6 ms·
Pentagon’s shameful effort to draft mentally disabled men to fight in Vietnam
- AlgorithmicTime 3y ago[dead]
- bm3719 3y agoPeople with IQs below 91 walk among us. Not sure why Project 100000 gets so much criticism of the moralizing type. Sure, it turned out to be a bad idea in retrospect and should have been a smaller trial run first, but the idea isn't crazy if you put yourself into McNamara's time and place. I could easily see myself thinking that systems were autopilot enough that the IQ of the body component of modern warfare to be of lesser importance. And if that were in fact true, we'd have found a way for such individuals to contribute. Is it more moral for the inevitable sacrifices of warfare to be solely among a society's higher IQ individuals? In the end, it turned out that those of lower IQ would continue having less of a productive role in society--something that was already accelerating at the time. Perhaps that's the real tragedy here. We have an oversupply of those only capable of simple labor. Maybe trying more "x's Morons" ideas isn't such a bad idea?
- bt4u 3y agoA simpler and probably more effective solution (and arguably more moral) would be to make it so only the sons of billionaires and sitting elected officials are allowed to go to war. We would have worldwide peace within a week.
- fakedang 3y agoDownvoted by the temporarily embarrassed, soon-to-be-multi-millionaire developers on Hacker News.
- Waterluvian 3y agoWarfighting, while largely a rote memorization and muscle memory exercise in many ways, is only getting more complex and requires more capability. Western doctrine also leans more than ever on the people being the valuable part of the war machine. This is because you can’t retrain as easily as you can build more tanks when training is now measured in months/years vs. weeks. And because battlefield experience is worth far far more than anyone generally understands. If you read the detailed accounts of this program, it’s clear that it wasn’t some inclusivity exercise. They wanted cheap fodder. They really just got a lot of battlefield liability. We’re witnessing what a “soldier comes second” doctrine looks like in Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Of course I’m all for better support for the less mentally capable. But let’s not pretend that fighting in a war doesn’t require intelligence.
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoanother name for "solder comes second" is quantity vs quality doctrine
- hulitu 3y ago> Western doctrine also leans more than ever on the people being the valuable part of the war machine. It really depends who's people.
- freemanon 3y ago[flagged]
- wolverine876 3y agoIf we completely ignore the human beings involved (it still is idiotic). They aren't dogs or machines, but real people, like you. War is a nightmare for fully capable humans, leading to lifetimes of PTSD, high rates of suicide, and much more damage. Beyond the emotional damage, people need to be able to function to survive. An autistic person under fire in a small intimate squad is in hell. It's also a threat to the people around them, whose lives depend on them, and highly demoralizing - setting an example of transparently bad judgment and disregard for even basic humanity of their own fellow soldiers. And it's a threat to the mission. I know it's trendy to perform amoral, sociopathic disregard for humanity (and geerally to post boundary-crossing provocations on the Internet). It's a very, very dangerous thing - which is probably why it's trendy; people like to play with those things, to look edgy. Our behaviors truly influence reality, as we know well now; the Internet is not a separate world, like a multi-player video game, but part of reality with direct impact. Also, not only does choosing that behavior introduce an enormous negative, but we feel the absence of the positive. If you and I don't do the latter, who will? There's no parents out there to fix what we break as we play. The world needs you.
- bigbillheck 3y ago> Is it more moral for the inevitable sacrifices of warfare to be solely among a society's higher IQ individuals? They're the ones that run the society, so I don't see why not.
- fakedang 3y agoThe fact that this tone-deaf comment is the top comment right now speaks volumes of the second nature of people on this website. Modern warfare, especially that since World War 1 and the rise of deaths on the battlefront on a massive scale, requires a high amount of intelligence on all levels to be executed. You need generals who can envision new strategies such as the blitzkrieg or the paradrop. You need sergeants and master sergeants to provision and allocate adequate resources for your regiments. You need privates and conscripts to figure out where enemy mines are, or to follow orders from top to execute their complex maneuvers. Of course, you could also adopt ages-old Russian-style human steamroller doctrines and send in men after men to their deaths, just like the world did in WW1. We're already seeing that in Ukraine - 3 day operation is going strong after 500+ days. > Maybe trying more "x's Morons" ideas isn't such a bad idea? Perhaps the US government should enlist a number of upvoters of this comment, put them on the median national wage and force them to work for days on to refurbish creaking government IT systems? Just a thought, heh.
- jhanschoo 3y agoIt is a balance. In the other extreme you can't just have gifted people manning your army, or you will have lack of manpower. Not all roles require average or above-average intellect anyway. Of course, we are discussing defensively, where one weighs the danger posed to, and contributed by, a low-IQ individual against the counterfactual of civilian liberties lost owing to the failure of the military from a lack of manpower.
- fakedang 3y agoAgain, you don't need gifted people to run along your entire army. You do need gifted people to lead it in the war room. And you cannot sustain it by having those gifted people leading poor IQ people - they need to be people able to follow commands while also being able to take initiative at the lack of command. For that, you need folks with an average level of intelligence.
- thworp 3y agoI think McNamara is the poster child for what damage unconstrained technocracy can do. This project is one of the less horrible ones he spearheaded, but it too had results that were completely predictable to anyone on the ground (who actually had to check their notions against reality).
- WeylandYutani 3y agoHe was dealing with the naive and idealistic bullshit that Americans are actually willing to fight in the wars that they vote for. The Pentagon immediately scrapped the draft following Vietnam and started recruiting from the trailer parks.
- mortureb 3y agoThe motivation wasn’t inclusivity, it was the idea of “less valuable” humans being more dispensable.
- ookdatnog 3y ago> People with IQs below 91 walk among us. I feel like you're misrepresenting what the article is about. I'm pretty sure it's not the people whose IQ is a bit below 91 we're really talking about here. As the article states (emphasis mine): > These men all had IQs below 91, and nearly half had IQs below 71. What people find inhumane about this policy isn't "the army recruited a guy with an IQ of 87 from our town", but "the army recruited a guy with an IQ of 68 who can't read or write and has never heard of Vietnam from our town". An IQ below 71 is typically labelled as a cognitive impairment, not only now, but then as well. These are people who are often considered unable to function independently in normal civilian life. The idea that, even with modern tech, a war environment is much simpler to navigate than civilian life, seems so obviously absurd to me that I have trouble even articulating an argument against it. > Is it more moral for the inevitable sacrifices of warfare to be solely among a society's higher IQ individuals? I object to your use of the term "inevitable". Sacrifices are inevitable during war, but the war itself wasn't inevitable. The moral thing would have been to end the war, rather than prolong a war that leadership knew damn well they were losing at this point.
- jmclnx 3y agoInteresting read, and yes children of the privileged could easily avoid service. That was probably one of the many reasons we "have a culture war" today. At the time, everyone knew the kids of the rich were never sent to Vietnam. Now with the press nothing more than a rumor mill, all abuses that are happening today may never see the light of day. During the invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan, the abuses that were reported were ignored because no one cared. By then, no one had any trust in the US Gov. And now, many Local and National Governments can hide a lot due to a very weak press.
- lo_zamoyski 3y ago> Now with the press nothing more than a rumor mill, all abuses that are happening today may never see the light of day. The press has always been, at best, a manicured presentation of events that, even at its best, is often hemmed in by external constraints. Some might say that the trashiness of today's press is a symptom of the erosion of elite control over an official narrative. Noise and sensationalism not only sell, but they can also function as distractions.
- wolverine876 3y agoWhat do you mean by "trashy" and what publications are you referring to? I'm sure it's out there (whatever it is), but thanks to the Internet I have more high-quality journalism to read than would have been conceivable back then. I don't have time for it all.
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoI think it’s harder to find, though. The lack of gatekeepers means there is a lot more garbage too. We don’t know yet how this will all turn out. Do we have faith in our fellows to sort through and find the good stuff, or do we assume they will mostly get sucked in by the best propaganda? Of course we always assume that we can tell the difference.
- wolverine876 3y ago
- mattw2121 3y ago2,600,000 US Servicemen served in country during Vietnam. 58,156 casualties (hostile + non-hostile). 2.2% casualty rate. This "project" allowed 354,000 to serve. 5,478 casualties of those. 1.5% casualty rate.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wolverine876 3y agoIf we just tortured all 354,000, all would have survived.
- bazoom42 3y agoThe article states: > Project 100,000 soldiers saw combat at a rate nearly twice as high as other soldiers and were killed at a rate three times as high.
- londons_explore 3y agoIf you look at it another way... Previously the army discriminated based on mental health status. An inclusive army should be welcoming everyone, no matter their mental or physical abilities - somewhere within the army, there must be a role for everyone.
- watwut 3y agoArmy is NOT able customize itself for individual nor is advertising itself as much. Instead, it is trying to mold everyone into being as similar to soldier next to him and act exactly the same. Otherwise said, a genius low level soldier is used in the same way as dumbes low level soldier. Army is able to absorb people of different races or gays and learned how to deal with gender. That does not imply it is, as an institution, capable to absorb handicapped people.
- londons_explore 3y agoBut it should probably become that. Just do an aptitude test when you join. Send the genius's to the R&D team. Send the good leaders to the officer training program. Send the good drivers to be tank drivers. etc.
- wolverine876 3y agoAt least some US services are working in that direction.
- watwut 3y agoYou do not have to join as a low level soldier. You can go for being the officer. However, if you enlist as a marine, army needs you to be the same as other marines. That is non-optional. Because, the big issue army is solving is "how to organize and coordinate large number of people effectively". And for that, you all need to be able to follow exact same behaviors, pack stuff at similar speed, the same command needs to lead to the same result with all of you. Aptitude test exist for both enlisted and future officers. However, once you passed the test and are on your position, you all need to be alike.
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoi was wondering if i needed to read the article to confirm that this was the work of one of the MBAs that made its way into govt with robert mcnamara. I only had to read up to the 3rd sentence : "Ehh, he’s one of McNamara’s Morons.”
- logicalmonster 3y agoOften when IQ is brought up, it seems that HN leaps to explain why those tests aren't accurate, don't really mean anything, etc. Is anybody going to make that case here?
- wolverine876 3y agoI don't understand what you want. If you've already read all that before, what else do you want to know? Why not post it yourself?
- purpleflame1257 3y agoThere is some evidence to indicate that the IQ-/life outcome relationship is stronger on the left half of the bell curve. That is to say, the improvement from 85 to 100 IQ is higher than the improvement from 100 to 115.
- watwut 3y agoIn cases where the test misfired, you would had higher IQ people recruited into canon fodder positions where they chance of dying is higher then normal. Army aptitude tests do not test IQ directly. They test general knowledge (like basic math), ability to follow directions, that sort of thing. IQ is not the only mental issue that makes you unsuitable. So kinda, reliability of those tests is not really relevant.
- woodruffw 3y agoThe article goes to lengths to explain that the aptitude tests for these draftees were regularly faked. The point was that people who were manifestly mentally unsuited for the military (whether because of a physical disability or lack of education due to poverty, etc.) were intentionally drafted; nobody is required to have a particular opinion on IQ to think that was probably a bad idea.
- thworp 3y agoThose tests do not mean anything once you clear a lower bound somewhere between 70 and 90. N N Taleb summed it up best as "IQ is a measure of unintelligence.
- _trampeltier 3y agoAnd today we have such Terrorists .. "The FBI came and picked him up from our home, they gave him a vehicle, gave him a fake bomb, and every means to make this happen," the statement said, adding that authorities "should not have aided and abetted a paranoid schizophrenic to commit this act." https://www.cbsnews.com/news/family-fbi-knew-oklahoma-bomb-plot-suspect-is-schizophrenic/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/family-fbi-knew-oklahoma-bomb-p...
- water-data-dude 3y agoHow is that not entrapment?
- rcxdude 3y agoMerely playing along is not entrapment. Entrapment requires the agent to coerce the individual into something they would not normally do. This comic has a good overview of what entrapment is and isn't: https://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=633 https://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=633
- water-data-dude 3y agoOh nice, I learned something today! Thanks for the informative and entertaining resource :)
- codetrotter 3y agoThe part of the Forest Gump story where he served in the military was based on this, someone on Reddit said.
- wolverine876 3y agoIs there a source for that story?
- wrp 3y agoThe military has acceptance standards along the dimensions of height, strength, intelligence, mental health, and I don't know what else. Project 100000 experimented with relaxing the requirement on intelligence, and found negative results from lowering it as much as they did. The change was based on perception of changing nature of warfighting. Something to consider is that more recently the military has been relaxing physical requirements, based on not unsimilar reasoning.
- wolverine876 3y agoRelaxing physical requirements is a different issue. Those people are fully capable and cognizant of deciding whether to join, and can handle the extreme emotional and mental load as well as anyone. Also, they can get themselves into sufficient physical condition. Putting people in that extreme situation without the mental and emotional capability is a nightmare of cruelty.
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoSomeone who was not physically capable of joining the military before they relaxed the physical requirements may be able to handle the mental load, but not necessarily the physical load. That presents just as many problems and dangers to fellow soldiers as someone with a lower IQ.
- wolverine876 3y ago> That presents just as many problems and dangers to fellow soldiers as someone with a lower IQ. That's a big assumption, and I doubt it applies broadly: Many military jobs do not depend much on physical fitness: Drone pilot, mechanic, truck driver, radar operator. Front line service is only one small part. Also, it omits the point that less-than-physically-fit can understand the risks, made their own decisions, and also improve their fitness. Imagine drafting people with physical handicaps - that would be the equivalent of McNamara's horrible program.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y ago
- ydnaclementine 3y agoYou should read Flowers for Algernon if you have not