7 ms·
Google to pay $93M in settlement over deceptive location tracking
- iterateAutomate 3y ago[flagged]
- eternal_braid 3y ago"a considerable payout for the tech giant that following a years-long investigation into its data practices."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- colesantiago 3y ago[flagged]
- havnagiggle 3y agoThis was just CA. There was a similar lawsuit by other states last year settled for $300-400 million.
- ouid 3y ago[dead]
- scottyah 3y agoJust keep funneling all the tech (big business marketing budget) money straight past workers and right to lawyers and politicians. The article didn't mention- where does this money actually end up?
- sitkack 3y agoFalse dichotomy. That money wouldn’t have made it to workers anyway.
- voytec 3y ago[flagged]
- andrewxdiamond 3y agoGoogle does not control moderation on HN
- rvz 3y agoThat isn’t good enough. It should be $9.3B dollars since Google does this on a repeated basis. A slap on the wrist like this will make them continue their actions and nothing will change.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dahfizz 3y agoThe behavior in question has already changed
- jacquesm 3y agoSo? No reason not to royally fine them. Because it isn't just about this particular action, it is also about all the other abuses, past and present.
- dahfizz 3y agoI am responding to this assertion: > A slap on the wrist like this will make them continue their actions and nothing will change. If this "slap on the wrist" does indeed change the bad behavior in question, then it seems like the system is working.
- jacquesm 3y agoNo, this slap on the wrist only changed this bad behavior, so they'll try again with something else. What needs to be done is not a slap on the wrist but a whack over the head with a cluebat that it's been enough and that the next fine will put them out of business so we can stop this endless game of whackamole.
- pxoe 3y agothis location timeline page https://timeline.google.com/maps/timeline https://timeline.google.com/maps/timeline should be included up along in there. if not deceptive, it's certainly badly designed and confusing enough for you to overlook what options are available to you. in dark mode, these little buttons (that actually manage your data and obscure important options) are almost unnoticeable. and this is somehow the only way to delete your location data, both web and mobile. even on android it's still just a redirect to that same web page. there is no native 'delete location history' button. (and if you do open that page on android, you might have to sign in to your account again before even seeing anything lol. as always, burying and obscuring controls. it couldn't be that hard to implement a 'delete all' button on activity controls page right before, but oh nooo, what if people would actually deprive google of location data.)
- lkbm 3y agoFor me there's a big "Manage Location History" button on the main page, which has a clear option to turn off or turn off and delete, as well auto-delete setting. Not sure how dark mode would affect how visible it is, but in the default view, it's pretty in your face. I'd say the trickiest bit is probably finding your timeline in the first place if you don't regularly make use of it, but I get periodic emails about it — at least a monthly summary. EDIT: Looks like, at least in Firefox, the page doesn't respect Dark Mode at all. EDIT 2: Here's the top and bottom of my monthly email from them: https://imgur.com/a/oUez8ZC https://imgur.com/a/oUez8ZC — multiple direct links to the page to turn off and delete location data.
- ethbr1 3y agoAlso, on Firefox Android Mobile, it flags private mode as an unsupported browser, and only displays the "Delete All" button at the bottom.
- jeffbee 3y agoThis has to be the most visible privacy control Google offers. Nobody is in Location History unless they turned it on, and if you have it turned on you get a reminder every month by email that says right at the top, in the snippet, "You're receiving this email because you turned on Location History, a Google Account-level setting that creates Timeline, a personal map of your visited places, routes, and trips. You can view, edit, and delete this data anytime in Timeline."
- CrzyLngPwd 3y agoThat fine is so small that it is just another cost of doing business.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jeffbee 3y agoThe fine reflects the weakness of the state's case. The defendants whittled it down to where the expected value of litigating it was equal to the cost of settling it.
- dehrmann 3y agoAnd they tie your location history to ad views and surface this to advertisers. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/aug/13/google-location-tracking-android-iphone-mobile https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/aug/13/google-lo...
- doctor_radium 3y agoI'm confused. What is the Android or app configuration necessary to enable this tracking? "Web and app activity", the only setting mentioned in the article, doesn't ring a bell. Is it all assuming the creation and use of a Google account?
- eks391 3y agoYes, however most people have google accounts. For example, with an android, it is impossible to download an app from the Play Store without a google account (assuming you aren't using a mirror, and other stipulations), so that alone encapsulats half of Americans, and google has several other products unrelated to android you could be using. The people in developed countries who this doesn't affect could be negligible.
- doctor_radium 3y agoThanks for explaining. Happy (for once) to hear that I'm negligible.
- arpowers 3y agoTwo weeks ago i was in San Francisco with a friend that works in "big tech" discussing "profit motives" in technology. They told me that the lobby behind their company had all sorts of tricks to help government "ignore" all the clearly negative things they are doing in the name of revenue. Lobbying, anonymous stock trading "tips" (see Pelosi), influence pedding, etc.. Modern technology companies are all doing what the Tobacco companies did, only they have more plausible deniability.
- jacquesm 3y agoSo a friend of yours told you that Pelosi accepted insider information to make a bundle and both you and your friend did nothing about it? Are you aware that the SEC will reward you for such information assuming it is true?
- devindotcom 3y agoFolks talking about how easy it is to see and change these settings, remember that many of the patterns and practices being litigated go back years to when these settings were less clearly stated, if they were stated at all. The reason there is such transparency now is because of years of pressure from lawsuits, regulators, and reporting.
- Justsignedup 3y agoAlso to add. Many people don't understand this in the same way that many people don't understand the tweaks you can make to your car engine. Sometimes they make changes which undoes the settings and sometimes settings are per device. It is quite difficult to keep track of it all. And sometimes turning off an ad feature cuts out a ton of non ad features. Example I can't turn off Google location tracking ad features without turning off googles ability to show me recent locations I drove to which I find quite helpful.
- gustavus 3y agoFor me it's less about knowing how to turn them off and the constant worrying fear they'll be reset with the latest update, or some random feature that I actually need will get turned off along with it.
- ethbr1 3y agoAgreed. It'd be nice to have a tiered, single-point consent system, where user-preference was cascaded down to preclude auto-opt-in. E.g. "Do you want to be tracked?" If you answer no, then no feature which tracks you can be default opt-in, even if subsequently shipped.
- chrsig 3y agoWhen considering bad faith actors, I tend to consider taking extreme: I worry that the toggles don't actually do anything at all. Or there's some other means of exfiltration in use that's not covered by the existing controls.
- 3y ago
- JohnMakin 3y agoThey likely made way more than $93M doing this, which means this is just a cost of business, and does nothing for consumer protections going forward, nor does it discourage google from continuing this behavior. You need fines with real teeth or pass laws that make this illegal.
- njovin 3y ago$93m is approximately 172 minutes worth of revenue for Google.
- booleandilemma 3y agoWhere do all these millions go exactly?
- predkambrij 3y agoDo fooled people get any of that?
- stuff4ben 3y agoWonder how much they made selling that data instead?
- AlbertCory 3y agoI don't know if this was already mentioned, but I am getting pissed off at how often my Settings get changed without my doing anything. Auto-rotate: goes off, have to reset. Screen timeout: gets reset to 15 seconds. Some programs are able to change your Settings without explicit permission from you. This should be just plain impossible.
- hotstickyballs 3y agoAre you on android?
- fusslo 3y ago[dead]
- julianlam 3y ago> While Google is not admitting any fault as part of the settlement, the company did agree to several other terms in addition to paying $93m. Those conditions include being more transparent about its location tracking practices; notifying users before location information is used to build ad profiles to target specific people; and getting approval from Google’s internal privacy working group before making any material changes to privacy. That last line is oddly reminiscent of the government delegating safety audits to the airplane manufacturers themselves.
- M3L0NM4N 3y agoYeah, but it makes me wonder if an internal privacy working group already existed, and they weren't approving changes in privacy rules, what were they actually doing?
- hedora 3y ago> is used to build ad profiles to target specific people I was wondering how they'd comply for logged out users. I'll bet the phrase "specific people" explicitly excludes pseudonymous profiles (which are trivial to de-anonymize) and explicitly allows them to use clustering algorithms with arbitrarily fine granularity. ("This isn't a profile for a specific user. It's a cluster that could contain an arbitrary number users. It currently only contains one, but that's bound to happen, given the number of clusters...")
- hk1337 3y agoShould be $93M/person
- distant_hat 3y agoSo like an hour of revenue.
- trollerator23 3y agoNice drop in the bucket.
- nologic01 3y agoYou can find hordes of shills to state otherwise but alas tech has become an industry that is based on deception. Its a fateful turn of events. It means that the fundamental and very powerful information engineering skill, something that is in-principle vital, neutral and promising, is lost to the world as a force for good. You cant put lipstick on a pig. That moral deficit at the core of the industry is fatal. Nothing good or lasting will be built on it.
- entropicgravity 3y agoWow $93m for each of us! I can hardly wait to open my mailbox.
- evolve2k 3y ago“To the rich, parking fines are just price tags” [1] While annoying for Google, this is a mosquito bite. Google Annual Revenue: $279,800 Million And today they’ll be fined: .. .. $93 Million It’s about “an hour” of their annual income. At these prices it’s pretty much worth it to be pulling all sorts of unethical moves. This is not even the price to play but rather the price if you get caught. 1. https://i.pinimg.com/564x/a6/06/ec/a606ec5c539472182cf126226e4f48ab.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/564x/a6/06/ec/a606ec5c539472182cf126226... 2. https://www.statista.com/statistics/266206/googles-annual-global-revenue/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/266206/googles-annual-gl...
- hnav 3y agoGoogle's net income is something like 60b, so more like half a day which is a bit more significant. Multiply that by all the different angles regulators are going to be coming for big tech and it might start to add up enough that it shapes internal policy further.
- hedora 3y agoSince almost all of their revenue is from tracking users, that implies we'll need over of these rulings per day if we want it to be economically rational for them to stop violating people's privacy.
- evolve2k 3y agoWhen we as externals are at “if enough fines are issued it might start to shift behaviour” we’re very much dealing with a party for whom this is a mere inconvenience.
- _jab 3y agoComparing the entire company's revenue to the fine is a bit misleading. Arguably, the more relevant comparison is to consider how much marginal revenue the violating feature actually produced. Granted, probably no one besides Google knows that number, but it's surely orders of magnitude lower. If those numbers are comparable, this starts to look like a reasonable penalty.