6 ms·
Conditions on Earth may be moving outside the safe operating space for humanity
- retrocryptid 3y agoIf only someone had warned us.
- quantified 3y agoEverything to too nuanced and uncertain in the effect of details for most leaders and followers to act upon. So we'll just end up reacting to whatever happens as though it was inevitable. "Turning the ship" is a common metaphor, this is more or less turning the entire fleet and it'll be messy and too late if it needed to be turned.
- retrocryptid 3y agoAs Mark Mothersbaugh and Getald Cesale once quipped "Remember to do nothing when you don't know what to do."
- jstarfish 3y agoMothersbaugh played both sides of the fence though. He also told us that when a problem comes along, you must whip it.
- DamnInteresting 3y agoCoincidentally I was listening to this song as I read your comment: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FtddIM6wfvs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FtddIM6wfvs
- retrocryptid 3y agoEnough said.
- mikece 3y agoThis will solve over-population, right?
- dadjoker 3y agoIf only this was really an emergency.
- retrocryptid 3y agoDepends on your definition of "emergency."
- renewedrebecca 3y agoIt's ok. It's not outside the safe operating space for billionaires.
- Scarblac 3y agoOnce society and rule of law break down, a billionaire is just another guy who used to have a lot of property when that was a thing.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoIt's not the amount of property that matters, it's the location.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> a billionaire is just another guy who used to have a lot of property If that property can shoot, then they’re qualitatively different. Robotics is, for the first time in human history, threatening to decouple control over a population with force projection capability.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- c1sc0 3y agoThen I guess it’s better to take out the billionaires now while we still can?
- pauldenton 3y agoRich people have always been able to buy Castles, forts, even battleships The difference being security guards you have manning the castle fort or ship expect a weekly salary and robots are a one and done purchase.
- defrost 3y agoRobots expect a weekly(?) charge and regular maintainance. They're absolutely not "buy and forget".
- labrador 3y agoI am not a climate change denier and I believe humans have contributed significantly to it with green house gases. That said. This headline and article are way over the top and give the deniers another article to point to as climate hysteria. Where on earth did it used to be habitable by humans but no longer is? There must be some if this article is true. I can't think of any.
- yoghurt 3y agoDoes the article actually mention that parts of Earth are no longer habitable already, or just that the conditions are moving into that direction? The title of this post seems to indicate the latter.
- labrador 3y agoIt says "human activities have breached safe levels for six [out of 9] of these boundaries and are pushing the world outside a “safe operating space” If we are over a majority of the set points but there is no inhabitable area to point to, then maybe the set points are wrong.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- badtension 3y agoYou can learn more about this framework here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_boundaries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_boundaries It is just a way to quantify something very elusive. The point is we are doing a lot of harm without any consideration for our actions. Profits over all.
- labrador 3y agoThanks. I had ChatGPT Plus read it and then asked questions. I now understand the problem. It's similar to the methane release from Siberia, a run away effect that can't be reversed. These are other modes of run away effect. Crossing 6 out of 9 planetary boundaries would not necessarily mean that parts of the Earth have become uninhabitable for humans, but it would signify a very high level of risk for abrupt and potentially irreversible environmental changes. These changes could severely disrupt the Earth's systems that make the planet habitable in the first place. The concept of planetary boundaries is designed to identify the "safe operating space" for humanity. Crossing multiple boundaries increases the risk of triggering non-linear, abrupt environmental changes on a continental to planetary scale. These could include extreme weather events, loss of freshwater resources, collapse of ecosystems, and other severe disruptions that could make life increasingly difficult for humans and other species.
- gottorf 3y agoEvery human problem is in essence a problem of energy abundance. We need to embrace all technologies that let us unlock more energy wielded per capita, preferably without harmful side-effects like pollution, but where there exist side-effects they must be weighed against the benefit, instead of being categorically banned. The latter, without an alternative source of energy, just means people will be worse off. Greenlash is already a thing in many developed countries that have tried to set unrealistic policy goals. In my opinion, the focus on net-zero should really be a focus on a clean, abundant, and cheap energy source -- like fusion, if it can be realized. Instead, it seems like the current focus of net-zero is on how to divide the energy we can currently produce and in what way. It is immoral to ask or force the global poor living in yet-to-be-developed countries to not raze their forests for agriculture or other use, when it is the same path that every developed nation has already trod; and besides, they aren't going to listen either way, when their own livelihoods are at stake. The way out of the problem is through: through more energy.
- mistrial9 3y agocheck out "energy efficiency" -- very useful; also "budget"
- Libcat99 3y agoMore energy only takes you so far. Unless we leave earth https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist...
- badtension 3y agoPeople will always need more energy, that's why cheap nuclear is a fallacy that many fall for (Jevons paradox). We need high marginal energy prices, preferably progressively increasing with usage. Similar with other types of consumerism.
- gottorf 3y ago> cheap nuclear is a fallacy that many fall for (Jevons paradox) Jevons paradox does not apply here. All of human progress has basically been about being able to use more energy per capita. You're right that people will always need more energy -- if they want to progress. A call for higher marginal energy prices effectively means that you're declaring that this is as good as humanity will ever be, and nobody would need anything better (in the sense that "640KB ought to be enough").
- elzbardico 3y agoHow low CNN can go to get page-views?
- gustavus 3y agoHere's the thing I can be sympathetic to the plight of climate activists, but many times it strikes me as having a lot of uncomfortable parallels to the end of days Christian millenialists that got big in the late 90s and early 2000s. Both meet the criteria of - Believe that we are rapidly headed for an end of the world catastrophe - Believe the only way to avert catastrophe is by everyone in the world suddenly making massive (unrealistic) changes to the way they live and how society functions. - Seem more interested in evangelizing and catastrophizing than actually convincing people. - Want to use the power of the state to force others to live in the way that will avert the imminent crises. - Get incredibly upset when anyone questions, (even well intentioned) their beliefs and proposed solution.
- discreteevent 3y agoLike that guy from the government who told us that our building was structurally unsound and we all had to leave. What a drastic solution and he was completely dogmatic about it. He reminded me so much of the other guy who went around telling everyone the sky was going to fall on our heads.
- knewter 3y agoThis is what op is talking about
- yoghurt 3y agoWhile I can see that you might experience these as uncomfortable parallels, there is a big difference you could consider: That climate activism is based on scientific research.
- sukhavati 3y agobased on scientific research, much like communism and scientific management and phrenology and racism. meanwhile climate models are not capable of predicting the past given current conditions, produce wildly incompatible results, and operate on a model of the earth that is pathetically simplistic, ignoring cloud coverage (which has 3-20x the magnitude of effects of carbon) solar variability and wind patterns. the world might end as we know it for it is clear that crucial features of the earth are changing at a rapid pace, especially oceanic currents, but it will happen in a way that completely surprised most people, if not climate scientists that are aware of the limits of their models.