7 ms·
San Francisco has tried. The first modern try was the JCDecaux self-cleaning street toilets. (JCDecaux is really an ad company. The street toilets are just a wa
by Animats 3y ago
San Francisco has tried. The first modern try was the JCDecaux self-cleaning street toilets. (JCDecaux is really an ad company. The street toilets are just a way to get ads on public property.) The first problem was that that the US required them to be wheelchair-accessable. So they were 3x as big and several times more expensive than the smaller units in Paris.[1]
They are noted for working fine in tourist areas, and badly in homeless areas. Making them big enough for wheelchair accessibility makes them big enough for drug deals, too.
They're also far too expensive. The cleaning machinery is standard industrial automation equipment from Telemechanique. I've seen one opened for servicing. If you built a washing machine that way, it would cost $20,000. It requires power, water, and a phone line.
There's the Portland Loo.[2] This is designed for maximum homeless proofing. Graffiti-resistant. Gratings at top and bottom instead of solid walls, for reduced privacy.
It's not self-cleaning, but can be hosed down or pressure-washed. Only needs a water line; power requirements are low enough to be supplied by a solar panel. “It’s not supposed to be a comfortable place” - Portland Loo sales manager. Seems to work, but $500,000 installed is a bit much, even with all that heavy stainless steel.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanisette https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanisette
[2] https://portlandloo.com/ https://portlandloo.com/
- lolinder 3y agoMost of the US gets by just fine with gas stations and restaurants providing them to the general public with no questions asked. Maybe instead of spending huge amounts of taxpayer funds treating the symptom, San Francisco should ask itself why local businesses find it impossible to keep their restrooms open?
- grumple 3y agoThe answer is pretty simple: because when you let non-customers use the toilets, you're letting homeless, mentally ill, drug addicts, or just shitty people use the toilets at a far higher rate. They do insane things like smear shit and blood on the walls and leave used needles lying around, or they OD in the toilet, so it ends up becoming a real pain for the businesses to keep them open and clean for their actual customers. I don't know if Europe has the same issue with toilets, but I do remember having to pay to use public toilets there (in Paris, for example).
- lolinder 3y agoRight, but this is a very San Francisco problem. To the extent it is a problem in the rest of US, it's not a big enough problem to outweigh the benefits to the business of offering a public restroom. Even most major cities I've been in don't have trouble providing public restrooms, there's a very specific set of cities that do. San Francisco and Portland and Seattle could spend tons of money trying to fill a need that most businesses in the US fill for free, or they could spend that money solving the root problem.
- fnimick 3y agoAnd how exactly would you solve the root problem of _other cities_ sending their homeless populations to those areas? Make it more miserable to be homeless there so they are forced to go somewhere else?
- pauldenton 3y agoLaw and order is one way. Homeless don't seem to gather in cities with Broken Window policing
- jefurii 3y agoSo your solution is to criminalize poverty and mental illness. I hope you never lose your job and have trouble paying your rent.
- pauldenton 3y agoYou get what you pay for. You spend billions on homeless services you get more homeless people. You spend hundreds of millions on Law and order and you get law and order. You defund the police and you lose law and order.
- rightbyte 3y agoI guess SF just have to stop the practice of dumping their problem on the rest of the country? "Between 2005 to 2017, the city of San Francisco sent 10,500 homeless people out of town by bus.[1]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_homeless_relocation_programs_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_homeless_relocation_pr... According to the Guardian the free tickets to SF are in the 100s, while SF sent 10 000 away. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/20/bussed-out-america-moves-homeless-people-country-study https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/...
- koolba 3y ago> Maybe instead of spending huge amounts of taxpayer funds treating the symptom, San Francisco should ask itself why local businesses find it impossible to keep their restrooms open? SF businesses already have to deal with a near daily hosing down of human feces from the street in front of their stores. If they opened up their bathrooms to vagrants it would just double the number of places they’re literally cleaning shit up.
- lolinder 3y agoThat's exactly my point: that is not a problem in most other cities. Which is why other cities can have the bathrooms open. For San Francisco to spend money on truly public bathrooms is putting lipstick on a pig.
- ethanbond 3y agoEh, New York City would absolutely benefit from more public restrooms (paid or not). Central Park is a prime example.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> that is not a problem in most other cities The well-meant and originally-necessary drive to end criminalising poverty overcorrected into absurdity by equating poverty with mental illness, and compassion for the mentally ill with not arresting people who smear feces over restroom walls. This fallacy, which dovetailed with anti-police sentiments, is most pronounced in San Francisco. But it’s also present in other American cities.
- yazzku 3y agoSan Francisco has the problem of inequality and an incompetent management, backed by people who wish the "homeless problem" just magically disappeared overnight. The toilets and piles of human defecation rolling down the hill are a consequence of the above, and unsolvable until the above is addressed first. You can't borrow ideas from other cities around the world because those don't have rampant inequality.
- yetanotherasian 3y agoIt's not just SF. Was in the Venice/Santa Monica area recently, every restaurant had a prominent sign "Restrooms for customers only. No Exceptions" My impression is the USA is falling apart. Every year people get more rude, more selfish, break more laws, are less courteous, there is more crime. I'm not sure I believe the "crime is going down" stats. (hope that doesn't make me stupid) The problem as I see it is people stop reporting crimes because they know the police will do nothing about it. I've had my car broken into 5 times. I don't think I reported it more than once. Further, some places like California, have declared they won't prosecute property crime under a certain amount so again, even less reporting. So, the numbers appear to be going down but in reality they seem to be going up (That's certainly my personal perception but maybe I'm being influenced by sensational news and personal experience. I definitely see objectively going up in traffic violations. People don't seem to give a fuck anymore. They just do whatever they want) I have no idea how to fix it or influence people to be nicer and more respectful of the law. Maybe it's the bankers getting off from the financial crisis. Maybe it's the police being perceived as part of the problem. All I know is more and more I think I should go back to a 1st world country because this one no longer feels like one.
- RobRivera 3y ago>My impression is the USA is falling apart In a theead about public toilets you move within 3 sentences to a vague thesis that the US is 'falling apart' without any metrics to a definition of what that looks like, a framework that is simpke, vague, generalized with very little quantitative datapoints that I cannot help but simply disregard the rest of what you have to say as anything more than hearsay amateur opinions. If you want to make a comparison between a pair of nation, state your specific metric and bring numbers. Ive had plenty of rude encounters in south america and europe
- pb7 3y agoHave to agree with this assessment of that comment. Of all things to complain about, Americans are not rude on average. Really quite nice, possibly even overbearing at times. Tells me GP hasn’t travelled outside of the US and if they had, sat at resorts the whole time.
- Karrot_Kream 3y agoAmerica also doesn't have paid toilets like Europe and many parts of Asia thanks to a bans pushed by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Committee_to_End_Pay_Toilets_in_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Committee_to_End_Pay_Toilets_i.... Before this America had many paid toilets. In Europe and Asia often the toilet requires a nominal fee (sometimes unfortunately expensive though) to keep out drug addicts or other folks at the bottom, but due to the bans from the campaign cities with huge drug problems are hamstrung from offering paid toilets. I think it's important to have free options but to blanket ban a paid toilet contributes to the restroom issues we see now in urban areas IMO.
- rightbyte 3y agoI think we should address the root problem, which is Jack Nicholson, who convinced everyone that mental hospitals are bad.
- lokar 3y agoThey were bad, very bad
- jl6 3y agoIt does seem like there should be some sane middle ground between abusing patients and throwing them onto the street.
- rightbyte 3y agoYes, but surely giving mother nature the task instead is not the proper reform. Psychiatric medication have come a long way since the 60s, so running wards should be alot simpler than back then with all those insane displine procedures.
- Natsu 3y agoPart of the problem is that it works like prison, where some of what makes it awful are crazy assholes ruining things for everyone else dialed up to 11.
- godelski 3y agoAt this point it seems cheaper to go about solving the upstream problems.
- sharlos201068 3y agoThat would involve Americans voting to solve the housing crisis, which they aren't interested in doing.
- godelski 3y agoFair, but I think a bigger problem is that politicians don't align their policies with public opinion so I'm not gonna blame inefficient or disenfranchised voters. When everything is Kabuki can you blame people for being confused?
- rcme 3y agoRequiring water and power seems like a pretty basic requirement for a bathroom! Or are you expecting a sunlit composting toilet?
- user3939382 3y agoSame thing happened with accessibility of these in NYC. So please tell me how it’s better for the handicapped that there’s no restroom at all. It’s ridiculous.
- nonethewiser 3y ago> San Francisco has tried I wouldnt say they’ve tried. Trying includes not letting the homeless ruin it.
- rewmie 3y ago> JCDecaux is really an ad company. The street toilets are just a way to get ads on public property. At the risk of going off on a tangent, JCDecaux is actually a marketing company which sells ad space to the highest bidder. Their business model consists of offering municipalities free public equipment/urban infrastructure such as bus stops, public toilets, public fountains, etc, and in exchange have the right to use that to post curated ads. > The first problem was that that the US required them to be wheelchair-accessable. I don't think that holds any truth at all. All JCDecaux public toilets I've seen were all designed with accessibility in mind. Why do you think that asking JCDecaux to provide something it already provides everywhere would be suddenly an issue? https://www.jcdecaux.com/press-releases/world-toilet-day-over-40-years-jcdecaux-has-been-committed-facilitating-universal https://www.jcdecaux.com/press-releases/world-toilet-day-ove... > So they were 3x as big and several times more expensive than the smaller units in Paris.[1] Those are already wheelchair-accessible. What's your point? > They are noted for working fine in tourist areas, and badly in homeless areas. Making them big enough for wheelchair accessibility makes them big enough for drug deals, too. I don't see your point. Do you think there are no homeless people in tourist areas where JCDecaux deploys public toilets? People still vandalize those, and also coin-operated ones.
- baud147258 3y agoJCDecaux also operated Paris' public bike sharing system; there wasn't any ad space on those (but then it wasn't free).
- n8cpdx 3y agoEven the Portland loo needs to be cleaned, and unfortunately the populations that uses them poses a hazard to workers. https://www.wweek.com/news/city/2023/08/30/city-of-portland-blames-former-contractor-for-hazardous-conditions-of-public-bathrooms-downtown/ https://www.wweek.com/news/city/2023/08/30/city-of-portland-...