5 ms·
National Motorcycle Museum Closing Its Doors
- DavidPeiffer 3y agoI have family in that vicinity and I've probably driven by it a couple hundred times in my life but never stopped. They took over an old Walmart building after Walmart expanded. If you've watched American Pickers (which started in LeClaire, Iowa, just upriver from Davenport), they worked with the National Motorcycle Museum on a number of finds.
- callalex 3y agoSelf-removed: this apparently came across as non-genuine political snark instead of a plausible solution that accounts for the strong political power of Iowa.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoLet’s keep unrelated US politics out of this thread. N.b. Does anyone else feel like their seeing more of this type of comment…?
- porknubbins 3y ago300 motorcycles is not a small collection, should go for 8 figures. Wish I could attend the auction even though I’m not really into collecting that era bikes.
- unethical_ban 3y agoMaybe Jay Leno picked up the cream of the crop.
- GenerWork 3y agoOn one hand, I hate to see unique museums like this close. On the other hand, they're in a small Iowa town that isn't near an interstate. Who thought that was a good location? If they were closer to/in Cedar Rapids, they'd probably have a much better time.
- bena 3y agoIt’s not a good location and the people who built it knew that. They were hoping to become a good location based on the draw of the attraction.
- grubbs 3y agoThe pro football Hall of Fame is in Canton, Ohio. I guess it's near a regional airport. Still a pretty random spot though.
- johnafranklin 3y agoThe NFL was created in Canton in 1920. It was weird for me seeing it where it was the first time I drove by. Like someone just dumped it in between a couple of warehouses and highways.
- fein 3y agoThe location and first football field/ stadium there predates the Cleveland Browns. It was the largest high school stadium when first built, and Akron/ Canton was the home of the largest rubber producers on the planet at the time. Additionally, the NFL was founded in Canton. It seems random now, but it was not when originally constructed.
- grubbs 3y agoI think they still use that stadium for HS and maybe even some special event college games?
- davewashere 3y agoThe Baseball Hall of Fame is in Cooperstown, NY, which is in upstate NY in the middle of nowhere. It's there because of a fake baseball origin story created to attract tourists. A few other halls of fame popped up in the same area to exploit the hall of fame branding, all of which have moved or failed, including the Soccer HOF, the Corvette HOF, and Hamburger HOF (which I think was just a mediocre burger joint).
- 3y ago
- jeffal 3y agoI highly recommend the Barber Vintage Motorsports Museum. The motorcycle collection is stunning. https://www.barbermuseum.org/collection/ https://www.barbermuseum.org/collection/
- jsanford 3y agoYes, it's worth making special travel plans _just_ to go to the Barber Vintage Motorsports Museum, even if one is not a motorcycle fan. The museum presentation, architecture, and surrounding landscaping -- it's world class.
- boomboomsubban 3y agoWhat made it the "national" museum? Just their decision to call it that? As Wikipedia lists fourteen US motorcycle museums. Including one in Sturgis, where you'd expect one, but seemingly not Daytona Beach, which is surprising. edit it has the "Motorsports Hall of Fame of America" which probably features motorcycles.
- bigbacaloa 3y agoLike the NBA world champions.
- twelvechairs 3y agoOr Miss Universe!
- nannal 3y agoMLB World Series?
- user3939382 3y agoIt is because the best players are recruited from around the world to play on those teams.
- massysett 3y agoPretty much. There is a “National Harbor” in Maryland which is a…real estate development? Well, it does have some boat parking too. But nothing is “officially” “national” about it. There is a National Aquarium in Baltimore. Confusingly there was a now-defunct National Aquarium in Washington, D.C. According to Wikipedia, the two had no common origin. I say the one in D.C. had a more legitimate claim to “National” as it had some federal government roots. Then there’s the Washington Nationals baseball team. And the Virginia neighborhood bogusly renamed “National Landing”. So pretty much anything can call itself “national” if it wants to.
- grubbs 3y ago
- s17n 3y agoWhat's going to happen to the money? The only reason I can think of to auction the bikes instead of donating them to another museum is that whoever controls the organization is planning to basically appropriate the cash.
- _moof 3y agoSeeing as how they're closing because they can't afford to stay open, I'd imagine the money will go to bills.
- nayuki 3y agoThe owners have the right to do sell the bikes and collect the cash. They can spend it for anything they wish - to start a new venture, to enjoy life, to light it on fire, whatever. That's the deal they entered into when they chose to become the owners of this collection. It's no different than if an individual sold a house or a baseball card. They can spend the cash however they like.
- psunavy03 3y agoThe internet always struggles with this concept.
- Ensorceled 3y agoYes, the internet always struggles when registered nonprofits with what must be millions in assets “go under” in ways where it is unclear what is happening to the assets.
- tass 3y agoIt’s a 501(c)(3) which doesn’t allow the board to spend the proceeds as they wish. Not an expert here, but from what I’ve read it seems anything left over must go towards charitable purposes.
- yial 3y agoIn theory, the funds should go to a nonprofit with a similar mission. I’m confused at the auction, unless no other museums of motorcycles wanted part of the collection.
- jzwinck 3y agoWhile we are recommending other motorcycle museums, I thoroughly enjoyed Museo Piaggio in Italy. It has quite a large collection, and it's free. It's easily reached by mass transit.
- okokwhatever 3y agoClosing museums is always a shame and a failure for a community and their administrators. Period.
- CalRobert 3y agoIt's a bummer but does it not go without saying that museums, like any institution, will come to an end at some point? I don't think that makes it a failure.
- michaelt 3y agoWell, some people think of museums as timeless - the sort of place we put 2000-year-old roman stuff, 5000 year old egyptian stuff, 200 million year old dinosaur stuff, and so on. Of course, the practical realities of most museums are a rather different matter; rent and employees have to be paid, and land in tourist-friendly areas is seldom cheap.
- jprete 3y agoI think car and motorcycle museums in particular live on the patronage of people who grew up when cars were symbols of independence and status, instead of a commodity. So the museums have nostalgic power for the customers, and that’s why they go. But that group is now 50+ years old, so I believe the lifespan of those museums is strictly limited.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoDepends; I think the state should have a fund to keep museums that aren't solvent around. A museum should never be dependent on capitalism, that is, ticket sales vs costs.
- matt_morgan 3y agoI've worked in and around museums for a long time and this topic comes up now and again. It occurred to me that if we think a museum should never close, then we'll never open up museums experimentally. There's no museum startup. I agree it's a shame for the community and the staff.
- sprobertson 3y agoThey could have used a better metaphor for the headline. Hanging up their helmet?
- cjrp 3y agoFlicking the killswitch
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoMaybe they could have advertised or something? Marketing is key for a place like that.
- radiorental 3y agoHere's a youtuber picking over the auction. You'll get to see the outside of the repurposed Walmart 'national museum', auction process and some really unique bikes. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DnX7hkZzLQ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DnX7hkZzLQ0 I get the feeling bikes in the last 5 years have turned into investment vehicles (pun intended) like rare bottles of wine and art. Often by people who have no personal interest in the chosen market, just a place to park money (again with the puns)
- fergie 3y agoTo be fair though- that guy definitely has a genuine interest in bikes, and the prices are way lower than for classic cars.
- radiorental 3y agoAll true, there was a few comments from other parties in that video where they noted a significant number of bikes were going for 2-3 times expected. Either there's a bubble in the rare bike market or an influx of money looking for somewhere to park.
- fergie 3y agoBuying a new bike today feels a bit like buying a Land Rover Defender in 2016. Or even a Seiko 5 today. Yes, its a new product, but its the technology of yesteryear. Its interesting to see the number of ~400cc 4-stroke "standard" bikes coming onto the market. They look and feel like bikes from the 50s. But it seems like in a couple of years utilitarian bikes will start to move towards electric drivetrains and consequently Surron-like designs. Its almost like we are in a 2-5 year window where you can still buy these museum pieces new from the dealership.
- Velofellow 3y agoMaybe they look like bikes circa 1950, but new standard bikes that look the part certainly do not ride like bikes from the 50's. Reliability across the board is dramatically better. ABS / associated rider aids, better tires (not just for motorcycles), suspension tuning, emissions technology, better engine output per displacement from high compression, better electronics. The list goes on. I'll take one old, one new please! Side note- Surron really needs to work on differentiating themselves away from the EBike scene, if I'm to take them seriously. I pretty much only see kids of affluent families destroying mixed use trails on Surrons or people forgoing any sort of judgement hoping between sidewalk, pavement, drainage ditches. "Mid-Drive Electric Bike you can ride anywhere" is an irresponsible sales pitch. I've not ridden one personally, but they seem roughly equivalent to a 125CC two stroke dirt bike. No Pedals? not a bike.
- javiramos 3y agoFor those in the Boston area, I recommend visiting the Larz Anderson museum. It’s a cute little museum with some automotive (and motorcycle) gems. https://larzanderson.org/ https://larzanderson.org/