6 ms·
The Disappearing Male [video]
- pg 18y agoCan someone just summarize what compounds are thought to be responsible?
- gruseom 18y agohttp://www.cbc.ca/documentaries/doczone/2008/disappearingmale/chemicals.html http://www.cbc.ca/documentaries/doczone/2008/disappearingmal... Bisphenol A (found mostly in hard colored plastics) is becoming particularly non grata (update: in Canada) these days. Edit: according to the article it's also "the de facto lining used in food cans". Wow.
- Alex3917 18y ago"Bisphenol A (found mostly in hard colored plastics) is becoming particularly non grata these days." Not in the United States.
- gruseom 18y agoFunny, my comment originally said something about Canada and I cut it out for brevity. I'll add it back. (Actually, it's not funny at all. The industry's argument appears to be: "But if we don't poison people, how will we make all those shiny plastic bottles?" With the fallback position: "How about if we just don't poison babies? Will that do?")
- dhimes 18y agoSome food storage containers, water bottles, and the like are advertising "BPA-free."
- pg 18y agoSounds like the probem is stuff made out of plastic. Is that a reasonable summary?
- gruseom 18y agoI have the impression it's some plastics but not all. A rule of thumb many people up here use is to avoid plastics with recycling number 6 (polystyrene) or 7 (polycarbonate). These are said to be the worst. Alex, does the film contain specific recommendations to consumers? (Normally I hate using the word "consumer" to mean "citizen" but in this case it could hardly be more accurate.)
- Alex3917 18y agoI didn't watch the last few min of the film, but here is a good list of things to avoid: http://www.sailhome.org/Concerns/BodyBurden/Burdens/Phthalate.html http://www.sailhome.org/Concerns/BodyBurden/Burdens/Phthalat... Realistically it will be impossible to completely avoid the stuff until it's made illegal.
- gruseom 18y agoGiven that the list includes water, I'd have to agree!
- rshao 18y agoFrom what I could tell in the video, bisphenol a's a petroleum derivative that is used to harden polycarbonates. The other one, pthalates (also a petroleum derivative) is used to soften PVC. So technically, not made out of plastic, but used to make plastic. Edit: Realized I misread your comment. Yes, the problem is with some plastic products, which use these chemicals (but not all, since the video mentioned that one hospital using safe plastic products).
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- ericb 18y ago
- ericb 18y agoYou left out phthalates, which are also in plastics, but are not the same thing as BPA.
- Alex3917 18y agoPhthalates and bpa.
- Tichy 18y agoDidn't watch the video, but I have also heard bad things about soy, which is also in a lot of processed food.
- gaius 18y agoYes, soy protein isoflavones are phytoestrogens. Males should limit soy consumption.
- ericb 18y agoPhthalates, which are in products made of PVC plastics (like the pipes) which includes childrens toys but are also found in tons of other things like cosmetics, deodorants, and fragranced products. Bisphenol A (BPA) is the other major offender. Many companies are at least removing from baby bottles and teethers now. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bisphenol_A http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bisphenol_A http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phthalate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phthalate
- steveplace 18y agoFound this post off reddit: Don't be so quick to condemn "unnatural, synthetic" chemicals. Some of the biggest troublemakers are plant estrogen that is sprayed on crops to increase plant yields. This has been known, studied and re-studied since the 1960s. Here's the science: About halfway through gestation, a male fetus emits a small amount of testosterone that travels from its testes to its brain. This tells it that it is a "male" brain. If it does not get that bit of hormone, the brain remains "female", by default. Importantly, while in animals this may determine mating behavior, it DOES NOT DO SO IN HUMANS. So please set aside any ideas about homosexuality, which is much more complicated than this. If during early pregnancy, the mother either uptakes a chemical that blocks this transfer, interferes with this transfer, significantly increases the amount of estrogen in her body (usually from eating Tofu), or increases the tiny amount of natural testosterone in her body (from other chemicals), it interferes with the process. While again, this will not determine sexual attraction, it will play some considerable part in the secondary sexual characteristics of the offspring. Either androgyny, more feminine males, or more masculine females. When this was first discovered in the 1960s, they evaluated the gamut of variations, even putting testosterone in just half the brain, but not the other half, which resulted in both male and female mating behavior, the animal, but not human, version of bisexuality. To conclude, once again, humans are a lot more complicated. But this is a serious problem.
- Alex3917 18y ago"Don't be so quick to condemn 'unnatural, synthetic' chemicals." Completely wrong. Phthalates and bpa have already been proven harmful. Certainly there are other chemicals that mimick estrogens as well, but saying we shouldn't condemn bpa and phthalates is ridiculous.
- emmett 18y agoHis point is that the problem with Phthalates and bpa is not that they are "unnatural and synthetic" but rather that they are bad for you. They'd be just as bad if they were natural.
- 18y ago
- kqr2 18y agoVideo description: The Disappearing Male is a CBC documentary about one of the most important, and least publicized, issues facing the human species: the toxic threat to the male reproductive system. The last few decades have seen steady and dramatic increases in the incidence of boys and young men suffering from genital deformities, low sperm count, sperm abnormalities and testicular cancer. At the same time, boys are now far more at risk of suffering from ADHD, autism, Tourette's syndrome, cerebral palsy, and dyslexia. The Disappearing Male takes a close and disturbing look at what many doctors and researchers now suspect are responsible for many of these problems: a class of common chemicals that are ubiquitous in our world. Found in everything from shampoo, sunglasses, meat and dairy products, carpet, cosmetics and baby bottles, they are called "hormone mimicking" or "endocrine disrupting" chemicals and they may be starting to damage the most basic building blocks of human development
- Prrometheus 18y agoAre there any peer-reviewed, properly controlled studies used to back up their assertions? I could watch the video and track the references on my own. However, doing so for every new consumer scare would be a full-time job. By the way, I'm still happily using a cell phone and brain tumor free. I'm hoping to live a long life if avian influenza doesn't get me. Long enough to see the end of my species by catastrophic global warming, which is unstoppable if we don't act drastically and soon, according to some folks with fancy degrees. I figure I am pretty lucky - I got vaccinated as a child but managed to avoid autism - so maybe I'll even get to be the last person left. I am so hardy, I have even been exposed to second-hand smoke and managed to survive. So yeah, I'll probably make it. Anything you guys want me to do when I'm the last man on the planet?
- tlrobinson 18y agoWhy would infertility in males result in fewer males? Since reproduction requires both, wouldn't it result in fewer males and females (assuming otherwise constant rate of reproduction)? I can't think of any evolutionary explanation.
- ericb 18y agoMales have only one copy of the X chromosome, which makes them more fragile. Not sure if this is the mechanism proposed, but if male fetuses do not make it to term due to environmental insults, there would be fewer males in a given population.
- tlrobinson 18y agoYeah, I think that's one of the real reasons, but at the beginning they imply it has something to do with males becoming more infertile, which makes no sense.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agoWHy couldn't this have happened sooner? I would have preferred to be born into a world with at least a 2:1 girl:guy ratio.
- astine 18y agoUmm... The other half of the issue is not only increased male fetus mortality, but also birth defects, like smaller genitalia and deformities thereof. So, yeah, the odds are better, but you have no dick.
- cubix 18y agoThey're not putting things into the proper context: Sure, these chemicals probably are threats to human well-being, and figuring out how to remove them from our environment is worthwhile. However, the 20th century saw an unprecedented increase in life expectancy and quality of life, two great wars and god knows how many chemicals notwithstanding. I doubt many -- even those inflicted with the abnormalities mentioned in this documentary -- would choose to live in the world before synthetic materials were available, in 1908, say. Also, it's totally one-sided and they lose a lot of credibility with the sensationalist tone of the piece -- ominous music, tableaux of helpless children next to deadly chemicals, mentions of human extinction... Please.
- ericb 18y agoI doubt many -- even those inflicted with the abnormalities mentioned in this documentary -- would choose to live in the world before synthetic materials were available, in 1908, say. We could make everything out of straw. Including men.
- cubix 18y agoThis isn't a straw man. It was open speculation (I doubt...) on my part. I wasn't attempting to misrepresent their argument, but making the point that the presentation is completely unbalanced. They make vague reference to modern day synthetics being 'convenient'. It would be like denouncing medicine for its side-effects and high cost while barely alluding to the fact that it saves lives.