4 ms·
I was just talking today to someone about how they don't like food from a certain global coffee chain anymore because their food has gotten kinda crappy. Shrin
by hinkley 3y ago
I was just talking today to someone about how they don't like food from a certain global coffee chain anymore because their food has gotten kinda crappy.
Shrinkflation generally means same price for less product (grams, fluid ounces), but enshitification by slowly decreasing the quality of the ingredients is also a problem.
Do we put that under the shrinkflation umbrella or track it as a separate problem? Since they are both unwanted solutions to the same problem, seems like they should be kept together (to avoid a Goodhart's Law fiasco)
I recall eating an Oreo after fifteen years of not having one. At first I just thought I'd forgotten what they actually tasted like, but the more I thought about it, the more I could see a long chain of focus groups asking customers if cookie A and cookie B taste the same, if one tastes better, and slowly changing the formula to only alienate 0.2% of the customers each time until one day I wander up and find I'm part of the 10% they've cumulatively alienated.
See also how only some of us can taste certain artificial sweeteners as sugary toxic waste instead of sugar (saccharin tastes to me like drinking soda after licking a 9 volt battery)
- cogman10 3y agoJust one more factor to consider, some ingredients are no longer available. Trans fats are a good example of this. They used to be the prime replacement for saturated fats. Now, in the US, they are effectively banned. This hit oreos. [1] [1] https://www.orlandosentinel.com/2006/01/02/manufacturers-trim-trans-fats-from-popular-goodies/ https://www.orlandosentinel.com/2006/01/02/manufacturers-tri...
- hinkley 3y agoFair point. Were oreos always palm oil or were they lard back in the day? The fracking industry has made guar gum too expensive to use as a food emulsifier. I know someone who reacts to xanthan gum (which has all but replaced guar) and she's not a happy camper, because it's in fucking everything.
- skyyler 3y agoNo, they were partially hydrogenated soybean oil back in the day. Palm oil is thick at room temp, like partially hydrogenated oils are.
- smnrchrds 3y ago> Were oreos always palm oil or were they lard back in the day? They did use lard till mid 90s. https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2008/02/getting-lard-out-koshering-oreo-cookie https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2008/02/getting-lard-out-ko...
- aequitas 3y ago> but enshitification by slowly decreasing the quality of the ingredients is also a problem. Every time you see a package with “new and improved recipe” you can bet it only improved their margins by using cheaper ingredients, not the actual taste.
- amelius 3y agoHow is that possible if the rock solid theory underlying the free market promises us better products? /s
- shaftoe 3y agoActually, free markets do lead to better products. But they cost more than the worse products. Look at coffee. The gradual shift from Arabica to more Robusta beans over a generation. Each year, an imperceptible shift was taken that, over decades, lead to coffee that tastes terrible. Opening the door for companies like Starbucks and a ton of gourmet roasters to compete. But properly roasted, single origin coffee costs more than Chock-full-o'nuts. So you have options.
- hinkley 3y agoI react poorly to some coffees and not others. I've been told by people who claim to know that some people can't stomach Robusta as well as they can Arabica. And I'll be damned if I know how to track which one I'm actually getting. I've surrendered and just drink tea and chai now.
- amelius 3y agoThe only thing that Starbucks did for coffee was that children now also love to drink it. In fact their coffee doesn't taste like coffee, but more like mocha/hazelnut ice cream.
- Retric 3y agoToday’s Starbucks is well removed from its origins. Starbucks was never great coffee, but I’ve heard it started out pretty decent. Much like how McDonalds, KFC, etc started by making decent food so did Starbucks. Add 40+ years of optimizing for the bottom line and the average person’s pallet and you get a very different product.
- amelius 3y ago> Do we put that under the shrinkflation umbrella No we call it just that, enshittification.
- krapp 3y ago>No we call it just that, enshittification. I'll be glad when this juvenile meme finally passes out of Hacker News' system.
- hinkley 3y agoIt's basically 'race to the bottom' but that term is not very inspirational. It's not evoking any kind of reaction in the masses.
- krapp 3y agoNeither is "enshittification." Only HN and some tech bloggers even use it as far as I know, and mostly just to be able to imply something is "turning into shit" while pretending to use a precise term of art. But it isn't, it's a poop joke.
- Cincinnati2 3y agoI agree with Krapp.
- hinkley 3y agoI mean, how can I argue with krapp about shit? I’m out of my depth clearly.
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- londonReed 3y agoI'll do my best to keep it going, unless you have a better term. Enshittification clearly communicates the point trying to be made.
- _sys49152 3y agomy sensory skills are on point. its beyond infuriating when i notice a change in a food or drink product, hop online and search for the others with the pitchforks to join in with - only to find crickets.wav.
- zerd 3y agoI've been buying the exact same pair of boxers for years. This year I noticed that they were actually smaller, by almost an inch. Elastic band is smaller and the actual length, so it started chafing. Shrinkflation even on clothes.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoHeh.. I'd like to blame my boxers getting tighter on the same thing but I'm pretty sure it's just my waistline that's grown
- hinkley 3y agoWhen Levi’s moved to Mexico it wasn’t that the sizes got smaller, it was that they got inconsistent. Before I started shopping around for more responsible brands, I enjoyed the privilege of being able to walk into a department store and simply buy jeans based on the label. No dressing room. After I had three pairs of the same sized jeans that varied from uncomfortable to comfortable. Tolerances matter.
- pnt12 3y agoI've heart the term "skimoflation". There have been posts on HN about it.