6 ms·
This is a tiny change. Almost half of the world still lives for less than $2.00 per day. Amazing that we can look at those statistics and think that there is
by ilaksh 15y ago
This is a tiny change. Almost half of the world still lives for less than $2.00 per day.
Amazing that we can look at those statistics and think that there is significant progress or not be distressed by the inequality.
If you honestly assess this fact that almost half live for less than $2.00 per day versus the "first world" consumption then you will come to the conclusion, as I have, that civilization is a myth. This is incredibly unjust.
- rglullis 15y ago> Amazing that we can look at those statistics and think that there is significant progress or not be distressed by the inequality. What is your time-scale? And what would constitute "significant progress"? For all the wars and all the Sudans that we still have left in the world, I still think we are in much better shape than the Romans. Or Feudal Japan. Or XVIII century France. I remain optimistic.
- apsec112 15y ago"Almost half of the world still lives for less than $2.00 per day." Simply untrue. http://rs.resalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/worldincome1970_2006.jpg http://rs.resalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/worldin... "Amazing that we can look at those statistics and think that there is significant progress" http://www.gapminder.org/world/ http://www.gapminder.org/world/ (hit "Play") "This is incredibly unjust." "To help clarify the matter, get rid of everyone else and put our worker on a desert island, hunting and gathering fruit. If he's bad at it he'll work very hard and not end up with much food. Is this unfair? Who is being unfair to him?" http://www.paulgraham.com/gap.html http://www.paulgraham.com/gap.html
- alexro 15y agoI like reading PG's essays but this one is a nonsense to me. What we (people) don't like about the rich is not their ability to make money, but their ability to corrupt the gvmt and screw the poor. All in the sake of more money.
- bullseye 15y agoI'm sorry, but that is just entitlement garbage that you are spewing. I don't dispute that there are certainly corrupt individuals in the world, but to cast every person of sufficient wealth as corrupting "the gvmt" and screwing the poor is near-sighted at best. I could give you countless examples of wealthy individuals that have donated significant amounts of money and time to help the poor, both domestically and internationally, although I suspect it would be ignored. You are entitled to your opinion, but your response doesn't even address the reason the poster referenced the article. Instead, you launched into some diatribe about evil rich folk. Reading the full article probably won't change your opinion, but it does address this "us vs. them" mindset you are in to some degree. It also contains well-reasoned arguments for variation in income, including the one the grandparent post mentioned. From PGs article: But since for most of the world's history the main route to wealth was to steal it, we tend to be suspicious of rich people
- alexro 15y agoFrankly, to this exactly moment the greater part of rich people doesn't help us to get less suspicious.
- DanBC 15y agoI agree that progress has been made. There is enough food to feed everyone; but there is still starvation happening, mostly in Asia. Your jpeg link has a graph with an unlabled axis and no source for the data. A commonly accepted figure for people living on less than $2 per day is between 2billion and 2.7billion. But that ignores the people living very close to that, who are at risk of severe hardship if they have a failed harvest. (http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/05/poor_economics http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/05/poor_econo...) > "To help clarify the matter, get rid of everyone else and put our worker on a desert island, hunting and gathering fruit. If he's bad at it he'll work very hard and not end up with much food. Is this unfair? Who is being unfair to him?" Now introduce one other person, on a different island. This person alters the environment; more rain, less rain, hotter climate, different water temperatures and salinity etc. These all make it much harder for the first person to grow crop and catch food. Sometimes his home is destroyed in flooding. The second guy is okay, he's living comfortably. He's a bit annoyed about the cost of petrol. If he watches a lot of news he may see the first guy being flooded out of his home. Is this unfair?
- nickik 15y agoThe problem is that we don't have a real notion how to change it in a large scale, we allready pure tons of money into poor countries but it does not really help (alot of times it even hurts). Alot of people feel like you but nobody has an idea how to help. Do you?
- ilaksh 15y agoI have a lot of ideas but to start, just the basic thing you are suggesting: 'pouring' 'tons' of money into poor countries.. this is just not the reality. We won't be able to fix the problem if we can't see it. Most people are living in a false reality, a matrix reality created by the propaganda machine. The truth is that the first world exploits the second and third world and hogs the resources. These 'tons' of money are pittance. The US alone uses more oil than the next three or four countries combined. The second world barely even figures in. Its very simple: the distribution of things is just quite unfair, deliberately so. Many countries are actively repressed. The World Bank provides loans as a mechanism of economic warfare or modern-day colonization. Again, a major problem is that many of the citizens of the first world aren't even aware of this. So people in every country need accurate holistic information and to have an egalitarian perspective. The first part is not happening, as I mentioned. The second part is not the case either -- most everyone in the first world subscribe to a type of Social Darwinism which is just the latest rationale for brutal primitive classism.
- nickik 15y agoFirst, we are spending alot of money on development, not just countries but NGOs too. Mostly in a bad way (somethimes with very good intentions sometimes with with not so got intentions). "Its very simple: the distribution of things is just quite unfair, deliberately so. Many countries are actively repressed. The World Bank provides loans as a mechanism of economic warfare or modern-day colonization. Again, a major problem is that many of the citizens of the first world aren't even aware of this." This is true in a way. The problem is that these countries let them self get hooked. - They overspend on stuff (mostly military but infrastructure too) witch the often buy from other countries instead of investing in (and thereby building) there own industries. - Then the get hooked and let the controll of there resources slide to private industrie from outside the country (witch would be ok if the taxed them enougth) All this is happening and it is bad I agree but these countries have to learn that if somebody comes and offers something its in the sellers intresst. This is not really diffrent from telcos offering bad deals you have to look at that stuff befor you buy. All this said I agree that the first world does really bad things they often act like the give a helping hand but its not really a helping hand. I agree that this needs to stop. The World Bank and the IMF do alot of bad things. I do not think that they deserve what they get but I would say that it is in part there fault. "So people in every country need accurate holistic information " You cant expect everybody to know enougth about economics but you can expect the countrie leaders to do so. The problem is that building up everything from with the west is much faster then doing it on your own and if you have bad leaders (diktators/persidents/kings) who only care for there themself, accepting "aid" from the west is the fastes way to get rich (a hole other problem is that sometimes the west helps them to stay in power) tl:dr: - What is called "aid" from 1st world often isn't - Developing countries don't look close on what they buy - Developing countries often have bad leaders --------------------------------------------------------- I just don't like the term economic warfare or modern-day colonization. Its a Free-Market there are just good players using bad players, but the bad players did not get forced to play or to play the way they did (Expet when the are actually forced like Iraq).
- ekianjo 15y agoThe fact that there are almost 10 billions people alive on this Earth prove otherwise. The population would not flourish if everyone was poor and starving. It's pretty obvious that the world is getting richer and the poors are getting richer no matter what the gap between the poors and the richs is. Now "poor" people in the US have internet access and mobile phones. Come on !
- kitsune_ 15y agoLast time I checked, the world population is at around 7 billion.
- ekianjo 15y agoWell, we'll reach 10 billions in no time at the rate the world population is growing.
- hythloday 15y agoThe rate of population growth has been slowing[0] since 1963, and monotonically so since 1991. The UN's "medium" projection suggests that the total population peak is just over 10 billion, and the low peak is just over 8 billion[1] [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:World_population_growth_rate_1950%E2%80%932050.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:World_population_growth_ra... [1] http://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/Excel-Data/population.htm http://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/Excel-Data/population.htm
- InclinedPlane 15y agoYour premise is faulty and following through on it could doom the poor of the world to continued poverty. First world consumption isn't something that's done at the expense of the 3rd world, it's something that sends money and skilled jobs to the developing world to help them bootstrap their way to wealth. Look at china, south korea, taiwan, etc. these countries have climbed out of 3rd world poverty by being "exploited" by the 1st world and have become developed and increasingly affluent. South Korea, for example, is rapidly becoming a 1st world nation. Would that more countries followed those examples.
- alexro 15y agoDon't be so optimistic. The globalization project hasn't ended yet. Who will control the world is to be seen. And whether the nations will be left with the wealth they had acquired is as clear as the Libyan's future at the moment.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoDon't be so vague, say what you mean, back it up with evidence.
- alexro 15y agoLike everything in capitalism, third world improvements is just an investment. The debt is due already for some nations and soon the next batch will follow the "debt settlement". Look around yourself in your country. Are people good enough there and no "occupy wall street" actions taking place? I know how the things are in the helped to be "developed" countries, and one from one of those.
- alexro 15y agoNo amount voting down can change the fact that economics is another form of war nowadays. The North American empire thrives at the moment, as the Romans did some time ago. But who wins the global world is yet to be seen.
- jvrossb 15y agoIt comes down to this: if you think that economics is a zero-sum game, then yes, it is unjust. First world consumption comes at the expense of the poor elsewhere, the rich are leeches sucking money from the rest of the economy, and 35 hour work weeks create jobs. Good news is all signs point to economics not being a zero-sum game, and thus most of the responses you are getting are likely correct - your premise is flawed.
- A1kmm 15y agoClaiming that anyone discussing inequality is implying economics is a zero-sum game is making a strawman argument. There is a continuum between two extremes - at one extreme, you have a zero sum relationship, where the total output (as measured by some sensible metric) is capped and it gets divided up, through to a view where there are unlimited resources and no constraints on growth, and the activities of people are synergistic but not competitive. Both ends of the continuum are easily shown to be fallacious, but your argument only holds if you assume the unlimited resource end of the continuum is true. The reality is that there are finite resources, and physical, biological and sociological limits how fast and efficiently they can be sustainably exploited. That said, there is clearly a lot of room for improvement in how efficiently we use resources - as many Internet startups are doing - as well as how sustainably we use them.
- DanBC 15y agoThere is a problem with rich people consuming things that drive poor people into unacceptable employment to provide raw materials for those things. Materials like gold, or minerals for tech, are often mined in ways that most people would find appalling. People have a perception of "fairness" and a big tech company making millions, billions of dollars of profit while people are mining minerals in dangerous conditions for very little money is seen as unjust. For someone getting $2 a small amount of money, just 50c, is a huge raise, and it would have little impact on the end price of the goods. Quite small amounts of carefully targeted money could make a big difference to developing nations - better schools, clean water, better medicine, etc. It would be really nice to see tech companies devoting a bit of time and smarts (and maybe even a bit of cash) to tackling those problems.