16 ms·
Close to 2k environmental activists killed over last decade
- vuln 3y ago[flagged]
- gonzo41 3y agoNever is the answer. And I think you know it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 0xDEF 3y agoHow are you going to hold all the permanent members of the UN Security Council responsible for this? They all have companies and organizations operating in this space.
- vuln 3y agoThere’s only 5 permanent members with voting rights: China, France, Russian Federation, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, United States of America. You start there. You sign effectually a cyber arms treaty which makes it illegal to export offensive cyber weapons for profit. If these members can sign nuclear arms treaties (Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW)), I don’t see how offensive cyber weapons could be any more complicated. Then go after the nonmembers that are profiting wildly off the offensive cyber weapons.
- 0xDEF 3y agoWhat makes you think they will do that? Especially considering that Russia's source of soft power in the developing world is their willingness to sell offensive weapons without asking ESG questions.
- vuln 3y agoI don’t know. Why would they sign a nuclear arms treaty?
- marcosdumay 3y agoThose things are not similar. A nuclear arms reduction treaty ensures that all parties keep their own relative power (that is not dictated by the nukes) without going into a boundlessly expensive arms-race that would bankrupt all of them. A prohibition on cyberweapons exports doesn't have any similar impact. It wouldn't even make defense cheaper. It's something that may be useful for civilians, but how often do civilian concerns enter those high-level treaties? (Anyway, I'm not even sure it gains us anything. The absence of somebody exploiting them does not make the vulnerabilities go away. What would really help is if some moderately advanced country decided to take their head outside of their ass and do something to protect themselves. But I don't expect to actually see that happening, everybody only wants to work on the offensive.)
- wyager 3y agoI looked at the report - reading between the lines (e.g. deaths by country), this looks to be at least 90% south/central american cartel related. This isn't the saudis sending agent 47 after people - it's more like people fighting over land for coca cultivation.
- vuln 3y agoAre the saudis in the room with you right now? Are the saudis the only country that uses offensive cyber weapons to kill civilians, activists and journalists?
- jonathanlb 3y agoI'm curious what statistics there are relating to deaths/injuries/imprisonment for protesting other causes as well.
- morelisp 3y ago[flagged]
- fortran77 3y agoProbably zero. This is a crazy straw man to change the topic.
- fortran77 3y agoThe UK, home to Novalpina, the company behind NSO, is a member of the UN Security group. You mean them?
- bluefishinit 3y agoRecently Georgia police killed an environmental activist protesting the construction of Cop City: https://www.cnn.com/2023/04/20/us/cop-city-activist-killed-dekalb-county-medical-examiner/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/04/20/us/cop-city-activist-killed-d... Then the government indicted 61 activists on RICO charges: https://apnews.com/article/atlanta-cop-city-protests-rico-charges-3177a63ac1bd31a1594bed6584e9f330 https://apnews.com/article/atlanta-cop-city-protests-rico-ch... This is currently ongoing.
- mu53 3y agoLikely, another case that end up only netting maybe one or two people with charges after the process is finalized. The remaining will have had their lives turned upside down by the process, and despite being innocent, will have suffered immense damage financially by the state.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DoneWithAllThat 3y agoYou mean the environmental activist who shot a police officer?
- PhasmaFelis 3y agoThe activist that police claim shot an officer. The state did a test to determine if there was gunpowder residue on his hands, but has so far declined to release the result.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Quillbert182 3y agoThe results were released months ago, gunpowder residue was found on his hands. https://www.fox5atlanta.com/news/autopsy-cop-city-protester-manuel-teran-death-gunshot-powder-residue.amp https://www.fox5atlanta.com/news/autopsy-cop-city-protester-...
- ot1138 3y ago[flagged]
- WanderPanda 3y ago[flagged]
- wyager 3y agoThe implication (that this many people are murdered specifically for environmental activism) sounds prima facie unrealistic. How many people are included in their definition of "environmental activist", and what is the risk-adjusted base rate for murders in that population? It sounds like they're including a lot of people from very high-risk populations. The fact that 88% of killings are apparently in Latin America (especially Colombia) is suggestive - this has to be picking up a significant amount of cartel conflict and trying to pass it off as environmentalism-related.
- morelisp 3y agoIf I was trying to clearcut a forest or build a dam in South America I'd happily point my finger at "cartels" any time something unfortunate happened on my land too.
- beedeebeedee 3y ago> The implication (that this many people are murdered specifically for environmental activism) sounds prima facie unrealistic Only because you have not been paying attention.
- wyager 3y agoAre you sure? Because when I actually looked at the claims in detail, as described several sentences farther into the paragraph, it turns out that my priors were correct
- beedeebeedee 3y ago> it turns out that my priors were correct No, they are not. Read the actual report. Do some actual research. It will take you a lot longer than a couple minutes to debunk Global Witness's work of over a decade.
- 0daystock 3y agoAlmost all happened in Latin America where individual rights, including to own and defend yourself with potent firearms, is severely limited (except for agents of the state). Without this fundamental ability and political right, lawful good individuals will suffer and fail. History is replete with examples of this basic and obvious fact. Armed minorities are more difficult to oppress.
- outside1234 3y agoI think you should now apply that reasoning to Mexico. Pretty sure the guns there aren’t making it safer.
- 0daystock 3y agoThere is one gun store in all of Mexico and a two-tier ownership/permitting system where only the oligarchy class actually has rights to arms. No wonder it isn't safe when the average person is deprived of the means to defend themselves.
- throwlejos 3y agoAs someone who migrated from a very conflictive area of Latin America, this is the answer, period. But the minute you mention this to the incumbents here in the US (specially to those claiming the need to “amplify” underrepresented voices) all of a sudden you will not be an ally anymore.
- 0daystock 3y agoThat is not by accident. The history of gun control in the USA (and mostly elsewhere) is deeply rooted in racism and classism. The very idea of an armed minority challenging the status quo terrifies individuals living lives of relative privilege and prosperity. Even if they don't consciously apprehend their bias (and most lack the emotional and spiritual maturity to do so), they are useful in promoting the false narrative of "only the State must monopolize power" as they are the benefactors of it.
- anigbrowl 3y ago
- thuuuomas 3y ago[flagged]
- marsven_422 3y ago[dead]
- andsoitis 3y ago> “Research has shown again and again that Indigenous peoples are the best guardians of the forests and therefore play a fundamental role in mitigating the climate crisis,” Where can I read more about this research?
- xhkkffbf 3y agoPersonally I'm a bit skeptical of this. Just right off the bat, it's easy to find research that shows how the Native Americans in California used wild fire to open up farming land. And there are the Native Americans who would drive entire herds of buffalo off of cliffs. They're human, not divine saints.
- ridicter 3y agoWe're a few narratives deep. You're responding to the "noble savages" strawman -- the OP article never claimed such. (Moreover, you're responding with a relatively isolated incident of Native Americans driving buffalos off cliffs, which I agree happened and Is Not Good. But it's odd to mention in the larger historical context that the American Buffalo became endangered due to industrial scale slaughter caused by European settlers--A Big Deal, relatively speaking.) On balance, yes, Native people are often the best guardians of the forest for a mix of reasons. One is the animistic belief systems, which falls under the "Noble Savage" bucket. But the other is they more often than not don't industrial-scale commoditize their living spaces, part and parcelling out the goods as raw material inputs. Which other groups, like Asians and Whites, often have.
- mathewsanders 3y agoThose smaller controlled burns help prevent organic matter from building up that can lead to more devastating uncontrolled fires. The national parks service has been incorporating those methods into their fire management practices. And driving bison of cliffs were a sustainable hunting practice - it was habitat loss due to farming and commercial hunting that led to their population decline.
- WalterBright 3y ago
- motohagiography 3y agoThis is objectively terrible, and at numbers that high I would wonder if there were another factor like being affiliated with insurgent groups and factions vying for power, which are a constant multi-decade problem in those countries. I'd wonder if being affiliated with international climate causes makes you more likely to have a kidnapping ransom paid as well, as there is a lot of local context missing from the article. The stories and data are terrible, but at that level, they must be the effect of a dynamic. It's also sad that this effects mainly indigenous populations in south america instead of the people who sit in the road and block traffic in the anglosphere, as the consequences seem to fall to the those who have earned the least resentment.
- _fat_santa 3y agoThere are alot of flagged / down-voted comments on here that express a negative view (to put it mildly) against climate activists. The reason for that I think is at least in the west, climate activists get a very bad rap because of their tactics. Every time I hear a story about climate activists it's always: stopping traffic by gluing themselves to the road, gluing themselves other places, spraying paint/tomato sauce/etc on walls, windows, and art. Now I get that this is a small subset of the climate activism but I even then I think that climate activists need to seriously rethink their tactics. Blocking traffic for example is in my opinion a completely counter-productive way of protesting. Rather than spreading your message, the only message you are spreading is: "I'm blocking traffic, I'm a complete a**hole" and the downvoted comments here reflect that sentiment. If you want to spread your message, you need people on come join your side, and no one is going to want to join your side if you're using these kids of tactics.
- ProjectArcturis 3y agoWhat would you recommend as a strategy that is hard to ignore but not disruptive to average people?
- beebmam 3y agoLobbying
- ProjectArcturis 3y agoHonestly, good answer.
- mikrotikker 3y agoImagine all these obnoxious climate activists went and lobbied politicians. I guess they don't have any grease to put in the politicians palms...?
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoWhy hard to ignore? Is the premise that everyone is ignorant of the special knowledge that only activists have and everyone should be forced to consume? Perhaps most people already know about the subject and are either already making their own changes or simply don't care. In both cases, hard to ignore activism does nothing to advance the cause and only serves to discredit the message by making it associated with unlikable and often seemingly unhinged activists. Of course if the purpose is to impress one's friends, mission accomplished.
- lelanthran 3y agoWhat's the killed[1]-rate of non-activists? From the cherry-picked datapoints in the article, it's impossible to tell if an activist is more or less likely to be killed than a non-activist. IOW, maybe activists get killed less often then non-activists? [1] They use the word "kill" not "murder". This means that they include, in their dataset, people who died due to accidents.
- uoaei 3y agoNo, "killed" still includes intention of the killer. You may be thinking of "died".
- lelanthran 3y ago> No, "killed" still includes intention of the killer. Not as I understand it. If I lost control of my car and ran you down, I would have killed you, but not murdered you. If I step on a landmine, it is grammatically correct to say "I was killed by a landmine", even though a landmine cannot have intention. Murder requires intention. Kill does not. The article, written by (presumably) a professional writer and edited at a professional publisher, almost certainly wanted to achieve the sleight-of-hand effect that they have achieved with you - to make it seem as if those deaths were intentional. This is partly why I am skeptical about the narrative they are selling.
- beedeebeedee 3y agoHi, instead of trying to discredit the idea that people are being murdered for defending the environment from exploitation, by pointing out the ambiguity in the word "killed" as used in a Yale e360 article about a report on investigations by Global Witness, why don't you go to the source and do a good faith attempt to understand what is going on? Here's a link to get you started, where they unambiguously use the word "murder": https://www.globalwitness.org/en/campaigns/environmental-activists/standing-firm/ https://www.globalwitness.org/en/campaigns/environmental-act... There is a lot of evidence about what is going on, beyond just Global Witness, so how about engaging with something more substantive than word play in a third party article? I know it makes people uncomfortable to acknowledge it, but it should be acknowledged.
- bhk 3y agoWe're these deaths from activism or with activism?
- coldtea 3y agoYes, but what about the tens of thousands of "green transition" environmental policy advisors who whitewashed capitalism and business as usual and got rich? There's some balance!
- af3d 3y agoTragic, yes. But from a journalistic perspective at least these deaths would probably be more accurately described as arising from disputes over land rights (as opposed to the environmental activities of the victims). Most likely died as a result of "drawing a line in the sand" after declaring some degree of self-sovereignty. In other words, they played a dangerous game and (rather predictably) lost.
- quadcore 3y agoI think it's one of the intents behind the article to call for less barbaric settlements because we want more disputes like that in the future, not less.
- systemvoltage 3y ago[flagged]
- zephrx1111 3y agoHow we measure the people killed by activists? Wild fire, ambulance etc.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- abeppu 3y agoSome comments have pointed out that this doesn't actually mention a difference from the base rate of violent deaths in the relevant countries. Sure, fine. I think the other significant missing numbers are those who die from human-driven environmental disaster. One estimate on climate change deaths in the recent decades is 2M, and the WHO has estimated 250k/yr in 2030-2050. Since we collectively have known about climate change as a concern for decades, and have known that large numbers of civilian deaths, disease, displacement, etc are predictable results, and have nevertheless chosen to pump carbon in to the atmosphere at ever-increasing rates (except a single dip in 2020), then under a consequentialist framework, these un-targeted victims ought to count just as much as intentionally-targeted activists. If those who benefit from the pro-emissions status quo may kill you whether you protest or not, either through neglectful inattention to the consequences their own actions, or through hostile retribution, but they can only possibly be confronted with any direct responsibility for their _intended_ victims, perhaps it's best to protest. As an ethics note, I am aware there are those who say, "we're not responsible for the 250k/yr who die from climate change in the near future merely because we emit above a sustainable level; our _goals_ were merely to heat our houses and fly to Europe on vacation, whereas the _goal_ of someone who murders an activist is clearly to cause death." And I think this _can_ be part of a coherent ethical vision, but I would ask that they revisit Anscombe's critique of Truman's decision to use fission weapons on civilian targets. If you believe that it was "good" to drop the bombs and hasten the end of the war because it resulted in fewer total deaths, and the hypothetical deaths averted in a long conventional war have the same moral weight and standing as the civilians killed by the atomic bombs, then why would you not believe that targeted and untargeted climate deaths have the same ethical weight? Or from the converse side, if you believe we are not responsible for deaths caused as predictable effects of actions which are motivated by heating/transporting/building etc, i.e. you believe an important ethical factor is the presence or absence of an _intention_ to kill innocent people (as versus merely knowing they will be killed as an effect of an action initiated with some other intention), then do you also believe that Truman, who chose to drop the bomb on cities, is a mass murderer? https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/5/22/climate-change-causes-2m-deaths-in-50-years-poor-suffer-most-un https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/5/22/climate-change-caus... https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/climate-change-and-health https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/climate-cha...
- hedora 3y agoImagine a world where the military was used to protect the environment. There are many, many slave vessels that dump huge amounts of plastic netting into the ocean (a double digit percentage of the pacific garbage patch is discarded fishing nets). They can do this because it is in international waters, and the law doesn’t apply. Spy satellites continuously produce proof that this is happening. Why can’t we have the navy seize the damn boats as part of their training exercises?
- bequanna 3y agoBecause international waters are international waters. Do you want China to start cruising around the world and arbitrarily enforcing their laws on other citizens?
- hedora 3y agoWhat if they enforced UN law?
- bequanna 3y agoOne country using the threat of violence to stop non-violent (but still bad) acts by citizens of another country in neutral territory seems like a bad idea.
- bequanna 3y ago> It's not non-violent if it's causing harm. Oh man… that’s a slippery slope. Allows you to justify using force against all sorts of non-violent things you don’t like. See the many examples where aggressive force was used “for the greater good” in the 20th century if you want some spoilers for how that turns out.
- rexpop 3y agoIt's not non-violent if it's causing harm.
- thelastgallon 3y agoEnvironmental activists are active spied on and blackmailed by Governments. Probably not the best use of taxpayer money? From: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/jan/25/activist-deceived-relationship-met-police-officer-wins-compensation-kate-wilson https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/jan/25/activist-dec... "An environmental activist who was deceived into a two-year intimate relationship by an undercover police officer has been awarded £229,000 in compensation after winning a landmark legal case. Kennedy was part of a covert police operation that spied on more than 1,000 predominantly leftwing and progressive political groups over more than four decades. Many undercover officers deceived women they were spying on into sexual relationships during their covert deployments." Environment activists: 'I got death and rape threats’: https://www.bbc.com/news/av/science-environment-54165868 https://www.bbc.com/news/av/science-environment-54165868
- fennecfoxy 3y agoGiven that the majority of these seem to be occurring outside of the West (even thought the West is obviously directly involved in the corporate hand shaking that drives these murders), what should we do? I think Western countries should definitely be enacting much heavier environmental protection laws, including ones that affect overseas territories (ie being able to link a Western exec to a corrupt forestry deal in Brazil = life in prison). But the truth is that Western governments are already corrupt, we've allowed billionaires to hoard wealth, wages have stagnated, political lobbying aka bribing is considered normal (esp in America). And the above is all only possible because the general population doesn't rise up to protest these issues, why does everyone just simply not care? Obviously as animals we're mostly concerned with what directly affects our tribe (big or small) but these issues do affect us, especially environmental ones. Is it overstimulation, modern life is so much more complex especially with technology in the mix? Is it resource contention, ie people would prefer their power bill to be $10 cheaper even if it causes a global temperature rise over decades? Is our ability to be social animals lacking, having evolved to only participate in tribes of 150~ (as far as I've read) people, we can't all work together efficiently because of that?