7 ms·
Google says it can’t fix Pixel Watches, please just buy a new one
- Clent 3y agoImagine if this was Apple saying this. It would be a top story across the web.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoIs there any factual information that Apple actually repairs your broken iWatch, or do they just replaces it with a brand new one, and then throws your broken one in the e-waste bin?
- goober24 3y agoThey most certainly repair them. You can get AppleCare on the watches and they'll repair devices outside of AppleCare for a fee - going all the way back to the first watch.
- fragmede 3y agoPedantically, with Applecare+, they don't. They confirm warranty status, accept the old watch, and give you a new one of similar vintage. https://support.apple.com/watch/repair/express-replacement https://support.apple.com/watch/repair/express-replacement
- paulmd 3y agothey don't repair it with you in the store, they send it back to a service center for refurbishment, but they do absolutely refurbish and repair units in house, and this stream ends up as other people's replacement refurbs, or on the apple refurb store, or sold in emerging markets.
- turquoisevar 3y agoThat’s a special service they offer with AC+ but not the only option (would be a problem if it was because they require a hold on your card of the amount of a new retail one to ensure you don’t fuck around). That said, most repairs are done offsite so anything they can’t do on the spot they just trade you a refurbished one and do it on their own time offsite. I say “refurbished” but Apple calls it a “replacement” model. This seems like a distinction without a difference at first but Apple has two streams, “refurbished” and “replacement”. The former you’ll see on their refurbished shop and might have minor signs of usage, the latter is used in their replacement process and always looks like a brand new one that you buy new (even though the fine print says it could have signs of usage). I always prefer replacement over repair if I have the choice, because you’re essentially handed a new device. In rare cases, > 3 coming back for the same issue, they’ll simply give you a new current retail model if your issue seems tied to a design issue in the model you own (e.g. this happened sometimes with the MBP GPU issue and later with the keyboard issue) so it always pays to keep badgering them if your issues aren’t resolved.
- dieortin 3y agoThey replace it with a new one, and recycle the components.
- mholm 3y agoIt appears that the screen and battery are both fairly straightforward replacements, about as easy as any modern smartphone. It would shock me if they weren't performing these repairs.
- renewiltord 3y agoThey do replace it, but it costs about $100. The watch itself can be had for $299.
- corbezzoli 3y agoPretty sure that's what happens with AppleCare+ https://support.apple.com/watch/repair/express-replacement https://support.apple.com/watch/repair/express-replacement
- AndrewGaspar 3y agoI can tell you from personal experience they will not repair Apple Watches - they recycle them and charge a pretty hefty replacement fee if you do not have AppleCare+. I had a Stainless Steel Apple Watch Series 6 just outside the 1 year warranty. The display came dis-attached from the frame, either because the adhesive failed, or the battery had swollen. Like, literally I was just driving down the road and the display started hanging off the watch from its flex. The Apple Store wanted $400 to replace it - would not even evaluate a repair.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoYeah, if you're out of warranty, Apple's m.o. is also to just buy a new device as they don't repair them or they quote you a cost to "repair it" that's as much as a new product, to discourage you from that track and encourage you to buy a new one instead.
- kube-system 3y agohttps://www.apple.com/shop/refurbished/watch https://www.apple.com/shop/refurbished/watch
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoIt says nothing there that they actually repair broken iWatches. "Refurbished" doesn't necessarily mean "repaired" but usually come from the pool of devices in good condition that have been returned in the 30 day period or traded in for an upgrade, but they are never "broken" to need repairs.
- kube-system 3y agoThey quote different prices to replace batteries vs other repairs, so I suspect that the process is: if(dirty || badBattery || badAccessories) { repair() } else { recycle() } And they also mention for other products that include new housings, which they don't say for the Apple Watch. So I suspect that cracking them open for anything more than a battery replacement would make labor exceed the cost of the entire unit. Because these are relatively cheap devices that are labor intensive to work on.
- lern_too_spel 3y agoApple has been doing the same thing since the Apple Watch launched. It was never a top story across the web.
- auguzanellato 3y agoThey provide replacement with ~reasonable prices, they only charge around 100$ for a "battery replacement" despite them replacing the whole watch.
- lern_too_spel 3y agoThis article is about screen replacement, which Apple charges quite a bit more for, more than the total cost of a Pixel Watch. Battery replacement does not require replacing the whole watch for Pixel Watch. https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Google+Pixel+Watch+Battery+Replacement/160348 https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Google+Pixel+Watch+Battery+Repl...
- RankingMember 3y agoI loved my Pixel, but Google's customer service experience is so poor that it completely drove me away from the line altogether. Doesn't look like things have gotten any better since I went to Apple (which definitely has problems of its own but at least has listened to critiques and responded in the past).
- pierat 3y agoGoogle has customer service?
- _ea1k 3y agoHonestly, the few times that I've needed for a Pixel, it has been pretty decent. It does depend on where you've bought it from, though. The Google Store has decent support in my experience.
- RankingMember 3y agoMine was from Google Store fwiw
- Jigsy 3y agoIt did, but like everything else Google does, they killed it after a few years.
- jacobsenscott 3y agoI've only ever needed support with google fi (their cell phone service), and their chat was responsive and helpful. Maybe their other support teams are not as good, idk.
- lph 3y agoSame. I had a terrible experience with Google CS and the original Pixel, which I ended up throwing in the garbage after less than a year because it was defective and they wouldn't do anything about it. Will never make that mistake again.
- adocomplete 3y agoWhy bother implementing great customer support when it's going to be sunsetted altogether in a few years anyway. Google just doesn't get or care about customer support in my experience.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- brandall10 3y agoI had such a terrible experience w/ Google CS from owning a Nexus 5 10 years back that it drove me away from their hardware products entirely.
- wombat-man 3y agoIt kinda got better with Pixel. I broke the screen on my 3, took it to an authorized repair store, somehow they broke motherboard. Since an authorized repair store screwed it up, they let me swap for a refurbished one. It took a couple weeks but I got a new-ish phone for free since everything was refunded. But I think the thing to do is get the extended warranty. They'll just swap you out. Wish they were a little tougher though.
- borg16 3y agothey are a software company trying to build some hardware. they also seem to not be learning anything from customers' negative feedback
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoI wonder how samsung's galaxy smart watch compares? I'd never own an apple watch because I'd never want an apple phone, but I might someday consider getting a smart watch. Seems the options are the galaxy watch or ...nothing?
- jklinger410 3y agoSamsung products are just data harvesting schemes built on top of Google products.
- nickthegreek 3y agoMaybe Garmin or Fitbit if you need only specific features or really want that battery life. Edit: Forgot Google bought Fitbit, but I still would bet Fitbit outlasts the Pixel Watch.
- veb 3y agoGo Garmin! You won't regret it.
- transitionnel 3y agoTry a used series 4 from eBay if you're curious. They have the same processor as the 5 and 6, and are dirt cheap. For me it's been good enough to overcome "I could take it or leave it" - it's handy for reading alerts without pulling out the phone, and Google Assistant even works most of the time. It's also nice to keep the phone on silent and just get a buzz on the wrist for calls and alarms. Plus smarthome integration if you do that.
- amoshi 3y agoSamsung Galaxy Watch6 has a newer chipset https://www.gsmarena.com/compare.php3?idPhone1=11045&idPhone3=12437&idPhone2=11748 https://www.gsmarena.com/compare.php3?idPhone1=11045&idPhone...
- Moldoteck 3y agogarmins are ok now too. Imo, their button offering like forerunner 245 is superior to touch interface of samsung/apple, gives some vibes of pebble
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thefurdrake 3y agoThe Pixel Watch always came across as half-baked trend chasing to me, so it's not surprising that Google would have flaccid support for it. ...And they'll probably abandon it or sell the business to squarespace in a couple years anyway.
- adeon 3y agoAfter my iPhone dropped into a pool last month I commandeered and wiped a Google Pixel 4a I had used as a work phone in the past. Oopsidoopsie, it went out of support last month and no longer has guaranteed security updates. This phone was released in 2020. Mine is barely used. I was a bit WTF when I found out. From an older article I found off Internet, Google justifying this policy: """ In response to an email asking Google why it stopped supporting the Pixel 3, a Googles spokesperson said, “We find that three years of security and OS updates still provides users with a great experience for their device.” """ Mine is still usable because you still get app updates and it's not like it stops just working but it's a bit uncomfortable to use out-of-security-updates phone. Waiting until the new iPhones get out next week. Why can't companies support their products for a longer time. I've heard the best way to reduce e-waste is to keep using the stuff you have as long as possible.
- Sharlin 3y ago> I've heard the best way to reduce e-waste is to keep using the stuff you have as long as possible. Of course. It's always been "reduce, reuse, repair" before "recycle". But there's a reason corpos want you to focus on the least efficient way to reduce waste and ignore the others.
- _ea1k 3y agoThe excuse has been driver and firmware support from the vendors. Google has extended security updates to 5 years for the newer Pixels. That's fairly decent, given that each one is only on the market for ~1 year. Obviously the cycle has to be longer for companies that keep older phones on the market as a lower cost option.
- ethbr1 3y agoIn the US, at least, I wouldn't be surprised if there's a ton of pressure to limit update timeframe from the carriers. US carriers want postpaid customers, because they're more profitable and less likely to churn. Having an incentive to swap phones at the end of a (typically 2 year) phone upgrade cycle helps them sell renewals back into a new postpaid plan. Google, in typical Google fashion, probably doesn't care. It's used to end users not being its actual customers.
- JohnFen 3y agoIf I can't fix it when it breaks, I'm not going to buy it in the first place.
- bhewes 3y agoI have a pixel watch and I smash it on things all the time, door knobs being one since I am short and it doesn't break. Maybe by the third version there will be enough second hand watches to warrant a repair program. Its the cheapest watch I have owned in 20 years.
- windex 3y agoNon repairable devices should be hit with massive environment related taxes.
- jeffbee 3y agoA carbon embodiment tax is way easier. The reason we don't have one is the embodied carbon tax would have to be 100,000x higher for a Rivian EV than it would be for a smartwatch, while superficial 20th century environmentalist doctrine concentrates on the relatively negligible portion of "e-waste".
- biogene 3y agoIdeally you will have a different definition of repairability for each category of devices or even per-manufacturer. Policy wise, the problem is the specificity of the legal language/phrasing. To me the easier approach is to make exclusive supplier contracts illegal in the retail segment. A third party repair shop should be able to buy the same parts as Google and offer a repair service if Google is unable to provide one.
- tombert 3y agoI was mugged about two months ago, and had my iPhone 12 Pro Max stolen from me [1]. Not wanting to spend $1000+ for a new iPhone, I figured I'd just get a Pixel 7 Pro since it's a bit cheaper and I never really considered myself an Apple loyalist. Going to Android, however, meant my Apple Watch would not be terribly useful anymore, so I was left with the decision of "do I buy a Google watch, or do I just go back to one of my 'dumb watches'?" I opted for the latter, and now I'm kind of glad I did. The watch I am wearing right now is a Casio from 2016 that still works fine, doesn't need to be recharged every day, and ironically I can get fixed by a whole bunch of places for a very cheap rate should it ever break. Obviously it doesn't do as much as the Apple or Pixel watches do, but honestly I wasn't using most of the features in the Apple Watch anyway, and for telling time I actually think the Apple Watch kind of sucks. Also, for those wondering, I really really hate the Pixel 7 Pro. [1] Before anyone says anything, I have reported the phone stolen to both Apple and the NYC police, and they have all the relevant IMEI stuff so in theory it shouldn't be turning up in any kind of black market.
- bkandel 3y agoAnalog watches are the best.
- tombert 3y agoI agree, though I think I'm happier with quartz analog over automatic/mechanical. They're generally cheaper, keep just as good (if not better) time, and usually can have more complications for a lower price. Granted, I don't really use the complications either, but I think they look cool on the watch face :)
- slim 3y agoand they can use solar energy. so no baatery swap every 3 years and the watch does not stop working if removed from your wrist
- CobaltFire 3y agoI picked up a Garmin Instinct Crossover for this reason. Absolutely loving having a normal set of hands, charging once a month (depending on my workout schedule can be once a week), and still having all of my features.
- superdude12 3y agoI needed a new mounting plate for my Nest Protect Smoke + CO Monitor. I was out of warranty and Google support gave me a run around saying they don't sell that part and I would need to buy a whole new Nest Protect. After complaining a bit they caved and sent me.... a whole new Nest Protect. How can you be so against providing spare parts? There are only a few required for the whole product.
- whynotmaybe 3y agoBecause they don't keep inventory of spare parts. Devices cost a few $. I guess that managing a warehouse for spare for all their products would cost way too much. I'm sure they don't make spare at all. They just buy one complete product made and packaged in Asia.
- bombcar 3y agoIt's an annoyance for them to track SKUs, it's almost as complicated to track spare parts as whole parts, and they just are not a manufacturer, but instead three kids and a dog in a trench coat pretending to be one. I give up and just use eBay for parts.
- aaomidi 3y agoHow does this compare to the Apple Watch?
- fckgw 3y agoApple will service Apple Watches back to the Series 2 https://support.apple.com/watch/repair https://support.apple.com/watch/repair
- aaomidi 3y agoThis service is effectively replacing the watch (and the price is high unless you have the Apple care plus). https://www.ifixit.com/Device/Apple_Smartwatch https://www.ifixit.com/Device/Apple_Smartwatch Has some guides
- fckgw 3y agoDepends on the service needed. Battery swap is $79 or $99 which is still much less than the cost of a new unit. Point is that they will provide some sort of service for you until it hits "obsolete" status which is 7 years.
- MBCook 3y agoPlus the old one doesn’t go in the trash, it gets recycled.
- turquoisevar 3y agoThey’ll provide service on any Apple device for up to 7 years, provided parts are available. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201624 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201624
- iamleppert 3y ago> “We find that three years of security and OS updates still provides users with a great experience for their device.” I find that I will never purchase any Google products and encourage others to not also.
- biogene 3y agoI think its OK if they can't fix it. The problem comes when companies like Apple (don't know about Google) block right-to-repair legislation, or block access to parts for third-party repair or generally spread FUD about third-party repair.
- turquoisevar 3y agoSo you’re ok with the company that sells it to you not being able to fix it and dropping support, but the company that provides repair services up to 7 years and battery replacements for Macs up to 10 years is somehow worse than that because they refuse to provide access to parts to third party repair shops that don’t join their program? Again let me recap here: - company that drops support, with no access to parts at all - company that provides support for almost a decade and limited access to parts And somehow you see that and say that the first one is better? Nuts.
- dns_snek 3y agoThat's a very disingenuous recap, the commenter was complaining about Apple opposing and derailing right to repair legislation. Apple doesn't just refuse to provide parts either, they're increasingly serializing parts such that perfectly working components from 2 brand new Apple devices can't be swapped between them. Not that Google is any better, they're all inexcusably terrible, anti-consumer, e-waste generating operations.
- turquoisevar 3y agoThe commenter said “Shit action is Ok, but boy that other company is worse” and that just doesn’t compute for me. > Apple opposing and derailing right to repair legislation I guess you didn’t hear the latest news[0]? > they're increasingly serializing parts A pedantic minor correction: they haven’t so much increased it as people have started noticing stuff that had been serialized prior > such that perfectly working components from 2 brand new Apple devices can't be swapped between them They can be swapped, the device doesn’t block it outright or refuses to boot (with the exception of biometrics). The problem is that some of the calibration and configuration is component specific, so in certain cases a replacement has unintended consequences, which, because it’s Apple, gets explained a purposeful attempt by Apple to break non-authorized repairs. Personally to me this is rather hilarious notion because Apple isn’t known to be shy about being explicit in their messaging, case in point would be the messaging when replacing a battery. The simple fact of the matter is that calibration is simply part of the repair and if not done, the repair isn’t done properly. It’s the same as replacing your tires without aligning them and then blaming the car manufacturer for all the vibrations you feel during your rides. Just about now the conversation then shifts to who gets access to calibration tools. Currently Apple, Apple Authorized Service Providers, independent repair shops that are part of the free Independent Repair Provider Program and customers using the Self Service Repair service have access to these tools. That covers pretty much all scenarios, with the exception being cowboys that want to go at it alone because they don’t want to subject their skills to any form of scrutiny. I think it stands to reason that they then use their unimpeachable skills to transfer the control chip that holds the calibration data. 0: https://www.theverge.com/2023/8/23/23843506/apple-california-right-to-repair-sb-244 https://www.theverge.com/2023/8/23/23843506/apple-california...
- _aavaa_ 3y agoI hadn't actually seen a photo of the pixel watch before. Gotta say, I like the look of the Pixel watch more than the apple watch. It reminds my of the Type 3 [0], but a little bit cheaper. [0]: https://ressencewatches.com/pages/type-3 https://ressencewatches.com/pages/type-3
- RichardCA 3y agoThe Samsung Watch 4 Classic had a rotating bezel, gave it a nice look and also practical. https://www.xda-developers.com/samsung-galaxy-watch-4-classic-review/ https://www.xda-developers.com/samsung-galaxy-watch-4-classi... The lack of a bezel is probably part of why the Pixel Watch is so damage-prone.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoI don’t think it look any more bezel-less than the newer Apple Watches.
- breakds 3y agoI bought a google nest hub on my office desk specifically for having meetings with Google Meet. Yesterday it tells me I can no longer do that after Sep 28. WTF.
- tamimio 3y agoAnd then apple attacked for planned obsolescence.. honestly, after I was an android user since smartphones became a thing after Nokia, I switched to Apple since 2017 and never looked back, the only company that used Android and I really liked was HTC (still have my HTC M8 with lineageOS), but it isn’t competing now, and the state of other androids phone is much worse than Apple, bloated and fragmented, and very poor on updates especially on security updates, sure, you might get a nice moon shot -that turned out to be AI generated, but I have a telescope for that.
- hnburnsy 3y agoLook up the cluster f that is the Fitbit Charge 5. Between this and Nest, Never buying Google hardware again.