6 ms·
I rented a Tesla for a month. It was a giant pain in the a*
- thghtihadanacct 3y agoI complain about tesla a lot but this article simply reads like a complaint from someone that rented an unfamiliar vehicle.
- vkou 3y agoI think it can generally be summarized as "In a desire to save costs, Tesla stuffed every single bit of instrumentation and input into a touchscreen. Which sucks."
- Empact 3y agoIt's not just to cut costs, it also means they can remotely update the interface as new features are introduced or new designs implemented.
- jkestner 3y agoThat’s cool in theory. How is the onboarding for new UI? I already don’t want to learn any new widgets on my phone, let alone a deadly tool like a car.
- worik 3y ago> they can remotely update the interface as new features are introduced And take away "features" you have already.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- akomtu 3y agoImagine you wake up one day, get into your car and realise that the manufacturer sent technicians overnight who have rearranged buttons on your dashboard, all without your permission.
- chrismcb 3y agoTrying to operate a touch screen WHILE driving more than "just sucks" it can also be dangerous. To make it worst the UI isn't very intuitive and is overly complicated
- MarkMarine 3y agoI rented a Volvo S90 to check out their driver assistance, and it was a similar experience after coming from a Tesla. Some of the way things work just didn’t make sense to me, but it wasn’t my car so I wasn’t used to them. An aside, the Volvo self driving was scary. Not ready for prime time. Surprising given their record for safety
- superhumanuser 3y agoI returned my S90 at the end of a two year lease. The self driving was frightening. It often drifted out of the lines then would jerk back into the lane then disable itself without warning. Also, the start/stop (or w/e it's called whereby the engine turns off when you stop) was such a jerky experience and sometimes it would turn off before I even came to a complete stop. The infotainment system was terribly slow and would take almost a minute after starting for it to become responsive. Typing into the nav was especially sluggish and unintuitive. One time the AC crashed (not the HVAC unit, the computer module) and I had to take it in for a software update to fix. The luxury, look and feel, and comfort were fabulous! The drivetrain and tech were trash!
- Tanoc 3y agoVolvo's been owned by Geely for a few years now, so any weird issues are inherited from them using Geely's home market technology. A lot of Chinese luxury automotive stuff seems to be looks first function second and it's been hitting Volvo hard with the S60 and S90.
- wk_end 3y agoThere's a number of interface conventions - especially about really important things - that "legacy" car manufacturers have standardized on but that Tesla jettisons. I frequently rent cars for travel, ride-share, etc., and while there's differences between them all, even if I can't figure out how to sync my phone (say), I can still drive any of them safely and comfortably within a matter of moments. Things like how a turn signal works are baked into my muscle memory. I haven't had the pleasure of driving a Tesla yet but wouldn't be surprised if the change-for-change's-sake is frustrating.
- hyperhello 3y agoPeople coming in green and using a product for the first time are the people you need to listen to the most. "Is this a car or a laptop?" is pretty solid feedback. He thought as a piece of technology, it was full of obscurantism and pretension, which wasn't his style. Complaints like not having a speedometer or turn signals are pretty understandable; the car's a poorly interfaced black box. That fits what I've heard about Teslas too (I'm going to test drive one this Sunday): they're fast but obnoxious.
- 38 3y ago> obscurantism damn thats a good word. I have known a lot of people like this, and they are really unpleasant to be around. I prefer the free flow of information and ideas.
- readthenotes1 3y ago>>obscurantism Eschew obfuscation!
- socks 3y agoto be honest, imo a test drive isn't enough. I test drove a Model 3 (was given 30 minutes), thought it was interesting, and might have considered buying one. A few weeks later I rented a Model Y for 12 days to go on a road trip with my family, and ended up absolutely hating it. And it wasn't because of the charging - that was quite pleasant - it was the constant beeping at me for the way I usually drive. Plus, overall, it just felt cheap, not sure how to describe it. The steering wheel feels too small, can't stand the buttons on the wheel, wish there was a small vibrate motor to tell me I'm going overspeed instead of noise (or nothing). No speed limiter which I find maddening (adaptive cruise control not suitable for city driving!). Basically, now I would never buy one, and the original test drive illuminated nothing
- Kaibeezy 3y ago> the constant beeping ... is why I hate renting cars these days. So many pings and you don’t even know why. You try to shut them off through layers of menus and then they go back to defaults the next time you start the car. Worst is the LDW dinging at you and jerking the wheel. Hyundai and Kia are egregious. F-off! And the map, reverting to zoomed-in-3D-direction-you’re-headed view after 30 seconds. Excuse me, Chrysler, but some of us understand maps better when they are flat, north is up, and there’s context. A memorable BMW shouting at me every time I exceeded the speed limit, in Dutch. The engine eco-shutting-off just when you’re about to dash across an intersection and a truck is coming. NDE. It used to be fun to try new things, now it’s just a headache.
- Laaas 3y agoMost of the complaints are "it's different" rather than having more substance. Tesla cars have issues, but not these.
- HPMOR 3y agoNot having physical buttons for things like windshield wipers, AC, and mirror controls, are very bad UX. Having all of these very important systems on a flat touchscreen require taking your eyes off the road to navigate these features. This is a serious safety hazard caused by Tesla's poor UX.
- acchow 3y agoCan't you just do it with voice commands?
- palmer_fox 3y agoI see this argument all the time. Any data to support it? Has AC UI caused many accidents and worsened road safety? Personally I find most physical AC controls in cars awkward to use. At least in Tesla I can set the direction of fans very precisely with a single finger. And forget about it for the rest of my life. We used to have physical cassette and CD players in every car that required - you won't believe it! - taking your eyes off the road.
- tharkun__ 3y agoI adjust fans all the time. Sometimes I want ice cold air blowing in my face. Half an hour later I may be annoyed by that or getting too cold because it's no longer 35C in the car but 23 and the air is making me shiver. Reverse in winter. I want the warm air to blow on me when it's -20C but once it's heated up I don't. A physical cassette or CD requires no taking your eyes off the road. I'd have a few of those around and would know which one is where and you can switch them by touch without looking. Just like I find buttons on the radio or other controls by feel. I know where things are from easy to find reference points like the edge of the middle concole.
- breadwinner 3y agoThe author complains about needing to go through on-screen UI to adjust the mirrors. Wait till he finds out that in the newest Tesla Model 3 you have to go on-screen UI to change gears!
- elkos 3y agoReally there's isn't a stick there? I'm not expecting manual in an electric or most hybrids but how are you supposed to reverse, neutral or park the thing?
- breadwinner 3y agoSupposedly, the car will correctly guess what gear you want to be in. Most of the time. So for example, if you press brakes to bring the car to a stop while in reverse gear, the car will guess that you want to be in forward gear next. If it doesn't guess correctly, there is on-screen UI to change the gear.
- maltalex 3y agoThat sounds like a recipe for hitting things by accidentally driving in the wrong direction.
- breadwinner 3y agoYes, pretty sure that's what will happen if I am the driver. Here's a video of this feature in action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TWdZYqiuecE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TWdZYqiuecE
- marssaxman 3y agoWow! That sounds maddening.
- ghaff 3y agoIt’s physical buttons on my ICE Honda Passport which is pretty efficient if it’s a fly by wire system anyone. If you want to switch forward gears manually which I rarely do it’s paddle shifters.
- arseneyr 3y ago> For example, in the default setting for when you reverse, the mirrors tilt to the ground so you can't use them to back up. That's to force you to use the image from the rear camera on the screen. Huh, didn't realize some people don't like this feature. I have it on my non-EV and it makes parallel and back-in parking much easier.
- sowbug 3y agoYeah, it's to make it easier to see the curb while parking, not to "force you" to do anything. Incidentally, looking at a side mirror while reversing is an excellent way to run over a child, no matter what kind of car it is.
- cameronh90 3y agoOn my 12 year old car, I manually point my mirrors at the ground when I'm reversing. I thought everybody did this. How else do you align yourself with the parking space? To see what's behind me, I mostly turn around to look. Too many blind spots to trust a mirror for that. However on newer cars with cameras, I am guessing they offer a less obstructed view.
- antisthenes 3y ago> On my 12 year old car, I manually point my mirrors at the ground when I'm reversing. What does this even mean?
- pruthvishetty 3y ago[flagged]
- codeTired 3y agoThis has to be the dumbest rant I read in a while.
- worik 3y ago* Knobs, please. I use touch to control the peripherals on my car. I do not want to take my eyes off the road * Analogue speed indicator. I know EVs do not need tachometers, so mēh, but the speed indication must be an analogue display. The data might be digital but my brain is not. * Door handles - well duh! * glove box with a knob (it is not a safe, I do not need a safe in my car, I do not lock my car in normal situations, it is not secure, trying to make it secure is asking your thief to destroy things they leave behind as well as steal the stuff they take away. I learnt that the hard way) * Data sharing default off. WTF? If you want my data - pay for it! The user interface of a car has developed over more than a century. Trying to change it all at once is stupid. It is hating your users. Disrespect for car users like this is not unique to Tesla.
- zzo38computer 3y agoI do not drive a car, but I agree, even as a passenger. I think it should have no data sharing at all (it should not connect to the internet, nor any radio communication other than that explicitly selected by the operator (AM and FM radio, receive only, with no software updates)). I also think that many parts should not need computers to operate (including the doors, windows, and lights). Furthermore, they should have manually operable windows. And, the different subsystems (e.g. driving, audio/clock, heating/cooling, etc) should be isolated from each other, to improve security and to allow powering off the subsystems which are not in use. And if you really want a locked glove box then I suppose you could add your own lock. I also don't like touch screens on other computers, whether or not it is in the car. But, at least the electric cars do not have the fuel, noise, exhaust, etc of other cars, so there is one advantage, but that could be done without all of the other problems, I think.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hindsightbias 3y agoElon probably would just say “ok, boomer” But I’m not sure what 20-somethings can afford his product.
- 3y ago
- Niksko 3y agoThere are two things going on here: * The author seems to be a bit older * The author drives an older car at home As a younger person who drives an old car, I too had to spend some time reading the car manual to figure out how to adjust things like automated breaking and steering assist when I rented a new model Camry on a trip earlier this year. The Tesla likely has even more features, but the idea that you can just jump in to a brand new car and understand everything about how to use it seems far fetched. Couple that with someone who is older and perhaps doesn't have as much intuition for digital user interfaces and you get what's in the article.
- etchasketch 3y ago>The author seems to be a bit older * The author drives an older car at home I mean, given the prices of cars nowadays, I highly suspect that any car buyer is going to be on the older side.
- Tanoc 3y agoThe safety features like forward emergency braking are relatively new and were forced to market quickly because of regulation. Between 1946 and 2016 the interface for a car was mostly the same, save for Citroen being weird until they were bought by Peugeot, and GM for that brief period in the late '80s where everything had to be a steering wheel "pod." The two biggest changes really were changing the headlight switch from a floor mounted pedal to a button or stalk knob starting in the '50s, and going from keyed ignition to push button start in the 2010s. Otherwise turn signals were on the left stalk and wipers were on the right, gas is on the right, brake center, clutch left, manual was 1,3,2,4,5,R (add or subtract gears as needed) and automatic was P, R, N, D, L, radio controls were left dial was power and volume while right dial was tuning, and the three dials below that controlled interior heat, A/C, and defrost. If you drove a car in 1973 and went into a coma you could wake up and drive a brand new car in 2003 no problems. If you went into a coma in 2003 you wouldn't be able to do the same with a 2023 car.
- anthonygd 3y ago> The Tesla likely has even more features, but the idea that you can just jump in to a brand new car and understand everything about how to use it seems far fetched. Tesla's just have terrible UX. Quit making excuses. I bought a 2021 Range Rover with all the safety features of a Tesla. It has sophisticated software with a big touchscreen but it also has knobs for the normal stuff. I was comfortable using the car immediately and found cool new features for a couple weeks. It was pleasant getting used to it.
- Spooky23 3y agoIn borrowed my sisters for a month when she was away and my car was in the shop. If you’re not invested (as far as putting $40k) it’s more irritating.
- uejfiweun 3y agoI'm still waiting for the point where EVs become objectively better than ICE cars in terms of range. Until then, I just won't even consider an EV. Like in the article it says it takes 45 minutes to charge even at a supercharger? No thanks. It would be acceptable if the actual range of the car was way ahead of ICE cars, but 450 KM (280 miles) is just not even close to your typical 16 gallon tank at 30 mpg. Other than fast acceleration I just see zero advantages to EVs. Believe me, I'm rooting for battery tech to improve dramatically just as much as anyone else, but after 20+ years of one hype-laden discovery after another with 0 to show for it, my hopes aren't exactly high.
- mingus88 3y agoRange anxiety goes away entirely if you have an L2 charger at home. I plug in at night and wake up with 300mi range in the morning. Way more than I need for every trip save one or two a year The biggest blockers to EV adoption IMO is all the folk who rent and won’t have access to a home charger.
- uejfiweun 3y agoYeah, I mean that is a big blocker. Housing is absurdly expensive in the bay area, I'll probably just have to leave eventually since my career has just progressed very averagely.
- breadwinner 3y agoI rented a Tesla Model 3 on a recent trip as well. I loved the car, mostly. I loved the instant torque. I loved the one-pedal driving (thanks to regenerative braking). Overall, a fantastic driving experience. The part I didn't like: I had to have the passenger help when I needed to adjust the AC. Most things need multiple touches on the screen, and given my unfamiliarity with the UI, I needed the passenger to help. If I had time to get familiar with the UI would I be comfortable with it? I am unsure. Despite this, I considered switching to Tesla. Then I read that in new Tesla 3, they are removing even more physical controls: the turn signal stalk is getting replaced with buttons, and the reverse-gear is now controlled through on-screen UI, so no stalk for that either. This made me change my mind. Elon Musk's philosophy is "best part is no part", but that doesn't necessarily match my expectations for driving experience.
- xtalx 3y agoI don’t think I’ve been in the super high end Tesla but every other one I’ve ridden in felt like an economy car. The seats are terrible and the suspension on those things is an abomination. I also severely dislike all the usual suspects… huge screen, no knobs. It’s like that “safe” spaceship in Futurama. I can understand making a totally utilitarian vehicle but Tesla isn’t in that price bracket. For the price, it should be a lot more comfortable.
- marcuspope 3y agoAs an owner of a model Y, I never access the screen for car features except for the glovebox, which I use maybe twice a year, while in park. I just get in and drive. Everything is automated and set to my preferences when I sit down. It’s frankly crazy how many knobs and buttons I press in my Sante Fe just to back out of the driveway. Every other complaint is applicable to any modern car, or even decades-old luxury cars for that matter. My 2011 Genesis had mirrors that angled down in reverse, it’s considered a safety feature for kids and animals. I guess if you care about these issues then don’t get a Tesla, but the notion that you need to fiddle with your car while driving is now foreign to me. Lights, temperature, heated seats, and wipers just do their thing when you expect them to. Turn signals turn off when you finish turning. Any music genre or artist ready at the press of a button on the wheel. I don’t know what else you would do while driving - or why you would want to. Complaining about the lack of an analog speedometer is something to be said about 1999, not 2023. But what it does say, is that there wasn’t anything more substantive to complain about. In my opinion that speaks volumes about how well the car was designed.
- BrandoElFollito 3y agoI've never driven a Tesla but this description indicates that it would be my dream car. All the ones I had suck so, so much on the electronics part that it is painful. It is like they were taking people who hate electronics to design it. I drive 1 year old Toyota RAV4 hybrid. Th screen is so awful I avoid looking at it before Android Auto starts. The features are from the 80's, like if it was a fake vintage car. A 1 year old SUV... OS on wheels, a dream.
- jiriro 3y agoThis is a rant from a lifelong windows user who got a mac and cries that “things are different here!”:-) The most hilarious part is “.. driving the car was not a problem”. His rant is basically - Oh, this is a new place. Why doesn’t it look like the places I already know?!