4 ms·
This would be good advice in a world where rescinded offers are extremely common and employers refused to take people back after their 2 weeks notice. However,
by Aurornis 3y ago
This would be good advice in a world where rescinded offers are extremely common and employers refused to take people back after their 2 weeks notice.
However, the opposite is true: Rescinded offers are extremely rare. When it does happen at a company of reasonable size, it’s so surprising that it’s a headline like this one. We’re here talking about it because it’s an extraordinary occurrence, not a common thing that happens all the time.
When you over-index on rare risks like rescinded offers, you start to lose sight of what you risk by doing things like quitting jobs without notice. Your professional reputation may end up mattering more than you think some day, and disappearing from a job without notice is the kind of thing that people remember you for.
Refusing to give any notice because you might possibly have a 1-in-10,000 rescinded offer reminds me of my grandmother-in-law who refused to fly on an airplane out of fear of airplane crashes. She definitely avoided death by airplane crash, but in the process she missed out on a lot of vacations and family events.
Don’t overindex on the rare thing.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoThis. I know that HN zeitgeist, weirdly, in some strange way likes to be "interchangeable cogs in a machine" (focus on standard easily employable tech stack, avoid learning company-specific stuff, change jobs frequently, be easily replaceable); but in a LOT of companies leaving with no notice puts everybody (coworkers, management, business, client - real human beings) in a crazy bad spot. Many large companies have a checkbox on whether a leaving employee is rehireable. I've seen enough people leave then come back, that it may not always be as ok as it seems to burn those bridges - not to mention that in some ways industry is surprisingly "small" - people move and bad reputation spreads. If Bob asks Fatima who worked with James, should he hire him - you can bet this'll come up. And if that feels like a low hypothetical risk - it's a lot higher than risk of rescinded offers.
- throwawaysleep 3y ago> but in a LOT of companies leaving with no notice puts everybody (coworkers, management, business, client - real human beings) in a crazy bad spot. Not my problem. Luckily for them, I stay because I practice overemployment.
- noirbot 3y agoI mean, it is your problem if you like any of those people and expect them to maybe be part of your career network in the future. I know I'd have a hard time considering referring someone who gave zero notice when quitting. Sure, it's just business, but that's some pretty anti-social behavior. The person who had to stay behind to clean up the mess you left is unlikely to ever want to help you in the future, or take your call if you want to hire them onto your team at some point You can certainly make it less abrupt in other ways - let people know beforehand or such, but if I showed up on Monday and one of the other senior folks on my team just was gone with no notice and didn't talk with me again, it would be hard to just treat that as normal.
- moate 3y agoThere’s this one cool trick I learned where labor solidarity means telling coworkers ahead of quitting but not managers. Also not everyone needs “their network” to get jobs. This employee karma from fucking management I’m always threatened with has never been real in any industry I worked in.
- noirbot 3y agoThere's definitely ways you could do it well that don't make a mess - telling your coworkers ahead, or at least the ones who would have to take your workload. Or subtly making sure to knowledge-share before you leave. I'm saying this from experience of people doing things as mundane as just moving to another team within the company with little to no notice. Yea, it "fucked management", but I also had to spend 3 months dealing with the mess they left behind, and inherited half-working code that they clearly had neglected because they knew they were about to leave. Labor solidarity isn't just "I screwed capital so it's all a positive". You have to... I dunno, support your fellow laborers. I certainly don't think it's some moral failing to have abandoned a job with no notice, but implying that this is just "fucking management" is missing how much it can really pile stress and bad conditions onto the fellow employees you leave behind. Maybe it's never bitten you, but I know if any of the folks I've worked with who have disappeared with no notice from my team asked me to work with them, I'd be having a hard time trusting them. Maybe they don't care, and they think I'm some corporate stooge or whatever, but when you're totally fine throwing me into the machinery of capitalism to advantage yourself, what would stop you from doing that again?
- Apocryphon 3y ago> likes to be "interchangeable cogs in a machine" This is totally a response to the employer side. When companies are laying off people en masse with little regard to either performance or years of service rendered, they reveal themselves to regard their workforce as interchangeable cogs. We are living in a market that encapsulates the adage, “your company will let you go without a second thought.”
- aspanu 3y agoMy understanding of why companies cannot purposely show that they take perf or years of service into account has more to do with labour law than a lack of caring. You cannot take into account perf in a layoff - if you did, you are not allowed to call it a layoff, AFAIK.
- Eisenstein 3y agoThat doesn't sound right at all. You would want to lay off the bottom performers, it isn't a lottery. Imagine if a company said 'we need to get rid of 20% of our labor cost' and just ran a random number generator and got rid of the people who's number came up.
- deprecative 3y agoNo, you want to get rid of just enough of the top performers to significantly lower labor cost while keeping enough that they feel safe. You can shed as many of the bottom performers as you like without worry. Gotta make those top performers do 2x the work for one paycheck.
- doktorhladnjak 3y agoCompanies absolutely take perf and years of service into account for layoffs. It’s not always the same process or formula but those are popular terms in such a formula, along with pay, location, role.
- ReptileMan 3y agoAnd that is a reason to turn yourself into indispensable cog, not the best replaceable there is.
- rewmie 3y ago> (...) but in a LOT of companies leaving with no notice puts everybody (...) in a crazy bad spot. Do you think gratuitously firing employees doesn't leave them in a bad spot? How come that a family needing to pay rent and make ends meet doesn't benefit from the same level of concern you're giving to a manager having to go through the trouble of replacing an employee?
- ambrozk 3y agoJust because many companies behave poorly does not mean there is not a code of reciprocal obligation between workers and companies. If a company lays someone off and gives them no severance, you would judge that company more harshly than if they had given them severance. Similarly, if a worker leaves with no notice, people judge them poorly. When you break the rules people judge you.
- rewmie 3y ago> Just because many companies behave poorly does not mean there is not a code of reciprocal obligation between workers and companies. What code are you talking about? Either you're referring to worker protection laws or collective bargaining agreements. If you're not referring to either of those, you're just projecting personal expectations that no one meets. > If a company lays someone off and gives them no severance, you would judge that company more harshly than if they had given them severance. Your frowns don't pay a man's rent. > Similarly (...) There is absolutely no similarity. At all. If a worker gets fired, he loses his livelyhood. If an employee quits, a few employees have a to-do item in their task queue. You're talking as if companies don't hire people dedicated to hiring and firing.
- aetherson 3y agoI think the super-hot job market in tech from 2012ish to 2022ish has really led a lot of people to underrate having a good professional reputation. When you were competing with 10 other companies to try to get a candidate, you couldn't be too fussy about "hey, why do you have a string of short tenures," or "did you get a kinda lukewarm reference from so-and-so." So now we've got people saying, "Hey, don't worry at all about making your employer mad," in an environment which favors employers over employees. It's shortsighted, unless we return to ultra-hot job market in a year and this is a one-time difficulty.
- Apocryphon 3y agoThe mass layoffs this year, almost universally executed on seemingly arbitrary criteria with little regard to performance or seniority, would seem to indicate that employers certainly don’t care about making employees mad. Any pretense of reciprocity has been destroyed this year.
- great_psy 3y agoYes and no … Just because somebody does not care about making an employee mad, it does not mean they will get a job if they do. You might think your employer is horrible, but it’s the ones that smile and stay how great the company is that will get hired. When you NEED a job, people will go back to being company-pleasers.
- hef19898 3y agoThere never was any pretense to begin with, people just happened to realize that lately. In tech that is. That being said, your relationship is with your, former and current, co-workers. I am rather good in blowing bridges up if I think someone else put them on fire first. But even then, I took great care of who was on the other side, as much for my own sake as for the sake of my reputation and relationships with others. Because even if you don't give a single f** about your employer, your co-workers will remember as would you. Especially if all of a sudden the job market is favouring employers again.
- Scoring6931 3y ago
- scarmig 3y agoAgreed that rescinded offers are not something to worry too much about. And, worst case scenario, you can often go back to your old team if you left on good terms. It would be nice, though, if you had some certainty of some support, though switching jobs inherently entails some risks. If you're recently hired and there are to be layoffs in the next month, you will absolutely be on the chopping block. I'd love there to be something like unemployment insurance, except effective immediately such that spectacularly bad luck while switching jobs doesn't ruin you (and ideally that imposes some penalty on the hiring employer, who recklessly hired you and put your well-being at risk) and large enough to maintain people's fixed costs. That's more of a <10% risk in a down market (I'd guess... <1% in a good market) than a plane crash risk.
- CapstanRoller 3y agoIt seems simpler to just implement UBI and robust safety nets for everyone.
- Shaanie 3y agoUBI is ridiculously expensive, it's not simpler in any way.
- lumost 3y agoThis entirely depends on how common rescinded/delayed offers are. We're seeing a general normalization of the following behaviors at major tech employers. - Rescinded offers - Delayed start dates Unfortunately, people's ability to maintain professional behaviors is entirely dependent on those behaviors working out. When Visas and other critical life factors are on the table, you can't blame someone for being protective.
- aaronbrethorst 3y agoreminds me of my grandmother-in-law who refused to fly on an airplane out of fear of airplane crashes Totally. It's just like a black fly in your chardonnay.
- theshadowmonkey 3y agoNot exactly true. Has happened with so many companies recently(Google, Amazon, Coinbase etc..,). And it hits most employees hard since they might be someone who just got laid off. This is even harder with people on visas who might be running out of time to find a new job or leave the country. Also, this happens more in a tougher economic climate where the people with rescinded offers are left in a really hard place. A lot of people on visas might have also planned their exits a few months before since visa transfer and everything takes a while. And lot of companies with hiring freezes will 100% refuse to give your job back.