are there to be sacrificed and just hope it does not happen on their watch.
- Eji1700 3y agoI suspect that's just an initial breakdown. They're estimating 4.2 to 8.4 million a day out of the 42 million they normally make, but that's just on the revenue side. Equipment, man hours, botched projects, and lawsuits are going to push that number waaay higher, and even then I feel like it's got to be pretty low given the vast amount of money that passes through every day. On a 15% hold 42 million would work out to 280 billion of flow through the slots max (and obviously that's estimating high and assuming all revenue is from slots). So 8 million a day is $53 billion in coin in that's not occurring? Maybe that's correct. Doing quick napkin math so pardon any errors.
- insanitybit 3y ago> Katz told investors in his Thursday and Sunday reports that damages from the cyberattack at MGM would be claimed against insurance, but it’s unclear just how much would be covered. I'm curious to see how this plays out. After all, if MGM is audited and found to have been negligent, would insurance pay out at all?
- crazygringo 3y agoPresumably the insurance requires a security audit (yearly?) in order to get in the first place? As long as the auditors OK'd it then the insurance should pay out. Unless they can show that MGM intentionally lied in the information they gave the auditors -- which will surely now be gone through with a fine-toothed comb. (See that HN thread from a couple of days ago wondering if they were personally liable for fraud for producing a document lying about pentesting.)
- insanitybit 3y agoThe audits you get for something like SOC2 are quite weak, I'm very curious to learn if the insurance team's audit is more thorough (if they perform one).
- NoPicklez 3y agoExactly, often quite weak and might not even include an appropriate scope that covers cyber security/information security controls
- justsomehnguy 3y ago> MGM is not earning up to $8.4M a day due not spending $333.3k a day for a proper measures against cyberattack, analyist says Fixed
- guestbest 3y agoPeople are saving up to $8.4M a day due to cyberattack, and gambling addicts are being spared, analysts say
- SnorkelTan 3y agoYep. They definitely can’t walk down the street to another casino to make poor decisions.
- mrguyorama 3y agoAh yes, a physical addiction is "Poor decisions", like being born poor is a poor decision
- ToDougie 3y agoThey can walk somewhere else. They don't have a disease.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoTheir ability to walk to another casino remains unhindered by the terminology arguments of internet commentators.
- snickerbockers 3y agoHow is it even possible for all aspects of such a massive enterprise to all share a single point of failure like that? And why can't they just cut their losses on the past N days of business, restore all these servers from snapshots and get back to business?
- SteveNuts 3y agoOften the attackers wait until the retention policy for backups has been hit before unleashing the payload of ransomware. This way, even if you have a snapshot from 7 days ago, it's also infected. Or even worse they have physical access to the backup server/storage and just delete backups infect them as well.
- jachee 3y ago“The DR planning meeting has been once again postponed until next quarter…” Some middle-manager somewhere, probably.
- specialp 3y agoThere are multiple things that are done here. Suppose you had great, immutable backups. They still have many things that can ruin your business 1. Restoring networks, servers, third party services with knowledge that anything you restore could be compromised as well. Keys 2. The attackers will then threaten to dump all of your private information. It is more than just restoring data, it is restoring and resetting your entire infrastructure. And most places have backups, but they don't practice entire restores
- baby_souffle 3y ago> And most places have backups, but they don't practice entire restores Or worse, they only practice part of it. Only once in my career have I seen a "restore.txt" that didn't start with something along the lines of "connect to $server". Ok, that assumes a LOT is already in place. Where is the "restore.txt" that goes over how to get $network up so that I can resolve the IP(s) for the server I need to restore? I can't prove it, but I suspect that most businesses know deep down that they _cant_ do a "black start" and they know that even a practice run is likely to find some pretty basic and embarrassing issues that will just be too costly to address.
- kneel 3y agoMGM is smart for not paying. You can't let the scammers dictate what a casino does, MGM is already in the business of scamming people. They'll build their whole system from the ground up and be incredibly resistant to future attacks.
- bob1029 3y agoThis is a good example of the kind of case study I will point to when someone starts to get cranky with my unyielding principle of putting the entire business inside a single SQL database. When you have geo replicas and point-in-time restoration capabilities which can synchronously bring 100% of the business back from the dead in a matter of seconds/minutes... How many $8.4m days before a complete rewrite of all systems would be justified? If you are going to entertain a rewrite, why not use one system to rule them all so you can audit one thing and move on with life? This industry does not seem like a good fit for non-traditional technology stacks. I'd strongly consider putting my entire casino on a mainframe if I could. Any vendor who indicates a lack of willingness for integration with that tech stack would be instantly disqualified from selection. I feel like this is a really good technology bullshit filter for the kind of industry MGM is operating in. If it's not good enough for Visa or Amex, it's not good enough for a gambling operation.
- paulddraper 3y agoWhat was their tech stack?
- sentimentscan 3y agoIt seems like a bug/wrong infra, nothing that mainframe could fix. >it's not good enough for Visa or Amex, it's not good enough for a gambling operation. We have multicloud/kubernetes
- 1970-01-01 3y ago>putting the entire business inside a single SQL database. I too have a theory that you could get away with this and come out ahead of the industry. The problem is no CEO has the balls to try it in FinTech or any other heavily regulated industry.
- aorloff 3y agoThe business logic has to live somewhere, and triggers and stored procedures are just not the right place to do it. Plus these guys apparently got majorly pwned. I don't think any particular blend of stack was to blame, more likely they have a lord-of-the-flies driven technology "architecture" and simply hoped nothing bad ever happened.
- raydiatian 3y agoanalyist
- 1970-01-01 3y agoThis must be some kind of incompetence record. It's been weeks since it began.
- k310 3y agoHas ANYONE thought of air-gapping email from the rest of the corporate network? This mania to "integrate everything" is dangerous. If it's war, elevate your game. (business opportunity?)