7 ms·
The MacBook Air M2 is so good it's given Apple a problem
- smoldesu 3y ago> The first is the extra graphics power of the M2 chip in the 13-inch MacBook Air – providing you go for the 10-core GPU only available in the 512GB model. > Despite being a laptop that's light enough to pick up with two fingers, the MacBook Air M2 can run the likes of Total War: Warhammer 3, a game that can make my slightly long-in-the-tooth gaming PC splutter. For reference, the $400 Steam Deck also runs it just fine: https://youtu.be/OhkVjcFGEAQ https://youtu.be/OhkVjcFGEAQ The article hits a nail on the head here, but this feels more like a broader industry problem. "Where do we go next" is also the current problem that AMD and Nvidia are both facing too. If Intel wasn't working on improving their fabs and services, they'd probably be in the same boat. We now have so much compute power on-the-go that we struggle to use it all properly. It's a good problem to have! For my money, the "final frontier" is more capable software.
- washadjeffmad 3y agoOr bringing back functionally integrated hardware and ports. I just got a Bambu X1C, and all I need to do is print eDP display mounts to finish* my OTG "cyberdeck" mITX build. Once I scale it down, I'll have something I could only have gotten if I'd bought a 96GB M2 Max with no battery for just 90% of the price! * (Yeah, right.)
- mnky9800n 3y agoWhy does it need to go anywhere at all?
- melling 3y ago“My hope is that Apple doesn't try to hurry out, say, a MacBook Air M3” Seriously? Drop an M3 in there as soon as it’s ready. Also, Apple still sells 8GB machines with a $200 upgrade to 16GB. Moore’s Law might be dead but we shouldn’t go down without a fight.
- slaymaker1907 3y agoAccording to Newegg, you can buy a 16GB RAM kit for $32 *total*. A $200 upgrade should be getting you 64GB+ and base models should really have a minimum of 16GB.
- wombat-man 3y agoMemory in apple silicon chips is in the unified chip. It's not just adding another stick of ram. But yes, how Apple prices upgrades is a little irritating in light of other options.
- rasz 3y agoPackage not chip, ram is soldered on top of cpu. You know who else does that? The other king of performance and expensive computing - Raspberry pi.
- wombat-man 3y agoWell, the point I was making is upgrading ram on a pc isn't really comparable. But sure, the raspberry pi. 2gb for $45. 4gb for $55(22% increase). 8gb for $75(66% increase over base) Both definitely price for higher margins for buyers who want more memory.
- postalrat 3y agoSo 1gb of ram in the raspberry pi costs about $5. $200 would buy 40 gigs if they had that option. For $200 apple gives you 8gb.
- chorsestudios 3y agoI'm not sure this is a fair comparison. The M2 was manufactured using the considerably more expensive N5P technology node. The 28nm cpu in the rasperry pi 4 was designed using a value node specifically to drive down price / transistor. EUV lithography is extraordinarily expensive so paying a premium for it seems appropriate.
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoI'd love to see a handheld game console with a M2/M3 Apple being stubborn missed an opportunity to work with Nintendo for their Switch 2 There are rumors about Apple working on a console, so maybe that'll happen some day Game Porting Toolkit is a hint https://developer.apple.com/games/ https://developer.apple.com/games/
- kanwisher 3y agoIt's called an iPad and it already has an M1. My son and all his friends almost exclusively game on iPads. So the next generation will be more used to touch screens then game controllers
- gjsman-1000 3y agoYou're kidding, right? Nintendo Switch has sold about 130 million units, over 6 years. Apple ships about 60 million iPads per year, for all use cases, but from 2017-2019 it was hovering around 45 million. 2018 was a really bad year at about 33 million. So, we're currently at about 283 million iPads sold since the Switch launch, missing 2023 - so maybe more like 310-320 million, for all uses cases which go far beyond gaming. 130 million Nintendo Switches. Pretty reasonable to say they are pretty even. Except, of course, they aren't even in the high-quality, paid games market where the revenue on iOS is a joke. How many games does iOS have that are paid, don't have IAPs, timers, or Loot Boxes? How many support local multiplayer on the same device? Switch has got hundreds, if not thousands; iOS has... name five.
- emodendroket 3y agoEverything on Apple Arcade fits your criteria.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoWell sure, that's about the only place, if you don't mind the subscription. The flip side though is that so many Apple Arcade titles are also available on Switch. Even ones that Apple showed in their presentations. You can also actually buy them without a subscription.
- kanwisher 3y agoLLMs (large language models) running locally in privacy are the next killer app. Mac Studio can already run 180b models that compete with Gpt-3.5, 2-3 more generations and MacBook airs will be able to run locally. Apple is already deploying smaller LLMs to macOS. This will drive the next hardware cycle
- smoldesu 3y agoIt's nice, but my Skylake laptop from 2016 also has pretty good llama.cpp acceleration. It might not drive the next hardware cycle as much as memory and storage constraints will.
- comboy 3y ago> Apple is already deploying smaller LLMs to macOS hm?
- oceanplexian 3y agoI don't know about macOS but they are supposedly including a local, transformer-based language model for autocorrect in iOS 17
- Spartan-S63 3y agoTheir improvements to the keyboard auto-correction features is coming to their new software as an on-device LLM. Basically, it looks like they're improving the neural engines on their chips, over time, to start running more LLMs on-device to ensure user data privacy.
- tcmart14 3y agoI've only dabbled in development in xcode a little. Most of my programming on my M1 are C and Rust programs. But the tooling for apple apps (macOS, iOS, etc) in xcode make it pretty easy with Core ML to make some models and bundle it into your app to run locally on the device it gets installed on. At least that is my understanding on playing with it (someone with more experience with CoreML correct me if I am wrong on that). So its not just Apple themselves, but they make it easier for developers to do it also.
- thangngoc89 3y agoI was skeptical when decided to go for an MBA M2 but right now I’m absolutely love it. Being able to just pick the laptop up, walk elsewhere because of it’s extremely lightweight. Charge once every night at home and don’t have to worry about battery at all. Note: I have a beefy server for compiling and AI training so the laptop is just a remote controller.
- dangus 3y agoNot a lot of useful insight in this article, but it does make me want to remind all of you that if you want MacBook Air, especially the 15” version, consider the 14” MacBook Pro. The price gap looks big, but it’s actually not. If you consider the upgrade to 16GB or RAM and 512GB of storage, you’re already at $1500 for the 13” model or $1700 for the 15” model. $1999 gets you the 14” MacBook Pro with 16GB/512GB standard, where you a get better screen, microphone, speakers, processor, graphics, thermal performance, I/O including HDMI port and dual external screen support. You sacrifice a little weight and thickness but not much else, and the difference in a backpack (especially with the 15” Air) is minimal. And here’s the other thing: you can just pick up the M1 14” MacBook Pro and essentially have a better machine in every way at a very similar cost to the base price of the M2 Air models. You can’t really do that in the same way with the M1 Air because you’re sacrificing the newer superior form factor to get a system with a really ancient design, large bezels, and bad webcam, while the M1 MacBook Pro compared to the M2 is a nearly identical system with almost all of the same advantages. The 8GB/256GB models of the MacBook Air are a price anchor more than a practical model, because I think that the majority of buyers should upgrade at least one of those specs if not both regardless of how light their usage is.
- denimnerd42 3y agothe 14" pro is so much better. The on board speakers are so much better and the ports on both sides is obviously so much more convenient. The con is the weight but it's a fair tradeoff if you spend most of your time working at a desk and not just surfing on the sofa. the big problem with the 8/256 is not that it's useless, it's that it's the primary model retailers like costco, bestbuy, etc purchse. So you end up with these great sales on useless computers. I'm sure some clueless people buy them and suffer from that but I can't recommend them to anybody. The price ends up being double the 8/256 price once the sales occur. 8/256 for $800 or 900 vs 16/512/or 1TB for 1600+ infuriating.
- washadjeffmad 3y agoThat's funny, the only two electronics deals I routinely follow are Costco's Macs and Chromebooks. Their $799 M1 Air is still a steal, and the M1 Mac Mini for $299 was unbeatable for the moment it lasted ($499 for the M2 Mini is pretty great, as well). $1200 for an 8GB M2 Air, though... It's a bit steep in comparison, but on it's own, it's really a 13" MBP inside... And if it's practically a Pro, why not just get the 14" for $1600? I think their final lineup of sickly Intel Macs really distorted things with the operations-centric "come get your ports, lol" pricing. Those are awful machines, and setting the expectation that a device's capability should be related to its display size was such a thinly veiled intelligence test. Between barely refreshing their hardware over a decade (the trashcan Pro was X79-based) and Batterygate, it wasn't their brightest era.
- mark_l_watson 3y agoI think Apple has the same problems with iPads. True, I did buy a new M1 iPad Pro two years ago and I love it (16G memory, 1TB “disk”), but when I travel like I am doing now I travel with an almost five year old small iPad Pro - this old piece of hardware really does most of what I need, including light duty programming on a VPS via mosh/ssh. Come to think of it, my Apple Watch is about five years old and still does everything I need. Apple is transitioning to a partially services company, which is a good move. Apple gets about $45/month from my family. EDIT: I also usually get at least four years service from Mac laptops, and even longer for two really old ones that run Linux.
- lacker 3y agoYeah, especially iPads for kids - if one day the newest version of Minecraft required a new iPad, I'd be buying three new iPads. But it doesn't, it works fine, and for the kids I'm even less likely to buy a new device just because it's faster and has more space and a better camera etc etc.
- plorkyeran 3y agoI still use an iPad Air 2 (from 2014) and every year I look at the new iPad coming out, think about upgrading, and just don't see a point. It's stuck on iOS 15 so I might finally be forced to upgrade to a device because of that eventually, but otherwise it does a perfectly adequate job of everything I want out of an iPad nearly 9 years later.
- technofiend 3y agoI'm with you in that there's no compelling reason to upgrade my iPad Pro because it just works. Having said that, I'm mulling over a mini, studio or macbook pro for a development system, but not the air. Why not the air? For reasons unclear to me Apple only includes Wifi 6e support on the Pro devices and not the latest Air. That's also currently true on the ipad line: only the pro devices speak 6e as well. Does it really matter on the ipad? Perhaps not, but in my area wifi pollution is so rampant, the devices I most rely upon (cell phone, windows laptop) speak 6e because it's the only way to get decent transfer rates. In fact I nearly purchased a macbook but decided to roll the device on an upgrade instead first because it was so cheap to do so. This would never happen with an apple device - my six year old windows laptop's upgrade to 6/6e was a $25 part purchased on Amazon and replaced on the motherboard in a matter of minutes. That's the other reason I'm not really dying to buy an apple device, no matter how portable or how great battery life is: it's a wasting asset that is designed to be unrepairable, much less upgradeable. And although it can be handy to do development locally, mosh/ssh and guacamole make it so there's no compelling reason to upgrade my six year old laptop either.
- JamilD 3y agoI think out of all companies, Apple has generally been the best (though not perfect) at maintaining focus even when a product is "good enough". I felt the same about the early MacBook Airs too, and my iPads. Reaching a local optimum is not necessarily a bad thing. My brother still uses my 2012 original retina MBP, and it works fine. For most people, upgrading every 4 or 5 years is more than enough for any Mac.
- nolok 3y agoTo be entirely fair, this is not just a macbook think and mostly a computer thing. My 4 years old work windows laptop is a dell xp13 with an i7-8something cpu and is more than enough for anyone who was ok with that laptop when it came out. Which is not to say the m2 isn't awesome, but since bazillion core cpu and nvme drives became commonplace there isn't much beside very heavy usage (gaming, ia, ... anything that require a top level gpu) that can stop an "old" computer, even a laptop.
- soylentcola 3y agoThat's what I've found as well. Only bothered to update my 10yo computer during 2020 work from home because I wanted to play around with some new stuff, had a bit of disposable income since I wasn't going anywhere, and it had been long enough that the performance jump would be nice in games/playing with graphics rendering stuff. But I easily could've kept using it for another several years for all but the most demanding software and it was an i7-3770k/16gb/GTX980/various SSDs/HDDs. Still, I understand that the form factor meant that portability wasn't an issue. The difference between a 10yo laptop and a modern one would've been much, much more noticeable.
- musicale 3y ago10-12 years ago was a sea change for laptops. On the Apple side, the "Retina" MacBook pro was a drastic improvement over its predecessors because of the display as well as the fast flash storage, while preserving a thin(ish) form factor. Unfortunately Apple followed up with some missteps like the awful "butterfly" keyboard, and the unpopular touch bar which initially removed a physical ESC key.
- denimnerd42 3y agoThey must have made like 90% of the models they sent out to retailers 256gb/8gb. This is frankly ridiculous as it's not a model I can recommend even on sale. I know they have their reasons, icloud, etc. but what a bad situation it creates for the consumer.
- r00fus 3y agoMy extended family has 5 M1 Air (base model) laptops and they're absolutely great and are way more powerful than they need. I only hear the occasional compliment, and no complaints. The storage is expandable externally, and the RAM is actually quite usable even on heavy loads.
- denimnerd42 3y agothe m1 is plenty powerful. not doubting that. my issue is the storage. the storage is not expandable actually. 256 is pathetic unless you only have cloud based workflows (which is what apple wants obvious for that reoccuring revenue).
- smoldesu 3y agoMy extended family bought an SUV instead of a minivan a few months ago. No complaints from them either, but I won't pretend it's a perfect car.
- denimnerd42 3y agosame manufacturer issue there too lol. like the toyota highlander and toyota sienna share the same factory but you can't find a sienna anywhere and a highlander can be found at dealers.
- r00fus 3y agoI think my point was that the commenter above mine complained that Apple pre-produced 90% of the base model. Fact is, 90% of people don't need any more than 256GB local storage or 8GB ram, so I think the distribution ratio is fine. disclaimer: Sienna owner.
- ipqk 3y agoBut wait, everyone keeps telling me that Apple cripples their products after a couple years forcing you to buy their latest version.
- lethologica 3y agoI’m still using a 2015 MacBook Pro. It still runs fine. I’m looking at replacing it with an M3 MacBook Air when they come out though.
- jpsouth 3y agoI've got the M2 Air with 8GB and the only time I've noticed any form of lag is when I've got a K8s cluster running locally with loads of containers. Looking back, the 16GB would have been nice, but it's hardly common that I will put the device under such load.
- mcintyre1994 3y agoThere are many Apple devices that are good arguments against that claim, but the barely over a year old M2 Air isn’t one.
- whynotmaybe 3y agoApple says it. "The company also says its power management update – introduced in 2017 to manage demands on older batteries or with a low level of charge – only reduced an iPhone 6's performance by an average of 10%." https://www.reuters.com/technology/apple-fights-2-bln-london-lawsuit-throttling-millions-iphones-2023-05-02/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/apple-fights-2-bln-london...
- musicale 3y agoYou might only ("only") get ~7 years of OS updates. A bit of a shame if the hardware is still OK. My 2016 model is abandoned for macOS Ventura and will probably only get macOS security patches through next year. I'd probably pay extra for a macOS LTS that actually had 10 years of support. ;-) I expect a lot of machines will be orphaned when macOS switches to ARM-only.
- nicole_express 3y agoThe big change I'd like to see in the MacBook Air line is the return of the 11" option; I realize that's too small for a lot of people but for me it was the perfect carry-everywhere form factor for a laptop. (Of course, I also found the iPhone mini line perfect-sized and that got dropped, so I'm probably an outlier)
- uuddlrlrbaba 3y agoThat's interesting. After trying a 13" macbook myself, I sized back up to a 16" and personally wont be going back. There is only a marginal difference in my backpack, I don't really notice it. But every time I was using the smaller device I was getting annoyed with the small screen and cramped keyboard/trackpad setup.
- pjot 3y agoIs the keyboard/trackpad on 16” not the same size as on the 13”?
- cassianoleal 3y agoKeyboard, yes. Trackpad, no. I prefer the smaller trackpad on the smaller laptops. Too much false touching on the larger ones.
- Fezzik 3y agoThis is me, still clinging to my 2015 11” Air. My biggest gripe is I miss the screen ratio. 16:9 is so much more aesthetically pleasing and functional to me than the 16:10 ratio of the new models. That 1 unit makes a world of difference to me.
- Clubber 3y agoDifferent strokes for different folks. I despise the 16:9 ratio and glad it's finally phasing out, if just a little bit. I read a lot of text, so that extra vertical unit is huge for me.
- drewg123 3y agoTo me, it seems like the best feature Apple could offer on a Macbook is a 2-in-1 form factor, with a touch screen and an iPad mode. I refuse on principal to carry an iPad and a macbook, since its basically the same hardware, and iOS apps should run on Macbooks (and do, if the developer hasn't outright blocked them, which sadly most do).
- mcphage 3y agoI don't really get this article at all. The M2 Air is a good, solid machine. Apple should be in the business of making good, solid machines. It doesn't matter how good this year's M3 Air is; I'm not going to buy it, because my year old M2 Air is great. In 5 or 6 years (or more) when I'm looking to replace my M2 Air with a M7 or M8 Air, hopefully that'll be a good, solid machine, too. Laptops aren't fast fashion.
- rcarr 3y agoThe 3nm chips in the M3 are rumoured to bring about a 30% improvement in power efficiency. If I wasn't moving towards using an Android for everything, I would definitely think about selling my M1 for that sort of improved battery life.
- 1nf_ 3y agoWould like to hear more about using Android for everything!
- rcarr 3y agoSo I’m about to start some long term travelling so I’ve been looking to shrink down my setup as small as possible. The plan is to use some Viture AR glasses for the monitor, a ProtoArc folding keyboard, a Swiftpoint Propoint mouse and then either a Pixel 8 (my first choice if it’s got the rumoured desktop mode) or a Samsung Galaxy S22 with Dex, which will be housed in a QuadLock MAG case which allows you to swap magnetic battery packs on and off really easily. I can then keep the phone in my pocket or a bag with the AR glasses attached and then the peripherals connected over Bluetooth. I personally think this is going to be the best way of doing it because if you have a usb hub connected to the phone for a powerbank or accessories the cables start becoming a mess on your desk, especially as you’ve got one cable that moves about when you do. Depending on where I work I may end up getting a wireless external portable monitor like the Asus Zenscreen Go so I can take meetings because the phone screen might be a bit small and if I’m wearing glasses people might find it a bit jarring. I’d be using the phone as the webcam and get it to eye level using the Quadlock tripod. Another option would be to use a Samsung Galaxy Fold, but they’re crazy expensive and they also have some durability issues so I’m not keen. You also lose the advantage of the being able to use a quadlock and the swappable battery packs. On the software side of things, I’m going to do all my dev work in containers via Codespaces/CodeCatalyst. Apparently someone has made a native android version of vscode now, if not there is the browser version. For gaming, I can use an 8bitdo SN30 Pro/razor kishi and Nvidia GeForce Now which in addition to the standard streaming library allows you to play games you’ve already purchased on Steam. I’m opting for taking two 8bitdos as well as a usb-c to hdmi cable in case I make any friends on the go I have a portable 2 player gaming setup that doesn’t take up much more space than a sunglasses case. If that doesn’t end up happening after a year or so I’ll ditch the 8bitdos and the cable and get a kishi for more convenient solo gaming. I was originally going to do this entire setup with a Steam Deck instead of an android but found it awkward to pack and it’s also not available worldwide so if something happened to my machine in say Australia, I wouldn’t easily be able to get another one without waiting a while and paying through the nose. If there’s any specialist software I want to use, I’ll spin up a cloud instance for it using AWS/Azure, there’s a few options for this now: - AWS workspaces and Azure Virtual Desktop if you want a GUI desktop experience in the browser. - AWS Appstream and Azure RemoteApp if you want to stream just a single application. - EC2 and Azure VMs if you’re no bothered about a GUI or you want to roll everything yourself. I don’t expect to have to do this often as I reckon I can get by on mainly android apps. I use Obsidian for notes, there’s Adobe Premiere Rush for video editing etc. If you want more examples, head over to the Samsung Dex subreddit. There’s quite a few people on there who have ditched their computers and have been using Dex for the last year.
- not_enoch_wise 3y agoIf this isn’t an advertisement, why does this article exist?
- xedrac 3y agoIf I could run Linux on one if these, that would be something. Apple makes great hardware, but I am not as fond of their walled garden software.
- naruhodo 3y agoI'd consider it if there was Linux and a 17 inch screen.
- ksec 3y ago>Notably, I've loved using Microsoft Surface laptops – their keyboards are awesome, in my humble opinion They have the same keyboard as the MBA / MBP 2015. The old Apple Scissors keyboard. Unfortunately Apple wanted every one to get used to typing like on iPad Screen they slim down the key distance to ridiculous level aka Butterfly. The new Magic keyboard is no where as good as scissors. >So where does Apple go next? Better Built in Camera although I am not sure how that is possible given how slim the lid is, and if they move to OLED for power efficiency it will be even slimmer. Intergated 5G Modem. Apple should have a 4G/5G only modem ( Not even 3G ) on MacBook to test out all quirks before it is even used on iPhone. And then a 3nm / 2nm M Series that is just more efficient. I mean these small but important iteration are enough for all the way till 2030. The form factor and power level itself has reached the end of the S curve. Note: I am still on my MBP 2015. So that is coming close to 10 years of using it. The last real improvement I see was the M1. But I hate the keyboard so much those improvement dont compare. Hopefully I could use this for another 3-5 years.
- manchmalscott 3y agoThe apple silicon laptops don't use the butterfly keyboard, they reverted that change.
- ksec 3y agoThey use the new magic keyboard and that is what I said in the post. The magic keyboard is still not the same as the old scissors keyboard. Magic Keyboard has a key travel of 1mm, while old scissors has 1.3mm.
- inkyoto 3y ago> Intergated 5G Modem. Apple should have a 4G/5G only modem ( Not even 3G ) on MacBook to test out all quirks before it is even used on iPhone. Please no, in any laptop. Mobile networks evolve faster than the computing hardware, and 5G (as well as 3G and 4G) is somewhat meaningless as 3G/4G/5G operate on different bands on different frequencies in different countries which means laptops will become region locked again. Over the last 12 years, laptop mobile modems have morphed from ugly PCMCIA extension cards through USB dongles through to portable WiFi enabled mobile devices (MiFi devices), 3G has seen a nearly full demise, 4G is nearing one whereas the laptop from 12 years ago can still work irrespective of the mobile network evolution. The MiFi devices seems to be the sweet spot as they decouple the laptop from the mobile network technology, are cheaper and easier to upgrade and also come with an added benefit of allowing multiple devices to connect to the mobile network which results in a better mobile network capacity utilisation as opoposed to each device requiring a separate capacity slot.
- sillywalk 3y ago(owner of mba m2) USB ports on both sides FFS, maybe even more than 2?
- bazmattaz 3y ago> One obvious - and genuinely exciting - upgrade would be to give the MacBook Air a touch screen. Really? A touch screen on a laptop just seems like a feature no user ever asked for. It makes sense that devices like tablets and phones have touch’s screens. It’s how the evolved. But laptops have keyboards - why do they need a feature of touch devices? What problem does this solves for users?