7 ms·
Geographic ‘hot spots’ for cigarette and firearm deaths in the U.S.
- neovialogistics 3y agoThe distribution along the basin and range parts of the country are very interesting. Just eyeballing it, it looks like there is a significant altitude component. Is it just the second and third-order effects of higher transportation costs, or is it something to do with barometric air pressure?
- dghlsakjg 3y agoThe basin and range distribution is particular to firearm suicides. Those are rural places, with limited access to healthcare, cultures of shame around mental health, limited economic opportunities, and high rates of gun ownership. I have no way to know causality, but my guess is that the social factors are far more important than the barometric pressure.
- neovialogistics 3y agoMost of those social factors you've listed are things that are influenced by base transportation costs, so I wonder if there are similar patterns in other places with gun ownership and varying topography: Australia, Canada, Russia, Southeastern Europe...
- pengaru 3y agoI don't know about you, but humidity and mosquitoes combined with no money for air-conditioning would certainly move me closer to the suicidal/violent addict end of the "versions of me" spectrum.
- mortureb 3y agoThe northeast, northwest and south west seem to be doing something very right.
- ghayes 3y agoThe graph is, in a large way, an inversion of population density.
- mortureb 3y agoThat’s one correlation but it seems like that conjecture doesn’t extend to Florida or Texas.
- ianai 3y agoIt’s a correlation but the correlation probably wouldn’t be so high. The north east is plenty dense compared to the south east (iirc). I think this really shows a cultural difference amid population and probably other things. I’ve outside of this heard the South has in someways never really bounced back from the end of slavery. Could be a kind of cultural scar or lack of “infrastructure”. Like how Lincoln’s reconstruction plans never happened and his successor went a quite different direction.
- pixl97 3y ago> Could be a kind of cultural scar At least anecdotally it feels that way. I moved from one of the states that was totally clear in this map, to eastern Texas when I was younger and the social scars from the civil war still exist and by the way some people talk even to this day, you'ld think the war had ended last year. It was complete insanity to me.
- mortureb 3y agoIf we’re jumping to conclusions a much simpler explanation would be that Republican led states enact policies that lead to poor health outcomes.
- parineum 3y agoYou might want to take another look at that map and then look at where the big cities in florida and texas are located. The smoking blob pretty much stops at the major cities in Texas and the population centers of Florida are white as California.
- UberFly 3y agoStrange that the counties with major cities like Chicago with high gun violence don't even register?
- paulcole 3y agoWhy is that strange? Maybe “high gun violence” in Chicago isn’t as high as you think it is? Maybe Chicago’s population is relatively low compared to Cook County’s population and the extra people balance it out?
- ianai 3y agoIn cities, you get “bad neighborhoods.” We’re seeing county data.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoChicago and/or Cook County isn't particularly high on a per capita basis for violence. Generally the most violent places in the US are in the Southeast. (https://www.visualcapitalist.com/most-dangerous-cities-in-the-us/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/most-dangerous-cities-in-th...) There are certain very specific parts of Chicago where violent crime rates are astronomical, but if you are worried about widespread violent crime, your best bet is to avoid the southern states. Where did you learn that Chicago is so violent?
- pixl97 3y agoNot really. In general if you watch one of the largest news networks in the US you've highly propagandized to the point of being completely disconnected from reality. News likes to use statements like "The most violent city in America" and then happen to leave off the qualifier of "only if you count cities with over 1 million population". When you start including per capita statistics of smaller towns. Beau did a episode on this a while back... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LCEqjXI1SLk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LCEqjXI1SLk
- fisherjeff 3y agoVery interesting but not a great map for us color deficient types!
- kallistisoft 3y agoCame to make the same reply!
- bmitc 3y agoHonest questions that just popped in my head. Are there not color conversion filters that convert colors into more readily seen colors? What is a resource one would use to select color palettes from when designing in general but keeping color blind people in mind?
- tester756 3y agoSmoking is biggest shit that's widely accepted, why? idk People argue that banning it would be against "freedom" Please explain to me how: 1) causing harm to yourself 2) causing harm to people around you 3) paying for it additional taxes(!!!) 4) and all of that while being highly addictive ... how is it a freedom? The nature of it being addictive removes "freedom" from the consideration. It isn't freedom when you're addicted. I know smokers and a lot of them says that they'd want to drop this shit, but they cant.
- thrill 3y ago"I know smokers and a lot of them says that they'd want to drop this shit, but they can't." Yes, they can.
- tester756 3y agoDropping requires specific traits, mindset, strong discipline, etc. That's pretty high bar. Not everyone can, *especially when surrounded by smokers*.
- Taek 3y agoCapitalist society has intentionally trained the general population to believe in free will and the strength of the human mind, such that population members say "I'm better than being brainwashed by ads" and allowing corpos to get away with a lot, lot, lot more manipulative psychological than should be legal. Believing that smoking addiction is a mind-over-matter problem is one major extension of this.
- parineum 3y agoAnd that's why there's such a huge correlation between smoking and capitalism.
- december456 3y agoThere definitely should be a scientific limit for addictiveness, meth versus cigarettes for example. I dont quite care if somebody can scientifically stop taking an addictive substance with reasonable self-discipline but it becomes a problem and elimination of the freedom status if its too addictive that it effectively takes over your brain.
- xrd 3y agoInteresting that this was created by a Florida professor but Florida is the only southern state where it is mapped almost entirely "white"; completely different than the other Southern states that are red indicating high mortality.
- lisper 3y agoOnly Southern Florida, which is where a lot of expats go to retire. Northern Florida looks like the rest of the South.
- paulcole 3y agoThere’s no conspiracy here. North Florida (where I grew up) is part of The South. South Florida is not part of The South.
- xrd 3y agoI live in Central Florida, so let's split the difference? ;) I agree with you mostly but if you look at the Opportunity Atlas (https://www.opportunityatlas.org/ https://www.opportunityatlas.org/) all of Florida looks pretty bad. But I suppose that doesn't all correlate to gun violence?
- daniel_iversen 3y agoI think I read somewhere recently that the majority of Americans were in favour of stricter gun reforms, yet no real change I laws seem to happen and all the current presidential candidates over in the US seems to not even dare touch the subject. I find it reprehensible and puzzling how they’ve got this weird relationship with guns, but it’s interesting how often people are using a certain interpretation of their constitution as to why they need all those guns, or thinking that it’s the safest option that everyone has guns to protect themselves against the “bad guys” than just making it really difficult for the average citizen to get a firearm.
- partitioned 3y agoIt’s because we don’t have a choice. A stacked Supreme Court that says any gun law has to be a gun law that would’ve been cool in 1776 has made any progress impossible without violent revolution
- oaththrowaway 3y agoIf that were true, the NFA would be repealed (the legal ground for it was pretty shaky originally and somehow it has stood)
- alistairSH 3y agoLaws don’t magically get repealed. Somebody has to challenge it in court and show that it damages them/infringes in their rights. The NFS might fail if challenged (I don’t think it’s been challenged since Bruen), given the Bruen decision. But it’s not in the GOP’s interest to find a challenge, as that would almost certainly definitely turn off swing voters.
- partitioned 3y agoIt is true, read the opinion. Clarence Thomas wrote it, which might help it make sense.
- netsharc 3y agoSeems like, just with many issues in the US, it's become another "The other side is against it, so we're for it!" problem... "Our kids are getting shot up in school, but the Democrats want to ban guns, so we're pro guns, there must be other solutions! Maybe Ivermectin also creates bullet-proof kids!". The opposition also becomes saboteurs because any wins they give the ruling party means the ruling party gets to look better, and hell no, we can't have that, we have to destroy them! Funnily enough when lockdowns started, the billions of bailout got bipartisan support. It seems like both sides knew a hungry populace would go for their heads, whatever the label after their name is. EDIT: then again, Dems are a more conscionable bunch (which makes fighting against a win-by-whatever-means-possible bunch hard), they knew people needed the money. The hypocrisy was GOP saying money doesn't grow on trees, until it does...
- stevenwoo 3y agoThis looks a little bit like Colin Woodward’s recent update on Eleven Nations of North America but with different focus https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/09/01/america-life-expectancy-regions-00113369 https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/09/01/america-li...
- pnw 3y agoI was intrigued to read the details but this is just a press release with the actual research paper locked behind a paywall unfortunately. I can't find the paper anywhere.
- uoaei 3y agohttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0091743523002025?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00917... You've heard of sci-hub?
- Animats 3y agoInteresting that firearms assaults are highest in the really empty states. Except Texas.
- ianai 3y agoLight blue is suicide. Edit-firearm suicide. Not the general category. Key is at the end of the page, sort of unhelpfully.
- throwaway128128 3y agoConfront anyone with this kind of correlation and you'll be accused of being an elitist snob who hates America. In America we are addicted to lethal things.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dbrueck 3y agoSort of interesting, but the whole setup is oddly misleading: "Smoking and firearms are among the leading causes of avoidable premature death in the United States" The statement is true for smoking but it takes some work to make it true for firearms. And then it describes tobacco and firearms as "both are legal yet lethal" - it borders on nonsensical to pair them that way (I guess possessing both can be legal, but it's worded to imply that the use of both, in the ways that resulted in death, is legal). I'd love to see fewer firearm deaths, but it just seems odd to try and link a really high cause of deaths with one that is an order of magnitude smaller, while skipping over others that are very preventable causes of death. You are, for example, many times more likely to die from poor diet than from being shot. I mean, using their framing, automobiles are "legal yet lethal" and auto deaths are the cause of about as many deaths as firearm deaths - and that includes suicide (i.e. intentional) deaths.
- scotty79 3y agoThere's another quality that allows to group cigarettes and guns together. They are both completely optional lifestyle choice. While cars and diet might be way harder to opt out given how cars are needed to get to work and stores and the most unhealthy diet is the cheapest and fastest one.
- BaculumMeumEst 3y agoDo you also consider living in an area with high rate of violent crime to be a lifestyle choice?
- scotty79 3y agoIn nearly all cases, no.
- conductr 3y agoEven “optional” gets a little fuzzy when all these things are likely to be a cultural phenomenon; as in, influenced by your parents/family. It’s like saying that Christianity continues to be the most popular choice of religion in the US. Sure it’s optional, but there’s a bit of inertia involved.
- cjensen 3y agoSome random observations on this... 1. The suicide difference between the Mountain & Basin West vs the Great Plains surprises me. I would have expected Wyoming and Nebraska would have been more similar. 2. The gradient across Texas is interesting, particularly the lack of both suicide and smoking death in the southwest part of the state compared to the northeast. 3. Rural Nevada counties, except the northernmost two, utter lack the suicide rate that is seen in nearly all of Arizona. 4. It's not helpful to conflate these three causes of death. Seems like it would be better as separate maps 5. It's not helpful to color-code these maps as a binary choice between "has problem" and "does not have." I wonder how much subtlety is hidden by not using a gradient. 6. Unlabeled graphs are a sin. What is the definition of "hot spot?" And why is it hidden from the casual reader?
- pierat 3y ago> 6. Unlabeled graphs are a sin. What is the definition of "hot spot?" And why is it hidden from the casual reader? Given that hidden fact, along with conflating firearm assaults vs suicide, tells me there's a definite bias of the story provided. Suicide is usually a last resort to life when faced with either hard to undo things, or impossible to undo things. I haven't dug much into this, but my guess it's something to do with the group that correlated this. But again, I find displays like this suspect.
- fbdab103 3y agoGiven suicide is relatively rare, I am wondering if this might be an artifact of low absolute population?
- tomohawk 3y agoIt would seem like pairing alcohol with cigarettes would be more worthwhile, as alcohol is much deadlier, being involved in about half of suicides, half of vehicle and other deaths, half of gun deaths, etc.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoInteresting how there is a correlation between smoking/firearms deaths and where African American communities are prominent.
- johnea 3y agoAlcohol, tobacco and firearms, like the little baby jesus intended...
- pengaru 3y agoI wish the map could represent gun ownership and smoker rates as well. Am I just seeing that there are a lot more smokers in the red areas? Or is it the same rate of smokers as many other states, just these have more smoking-related deaths? Did they normalize the data for that already? I feel like there's not enough information here to really interpret the visualization.
- jeffbee 3y agoThis is a bit of a meta comment, but it's interesting that slapping data from WONDER onto a choropleth, with some paragraphs describing the map in words, amounts to research from authors with these titles. I am not saying this research isn't worthwhile, but I am saying there are members of the public doing research at this level or higher and just publishing it on Medium, Observable, or their blogs. Perhaps weekend volunteer researchers should seek university affiliations so they can get published in prestigious journals.
- based-nerd 3y ago[flagged]
- khaki54 3y agoThey finally found a way to make a US gun violence map that didn't show the most gun violence in the places with the strictest laws
- notjoemama 3y agoI dislike they’ve confounded suicide and assault, yet again. The point of collecting and presenting data like this is to understand the problem and those two sources of “gun violence” (a political weasel word) have very different reasons for existing. Because of this the solutions must look different but without seeing the categorical error only one broad solution will be presented. Chances are it will do little or nothing because it is not actually a solution to the individual issues.
- CapstanRoller 3y agoIt's very disingenuous to conflate suicide (something done by someone) with violence (something done to someone else). Suicide is an act of bodily autonomy.