6 ms·
Why do so many people hate EU bureaucracy?
- TekMol 3y agoI'm in Europe. I don't know how much time I already wasted clicking away cookie banners. Maybe a minute a day? That's 6 hours a year. That's a day of clicking on cookie banners every 4 years. One week of clicking away cookie banners every 28 years. About two weeks for every adult life. There are 450 million people in the European Union. Two weeks times 450 million is 900 million weeks of clicking on cookie banners. Average life expectancy in the European Union is 80 years. 4160 weeks. 900 million weeks of clicking on cookie banners is 216346 times that life expectancy. The EU will kill 216346 people of my generation with cookie banners. Those are good people. And you ask why I hate that?
- PrimeMcFly 3y ago> I don't know how much time I already wasted clicking away cookie banners. Maybe a minute a day? That's 6 hours a year. Just install consent-omatic
- dehrmann 3y agoAnd this has been going on for over a decade, but the EU hasn't decided to fix it.
- username332211 3y agoThat'd be admitting failure. We can't have that, can we?
- msm_ 3y agoBut that directive is a big success? I know which sites are trying to track me, and which do not. What's more, even less technical people know that and may make an informed choice. Way better than allowing advertisers do whatever they want everywhere.
- dageshi 3y agoYou know that pretty much all large sites are tracking you and most smaller sites probably are too but they couldn't be bothered with the consent popup because nobody will ever enforce anything against them. Advertisers still do everything they want everywhere, we just got a bunch of pointless popups on top.
- jmye 3y agoDo you really think most people are making an informed choice, as opposed to clicking the button that gets rid of the pop up fastest? Especially on mobile where the pop up obscures basically the entire site, and the byzantine process of opting out takes several clicks? I think this was a spectacular failure of the EU to consider legislative effects, and problem solve. But that seems to be their recent MO.
- ianlevesque 3y agoCan you do us a favor and vote in someone to correct that particular one? It’s leaking into the rest of the world.
- Joeri 3y agoThe EU didn’t tell those sites to show cookie banners, they just told them to stop collecting people’s data without their consent. It’s the sites that interpreted that as “annoy people until they consent so we can keep collecting their data”. That’s not really the EU’s fault, although they should have seen it coming.
- tommiegannert 3y agoThey could have also started by making the ~4 web browser suppliers implement this consent dialog (remember Netscape cookie dialogs everybody hated 20 years ago?). Then the two W3C/IETF to create a protocol for transmitting consent to the server. Instead of making thousands of companies having to individually spend the money to implement it. Great for job creation numbers. Crazy mismanaged in all other aspects.
- doublepg23 3y agoI think the “Do Not Track” HTTP header was inspired by a similar idea…but then people used it for tracking (using a non-default setting is a good way to be unique.) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Do_Not_Track https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Do_Not_Track
- toto 3y agoThank you! Actually, they could also take this strategy to protect kids from adult/violent/sensitive content. I suspect their strategy is to replicate, with Internet, what they have done with the Financial industry. So it should not be considered as incompetence... on the contrary. (See my other comment for further details https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37457745#37461669 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37457745#37461669 )
- rootusrootus 3y agoIt's like we need to have a recurring demonstration of the old saying 'the path to hell is paved with good intentions' because we keep forgetting.
- pjscott 3y ago
- awei 3y agoSame here, what triggers me the most is also the « tech laws »: GDPR, cybersecurity resilience act threatening open source, The coming AI act possibly limiting innovation and concentrating them in the hands of existing giants instead of a decentralized ecosystem, as it begins to be the case in the rest of the world. I understand the thinking behind all those laws and they probably are born from good intentions. I feel like, in this case, Europe lacks some big tech lobbying pointing out the technical flaws (and yes I agree that with lobbying you do have to sort out the « pointing out the technical flaws » from the « pushing single interests forward »).
- _Microft 3y agoIt is not necessary to ask for consent for cookies that are required to provide service. Unfortunately the barrage of cookie dialogs seems to be working because you‘re blaming the EU now instead of those who decided to collect more data than necessary (or even to ask unnecessarily!)
- micromacrofoot 3y agoThe EU never mandated cookie banners, websites added cookie banners instead of not collecting your data
- klntsky 3y agoImagine how many people JavaScript killed Those are good people
- mrtksn 3y agoCookie banners are not compulsory at all, that’s only needed if the websites want to share your activity on this site with others in order to profile you.
- eddtests 3y agoHow's it take you a minute to close cookie banners a day? Imagine the damage companies like FAANG are doing with their adverts, if you try the many minutes per day in your calculations! Also, this is a UX issue with the site, not an issue with the EU. The EU wants companies to outright ask permission to collect your data and sell it. I can't think of another organisation at that level so pro-individual against big tech, can you? If cookie clicking is an issue, use companies that don't collect your data. Edit: Look at the US is doing on another HN front-page article https://www.vice.com/en/article/m7bge3/dhs-uses-ai-tool-babel-x-babel-street-social-media-citizens-refugees https://www.vice.com/en/article/m7bge3/dhs-uses-ai-tool-babe...
- kkfx 3y agoI still don't care about cookies works well, and that's not an EU absurd bureaucracy fault... The main bureaucratic issue is that the institutional stack is not much democratic and it's dominated by economical powers that's have mostly only hurt EU citizens.
- lnxg33k1 3y ago>> Those are good people. I don't know, maybe they are libertarians
- piuantiderp 3y agoBecause they employ tens of thousands unelected bureaucrats at wildly inflated (six figure in EU) salaries? 20,000+ just in the EU Commision. They have their own Cartier/LV/etc... in Brusels HQ?
- sunbum 3y agoDid you even read the article?
- blibble 3y agoEU employees also don't have to pay income tax and have separate private schools for their children it's like something out of brave new world
- foldr 3y agoThey pay a special tax instead: https://politics.stackexchange.com/questions/715/do-e-u-employees-pay-tax-on-their-salaries#:~:text=From%20the%20European%20Commission%20Permanent,back%20into%20the%20EU's%20budget https://politics.stackexchange.com/questions/715/do-e-u-empl....
- blibble 3y agogovernment employees being exempt from regular taxation would never be accepted in a normal country so I don't see why it should for something that isn't even a country can you imagine federal employees in california being immune from california state taxes? me neither
- foldr 3y agoIt's not really a comparable situation as the US Federal Government isn't an international organisation. I think the aim is just to avoid having countries that happen to host lots of EU institutions receiving lots of national tax revenue as a result. It's also not an exemption that's entirely unique to EU employees. For example, NATO employees based in Belgium pay no income tax, and neither do employees of the United Nations. Similar response here: https://politics.stackexchange.com/a/4968 https://politics.stackexchange.com/a/4968
- vjerancrnjak 3y agoThe redesign of the plastic bottle cap was one of the weirdest recent directives in EU. How did this micro optimization make sense? How can we take people that pushed for it seriously? They made regulations on separating waste that did not put a requirement on recycling. Many cities, to avoid fines, provide separate containers, but in the end just throw everything on the same pile. This new bottle cap design requirement must have created a new economy for producing these bottle caps for all of the containers, someone profited. The need for it was created in EU institutions. There are massive problems around waste that no one there dares to approach, so they make these weird directives that just smell of corruption and incompetence.
- oezi 3y agoQuote: The single-use plastics legislation will address 70 percent of marine litters items, avoiding environmental damage that would otherwise cost €22 billion by 2030. It may seem weird to you, but we need to develop good regulations to deal with all the negative externalities. For instance, I think we could have also added a recycling fee per plastic item sold (say 5 cents). This would have made it more economical to sell bigger units and avoid technically unnecessary items such as the tear-off rings on bottles.
- vjerancrnjak 3y agoCroatia already has that ~7 cent tax on the container. Don’t know how that worked out. I know the capital has no recycling infrastructure. The tourists make no effort to collect that tax. But the paper straw legislation was botched by allowing forever chemicals.
- coldtea 3y agoI seriously doubt the accuracy of their estimations.
- flir 3y ago> technically unnecessary items such as the tear-off rings on bottles. Aren't they a tamper-proofing mechanism?
- 3y ago
- PrimeMcFly 3y agohttps://archive.ph/rin5B https://archive.ph/rin5B
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoSome stuff the EU does is fantastic and benefits EU citizens as well as the rest of the world, like enforcing a standard charger on phones. Some stuff is asinine in how ineffective and pointless it was, like enforcing Windows have a browser select screen, or these stupid cookie banners (which yes, are 100% the EUs fault). Or claiming the GDPR has extra-territorial jurisdiction. Like most governments it's a mix, but they seem better than most.
- maccard 3y agoThe cookie banners are US tech company interpretations of "don't hoover up all the data unless you need it, and if you do, you need consent" You can be compliant without a cookie banner - don't collect the data or give a choice when you start collecting the data. > enforcing Windows have a browser select screen I think that giving a set of options on first install for preferences like browser is a great thing for the EU to enforce personally.
- rootusrootus 3y agoThis is a good argument that we need better representatives who have some appreciation for how their idealistic regulations will be enacted in real life.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoI was waiting for someone to make that excuse. No, the banners are solely the EUs doing. Their solution to the problem resulted in the banners, so they get the blame. > I think that giving a set of options on first install for preferences like browser is a great thing for the EU to enforce personally. It would have been great in the 90s/2000s. They did it about 10 years too late where everybody downloads whatever browser they want anyway. For most people that would be Chrome. The whole thing only exists because Opera couldn't compete and made a stink about it.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> enforcing a standard charger on phones. Given that the world was going to USB-C all on their own, I don't think it's fair to give credit to the EU for this one. Let's talk about it again in a decade when we're all still stuck on USB-C because going to something better would violate the law.
- akira2501 3y agoIt's apparently not that the people actually dislike the bureaucracy. Very few people actually have any real experience with it. If they have negative opinions it's because they read tabloids and are somehow unaware that their personal views have already been fully debunked by the ivory tower. No.. the reason people _seem_ to dislike it is because the bureaucracy just hasn't produced enough propaganda telling the people they should like it more. I find this entire article insanely out of touch.
- parenthesis 3y agoWhy do so many people hate the US federal government?
- Slava_Propanei 3y agoBecause federal bureaucrats are effectively an occupation government with views and goals wildly different from the citizens
- barsonme 3y agoHate is a strong word. People tend to like or dislike it more depending on whether they agree with the people who are in charge of it. I think, at its core, the negative attitudes stem from it being a “one size fits all” approach. Plus also a sense of detachment since state and local governments are what people interact with 99% of the time.
- rootusrootus 3y agoIt feels like comparing 60K EU employees with 2M USG employees is apples to oranges. It's entirely possible that the actual equivalents in the USG are less than 60K, and criticisms of EU bureaucracy justified.
- gretch 3y agoYeah the comparison doesn't make sense to me. # of people governed is about the same, but without the EU, each of the member states still has a full national government that does a lot of the legwork of administrating their country. USG does more because US state governments are not equipped like EU member national governments.
- foldr 3y agoBut that's the point, right? The EU is a much lighter touch than the US Federal Government, so it's weird that people fixate on the comparably insignificant bureaucracy of the EU rather than the much larger bureaucracies of their national governments.
- username332211 3y agoWhat the writer is missing is that the local bureaucracy is the EU bureaucracy with extra steps. Unlike Congress, the European parliament does not enforce it's legislation trough EU agencies, it dumps it to the local agencies working in that particular sphere and lets them figure it out. Fairly often the particular activities imposed on local agencies get funded trough an Operational Programme. Rather than the EU parliament just allocating the funds for the activities it wants carried out, this involves the local agency writing a grant application for the funds, which is quite a silly bureaucratic exercise. If it enforces EU law, while being funded by the EU, it's not really member state bureaucracy, is it? Moreover EU legislation usually imposes a particular process to local administration, so member governments can't streamline or improve EU-related administrative process unless the Commission decides to look the other way. (Which is not common, but not exactly unheard of either.)
- jimnotgym 3y agoOn the other hand, if you do international trade outside of the EU you get the effect of lots of different bureaucratic systems that mean you have a lot to learn. It is much easier inside the EU.
- orwin 3y agoThe state choose how to implement the law, if it want to implement it at all. If EU is mad at the local implementation, it stop subventions, then sue. I think the last case was Ireland for giving tax breaks to companies, and it was weird. The previous one was France that had to pay millions because water quality in Brittany's rivers was a lot lower than it should have been. I think there's also a case wis asylums laws in Hungary, but tbh, it's very rare that it comes to litigation. And most of the time, it's citizens of the country being litigated that called the EJC/CJE in the first place (Ireland and Hungary being two exceptions).
- Scotrix 3y agoI believe this research is hugely flawed since it seems to focus solely on bureaucracy coming directly from the European institutions, while it might be true that we as citizens don’t get actually really in touch directly with EU bureaucracy we certainly experience a lot of bureaucracy in our daily lives. This comes from countries policy and law making who are obliged to implement EU regulations but also are adding their own local bureaucracy on top of it. While it’s here different in different countries within the EU it certainly feels more often overburden, restrictive and senseless (speaking from my own individual experience in Germany and Netherlands).
- mrtksn 3y agoYes but the level of bureaucracy varies quite a lot between countries to countries. What you are experiencing is poor or good local implementation of a streamlined architecture. That’s why bureaucracy in UK didn’t go down but increased with brexit. What British previously experienced was just UK civil service, now they keep experiencing that but on top of it they have added bureaucracy at any time they want to interact with an EU country.
- makomk 3y agoErrm, one huge reason why the EU bureaucracy can be so comparatively small is precisely because it relies on the domestic bureaucracies of its constituent states to translate its decisions into actual actions that impact the actual people living there. That is, the actions of the domestic bureaucracies that people actually interact with aren't merely some unrelated thing that people are basing their view of EU bureaucracy on, they effectively act as the public face of that bureaucracy and the rules it creates.
- jimnotgym 3y agoThis will be the tragedy of Brexit for future UK governments. For decades they could blame their own bureaucratic failings on the EU, now they have to own them!
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoNonsense, they are already blaming internal enemies, such as lawyers, civil servants, people who live in North London, and "the blob" (i.e. everyone who doesn't agree with them).
- Ghostking666 3y ago[dead]
- Ghostking666 3y ago[dead]
- nvm0n2 3y agoThey're blaming lawyers for the deportation fiascos, which are technically due to the European Court of Human Rights and not the EU. That bit will have to be left separately. However, what they're dealing with is ultimately all the same culture of managerialism: https://theupheaval.substack.com/p/the-china-convergence https://theupheaval.substack.com/p/the-china-convergence Civil servants went into meltdowns over Brexit because for the first time they might actually have to follow orders instead of telling ministers they can't do what they were elected to do because of the EU. We've seen how many of them claim to be neutral and then go straight into the Labor Party/Amnesty International/etc. The head of the Border Force even stated he'd never believed in borders at all. So the idea that they're merely blaming "people who don't agree with them" is right in some ultra-pedantic technical sense. The problem is, those people aren't supposed to have political opinions to begin with.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smfugit 3y agoIts a veblen style leisure class. 95% signalling 5% work.
- nvm0n2 3y ago> one often hears that EU governance is equal to governance through “unelected bureaucrats”. Although this notion has been debunked many times Good old academics, boldly stating that a trivial matter of fact has been debunked many times. EU law can only be made by the EU Commission. Employees report to EU Commissioners. Here's an FAQ on how the process works. Q: How are Commissioners elected? A: They aren't. Each country gets to choose one. Q: How do the countries choose their commissioners? A: Political appointments, like being an ambassador. Q: So they represent their country? A: No, they are given specific policy areas and told that their main loyalty must be to the EU. Q: But countries can send anyone, so their loyalties could remain at home anyway. A: By treaty, yes. In practice, the President of the Commission can exercise a veto over Commissioners who they feel are not pro-EU enough. This is illegal, but the EU frequently ignores its own laws. Q: OK, but they could just lie and still be loyal to their country. A: The EU pays Commissioners vast bribes. They call these "pensions" but they can be received before retirement, are much larger than any normal pension and can be forfeited if the Commissioner is considered to be disloyal both during and after their employment [1]. For example, criticizing the EU in public counts. They also get many other perks such as not having to pay taxes, which would be illegal in their origin countries. Q: Who elects the President and how? A: The heads of each member state decide. The mechanism used is unknown, as the appointment process is secret and they refuse to discuss it. Q: From where are the candidates drawn? A: Unknown. Q: On what platforms do they campaign? A: They don't. Q: What about the European Parliament? A: It's not a Parliament as it can't change the law by itself, nor choose who runs the civil service. They're allowed in theory to vote on the President, but last time they were given a list of candidates with only one name on it. ------- This, according to people like the LSE, is "democracy", by which they mean the exercise of power by those as far removed from accountability as possible. Because at some point, someone was chosen by someone else who formed a coalition with some other people who won some votes by not talking about anything EU related, and then told to be loyal to the EU institutions. [1] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/labour/4996440/Lord-Mandelson-must-remain-loyal-to-EU-to-guarantee-pension.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/labour/4996440/Lor...
- Ekaros 3y agoCommission really is not that different from ministers or cabinet in general. In most countries these are not elected positions, but selected by government currently in power.
- darkclouds 3y agoI'd have to get past the French farmers at the ferry ports and channel tunnel if I wanted to descend on Brussels with my pitch fork. By having Brexit, we now have the chance to have two Bonfire nights!
- toto 3y agoI see them doing with the Internet industry what they have done with the Financial industry. - What are they doing: force smaller companies to die or be bought by bigger ones. - How are they doing that: They keep adding regulation so that fix costs and complexity to manage a company increase. - Why are they doing that: having a lot of smaller companies is difficult and expensive to control. Usually it is impossible. Having a few big companies is easier and cheaper to control (you only need to book a room and invite a few ceos to regulate everything). The fun part is that companies like Google, Apple, etc fake a fight against the regulators, but are actually the 2nd beneficiaries (1st being the regulators). If you speak with seniors in the financial industry, they will talk about it with passion and anger because they can provide countless practical examples which killed their industry and the "joy" to wake up in the morning. As an exemple, you can see how JP Morgan seems to fight regulation and make it appear to be a victim of regulation, but finally is always the winner. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-03-10/banking-why-is-the-us-regulating-jpmorgan-but-not-svb?embedded-checkout=true https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-03-10/bankin... https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/california-financial-regulator-takes-possession-first-republic-bank-2023-05-01/ https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/california-financia...
- jakubmazanec 3y agoAs always, I see a lot of outright misinformation, a lot of information taken out of context, and mostly - as is usual on HN - "Why they do X, if Y is better?" "Well, read the legislation, they actually do Z and they had reasons." I wonder how would George of Poděbrady (who thought of something like EU in 15th century: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_of_Pod%C4%9Bbrady#Message_of_peace https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_of_Pod%C4%9Bbrady#Messa...). I don't think he would be worried about bureaucracy, I'm sure he would be in awe we can actually solve things this way.