8 ms·
Oxford study proves heat pumps triumph over fossil fuels in the cold
- gustavus 3y agoLink to actual study: https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(23)00351-3 https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(23)00351-3
- mattbee 3y agoMy mum has a heat pump install which she hates for being lukewarm all the time. It feels underspecced! When I've looked at one for my home to replace a 24kW gas boiler, all I can find is 14kW kits. Am I missing something? Can I not match the output of a big gas boiler?
- gymbeaux 3y agoI would look at BTUs rather than wattage and o would expect an equivalent heat pump system to use less electricity.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoWattage on a heat pump or furnace or boiler is a measure of heat output, not of energy input.
- photon_rancher 3y agoYou can, but central units aren’t great right now. Mini-splits are much better. Price is lower, cheaper to install, regulation between rooms is more even, and you can turn off unused rooms to save energy. Not sure why the market has moved this way but it is what it is. That unit probably is underspeced
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoMini-splits are functionally excellent but have a difficult time with the Wife Factor. So far most of the decorative "solutions" are rather poor. I'm sure over time, as they become more popular, people will come up with ideas for how to work them into the home's interior design, but for now, many find them too utilitarian in appearance.
- cillian64 3y agoI was looking into this and one factor is that you still need hot water. So with mini-splits your options are either resistive water heating or having a gas boiler as well. I haven’t seen any systems which do mini-splits and also heat a hot water tank.
- guruz 3y agoHeat Pump Water Heater. You can put it next to high end computer to suck its heat in :-) https://carbonswitch.com/heat-pump-water-heater-buyers-guide/ https://carbonswitch.com/heat-pump-water-heater-buyers-guide...
- sdflhasjd 3y ago24kW is basically the peak when it's doing instant hot-water for the taps. You shouldn't need that to heat a home. You're right, it can't match the _peak_ output, but the whole system is designed so this isn't necessary. With a "traditional" combi-boiler, it will turn on occasionally to heat the water in the central heating system, and continue to pump it around. When you need hot water, it switches over the heat-exchanger to directly heat the incoming water and this is when it will ramp up and burn the most gas (24kW+). For an air-to-water heat pump system, the system will be on almost continually, but will heat the water to a lower temperature, the peak power output is less, but it averages out the same. For hot water, the system will heat a storage cylinder. One of the catches here is that's it not always an easy retrofit as the lower water temperature can necessitate larger radiators.
- morsch 3y agoShe might need larger radiators. https://www.heatgeek.com/do-i-need-to-upgrade-my-radiators-for-a-heat-pump/ https://www.heatgeek.com/do-i-need-to-upgrade-my-radiators-f...
- mattbee 3y agoMaybe, but it's not a conversion. The house was built new with heat pumps.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoMight be worth checking how they are using it. If they're used to gas heating in a less well insulated home they may swich it off until they need it, whereas in a well insulated home with a heat pump you want it on basically all the time. edit: In-depth geeky video on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGs_biFA87Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGs_biFA87Q
- Loic 3y agoYou need to size the heat pump based on the gas consumption over a year, not the instant supply. Here is a very good explanation: https://protonsforbreakfast.wordpress.com/2022/04/05/what-size-heat-pump-do-i-need-a-rule-of-thumb/ https://protonsforbreakfast.wordpress.com/2022/04/05/what-si...
- akira2501 3y agoI don't see any actual comparison to fossil fuels. They use a measure, COP, which is coefficient of performance, which doesn't seem applicable to fossil fuel furnaces or if applied there would give those furnaces an enormous COP number. Anyways, I don't understand the need to draw these types of "total" comparisons. If you have reliable electricity, a heat pump is probably great, if you don't, then fossil fuels are clearly the way to go. There is no "one size fits all" energy strategy.
- francisofascii 3y agoUsing COP is a easy way to compare heat pump efficiency to conventional heating methods. It is a multiple of the amount of heat energy output given the electricity energy used. A fossil fuel boiler is always less than 1 (usually 0.6-0.8) since it is never 100% efficient at converting the fuel energy to heat energy. Your electric space heater has a COP of exactly 1. So when you see the COPs in the 4-6 range, you get a good sense of how much more efficient heat pumps are.
- gruez 3y ago> A fossil fuel boiler is always less than 1 (usually 0.6-0.8) since it is never 100% DOE mandates 80% efficiency for new furnaces, and high efficiency units are in the 90-95% range.
- paul_f 3y agoThe COP for a heat pump drops as the temperature decreases. The climate should have a large impact on the choice of technology. Here in Florida it is a no brainer, everyone has a heat pump for the cool winter days. In Minnesota, it is a non starter.
- francisofascii 3y agoThe article is pointing out that heat pumps today can still be more efficient down to -20 C (-4F).
- sbradford26 3y ago
- rudedogg 3y agoIf you live in a cold climate, and are looking at heat pumps, make sure you use https://ashp.neep.org/#!/ https://ashp.neep.org/#!/ to look at the low temp BTUs. The defrost specifications are also worth thinking about. Having your heat turn off for a few minutes to do a defrost cycle can be annoying if you only have one unit.
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoThis thing can be fixed by having low temperature floor heating. It does imply that your heat pump should be air to water or water to water versus a mini-split which is air to air. Low temperature means only a couple of degrees higher than ambient. It just constantly radiates. That also mean that heat pump needs to work less hard. It does require a significant amount of insulation to ensure you don't lose the heat immediately. And because of the high mass it means that interruptions aren't noticed.
- msandford 3y agoIf it works great at 10c and OK at 0c and just a little bit at -10c but extracts no useful heat at -20c and your local weather has lots of time below 0c, then no amount of low temp floor heating will help.
- Maxion 3y agoThis is just plain false. The entire country of Finland (and Sweden, and Norway) installs pretty much only air source heat pumps, air-water heat pumps, or ground source heat pumps in all renovations or new built buildings. In the north of the country you end up heating your house for some days with resistive heating, but it is still cheaper than any alternative source.
- seiferteric 3y agoUp until this past winter basically, natural gas in NorCal was so cheap that you could probably use much more energy and still come out ahead money wise.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoWe're well past the point of optimizing for cost unless you're one of those "well it doesn't matter, I'll be dead by then" people who don't care about what's happening to the planet.
- lazide 3y agoOr just don’t have massive amounts of unused capital sitting around to spend, or are poor. I guess they can just freeze then?
- seiferteric 3y agoNot at all, but the article talks about it as a money saving thing as well and doesn't even mention the fact that gas has been cheaper: > he said it also stresses the need for more supports for low-income people to install heat pumps to save money and limit emissions.
- ilyt 3y agoOne of interesting-if-too-expensive methods I've seen was basically having gas powered heat pumps. IIRC It was basically using normal gas engine to move the coolant around but it also used heat produced by engine to heat the coils on the cold side so it was getting essentially more than 100% efficiency out of gas. But it was even more expensive than traditional heat pump.
- seiferteric 3y agoAh sort of co-generation, sounds interesting.
- tomatocracy 3y agoSounds a lot like the idea behind combined cycle gas turbines.
- PreInternet01 3y agoOK, so, once again, a total anecdote here. Anecdotes are definitely not a substitute for actual data, there is a sample size of one (possibly zero) involved here, so proceed at your own risk. During winter in Greenland, it's totally accepted to leave your car engine running at all times. Why? Because it's likely your diesel supply will freeze up otherwise. The initial rollout of EVs in Greenland was a disaster. Fine during boring season (as summer is known locally: you can't go out and hunt properly!), but useless most of the year: the batteries would just die. Then, EVs with built-in heat pumps became available, to aid with cabin temperature (mostly) but also very-cold-weather startup performance (coincidentally). These worked pretty well: when parked, the heat pump would supply warm-ish air to the batteries, which would then continue to feed the heat pump, and work with a properly charged power pack the next day. So, instead of diesel cars idling 24/7, new EVs now run at, say, 80% efficiency in Greenland. Not a huge deal, globally speaking, but still a nice win.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoI'm guessing the price of gas is ridiculous in greenland. Makes sense that an ev would net a quick payoff there. Even if you guys are running your power plants off fossil fuels, the larger generators are probably more efficient.
- PreInternet01 3y agoDiesel is pretty cheap in Greenland, but that's not related to the actual cost of getting the stuff there. One thing to keep in mind, though, is that pretty much nobody has a car in Greenland. Not because of some enviromento-wokism, but just because there are not that many roads. You live in Ilulissat? Have fun driving between the harbor and the airport (all of the 20-or-so miles). And people do, but they tend to be taxi drivers, and they mostly drive EVs these days, again, not because of the actual cost of the vehicles. Now, if you want to go anywhere in Greenland, you need a boat. And a sled and some dogs, or, if you insist, a snowmobile.
- serpix 3y agoHow cold does it get then? EVs are good to -35C and most cars should be ok down to -30C. Idling solves nothing about the frozen tires and stiff axles and shock absorbers. Best would be to insulate the car with a simple tarp and I bet -50C wouldn't be a problem.
- anyoneamous 3y agoGiven the name of the lead author of the paper and the way heat pumps work, I really wish the atricle had worked "Gibb's Free Energy" into the write-up somewhere.
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agoI don't understand how to use heat pump in traditional boiler systems. The smallest boiler is 25kw/hr while residential heat pumps are tiny as compared. Maybe 2-3-5kw/hr output. The way it was put to me, there is no way the heat pump will output so much heated water to heat the house. I could be missing something here. In terms of BTUs, residential radiator boilers are like 40k BTU, I don't think heat pumps can output so much
- ilyt 3y agoYou put a bigger buffer tank and you heat it over time. 25kw/hr boiler isn't working all the time. That boiler is also often sized to just heat a lot of water for shower/etc so the power is oversized "just" for heating house. So during normal work the gas boiler will be cycling , while heat pump with lower power is just constantly heating the buffer and then heat from that buffer is used for heating the house.
- fest 3y agoHaving thought about this when I retrofitted a heat pump in my house, I don't see how a buffer helps here. For a buffer to work, it necessarily needs to be hotter than supply temperature, which means more losses and more work for the heat pump. Since heat pump can easily adjust the supply temperature, the most efficient system will be the one where the energy delivered to underfloor heating or radiators is just balanced out by heat loss of the building. Where buffers are useful is heat sources whose power cannot be modulated (my old diesel furnace for example- when it fired, it produced roughly 20kW, with the only adjustment being supply temperature at which it turns off), or where there is a cost to frequent starting/stopping the heat source (I.e. you probably don't want to get up in the middle of night to add wood to a wood-fired furnace, and pellet-fired furnace needs to be maintained more often in such operation mode). If one really needs 25kW heat source, one really needs a 25kW heat source. There is no clever way around it. The real question is whether one really needs 25kW heat source (which can be answered definitively by either measuring the delivered==required power, looking at the peak continuous fuel consumption (let's say the coldest day or week), or by having accurate heat loss model of the building. In a heating season, the buffer cannot realistically be large enough to significantly reduce the power requirement. For example, 1m3 of hot water when used as a buffer can store roughly 30kWh (when heated 25 degC above supply temperature). My house needed 240kWh of energy in the coldest day, so the buffer would only cover 10% of the needed heat. I had set up monitoring for my diesel furnace, so I could see for myself what was the peak heat requirement over two heating seasons (10kW continuous in the coldest winter day). So, I selected an 11kW heat pump, which, if needed also has 9kW of resistive backup heaters. It also matched the numbers in energy-efficiency certificate of the house (theoretical calculation based on materials/thickness/local outside temperatures) within 10-15% or so.
- ilyt 3y ago...we knew that already ? Why they need a study for it ?
- Anon_Forever 3y agoAt this rate governments should ban fossil fuel based heating for new construction and renovations. I see new houses all over the US and Canada still being constructed with natural gas or propane for heating.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoThat would be dangerous for many rural areas. For some remote regions, blizzards taking out the electrical grid is a real concern. You need a local mechanism to generate heat and an on-site propane/oil tank is the only realistic option.
- Anon_Forever 3y ago>That would be dangerous for many rural areas. Not at all, I live in a rural area. >For some remote regions, blizzards taking out the electrical grid is a real concern. Effectively every fossil fuel powered heater being installed requires electricity for the fans to work. >You need a local mechanism to generate heat and an on-site propane/oil tank is the only realistic option. A backup generator that runs on propane. You'd need a backup generator to begin with even for propane heating, so just go full electric with a heat pump.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoEh, most rural folks I know have wood heaters or fireplace inserts, even in the south. If the power is out, they can still manage to keep a room toasty warm and the pipes from freezing. Same with having a gas stove. It's really nice to be able to have a hot meal when the power is out from a hurricane or whatever. I'm all for electrifying things, but I wouldn't bet my life on them.
- SAI_Peregrinus 3y agoEven non-rural areas. See the December 2022 North American winter storm's[1] effects on Buffalo, NY. 11 people froze to death in their homes because power was out for days. Of course a lot of that blame goes to the city government for not having a plan to close the roads well in advance of the blizzard, having no plan to clear the side streets of snow, and thus making it impossible for the power company to service many of the downed lines in residential neighborhoods. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/December_2022_North_American_winter_storm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/December_2022_North_American_w...
- gruez 3y agoWhile I feel like heat pumps have come a long way and have their uses, the article/study grossly misrepresents the advantage that heatpumps have over fossil fuel heaters. 1. Overall efficiency: fossil fuel heaters burn fuels directly and produce heat, whereas heat pumps require electricity to be generated somehow and then for the electricity to be used. If you have a heat pump with a COP of 2, but the electricity comes from a natural gas power plant with efficiency of 40%, then that's an "overall" COP of 0.8, not 2. If you have a natural gas heater with 90% efficiency, that's actually more efficient than the heat pump overall, despite having a lower COP. 2. Price efficiency: similar to the above, electricity is more expensive than gas in most markets. Even if the efficiency is double that of a natural furnace, if electricity costs more than double than gas (per unit of energy), you can't really conclude that "heat pumps triumph over fossil fuels". If you take these factors into account, heat pumps don't really "triumph over" fossil fuels once you get below around freezing. Things get more complicated when you're optimizing for carbon emissions vs energy/cost alone, or the upfront cost of the fossil fuel heater (to have the option of using fossil fuel, you need a fossil fuel heater which costs money, so you forgo that and only use the heat pump you might come out on top if it doesn't get too cold too often), but it's frustrating seeing articles proclaiming "COP > 1 therefore heatpumps better".
- bryanlarsen 3y agoNatGas power plants typically have an efficiency above 55% and most heat pumps operate well above a COP of 2 unless it is super cold. But your point #2 is dead on. The best path to decarbonization is electrification, and expensive electricity is going to slow that down dramatically.
- katbyte 3y agoElectricity seems to generally be expensive where the “free market” has enabled private companies to extract wealth, and then reasonable/cheap and reliable where a Goverment entity provides it. I love my 9c cad Goverment power (and that is after the last right leaning government saddled it with 20 billion in additional costs going straight to private companies)
- 3y ago
- dunefox 3y agoBut would oil companies profit as much? Didn't think so.
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoHeat pumps suffer from some issues that I believe can be solved from a policy point's of view. Heat pumps aren't that powerful. To enjoy it to its fullest you must have a well-insulated house, and ideally low-temperature floor heating. That way the insulation and floor's volume provide the buffer for when your heat pump is defrosting. So getting a heat pump without insulation is not smart. Then there's the cost. A gas heater is 3 times as cheap, and for that price, 3 times as expensive. Lastly, there's the issue of when it's really cold and the heat pump cannot extract heat from the outside air (this is much less a problem when you have an water to water heat pump, but they are significantly more expensive). Then the thing just runs on electricity. And that can be VERY expensive in certain parts of the worlds. So we need incentives for insulation first. Then heat pumps. And probably electricity plans that a cold month isn't insanely more expensive.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoMaybe I am wrong, but I thought colder climates already had legal requirements for insulation. Warm climates seem to be the ones with a more lassiez faire attitude. Which is not ideal, but mostly fine? The temperate gradient of 10f to 70f is significantly worse than 90f to 70f.
- SAI_Peregrinus 3y agoThose requirements tend to be present for new construction, but old buildings get "grandfathered in" and are exempt. The apartment I currently rent has essentially no insulation. There's the outer (wood) cladding, an air gap, then the lath & plaster inner walls. Single-pane windows. In Buffalo, NY.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoHow old is that old building? My wooden house in Norway was built in 1952 in a time of relative poverty not long after the war yet it had insulation (wood wool) and double windows from the very beginning.
- tstrimple 3y ago
- yodelshady 3y agoThe crossover point in any grid that has significant gas presence - which is absolutely ANY "renewable" grid- is not a COP of 2. It is 3. That is, per this graph, 5 C. A temperature at which if you do things right, process heat (ovens, showers, humans) should be supplying enough of the required delta T that you really don't need to spend a lot with any energy source. And that's the marginal crossover point, not the "I need to remodel my home" crossover point. Just... what happened to the meanest part of self-criticism that science bodies used to have? Do they think other people won't ask questions? Because I'm sorry, they do so a great deal more now than ever. Many of those "questions" are stupid. But some are not, and shouting them all down means people should distrust you.
- arthur2e5 3y agoComment confused me a little bit (won't heat pump heat be reused too?), until I realized that you were factoring in gas-to-electricity efficiency. That makes sense.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoCalculations should include not just the CO2 output per kWh of today's grid but also the CO2 output per kWh of the grid over the 20 year expected lifespan of the heat pump. Most developed countries have committed to a net-zero grid by 2035. Even if you believe that they'll break that commitment, they will likely get close.
- antod 3y agoAre they taking into account the side benefit of fossil fuels? The more you use them, the less you need to worry about the cold in the future. It's like a two birds with one stone thing.
- trashtester 3y agoIf the temperature outside is -20, heat pumps have an efficiency of around 200%. That's nice. But if you feed it electricity from a coal plant running at 33% efficiency, total efficiency becomes 66%, less than many stoves. That doesn't take into account the transfer loss or the cost of producing an maintaining all that gear. In places where the vast majority of electricity comes from renewables or nuclear and where the supply is quite stable, heat pumps still make sense in cold weather. But using lignite based power plants to fuel heat pumps in Eastern Europe is something that is attractive more because it lets you heat buildings in highly populated areas while having the air pollution happen far away from population centers.
- mikewarot 3y agoGround loop heat pumps offer a COP of 3 to 5. If I were to start from scratch, I'd have a diesel/gas powered generator for backups, and if possible, use the exhaust heat to help increase the COP even higher. Even with the inefficiency of the generator, you'd likely get more than twice the heating out of such a system than just burning the fuel directly.
- rasz 3y agoIv seen some presentations of modern heating systems where exhaust is almost ambient temperature - they are that efficient in extracting heat.