8 ms·
California passes bill to make it easier to delete data from data brokers
- notfried 3y agoThe article doesn't make opt-out very clear. If you submit a request and ask to opt out of future tracking, are the data brokers able to re-collect your data on the next day and keep/use/share it for 45 days till the next deletion cycle?
- jeffbee 3y ago> after a consumer has submitted a deletion request and a data broker has deleted the consumer’s data pursuant to this section, the data broker shall delete all personal information of the consumer at least once every 45 days pursuant to this section unless the consumer requests otherwise https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CIV§ionNum=1798.140 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio....
- doctorpangloss 3y agoWell fortunately 45 days is within the time span of attributing a click (30 days) and with the best algorithms, you only need about 3 days of behavioral activity of each person to forecast LTV correctly on an aggregate of just dozens of people. So I can’t say this law will have a big impact on the industries that use this data (besides red tape). Can’t really comment on how effective or ineffective it is for the consumer though.
- jeffbee 3y agoNo version of this bill was ever known as "Delete Act". Press outlets just invented that. There is a proposed federal "DELETE Act" with a similar purpose.
- ceejayoz 3y agoAt least one CA Senator called it the "Delete Act". https://sd13.senate.ca.gov/news/in-the-news/september-1-2023/what-the-california-delete-act-means-consumers https://sd13.senate.ca.gov/news/in-the-news/september-1-2023... So does the EFF: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/08/californias-delete-act-protects-us-data-brokers https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/08/californias-delete-act... And the LA Times: https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2023-09-14/california-bill-delete-online-personal-data https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2023-09-14/california...
- hollerith 3y agoMight this law make it too risky for HN to continue its policy that comments are not editable or deletable after 2 hours unless the site owner / admin manually edits or deletes?
- jeffbee 3y agoThe regulation applies to data brokers, those without a direct relationship with the person in question, who sell information about that person to a third party. I don't see how that applies to a site like this one, where users have a direct relationship and the worthless accumulated corpus is freely available.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe CCPA does grant a right to data deletion, but I'm not sure if YC technically counts under the 100k user / $25M revenue criteria.
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoThis will be great! ...for California! Anyone who thought that California's "Do Not Sell My Data" requirements would cause websites to tamp down on the data collection nationwide were sorely disappointed when sites simply implemented an IP Address check to only display the option if they were in California. Other states followed suit, and sites amended their logic to show the banner in California, Virginia, etc. They are going to cling to data vacuuming for as wide and as long as they can.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoIt's interesting how so many sites deployed cookie banners even if you weren't in the EU, but decided to only display this option if your IP address is located in California. Yet another use case for VPNs...
- mysterydip 3y agoI actually just saw on an insurance website today "opt our of sharing your data: (california residents only)"
- jslpc 3y agoHonestly, I live in Los Angeles and feel like I never even see these California-specific opt-out banners. I typically reject all but essential cookies on every website that prompts me, but never see anything related to the CCPA, which is a shame because I really do want to utilize it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- srsqsonyl 3y agoWithout giving everyone read rights, this is still pretty much “take their word for if”. I have no doubt California businesses will immediately ship data outside California and play dumb.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoMoving the servers that store Californians' data out of California doesn't move Californians out of California. How could they play dumb?
- aliwejrlia 3y agoI'm all in favor of this bill, I think it's an important step in the right direction, but let's temper our expectations and replace "will" with "should" or "might" in the headline.
- Simulacra 3y agoPerhaps I'm a radical, but if you do not have a current ongoing direct relationship with the company, then that company should not be able to store and sell your private data. I realize this is probably very contrary to Silicon Valley business models, but I think the issue requires a hard line or else people will just violate it.
- cgriswald 3y agoI don't think you are radical enough. I want to own my data and allow companies to collect and lease it in exchange for money, goods, or services. I want to be able to sue anyone who uses this data without explicit permission with option for punitive damages. I want mechanisms to control my data and I don't see that happening without signed contracts. I want to control what data is collected and how it can be used. I want this in writing in clear language in terms that cannot be changed until the contract termination date, some other specified period (with option to terminate), or with my signed consent. I also want the option to object to the sale of data to particular buyers. And I want the option to have the data deleted when my contract is terminated or when the company is sold. I think the current hodge-podge of laws surrounding this don't come close to this kind of control and to the degree that they do, they're mostly a lot of work for the consumer; more opt-out than opt-in. Companies rely on people mostly not really knowing what they're doing with data and changing their privacy policies on a whim because how many people really read all these changes or leave? I'm not sure I've really seen any mass migration on privacy policies (although I have seen that on 'we own all your stuff forever' type TOS changes).
- EMCymatics 3y ago[flagged]
- lesuorac 3y agoI mean what if I want to outsource payroll to say Equifax? That would require sharing private data about employees with Equifax so that they're able to handle paying them. Or if I want to ship a package to somebody; can I not give a 3rd party (DHL) the recipients address? I like your idea but I think it needs some refinement. Perhaps just a time restriction; although I'm sure DHL would love to keep a photo proving that the package was delivered for a year.
- _8j50 3y agoThe thing this and other privacy laws don't take into account is data derived or mined from the consumer data. Tech companies are smart enough to transform the data just enough to where deleting the original data will have no impact on monetization. For example, any ML models trained on user data must be retrained when specific users' data is deleted.
- gagege 3y agoSo every 45 days, the CPPA will tell these companies to delete your data. I wonder how many people realize that that means the CPPA or these companies have to keep a record of some of your PII, so that they can look you up and delete you from the database. Maybe privacy conscious people are fine with the California government keeping their PII?
- contravariant 3y agoNot sure you know what CPPA stands for. Your objection makes little sense.
- phendrenad2 3y agoIt stands for the California Privacy and Protection Agency, right?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- contravariant 3y agoYeah turns out it was my reading comprehension that failed in this instance...
- phendrenad2 3y agoOh but the government won't become a new data broker and sell our data to 3rd parties, right? https://hallboothsmith.com/california-dmv-sells-personal-information/ https://hallboothsmith.com/california-dmv-sells-personal-inf...
- menus 3y agoYour DNA too https://www.cbsnews.com/news/california-biobank-dna-babies-who-has-access/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/california-biobank-dna-babies-w...
- jkubicek 3y ago
- blueridge 3y agoQuestion: has anyone used tools like DeleteMe and Optery to remove their data from the web? Curious to hear thoughts, opinions, experiences. https://joindeleteme.com/ https://joindeleteme.com/ https://www.optery.com/ https://www.optery.com/
- PonderingPirate 3y agoI can confirm that DeleteMe works.
- dheera 3y agoI used OneRep for a while, but moved to Optery after finding OneRep seemed to be a bit shady.
- Vinnl 3y agoWhat seemed shady about OneRep?
- opteryology 3y agoOneRep has affiliate partnerships with data brokers (https://imgur.com/a/juSC66b https://imgur.com/a/juSC66b).
- Vinnl 3y agoAh, thanks for sharing that.
- opteryology 3y agoThere are a couple of in-depth threads here on HN discussing the different companies you mentioned. Here is one in particular that includes some people sharing reviews, plus Optery's CEO going into detail on the different data removal companies: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30605010 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30605010 If you're interested in these services, a good approach is to sign up for each company’s free scan and compare the results. Full disclosure: I am on the team at Optery
- scrollaway 3y agoLet this be referred to as the “Californian Transparent Removal Legislation”. That way we can call it CTRL Act Delete :)
- febra_ 3y agoWatch HN posters scramble to find a reason to bash this because it has been pushed by California
- fpgaminer 3y agoI've been quite pleased with California and the CCPA thus far. I've submitted a few deletion requests a now, and despite my jadedness all but one went through without a hitch. I reported the one to the California AG and within two weeks the AG had followed up on it and forced the company to delete my data and the company fixed their processes. Color me slightly less jaded. Of course, it's all still a manual process. Requiring that the deletion of PII be a "single button click" would be great. And making all data collection opt-in, instead of forcing me to fill out Do Not Sell My Data forms on every single website. But the Act mentioned in this article will be the third "Change Logs" we've gotten to the CCPA since its passing seven years ago. So, again, color me less jaded; it seems California is slowly and steadily clawing back our rights. Good on us!
- johndhi 3y agoCouldn't disagree more as someone who works in tech and guides companies in complying with laws like this. So expensive for so little real gain. We're spending more on making companies who don't use your data for anything nefarious (basically all companies outside of the advertising industry, if you even consider advertising nefarious) than we're spending on fixing climate change. Or preventing war. What a joke. Edit: looks like this law applies specifically to self defined 'data brokers' (no one can find these entities IME and no one admits they are one) so at least it's somewhat targeted. Comment stands for CCPA and CPRA, which apply to all "businesses."
- whelp_24 3y agoDo you not feel privacy is worthwhile? Do you believe that these companies aren't collecting data for advertising reasons?
- johndhi 3y agoHi - good questions. In general I think some privacy concerns are valid and others are not. Specifically I believe government surveillance is problematic and I wish there were more visibility and restrictions on it. I do believe many companies are collecting data for reasons other than advertising. For example CRM tools (eg Salesforce) have heaps of personal information their customers store with them for a bunch of different reasons. It's really complex for them to comply with these laws - even though they aren't doing any advertising.
- endisneigh 3y agoI'm curious how this will work if we want to delete our data from this site. Will children posts be deleted, or will it just say [deleted]. Furthermore, if someone trains an AI on your data, does the AI have to be "untrained?" If not, I doubt this will have too much effect for some applications.
- johndhi 3y agoNo untraining. But it can't go into the next round of training.
- endisneigh 3y agohow could that possibly be enforced though?
- johndhi 3y agoHmm I guess the idea is you have a db of training data that you need to flow deletes into. That db contains personal information so you need to keep it up to date. The model itself, once trained, doesn't contain personal information hence no requirement to retrain it.
- bob1029 3y agoI've gained a tremendous amount of respect for PII while selling software to banks. My position on this type of data is that I am simply a temporary custodian over it. The identifiable person owns this information. I recognize it as pure liability for us. All downside in our business models. We go out of our way to keep this stuff out of our systems. We spent the better part of a month talking about various architectures that would "keep the mess over there" (aka inside the bank's 'secure' environment). The closest we get to liability is storing salted & hashed PII so that we can correlate business keys within sessions. If we find a piece of PII actually makes it through our layers of redaction, it is treated similar to production going down. Our entire team is trained to respond to a PII incident as if it were a radiation leak at a nuclear power plant.
- ptmcc 3y agoThis is the path to enlightenment. The best way to protect PII is to ruthlessly minimize it in your system. Better for compliance and better for customer security. And get to avoid whole sections of scrutiny and review when infosec comes knocking.
- happytiger 3y agoAs someone who’s dealt with vast troves of PII, you clearly speak from deep experience.
- jjav 3y ago> The best way to protect PII is to ruthlessly minimize it in your system. Absolutely, been trying to preach this for ~10 years now at various companies. Another argument to make is that I can guarantee 100% certainty against leaks with a budget of $0, for all the data columns that I never had. Such a deal! Any other choice is going to cost a lot more and have reduced chance of success. Sure, we need to handle some sensitive data to run the business but choose selectively, since every one just adds both cost and risk.
- skymast 3y ago[dead]
- happytiger 3y agoIf spying on people is the “lifeline of our digital economy,” maybe that needs to change. Seems like a deeply positive step towards allowing people sovereignty over their own identities, albiet their identities in digital forms, which is deeply humanistic and a core of a less evil civil cyberpunk future.
- pixl97 3y agoIn before "What about all the poor people that need these free services" that commonly come up in these threads. The internet is a mess with the "It's free, but actually the costs are deeply hidden" architecture we have.
- guilhas 3y agoAlthough interesting I always also see this as erase poor people data policy, same as people deleting their reddit comments In 100 years they'll be investigating the real history of 2023, and most records were deleted, only aggregates survived by CNN and FoxNews, and other billion dollar institucions preserving their point of view Today you can go 100 back and that John Panini traveled by boat from UK to US on what day and paid 1 cent
- jarjoura 3y agoThat's quite a hyperbolic stance. There's plenty of unerase-able public data on all of us, especially data that's going to be interesting in 100+ years from now. For example, things like owning property are recorded in the county registrar and will be there as long as the county registrar is. Everything else, like travel logs and diaries will continue to exist for everyone who wants them to exist. Just as people did 100 years ago, who intentionally kept diaries, these things will remain indefinitely. Regardless, there's so much content being pooped out right now that a single year will keep future anthropologists busy for centuries. There may be some overcorrection going on, but there's no way this is a bad thing. We had no idea what Einstein had for breakfast on May 5, 1903, and we're doing just fine.
- notorandit 3y agoHow do I know my data have been erased for sure? No way.
- yieldcrv 3y agoor else what?
- coding123 3y agoHopefully we get to sue them out of existence this time
- jhart99 3y agoDoesn't look like it will be a private action. We will still need to get the State Attorney General to initiate it which will mean nothing will happen.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smcin 3y agoDC Attorney General Karl Racine has been the most impressive on data privacy. More than CA, WA, NY, MA. It probably keeps him pure that he represents a district that mainly feels the impact of the credit industry, and doesn't proportionately have that many tech jobs (as CA).
- yieldcrv 3y agoDid they pass a specific data privacy law in the district? Or are they just strong arming under consumer protection statutes or something Flew under my radar
- striking 3y agoFrom the bill: > This bill would provide that a data broker that fails to comply with the requirements pertaining to the accessible deletion mechanism described above is liable for civil penalties, administrative fines, fees, and costs, as specified, and would raise the amount of the existing civil penalty provisions described above. The bill would require that moneys collected or received by the agency and the Department of Justice under these provisions be deposited in the Data Brokers’ Registry Fund, which the bill would require to be administered by the agency, instead of the Consumer Privacy Fund and would expand the specified uses of moneys in the Data Brokers’ Registry Fund to include the costs incurred by the state courts and the agency in connection with enforcing these provisions and the costs of establishing, maintaining, and providing access to the accessible deletion mechanism described above. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202320240SB362 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
- kepler1 3y agoAre we talking actual data deletion, or just "not serving it up when queried" or attaching a "do not use" flag to the data but keeping it? Because if there's one thing I've almost never seen, it's data being deleted from a db.
- striking 3y agoFrom the bill: > The bill would, beginning January 1, 2028, and every 3 years thereafter, require a data broker to undergo an audit by an independent third party to determine compliance with these provisions and would require the data broker to submit an audit report to the agency upon the agency’s written request, as specified. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202320240SB362 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
- d3w4s9 3y agoI don't think that section answers the question.
- kepler1 3y agoThanks, that spurred me to read about it given the link above. > "This bill would require the agency to establish, by January 1, 2026, an accessible deletion mechanism that, among other things, allows a consumer, through a single verifiable consumer request, to request that every data broker that maintains any personal information delete any personal information related to that consumer held by the data broker or associated service provider or contractor. The bill would specify requirements for this accessible deletion mechanism, and would, beginning August 1, 2026, require a data broker to access the mechanism at least once every 45 days and, among other things, process all deletion requests, except as specified. Beginning July August 1, 2026, after a consumer has submitted a deletion request and a data broker has deleted the consumer’s data pursuant to the bill’s provisions, the bill would require the data broker to delete all personal information of the consumer at least once every 45 days, as specified, and would prohibit the data broker from selling or sharing new personal information of the consumer, as specified.... > "This bill would provide that a data broker that fails to comply with the requirements pertaining to the accessible deletion mechanism described above is liable for civil penalties, administrative fines, fees, and costs, as specified, and would raise the amount of the existing civil penalty provisions described above...." I guess it all comes down to the implementation level how specific and "actually deleting" they will be. And whether the new agency (ugh) charged with enforcing this will actually have teeth in the details. And I don't know why such a long 45 day period is required. For reasons we're all too familiar with, people are quite able to gather data within seconds, but somehow need 45 days to delete it?
- azinman2 3y agoCurious about the issues surrounding credit scores and how much this gets into it.
- TrendyCPU 3y agoI would also be curious to learn how it impacts Early Warning Services which collects/reports data on bank accounts and transactions. The Privacy, Security, & OSINT Show did a podcast on it.[0] 0. https://inteltechniques.com/blog/2022/04/15/the-privacy-security-osint-show-episode-257/ https://inteltechniques.com/blog/2022/04/15/the-privacy-secu...
- AJ007 3y agoI assume it would be similar to declaring bankruptcy
- hedora 3y agoBack when interest rates were low, Rocket Mortgage incorrectly tanked my credit score. They refused to fix it, which means they were liable for whatever economic damage that causes. When I refinanced, I explained the situation to the other bank's loan agent. They emailed their underwriting division, and the underwriters simply issued an override. Not sure if that works these days or not, but my point is that credit scores are complete bullshit. Hopefully most people will push the button, inadvertently opting out of credit reporting, and that corner of the industry will simply stop existing. Lenders already do more due diligence than the credit agencies do. If you default on a loan, there could be a central record (say, at the court house) of this, and lenders could consult that. That would fill in the remaining missing functionality of the score (and do so in a way that is transparently free of institutional racism, etc).
- adrr 3y agoBesides defaults how would you get precision in a model without any other data? Payment history and total outstanding credit wouldn’t be there. You would have to trust the customer to provide you with all these details. Without precision in the risk model, cost to the consumer will go up to mitigate risk. Someone who has paid all their credit lines for 10 years but and has never defaulted has the same risk profile as a person who has frequently missed payments.
- TrendyCPU 3y agoThe legislation appears to be limited to data brokers. While this is nice and welcomed, this also means it doesn't cover entities like Google or Facebook.
- CharlesW 3y agoI'm astounded that they aren't considered data brokers in the eyes of U.S. law.
- 0xcde4c3db 3y agoThe standard answer (at least for Google, not sure about Facebook) is that they're not considered data brokers because they only sell ad placement based on the data, not the data itself.
- hef19898 3y agoOne could make a case for splitting the data collection activities from the ad sales business as part of an anti trust case. Or pass regulations and laws to that effect.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chimeracoder 3y ago> One could make a case for splitting the data collection activities from the ad sales business as part of an anti trust case. Or pass regulations and laws to that effect. That would be a net negative for privacy, because it would mean more parties having access to your data (without your consent or even knowledge). And given the state of security in ad-tech aside from Google, that means the chances of your data getting breached and leaked would increase exponentially.
- vineyardmike 3y agoThat would be a pretty weird case to make. Typically anti trust is used to prevent a business from using market dominance in one market from entering another market. Considering they don’t participate in the data sales business it’d be a weird scenario to force them to start. I’d prefer we don’t force them to start. Gmail with ads seems way preferable to Gmail who sells your data to others.
- NelsonMinar 3y agoI've been grateful as a Californian for our regulations of online businesses. I regularly invoke our right-to-unsubscribe and the CCPA gives us something similar to the GDPR in various ways. To what extent do companies extend these rights to all Americans because it's easier than building a California-specific version of a website or online product?
- nolroz 3y agoI would think a lot. Everyone would rather not have wait for legal to answer a new set of questions every time a state changes their laws. Easier to align on the strictest legislation and go from there, IMHO.
- gochi 3y agoLikely depends on the scale of the company. The likes of Google (I know they aren't specifically on the line for this law anyways) will have more than enough resources to ensure you're a California resident before allowing such. Hard to see others caring and just adhering your request as a non-California resident when it's always a small margin of people that even take advantage of privacy respecting laws.
- Alupis 3y agoExactly. The Parent comment strikes me as being very naïve. Right to Unsubscribe? Gmail and other email providers do this for you even if you are not a CA resident and even if the Marketer does not have a built-in Unsubscribe link. From a Marketer perspective, you cost money to send emails to, and if you are not going to open, they kind of don't want you on the list anyway. CCPA == GDPR? Not even close. Majority of CA businesses do not reach the compliance threshold and therefore do not have to or will not comply with requests. Additionally, you have no way to validate if the request was actually carried out. The company's "best efforts" to remove data from their systems is all that's required at best - and a lot of data can be retained for valid business reasons. Lastly - despite what CA residents believe (and similar to EU residents with GDPR) - CA laws do not apply to the rest of the country simply because they are unenforceable except in the most egregious cases - and even then it would have to be a very large business anyway. > because it's easier than building a California-specific version of a website or online product Nobody is doing this in practice. At best, they use some GeoIP thing or if you are logged into an account (which means they have your data anyway). The law does not require them to validate the user anyway, so it's all "best effort" again which usually means low effort. But hey, if it makes you feel warm and fuzzy believing these things - more power to you.
- neonate 3y agohttp://web.archive.org/web/20230915153457/https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2023-09-14/california-bill-delete-online-personal-data http://web.archive.org/web/20230915153457/https://www.latime... https://archive.ph/1ebn0 https://archive.ph/1ebn0
- qwerty456127 3y agoI want a bill which would let me just ban all data brokers forever. I don't mind first parties to save some relevant data necessary for them to do their job, I can even understand 3rd parties like Google Analytics involved, but data brokers - I really don't want any of them to have any data about me ever.
- willio58 3y agoYeah this is it. I want to have full knowledge over who has my data and for what purpose. I think we'll get there eventually but it'll take a while.
- qwerty456127 3y agoHonestly, I don't really care who as long as I can block them altogether. It was curious to find out how many weird companies do. Thanks to the GDPR we now can see the lists. Do I read them? Not anymore, I just make sure all the switches are off. It can be reasonable for a particular website I visit to save some data (not fingerprinting though) on who visits it. It can be reasonable for Google Analytics or Facebook or a similar system to process the data so they can target ads which make so many good small businesses possible nowadays. Sharing the data with other parties makes no sense I would ever want.
- pauldenton 3y agoDo you want to ban Manual Data Brokers. Private Investigators?
- ofjcihen 3y agoSure. Is there a counter argument to this?
- hackncheese 3y agoThis reminds me of a company my friend used to work for, Ketch [1]. Basically described their service as automation that fulfills this exact requirement on customers databases. Sounds like they were ahead of the game. [1] https://www.ketch.com/ https://www.ketch.com/
- maaand 3y agoQuestion is what are the loop-holes available for the databrokers to ignore data deletion requests?
- TheCaptain4815 3y agoVery few things I'm jealous of in blue states, but their online privacy protection is up there. I've pondered why no party has made this a major priority, but the reality is the vast majority of Americans simply don't care. I would love to tell these big tech companies I want all traces of myself removed from their search engines. I understand it gets a bit nuanced with first amendment n such (what about a news article of me committing "x crime"), but give citizens SOME protection. At least Europe tries and pushes back.
- gonehome 3y agoI'm in California - reality is even with this stuff it's hard. I'd say maybe 20% companies you send CCPA request emails to don't know what to do, have broken forms, etc. It does work probably 80% of the time though. I also use this which seems to work, but it's hard to know how effective it is really: https://joindeleteme.com/ https://joindeleteme.com/
- kanary 3y agoThe best services will cover removals across more sources than just data brokers. They are in the category of "Authorized Agents". Take a look at https://www.kanary.com https://www.kanary.com too - yc grant awardee in 2018.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- c420 3y agoI'd wager that lobbyist$ play a larger role than citizen apathy for the lack of legislation.
- rabeener 3y agoThe first sentence of your comment is unnecessary to make your point and I’m curious why you chose to post it.
- TheCaptain4815 3y ago
- ChiMan 3y agoThere is a simpler way. If it’s data about you, it’s your property, wherever it’s stored. As such, you, not the software company, have the right to sell it if you wish.