14 ms·
Why is the ocean salty? (2022)
- johncole 3y agoTIL USGS has an FAQ
- supportengineer 3y agoNa CLue
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- politelemon 3y agoThe variants I've heard on this joke are: Because the land didn't wave back Because it's full of seamen Because it's full of <name of game> players
- asimpleusecase 3y agoTwo questions come to mind. 1) what would our world be like if the oceans were not salty? We could pump fresh water all over the globe, but are there other things that would happen at scale without the salt? 2) by the article it seems like the oceans will always increase in salinity. What is that rate of increase? Then run that model backwards was there a time when salt content was low enough for ocean water to be potable ?
- emodendroket 3y agoIt would surely affect settlement not just in the positive sense (more potable water) but also in the negative (people need salt to live and it wasn’t always as abundant as it is now)
- perihelions 3y agoGlobal climate would be pretty different without ocean currents driven by salinity gradients. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermohaline_circulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermohaline_circulation
- eep_social 3y agoI guess that at the time when ocean water would have been potable it would have had to wait millions of years for an animal to come along and drink. We don’t talk about air being potable ;)
- rsa4046 3y agoThe chemical composition of the world ocean reflects the balance of inputs from the continents (as described, from riverine input as well groundwater), atmospheric cycling, and outputs: extraction via evaporite minerals in marginal environments, weathering at the seafloor, exchange over a range of temperatures with mid-ocean ridge basalt, and precipitation of minerals (mostly in the form of biogenic carbonates such as CaCO3, biogenic silica, etc.), as well as their subsequent dissolution, and lastly the biological processes of CO2 fixation and respiration of organic carbon (including electron acceptors other than O2, such as iron, sulfate, etc.). It is the solubility of sparingly soluble phases such as CaCO3 that controls much of the seawater composition: surface seawater is close to saturation with respect to CaCO3 (calcite, aragonite). Because halite (rock salt, NaCl) is highly soluble, seawater is, conversely, fairly concentrated with respect to these ions. Seawater must be extensively evaporated to remove the far more soluble (evaporite) minerals. Over geologic time, the composition of seawater has changed, reflecting the relative pace of the various processes listed above that deliver and remove components from solution.
- gumby 3y agoAnimals, and perhaps all life, would not exist. We carry the ocean around with us in our circulatory system, from a long ago bootstrap in which some creature needed to drag part of its "home" with it when it left home. Why? Well fresh water is pretty boring. Seawater, with all those polar ions in it, enables and facilitates all sorts of interesting (i.e. useful) chemistry. One of the reasons we can't drink seawater is that our body needs to maintain homeostasis on the blood so the chemistry continues to work properly. If you drink a lot of seawater the kidneys can't excrete the salt fast enough. For that matter, if you drink too much fresh water the opposite happens and you die too.
- iancmceachern 3y agoExactly. We die if we don't get enough salt. There are all sorts of mechanisms in our body that rely on it. As an engineer, I like to think it's as simple as electricity not being nearly as conductive through pure water, various osmosis processes like happens in dialysis, etc.
- eru 3y agoIf the ocean's hadn't been salty, we would likely have biochemistry that doesn't rely on salt so much.. instead of just keeling over.
- iancmceachern 3y agoLife finds a way
- Gibbon1 3y agoJust offhand thought is the earths geology over time tends to remove salt from the ocean. An example is the Messinian Salinity Crisis when the Mediterranean sea closed off and then mostly evaporated. The result was a huge layer of salt deposited under the seabed. And the rest of the earths oceans became much less salty. Would not surprise me if plate subduction doesn't sequester salts as well. https://www2.atmos.umd.edu/~dankd/MessinianWeb/_private/HOME.htm https://www2.atmos.umd.edu/~dankd/MessinianWeb/_private/HOME...
- Gare 3y ago> And the rest of the earths oceans became much less salty. Source for that claim? Mediterranian is still more salty than oceans because of the high evaporation rate.
- Gibbon1 3y agohttps://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40766-023-00042-9 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40766-023-00042-9
- ThePowerOfFuet 3y ago>In a cubic mile of seawater, the weight of the salt (as sodium chloride) would be about 120 million tons. A cubic mile of seawater can also contain up to 25 pounds of gold and up to 45 pounds of silver! But before you go out and try alchemy on seawater, just think about how big a cubic mile is: 1 cubic mile contains 1,101,117,147,000 gallons of water! This is one of the best sales pitches for the metric system that I've ever seen.
- VoodooJuJu 3y ago[flagged]
- emodendroket 3y agoYet regimes all over Europe adapted it anyway. The reason the US retained its system has less to do with the units being so intuitive and more to do with having industrialized early enough that switching would have been expensive.
- spookie 3y agoThe metric system came about around the same time as the U.S. Either way, that intuitive understanding of the imperial system may just come about due to one's growing up with it. I have the same (I assume), innate understanding of the various metric units, given that I was exposed to it all my life. It's easy for me to glance at something and know if it's as big as a centimeter, a couple, perhaps a decimeter or even a meter. The same goes for the volume of something. I think it has more to do with your education, and experience in life, than it's with... the arbitrary way someone came about with those units. Nothing against the imperial system, I understand how difficult it is to leave it now, and no-one could predict if the metric system were to take off at the time. I wish all of us would use only one though.
- emodendroket 3y agoIt seems likely, yeah. Also, these customary units had all kinds of variations (technically they still do in countries using the UK-derived units though in practice the US ones are the ones people care about).
- kbrisso 3y agoI love facts like this, thanks!
- skymast 3y ago[dead]
- leetharris 3y agoThis is a great perspective check. Water is truly a near-infinite resource. If we can master desalination then humanity is in a great spot in regards to fresh water. It also frames the challenge well. Desalinating a cubic mile gives you 120 million tons of leftovers. Another extremely difficult challenge.
- CapitalistCartr 3y agoI wonder if we could use that as a building material.
- thombat 3y agoThose leftovers are water soluble, so either you perform some interesting chemistry to convert them into something more durable or your buildings have to be in arid places (condominium in an old salt mine?)
- zdragnar 3y agoAnything that is water soluble is going to be a pretty poor building material, unfortunately. The organics floating about (protozoa, algae, fish) also generally decompose, another undesirable property. The remainder- very very fine silt and microplastics- might be useful. With all the chemical processing that would be needed to stabilize the salts, mechanical filtering and such, I think we're better off continuing to use bricks and ground sourced gravel and cement. At least the holes we dig can be repurposed into sanitary landfills.
- Blahah 3y agoCorals manage it quite effectively
- zdragnar 3y agoBut not efficiently. Scientists think the polyps absorb bicarbonate and calcium ions and deposit calcium carbonate, but they're not really sure of the bio/chemical process involved. Regardless, a polyp adds about 1mm to 1cm to the reef a year. You can get that right now just by throwing a shovel at the ground where I live.
- pcurve 3y agoI wish more scientific explanation were this concise and to the point. Basically in just one short paragraph.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoYeah, and without being "dumbed down".
- aquafox 3y agoSince salination is essentially driven by the CO2 in the air, does this imply the CO2 we add to the air increases the rate of salination (f' > 0, where f(t) is the salt content of the oceans)? If so, does this affect ocean currents?
- phkahler 3y agoYes, increased CO2 probably contributes. I'm guessing it's a drop in the bucket for ocean currents though. Mining salt and dumping it on roads is probably an issue to, as it runs off and goes down rivers. Again, not doing much because the oceans are so big. But over a million years maybe not so great to do.
- pcthrowaway 3y ago... because the shore never waves back.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- helf 3y ago[dead]
- ColinWright 3y agoSomething I heard a while ago: The sea is salty because it remembers the taste of the land.
- barrkel 3y agoThe answer that springs to mind from general knowledge is that rainwater picks up minerals in solution on the way to the sea, where it gets concentrated by evaporation. The real question is why the sea isn't saltier. Why is the Dead Sea so salty? (Because the Dead Sea is enclosed and in a hot location, so evaporation happens faster.) Why aren't the oceans as salty as the Dead Sea? What is cause of equilibrium? The article briefly mentions (a) "organisms" using the salts, and (b) concentrations continuing to rise (!). So is the ocean on its way to being as dead as the Dead Sea, just really slowly, or what?
- actionfromafar 3y agoIt was less salty in the past, so I always assumed it will get saltier and saltier. Edit: Our blood has the same salt concentration the ocean had when our ancestors formed or split off or something. Someone with actual knowledge will surely come along and enlighten us with a comment.
- marricks 3y agoExactly. It's been around for billion(s?) of years having rain water dissolve land and run into it. Shouldn't it be as salty as it can be? Perhaps it's deep sea flour shenanigans keeping it at some stable level.
- eru 3y agoWell, there are also salt mines where we get the salt for eating and putting on the road from. They are dried up sea bed. So whatever process produces the mineable deposits will necessarily remove salt from the wider oceans. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt_mining https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt_mining
- qup 3y agoThese gluten-free artisinal flours are getting out of hand.
- __alexs 3y agoDon't worry, the melting glaciers are not at all salty so that should keep the concentration down for a while.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoMany of the dissolved ions are used by organisms in the ocean and are removed from the water... The two ions that are present most often in seawater are chloride and sodium. These two make up over 90% of all dissolved ions in seawater. The other ten percent are micronutrients that are also essential to life. Most land animals have a skeleton not just to provide physical scaffolding to hang tissue on but because we need a store of calcium to mediate blood pH, something sea life doesn't require thanks to those minerals in the water. That's why you can have sharks which are mostly supported by cartilage with one set of bones: Their jaws.
- Blahah 3y agoI have long known sharks have cartilaginous skeletons but only just wondered whether that means shark bodies are squishy like human ears? Like if you hugged a shark would it deform?
- DoreenMichele 3y agoI don't know but I wouldn't recommend trying it, at least not without wearing chain mail. Their skin is abrasive if you hug them and call them George and rub their skin backwards.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoNo. The human nose is mostly cartilage and it's hard.
- dang 3y agoRelated: Why is the ocean salty? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16129786 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16129786 - Jan 2018 (90 comments)
- pomtato 3y ago[flagged]
- tiler2915072 3y agoMakes you wonder how big the mountains were that dissolved into all that salt and other minerals…
- Davidzheng 3y agoBut why are the ions primarily Sodium and Chloride, why not like Lithium, Flouride, Magnesium, iron, etc?
- pvg 3y agoLikely some combination of abundance and electronegativity. For instance, from your example - Sodium is about a zillion times more abundant than Lithium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_elements_in_Earth%27s_crust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_elements_in_Earth...
- mcv 3y agoNice graph. But if I understand it correctly, Chloride is about as abundant as Lithium, and less abundant than its neighbours Sulfide, Phospor, Fluoride etc. So why is chloride so abundant in the ocean? Sodium makes sense, but chloride does not. I'm also surprised to see that Nitrogen is relatively rare compared to its neighbours Carbon and Oxygen, despite making up 80% of the atmosphere. Or maybe that's why? Are we losing nitrogen to space?
- pvg 3y agoThe 'electronagativity' was a handwave for 'the chemical and physical properties of the element'. E.g. the solubility of its salts or other compounds in water, processes that cycle or collect it elsewhere, etc. Nitrogen is less reactive than Oxygen, doesn't form as many compounds as Carbon and has a molecule too fat to easily escape into space.
- rocqua 3y agoThose ions can easily remain disolved, even in the presence of many other compouns. Many other ions are quite likely to bond to other ions, causing them to bind and fall out of solution.
- cbovis 3y agoBecause cod made it that way.
- Mistletoe 3y agoI’ve googled this before and gotten a different answer- that it is the water going in and out of the seabed floor and dissolving all the salts in the rock.
- k__ 3y agoThis doesn't explain why the water in springs, creeks, and rivers isn't salty. There is much more water in an ocean for the salt to disperse than in a creek, somehow I can drink from it, but not from the ocean.
- mcv 3y agoI suspect it's because the erosion of the elements from land happens extremely slowly and barely detectable trace amounts, but the oceans is where they accumulate over the course of billions of years. I think the real answer is that these elements (sodium and chloride) easily dissolve in water, and there's no process that removes them from the ocean, so they linger and accumulate.
- onethought 3y agoBecause the water is flowing, in only one direction, with no feedback. So any salt is taken out and put into the ocean/sea it connects to.
- chakintosh 3y agoWater from springs (then creeks) comes out of the ground pre-filtered, some springs are salty, others are red from high concentrations of iron and so on. Second reason is because it's running water, so it doesn't stay in one place accumulating minerals.
- rocqua 3y agoThere is a slight amount of salt in the rivers, but it is very low. In the oceans, this accumulates, but the water evaporates. Hence the salt content goes up whilst the water volume remains constant (ignoring ice melt) which means the salt concentration goes up.
- Tangurena2 3y agoIn the early days of trying to determine the age of the Earth, one set of scientists were trying to determine from mineral flows from rivers into the oceans. Depending on which mineral was picked, the Earth was as young as 20,000,000 or as old as 10x that.
- 3y ago
- mcv 3y ago> Many of the dissolved ions are used by organisms in the ocean and are removed from the water. Others are not used up and are left for long periods of time where their concentrations increase over time. > The two ions that are present most often in seawater are chloride and sodium. This makes it sound like sodium and chloride are the most common ions because they're not used by the organisms in the ocean, unlike all the other dissolved ions. But that's not correct, is it? The ocean is salty because we don't need salt? But we do. So why is there so much salt in the ocean? Do sodium and chloride simply happen to be the most common elements on Earth that are able to dissolve in water?
- hoseja 3y agoThey are used by organisms but they are not removed from circulation. Other ions, calcium etc. are used and incorporated into insoluble minerals.
- mcv 3y agoThanks. That sounds like the real explanation. Although this graph of the abundance of elements[0] puts sodium with the rock-forming elements (and chloride just inside, but on the edge). So doesn't that mean they should also form insoluble minerals? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Elemental_abundances.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Elemental_abundances.svg
- pjc50 3y agoChemistry stackexchange says yes, they do: https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/82328/are-there-any-sodium-salts-that-are-insoluble-in-water https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/82328/are-ther... (wow, there are a lot of different minerals https://www.mindat.org/element/Sodium https://www.mindat.org/element/Sodium .. ah, 50% of the earth's rocks are feldspars which contain some sodium. https://www.imerys.com/minerals/feldspar https://www.imerys.com/minerals/feldspar )
- mcv 3y ago
- b3nji 3y agoFun fact, Blue Whales ejaculate 20 litres each time. Maybe, this is why the ocean is salty?
- bozhark 3y agodoes the whale sperm turn into salt?
- amelius 3y agoAnd how does sea life filter out the ions? And can we acquire that gene, as it would solve a growing problem?
- layer8 3y ago> In a cubic mile of seawater, the weight of the salt (as sodium chloride) would be about 120 million tons. A cubic mile of seawater can also contain up to 25 pounds of gold and up to 45 pounds of silver! Earth’s oceans contain a combined volume of 320 million cubic miles, according to Wikipedia.