2 ms·
The herd vs merit distinction is interesting, and I think they both have value. Maybe differently to different people, but non-zero. Imagine a handful of objec
by ethbr1 3y ago
The herd vs merit distinction is interesting, and I think they both have value. Maybe differently to different people, but non-zero.
Imagine a handful of objectively "good" songs.
Play them for a crowd where nobody knows them.
Or, in a more humorous example, imagine the Beatles played tracks only from their second album, while touring for their first album. Would audiences be disappointed?
I struggle to imagine an overly negative reaction. People love hearing songs they love, but they also fell in love with those songs for a reason. Well executed music is well-executed music.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoYes, agreed, music has a particular value to a person (I was going too say 'intrinsic' but it is personal) as well. But shared love of music, or shared experiences of music transcends this value IMO; and is largely orthogonal. "That song we danced to", "what we sang at the campfire", crab dance for LTT watchers, 'easy for ENZ' for CSGO players, a national anthem to a nationalist, ... the music matters a little but it's only really a rallying point for shared experiences.