4 ms·
Even if Landis is being honest to the best of his ability, this account seems suspect for one simple reason: human memory is incredibly unreliable even in routi
by kelnos 3y ago
Even if Landis is being honest to the best of his ability, this account seems suspect for one simple reason: human memory is incredibly unreliable even in routine cases. Considering the stress and trauma around witnessing and being so close to an awful event like that, as well as the amount of time that has passed, I don't see how we can consider this story to be even remotely reliable.
He may truly remember these events as he is describing them, even if what he's described never actually happened. That's unfortunately how (poorly) human memory works.
- agumonkey 3y agoI agree. Having gone through stuff I know how my mind can distort / hallucinate stuff in confusing / high stress situations. Even without questioning the person's honesty.. your brain is not a high quality source of information.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoTotally, that's why I don't trust anything anyone says, ever. I can't trust that my fallible brain is hearing what people are saying correctly, so even if they're right my understanding of what they're saying may still be wrong.
- bbor 3y agoThere is no such thing as knowledge, just justified beliefs ;)
- WalterBright 3y agoMy dad kept a diary during his WW2 duty. In his 80's, he read it and was shocked to discover it did not line up with his memories.
- paint 3y agoInteresting! Without going into personal details, can you explain what sort of incongruence he found between his diary and his memory? I sometimes keep a diary, for example when I go on long trips that are different from my day-to-day life. I try to be as accurate as possible, but sometimes i notice what i write isn't fully representative of my state of mind at the time, simply because when you're writing stuff down (especially when you're writing with a pen and paper (slow!)), you can never fully capture all the concurrent thoughts and emotions you're experiencing, so its impossible for a diary to be fully accurate. Undoubtedly, e.g. Elizabeth Loftus has done a lot of prominent research in that field, our memories tend to be fallible, but maybe that's part of the reason?
- WalterBright 3y agoIt was about what transpired on the missions. When I was writing a paper on the history of D, I had kept a lot of records, such as emails. I was often surprised when the details didn't quite line up with my memories. This is one reason why one cannot get a fair trial 40 years after the fact, if any of it relies on eyewitness testimony.
- fsckboy 3y agomaybe your memory of being surprised or the one that the details didn't line up is the false memory!
- jimhefferon 3y agoI remember with 100 percent clarity doing great in sophomore high school math. I loved it and I went on to get a PhD. Then my mom passed and I got a box of stuff with my name on it from her house. It included my report card. C.
- 7thaccount 3y agoThat's because you remember correctly...the simulation just messed up the report card object and accidentally decremented the counter twice. In all seriousness it's crazy how bad memory is. Like we all have a false version of the truth.
- wolverine876 3y agoConversation is throwing fictional worlds at each other.
- 7thaccount 3y agoSorry that came off like a reddit comment. The first part was just me joking. I don't actually believe in the simulation hypothesis although it is fun to think about. The second part was just me agreeing with their comment that it's crazy how bad our own memory is and how it's difficult to come to grips with. Like when my mom, sister, and I are all arguing over a past event and remember it very differently. The true events are (to my knowledge) absolute, but in a philosophical sense, we're all living in our own reality as our memories are telling us the events unfolded differently even though they didn't.
- IAmGraydon 3y agoIt's not only memory. Realtime perception is completely warped as well. An objective view of reality is impossible for humans.
- philistine 3y agoYou had low standards when you were a kid. You thought a C was great.
- dangus 3y agoJust to reiterate and point it out, this was 60 years ago.
- EliRivers 3y agoThe JFK assassination has been such a recurrent theme for so long that I reckon I might have memories of it, even though it happened decades before I was born.
- interestica 3y agoAs time goes by I'm less and less sure that I saw the second plane hit the tower on 9/11 live. I think there's a similar "induced memory" surrounding who watched the challenger disaster live. (Fwiw, I'm still pretty sure I watched it live)
- simonh 3y agoI didn’t see it live, it was on a news replay minutes after it happened. I remember thinking I have to tell my brother and my dad, but what will I say? It felt a bit like when you stub your toe and it doesn’t hurt yet, you know something bad has happened and this is the pause before the impact hits when you tell everyone. I seem to remember them asking what exactly had happened, and I struggled to explain what I’d seen on the few seconds of replay I’d seen, and couldn’t really describe it. Years later we discussed it and they were both adamant we all watched it live on TV. Am I misremembering, or them, or all of us? Tough one. With 9/11 I seem to remember one of the impacts only being seen from the explosion, but you couldn’t see the plane itself. Maybe that was the second one?
- jcranmer 3y ago> With 9/11 I seem to remember one of the impacts only being seen from the explosion, but you couldn’t see the plane itself. Maybe that was the second one? There is an archive of several news channel and their coverage of 9/11 at https://archive.org/details/911/day/20010911#/ https://archive.org/details/911/day/20010911#/. Some of the news channels had better viewpoints and saw the second plane hit on live footage [1]. The NEWSNW channel has a very solid view of the second plane as it hits, which causes the reporter there to react mid-sentence. Note that's the live coverage; since there's so many cameras pointed out the towers by that time, there's several different angles of the actual moment of impact (although most news channels were focusing on the views that best showed the damage at the first tower when it happened live). There's only three known recordings of the first tower being hit (the best quality one being from someone shooting a documentary film who heard the plane, looked up with the camera, and recorded it as it hit). The hit of the Pentagon is only recorded by a security camera, where there is but one frame with part of the plane being just barely in the view before the impact. [1] This takes place in the first or second clip of the second row of the 9:00-9:10 segment, depending on how bad the delay is.
- jl6 3y agoI am reminded of an incident relayed to me by an office worker in the early 2000s. A colleague had left the building at lunchtime and had been witness to some kind of shooting incident where robbers or gang members on motorcycles had opened fire on someone or something else - I don’t think it was ever discovered what the target or cause was. This was in South America, so not a wholly unusual scenario. But the debrief of the employee was eye-opening. He described everything that had happened from his perspective: he heard gunshots, hid behind a bin, and waited until it was over. He said there were dozens of gunshots and he had stayed in hiding for about ten minutes, until he heard the bikes speed away. However, upon reviewing the CCTV footage, it became clear that the whole incident, from bike arrival to employee emerging from behind the bin, lasted about 11 seconds. The colleague was astounded to see the footage and couldn’t explain why he had felt it was so much longer. I think there’s a good chance that stressful situations play havoc with human memory formation.
- tasogare 3y agoMy theory is that in a really stressful situation the mind hyperfocuses and "processes more frames per second" to react quicker. Just like with movies this mean that replayed at normal speed the movie serms very slow, hence the long timespan memory.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoI believe this is also responsible for so called dad reflexes.
- nradov 3y agoTime dilation is well known to occur in dangerous situations. https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fpsyp.12836 https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fpsyp.12836
- jonplackett 3y agoTime dilation is pretty amazing. I experienced it one time when I accidentally put the car into a a skid at 70mph. I remember calmly realising the car was moving sideways. Having time to ponder that for a few moments. Then deciding to start steering into the skid. Then think about that for a while. Release the break a bit. Finally we did a full 360 and ended up in the middle of the road again. It seemed like it took a minute or more but was probably a few seconds if that. Brains are awesome! (My younger self driving ability, much less so)
- colordrops 3y agoThis seems like a pretty arbitrary criticism. Do you have any reason to believe that he didn't remember things correctly?
- wolverine876 3y agoLandis also said different things in his report at the time.