4 ms·
I'm kind of lost trying to understand this. Wouldn't make more sense to just heat the water directly and make a steam thruster? What does the electrolizing step
by marcosdumay 3y ago
I'm kind of lost trying to understand this. Wouldn't make more sense to just heat the water directly and make a steam thruster? What does the electrolizing step gain? (They claim not to store the gases, so it can't be decoupling the steps.)
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoMy guess is that the energy required to dissociate H2O into 2H and O is less than to change the state of H2O from liquid to gas. [edit] Quick research shows that no, that's not right! But the article says "feed the gases into a thruster." Are they burning them at that point?
- NortySpock 3y agoYes, I think so. Water gets you dense, room-temperature propellent storage. Big solar panels give you lots of excess power. Converting small amounts of water into gas as it's needed and then burning it means you don't need to plan to store cryogenic liquid hydrogen.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoSo basically a cool way to turn electricity into thrust!
- r2_pilot 3y agoI really hate being pedantic here, but it's ultimately using mass for thrust instead of being a pure photon rocket (which arguably is also expelling energy which has mass but in this particular case you're expelling momentum - and probably causing smarter people than me to groan in exasperation at my description).
- xeonmc 3y agoOr more like using water as a form of capacitor, since electrolysis only require voltage and can be run at any power, whereas thrust is something where you want immediate demand of power
- perihelions 3y ago- "to just heat the water directly" Recombination of hydrogen/oxygen gives you flame temperatures far north of >3,000 K. This is probably the simplest way to "just heat the water", in this temperature range. I imagine a "conventional" 3,000 K heat exchanger (for example, electric-resistive) would be very difficult to engineer. (Those also exist, and you can look up "resistojet" to find alternative approaches to compare against. As best as I can tell, those tend to operate at much lower temperatures; and the high-performing ones use hydrazines as their (mono)propellant, boosting the final temperature by exothermic chemical decomposition. I might have misunderstood the literature).
- marcosdumay 3y agoInteresting. Resistorjets seem to be all over the place. There must be some simplicity factor that makes the circuits we use on the ground unfit to space. Because people build 3000K heaters all the time (usually arc-based, but also, a light-bulb is one).