5 ms·

They mean they are syncing the private key used to generate the tokens on demand.

magospietato 3y ago
Well that's even worse isn't it?
kerblang 3y ago
Do all these 2FA apps - like say Microsoft Authenticator - have these hidden/not-so-hidden private keys? From other posts it sounds like you can view the token and write it down... MA doesn't have that, I don't think.
- kerblang 3y ago
  Answering myself again, yeah, they all seem to have this private key hidden away somewhere. Didn't know that. https://frontegg.com/blog/authentication-apps#How-Do-Authenticator-Apps-Work https://frontegg.com/blog/authentication-apps#How-Do-Authent...?
- e12e 3y ago
  TOTP (Time-based one-time password) need a shared secret (and two synchronized clocks) to work, so yes. FIDO2/WebAuthn relies on public key technology - so does also have a secret key - but is designed to be kept secret from the service/server one authenticates against. For use - FIDO2 is more like a multi-use id. Like a driver's license many services accept as id. If you lose it - you don't restore a backup copy from a safe - you use your passport until you get a new one issued. This makes more sense than with TOTP as the services only need your public key(id) on file. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-based_One-time_Password https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-based_One-time_Password https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebAuthn https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebAuthn
  - rawgabbit 3y ago
    Which FIDO2 service do you recommend? I get tired reading all these security articles. The more I read, the more I feel they are hiding something.
    - e12e 3y ago
      > Which FIDO2 service do you recommend? Generally what comes with your phone and one or two hw tokens for backup? Looks like token2.com is a reasonable choice if you just want NFC/USBc and FIDO2 (and not storage for ssh/gpg keys). But I have little experience with hw keys.
      - drhuseynov 3y ago
        ssh and pgp keys are not based on the similar functionality. the keys from Token2 support *-sk key storage https://www.token2.com/site/page/using-token2-fido2-security-keys-for-openssh https://www.token2.com/site/page/using-token2-fido2-security... But not PGP
        e12e 3y ago
        Thank you for the reminder that ssh now has FIDO2 support!

Well that's even worse isn't it?

Do all these 2FA apps - like say Microsoft Authenticator - have these hidden/not-so-hidden private keys? From other posts it sounds like you can view the token and write it down... MA doesn't have that, I don't think.

kerblang 3y ago
Answering myself again, yeah, they all seem to have this private key hidden away somewhere. Didn't know that. https://frontegg.com/blog/authentication-apps#How-Do-Authenticator-Apps-Work https://frontegg.com/blog/authentication-apps#How-Do-Authent...?
e12e 3y ago
TOTP (Time-based one-time password) need a shared secret (and two synchronized clocks) to work, so yes. FIDO2/WebAuthn relies on public key technology - so does also have a secret key - but is designed to be kept secret from the service/server one authenticates against. For use - FIDO2 is more like a multi-use id. Like a driver's license many services accept as id. If you lose it - you don't restore a backup copy from a safe - you use your passport until you get a new one issued. This makes more sense than with TOTP as the services only need your public key(id) on file. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-based_One-time_Password https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-based_One-time_Password https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebAuthn https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebAuthn
- rawgabbit 3y ago
  Which FIDO2 service do you recommend? I get tired reading all these security articles. The more I read, the more I feel they are hiding something.
  - e12e 3y ago
    > Which FIDO2 service do you recommend? Generally what comes with your phone and one or two hw tokens for backup? Looks like token2.com is a reasonable choice if you just want NFC/USBc and FIDO2 (and not storage for ssh/gpg keys). But I have little experience with hw keys.
    - drhuseynov 3y ago
      ssh and pgp keys are not based on the similar functionality. the keys from Token2 support *-sk key storage https://www.token2.com/site/page/using-token2-fido2-security-keys-for-openssh https://www.token2.com/site/page/using-token2-fido2-security... But not PGP
      - e12e 3y ago
        Thank you for the reminder that ssh now has FIDO2 support!