3 ms·
> Problem is, how do you generate that energy - on the civilizational scale required - in a way which produces less CO2 than you're removing from the air? The
by mschuster91 3y ago
> Problem is, how do you generate that energy - on the civilizational scale required - in a way which produces less CO2 than you're removing from the air?
The answer is simple: trees, moors and other biological processes. That would also work out on scale, as it has before humans have ever entered the play.
- david-gpu 3y agoForests and such are carbon neutral unless somebody goes there, cuts the trees, and crucially does something to prevent the wood from burning or decomposing for hundreds or thousands of years. That is the costly part.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoThat's a fairly simplified view of what a forest is. A forest is not just a bunch of trees, but an ecosystem where perhaps the most important part is the soil, which in the long term is the bigger carbon reservoir. A lot of the carbon that first goes into the trees eventually ends up in the soil, which if left undisturbed (i.e. not used for farming) is stable and does not leech significant amounts of CO2. Admittedly the downside of this is that such soil is almost absurdly fertile. This is in large why slash-and-burns are so popular where ever there's old forest. Indonesia, Brazil, etc. Like it's not even about the lumber, the farmland is amazing for a decade or so.
- david-gpu 3y ago> A lot of the carbon that first goes into the trees eventually ends up in the soil, which if left undisturbed (i.e. not used for farming) is stable Stable, as in the amount of carbon that is captured is offset by the amount that is released? That sounds like after a short while forests become carbon neutral, unless we cut the trees down and do something to prevent the wood from burning or decomposing. I think we are in agreement?
- marginalia_nu 3y agoThere's a lot more biomass in an older forest than a younger one, especially a planted forest. Carbon capture will slow down, granted, but a forest takes hundreds if not thousands of years to reach true equilibrium. There's an immediately obvious difference in biosphere density if you step into a forest that was cut and re-planted a fifty years ago, one that was slash-and-burned a hundred years ago, and primeval forest that's been around since the end of the ice age. There's just a lot more stuff growing in a forest the older it gets. Trees keep growing for a very long time as well, easily doubling or even quadrupling the biomass of a younger tree. All the fossil-sourced carbon we've put into the air the last 100 years or so was, at one point or another put into the ground, mostly by vegetation. Re-planting forest isn't probably in its own an adequate solution, but it shouldn't be dismissed entirely. Compared to active carbon sequestration, the energy cost of letting a forest grow is negligibly low.
- david-gpu 3y ago> All the fossil-sourced carbon we've put into the air the last 100 years or so was, at one point or another put into the ground, mostly by vegetation. As I understand it, carbon comes from plant matter indeed, back from the Carboniferous period. Back then no life form had evolved that was able to break down wood lignin, so wood could not decompose. That stopped around 300 million years ago when certain fungi evolved, which is why carbon is no longer produced and thus remains a fossil fuel. Forests are essentially carbon neutral according to every source I can find. I'll be happy to learn otherwise.
- kaba0 3y agoForests are carbon storage. They sorta become carbon neutral over time, but they generally won’t burn by themselves in many kinds of climates.
- imtringued 3y agoUnless you are talking about terra preta (where you intentionally produce charcoal and work it into the soil), the natural process of accumulating soil organic matter is too slow to make a dent to climate change.
- badtension 3y agoI've heard people mentioning biochar and similar processes of capturing carbon in the soil, do you know how viable it is? How much bang for the buck we could get from it? Is it a possible strategy when done in a decentralized manner all over the planet?
- brazzy 3y agoExcept it tooks millions of years to capture the amount of carbon we are releasing in decades, and much of that capture will not actually work in today's ecosystems: all coal deposits were formed in the window of time between trees evolving the production of lignine and microbes evolving the ability to decompose it.
- xavxav 3y agoIt takes ~40 trees to capture one ton per year, with ~40B tons emitted each year, that means planting roughly 160B trees each year. Humans have changed the world in a manner which natural ecosystems cannot recover on their own. We need to cut emissions to 0 and plant trees, establish moors, and other forms of CO2 capture.
- concordDance 3y ago> It takes ~40 trees to capture one ton per year I'm confused, where is this CO2 going? Once the forest reaches its maximum average tree size doesn't it stop carbon capturing and just occupies space?
- xavxav 3y agoYes, but I you cut and store the wood at maturity you could plant fresh trees instead. The point is, trees are an entirely inadequate solution to climate change, at least on the CO2 front.
- concordDance 3y agoHow you going to store the huge amount of trees without decay (which causes emissions)? How are you preventing soil depletion given you're cutting down and storing trees? Fertilizer production is very greenhouse gas intensive.
- concordDance 3y agoThat's far too inefficient to supply the energy needed to sustain modern area-efficient farming, so which 5 billion people are you picking to die of starvation?