8 ms·
It’s way past time to stop police ‘testilying’
- matt3210 3y agoAll testimonies police or not should be subject to lie detectors
- thfuran 3y agoWhat lie detectors? Polygraphs are not effective.
- stephen_g 3y agoWell, they can be effective as a prop to psychologically manipulate the subject into thinking you know when they’re lying, to try and pull out a confession. But that mostly only works if the subject doesn’t know it’s pseudoscience and believes polygraphs actually work… From what the anti-polygraph people say, apparently it only takes about 30 minutes of training before most people can actually manipulate the polygraph in a controlled way.
- pixl97 3y agoWhich means every cop will know how to get past them. I grew up in a family with a number of members in law enforcement and other parts of the justice system. Cops actively teach each other what to say/what to do in court and when they themselves are questioned. The county I had lived in at that time was the worst. The guy in the sheriff's office that administered the lie detectors was "criminal scum" himself. For the longest time there were allegations of criminal behavior, but he finally pissed someone off and they hired a PI to follow him around. Caught this 40+ year old member of law enforcement giving minors alcohol at a party and hitting on them. It broke on the news and he was fired from his law enforcement position, but no criminal charges where ever brought... What was even better, he was quietly brought back on as a consultant to administer lie detector tests!
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoInteresting that you should bring up some pseudoscience. It is well-known that jury trials often employ myriad methods of pseudoscience to admit artifacts into evidence, and to admit "expert witness" testimony into the record. Police, prosecutors and judges are incentivized and desperate to get a great record of convictions, and so they're positively motivated to do that by any means necessary. If you watch copaganda shows like NCIS or CSI, or the lovely Canadian Murdoch Mysteries, you will be introduced to a lot of smart scientists who use a lot of smart science to catch bad guys. Well, guess what, a lot of the "science" actually used in court, and believed by everyone on all sides of the case, and the spectators as well -- that "science" is fake, it's quackery, it's just an excuse to get convictions. Now there are whole categories of testimony and evidence which are always excluded and stricken from the record, because they are known to be invalid, such as "hearsay", and I think that if courts and the justice system compiled lists of pseudoscience and quackery, and then excluded that sort of crap out of hand, we would approach fairer trials and better justice for all.
- readthenotes1 3y agoI am shocked, shocked! to find malfeasance in the FBI crime labs. https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/04/csi-is-a-lie/390897/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/04/csi-is-... (So not just the pseudoscience and quackery but also the manipulation of replicated science)
- jakelazaroff 3y agoCounterpoint: lie detector tests should not be admissible as evidence at all.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoLie detectors aren't remotely reliable enough to be used like this. Sufficiently skilled people can beat them and people tend to react to the sensitive questions (is the machine going to falsely say I'm lying???) even when telling the truth. However, I do believe they have a role in law enforcement. The same hardware can be repurposed for a guilty knowledge test. The police keep secret the details of the crime. If they catch a suspect they hook them up to a lie detector and make them repeat the details--some true, some false and compare the reactions. (I do not consider this compelled testimony as they're just reading a script.) Someone who shows a sufficient pattern of hitting on the true ones knows the details. It won't false positive because the innocent doesn't know which answers are the guilty ones (to be safe the person doing it should likewise not know so you don't get a Clever Hans effect) and won't tense up because if it. It could statistically but if you have enough questions you can make this possibility vanishingly small. There still is a chance of a false negative if the guy can beat it (unlikely) or actually didn't note the details you're asking about.
- thfuran 3y ago>People accused of crimes deserve to know if the officers involved in their arrest have a history of lying; judges, too, deserve to know how credible police witnesses are in their cases. This seems like a pretty bizarre framing. A police officer with a history of filing fraudulent reports or committing perjury should not still be a police officer.
- eviks 3y agoThat's too radical!
- drdec 3y agoI think the idea is to solve the problem you can solve. Getting police fired is much more difficult than getting information shared.
- FFP999 3y agoAt the very minimum they should not be a cop. Better still would be if we considered this a serious felony and a cop who did this was liable to trade in their blue uniform for an orange one. I doubt this will happen in my lifetime.
- failTide 3y agoAgreed - but if they're no longer able to effectively testify in court, they'd presumably no longer be able to do real police work - at best they'd be put in some administrative duty.
- drewcoo 3y ago> A police officer with a history of filing fraudulent reports or committing perjury should not still be a police officer. But they're paying union members, too!
- phatskat 3y agoI mean, you can murder, rape, steal, lie, and more with a badge. If you want accountability, you have to get rid of the unions
- vintermann 3y agoOne thing I never understood, that "Miranda rights" are celebrated as some sort of civil rights victory in the US. It's actually not great that everything you say will be used against you. Ideally, police should not be belligerent hateful scumbags eager to pin any crime they can at you. That they have to announce that they are, isn't really helping much. I wonder if it actually makes it worse - that they have come to see it as their right, their right to nail suckers who make the mistake of seeing them as fellow decent humans.
- mpalmer 3y agoTry living somewhere where the law compels you to answer police questions and get back to us.
- stavros 3y agoIt's not the role of the police to be pinning crimes on people, that's the judicial system. The police just collect evidence, and, as I understand it, the Miranda warning just means that there's no "off the record" when talking to the police. In other words, it doesn't mean "we're going to twist what you say as much as we can", it means "we'll tell the court whatever you tell us, even if that's self-incriminating". Pretty much what you'd expect, really.
- FFP999 3y ago> It's not the role of the police to be pinning crimes on people I don't think the cops got this memo, could you please tell them.
- simoncion 3y agoYep. AIUI, Miranda's only change to the status quo was to make it mandatory for the cops to _tell_ you what the status quo is. Prior to Miranda they didn't have to tell you shit, and were probably justifying it to themselves with some lame "Ignorance of the law is no excuse, so if you don't know that you have a right to an attorney, that there is no 'off the record' conversation with a cop, and that you don't have to tell us shit, then that's your own damn fault." justification.
- Simulacra 3y agoIt's way, WAY past time to remove police and prosecutorial immunity.
- torstenvl 3y agoThat's fundamentally impossible. It's nonsensical to suggest that the government punish a private citizen for doing what the government forced that private citizen to do. Any attempts to implement your proposal will lead to exactly one inevitable outcome: lawlessness. This is because, if the government does start punishing a certain class of private citizens for doing what the government forces them to do, private citizens will no longer voluntarily join that class.
- LgWoodenBadger 3y agoIt’s not fundamentally impossible. The US armed forces and the UCMJ is centuries-old evidence of that.
- torstenvl 3y agoWhat argument are you trying to make here? I have over a decade of experience in prosecuting and defending cases under the UCMJ, I have an LL.M. in military criminal justice, I am qualified as a Special Trial Counsel, and I recently served as the Marine Corps Senior Defense Counsel for the National Capital Region. Let me assure you that military law enforcement has qualified immunity.
- CogitoCogito 3y ago> if the government does start punishing a certain class of private citizens for doing what the government forces them to do, private citizens will no longer voluntarily join that class. The government "forces" the police officers to engage in this malfeasance?
- stonogo 3y agoThat's a bad-faith interpretation of removing qualified immunity. If a police officer's actions can be found to have been necessary to their duty, the laws already protect them. Nobody proposes to "punish a private citizen for doing what the government forced that private citizen to do." The proposal is to hold them accountable when they exceed their remit.
- RecycledEle 3y agoI follow a simple rule: Anyone who probably has video of something controversial (like a car wreck or a fight) can be trusted IFF the bring out the video within 48 hours. A delay strongly implies they are trying to lie. As a bonus, posting the video to YouTube within a short time proves you did not spend a lot of time editing it before posting it. This is increasingly important in the era of AI fakes. This would make a great rule for court cases: Anyone who publically posts video within 48 hours is assumed to be in the right. Anyone who likely had video but did not post it within 48 hours is assumed to be in the wrong. There is no legitimate reason cops do not post video of their shift as soon an they get back to the police station.
- DoctorOetker 3y agoeven better, constantly hash sign footage as it is generated, publishing the signatures immediately, preferably signed by sensor itself so authorities don't have access to the private key.
- RecycledEle 3y agoWelcome to Planet Earth, you must be new here. Cops just want power. They get power, and lie to us non-cops to keep power. There is no such thing as a computer that cops use that they can not hack.
- DoctorOetker 3y agoIs it truly futile to hope for the occasional technologist to bring rigor to the matter? If one thinks of Almond Strowger, he nearly single handedly initiated the weeding out a specific form of corruption (corruption of human telephone operators, to redirect economic traffic) for about a 100 years by inventing the automatic telephone exchange and phone numbers.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoDisagree--bodycams will sometimes record things that legitimately shouldn't be released. (Extreme example--cop rolls up on a 10 year old being raped. You think that should be out there???) Thus police video needs to be reviewed before release. The defense should *always* have access to the whole thing, although sometimes with restricted access (like a lesser version of a SCIF--they can go to a secure location and examine it but not make copies.) What we need is bodycams with secure digital signatures. The camera signs the video when it makes it, the key set during manufacture and not accessible by *any* means. The public key for the camera can be accessed from the camera as well as from the manufacturer--the defense can verify the image actually came from the camera. I'd actually like to see this for all cameras but it's less important for others. (Note that this would *not* indelibly fingerprint an image--it would be like the EXIF data, the user could remove it if desired. You can make an image anonymous, you can't pretend an image is from some other camera.)
- more_corn 3y agoI’ve had a police officer lie on the stand. It destroyed my faith in the justice system. Without truth there can be no justice.
- bannedbybros 3y ago[dead]
- CWuestefeld 3y agoI have too - and I'm supposedly one of the privileged people (white male) that get to skate through. It wasn't a particularly big deal - it was just a speeding ticket. But maybe that makes it even worse, that a cop is willing to casually lie about the smallest things. In the big picture, maybe his success with his lie does more harm than even if he'd let go free someone he believed was guilty. Maybe I get to skate on a speeding ticket, but at least it doesn't give me a story I can tell everyone, for the rest of my life, about how the cops cheat and lie.
- tennisflyi 3y agoEveryone lies on the stand - it's up to the jury (to determine truthfulness/credibility).
- anigbrowl 3y agoNot true. Please contemplate how this works out for an actually honest person subject to a false accusation.
- pixl97 3y agoHow it works out for an honest person? They commonly go to jail. Just ask Michael Morton.
- tennisflyi 3y agoPerhaps some subtlety was needed and “everyone” is too large of a swath but judges are not dolling our perjury charges a dime a dozen and taking the stand doesn’t make some just answer carte blanche.
- tennisflyi 3y agoFrom the horse's mouth in a current trial as of this post, https://youtu.be/8adXCmoFPEU?t=5096 https://youtu.be/8adXCmoFPEU?t=5096 (FL v. Johnathan Quiles). "The fact that a witness is employed by law enforcement is just another witness. No better. No worse than anybody else that's going to take the stand. And you, ladies and gentlemen, will determine the truthfulness, the veracity, and the weight of the evidence, and the testimony they're are going to be giving to you."
- random6754478 3y ago[flagged]
- gruez 3y ago>There was a dead body found in a car rented by Breonna Taylor. Is the implication here that she's therefore a bad person and therefore the police's actions were justified? If so your presentation was heavily misleading. From wikipedia >In December 2016, Fernandez Bowman was found dead in the front seat of a car rented by Taylor and used by Glover.[12] He had been shot eight times.[12] An unrelated party was later arrested for Bowman's death[51]
- eggy 3y agoI don't condone bad cops and I am very strong on prosecuting them, but the way the media and the protesters portrayed Breona Taylor as a totally innocent victim of a botched police raid was lacking in some important details. The rental car under her name, and a person found shot dead inside of it, didn't bode well for her. When's the last time you rented a car and a person was found dead in it? Your boyfriend's a drug dealer and arrested on drugs and gun charges and you are having calls with him in jail about holding onto his money? I am glad I grew up where I did. It taught me some life lessons street smarts that seem to be non-existent in those who grew up quite differently. Breona didn't deserve to die, but she was not a wholly unrelated, innocent victim in this scenario as the media and protesters tried to paint. All of your choices have consequences.
- ttfkam 3y agoHBO's "We Own This City" (along with "The Wire") should be required viewing. https://youtu.be/1BgwYXGdHE0?t=1201 https://youtu.be/1BgwYXGdHE0?t=1201
- rootusrootus 3y agoIt's time to make accountability match the crime. [In my jurisdiction, at least] police officers are considered officers of the court, and considered more trustworthy than other witnesses, under oath or not. When a police officer abuses that by perjuring themselves, there should be a additional punishment. Some kind of modifier, like a hate crime, that really makes it hurt.
- petesergeant 3y ago> there should be a additional punishment Going to jail as a cop probably counts as that
- giantg2 3y agoSo what is the solution here? They're already supposed to keep lists. Has the CO law made improvements? The way I envision it would be that the problematic offices just end up with empty lists because they evaluate that some action didn't meet the threshold. Maybe we can do something about complaints and misconduct for judges too? Right now judicial misconduct is considered so secret that you can't even subpoena exculpatory contained in those complaints. The reasoning is that public knowledge of mistakes and wrongdoing would undermine the courts. I think that position is outdated and trust would be kmproved if mistakes were corrected and bad actors were removed from the system. This is especially important at the magisterial level where there is minimal training, minimal requirements, and often a background that leads to bias (lots of ex-cops as magistrates). Part of why I bring this up is that I have submitted a complaint in the past and they simply closed it even though the magistrate was unprofessional, yelling, completely onesided (retired cop), etc. Some of the things like unprofessional conduct and yelling are even examples given by the judicial board, yet they simply closed the compliant without investigation. I guarantee this happens with the Giulio lists too - close it in favor of those in power. The system is so corrupt/rigged at this point, I'm not sure if we'll ever get to a reasonable level of accountability and fairness. I guess it's always been this way (and worse) though.
- bloomingeek 3y agoYears ago a co-worker or mine was assigned to a jury on a murder case. Without going into details, he told me the worst thing that can happen to you is to find yourself in the hands of any jury. OK, one detail, the accused had a lengthy history of mental illness. The police and the prosecutor tried to paint this a some sort of joke and sought the death penalty! After much arguing and the legal definition of mental illness defined, a life sentence was given. My co-worker begged all of us to sit down with our families and have a talk about the legal system and it's flaws.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoThe US police, justice, and carceral systems are over-zealous and punitive. The US has among the highest incarceration rates on the planet (including a large pre-trial detention population) and their conditions are often inhumane. To be fair, juries are an approximate averaging system of guesswork by people who weren't there, listening to other people who weren't there arguing for the interests of 2 sides who present different stories.
- brucieb 3y ago[flagged]
- brucieb13 3y ago[flagged]
- RickJWagner 3y agoI agree that police who lie should be dismissed from the job and also prosecuted if warranted. I also believe that failure to obey a lawful order from a cop should result in hard jail time. Once both are passed, I think police will have less incentive to lie and violent encounters will be dramatically reduced. When citizens realize that failing to obey a lawful order results in long jail sentences, all kinds of bad behavior will melt away.