5 ms·
It's curious how people are responding to the title, rather than the post, which touches on the title but is mostly about another thing: >> There’s something b
by ethbr1 3y ago
It's curious how people are responding to the title, rather than the post, which touches on the title but is mostly about another thing:
>> There’s something beguiling about the thought that a simple arrangement of lines might explain the world — like seeing human history as an enormous game of Civilization 6. But of course, that’s also the problem with using maps as a way of understanding history. If you’re not careful, they go from being helpful tools to misleading simplifications.
To which I think the blog post makes an interesting argument.
I've always thought about maps from a Tufte perspective:
(1) They are abstractions from reality. (2) Consequently, they simplify and omit select details. (3) Consequently, they are created with an inherent and specific purpose in mind: details necessary for that purpose are included, those unneeded are omitted.(4) Ergo, we must be careful to understand a map's original purpose and ask whether its abstractions are likely to remain valid if we choose to employ it for another.
F.ex. the tactical drawing of Cannae's double envelopment likely doesn't generalize to the strategic realm
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hammock 3y agoIncredibly relevant commentary today, in regards to the Ukraine conflict
- nonethewiser 3y agoAnd to the Chinese map including new territory.
- cratermoon 3y agoAnd Russian and Japanese maps of the Kuril Islands. Pakistani and Indian maps of Jammu and Kashmir and the Siachen. "thence north to the glaciers"
- kqr 3y agoI'm reminded of how all models are wrong...
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoAll models are wrong, some are useful. The map is not the territory.
- Someone 3y agoThat isn’t limited to maps, but applies to all models of reality, such as Newtonian physics, spherical cows, models of the economy that are used to guide policy or large language models. Also, oftentimes creators of models do not know what details are necessary for a model’s purpose, and may omit ones they aren’t aware of.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoIn fact it's almost always the case, since the world is so complex with so many competing and overlapping models.
- dkarl 3y agoThe intentions don't just affect the way the data is presented, but can affect the underlying data itself. For example, the "German Claims in Africa" shows vast areas as "German claims" on what must be very shaky justification. The presentation is very clear, but the data is misleading.
- ethbr1 3y agoIntentions absolutely affect both the data and presentation! Because one cannot summarize without editorializing. F.ex. the "German Claims in Africa according to Professor Delbruck" map appears to originate in a British publication [0], in the context of a "German aims in Africa" section [1]... >> [Beginning with] "It might be thought that even the rapacity of Prussia could hardly fail to be satisfied with such wholesale spoliation of territory such as this, but the foregoing [European territorial] terms by no means exhaust the demands which are to be made of the striken foe." >> "The idea that at the end of the war Germany would make enormous acquisitions in Africa was just as popularly believed and lingered just as tenaciously in the Teuton mind as the delusions with regards to the European settlement. As late as the Summer of 1917 the well-known German historian, Professor Delbruck, gives the following interesting account of German's aims in this directions [... Prof Delbruck's quote...] [...] I have therefore reduced it to map form in order that a comparison may be made between these two pathetic tributes to the tenacity of German hopes (See Map 13)." So the map that we're looking at is a British graphical depiction of something a German military historian said, provided in the context of demonstrating that German colonial claims in Africa are over-optimistic and -broad with regard to their military performance by the end of WWI. And yet the intent behind the creation of that map is largely lost by viewers. The blog post captions it as "Putative German claims in Africa amounted to nearly half the continent" which is more or less accurate, albeit leaving out the fact that the map is apparently a British creation. The British component possibly affected the precise boundaries as drawn, as well as the decision to make British and German colors similar, so as to decrease the obviousness of British colonies and emphasize the monolithic nature of desired German African colonies. [0] Maps 12 and 13 from "The British Dominions Year Book 1918" https://maps.lib.utexas.edu/maps/historical/history_dominions_1918.html https://maps.lib.utexas.edu/maps/historical/history_dominion... [1] "The British Dominions Year Book 1918" https://books.google.com/books?id=wiI0AAAAMAAJ&vq=africa&pg=PA151#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=wiI0AAAAMAAJ&vq=africa&pg=...