5 ms·
> It's even amazing that mRNA vaccines actually made it to the market, and if it hadn't been for the pandemic, there's a good chance that it would be another 15
by scarface_74 3y ago
> It's even amazing that mRNA vaccines actually made it to the market, and if it hadn't been for the pandemic, there's a good chance that it would be another 15 years before they do, and this mRNA vaccination tech has been brewing since the 90s, I think?
I’m by no means an anti-vaxxer and believe that even if the “vaccines” did reduce the severity and number of deaths it was a win. But, I think it was a disservice to call something a vaccine that didn’t seem to reduce the chance of you catching it, the effects of the vaccine completely disappeared within 6-9 months and it didn’t keep you from catching Covid.
We wouldn’t accept that definition for any of the other vaccines like Smallpox, measles, etc
- Loughla 3y agoI think if the vaccine decreased the severity and mortality rates of the disease it targets, we absolutely would call it a win. Flu vaccine. I'm talking about the flu vaccine.
- scarface_74 3y agoI agree and I said as much. I am arguing more about definitions and marketing than anything else that led to skepticism. Besides the looney bins, very few were anti vax about the traditional vaccines we all had to get to attend school. We saw those as effective to prevent the diseases they were meant to. I was first in line when it came to Covid “vaccines” and kept up to date with boosters because I knew even the common cold can trigger my overactive immune system/asthma. I’ve had Covid twice and I was coughing for a couple of weeks. It was more irritating than anything else. I attribute my not having a more severe reaction to the vaccines. It probably wouldn’t have been that bad with the other preventive asthma meds I take now. But the marketing by the government behind the vaccines and the early suppression by the government and the tech industry of information about the long term effectiveness has set us back.
- sunshinesnacks 3y agoSounds like you are moving the goalposts from “it doesn’t help at all (after 9 months) and isn’t even a vaccine” to “there was poor government marketing and tech industry actions were bad”, which are very different things. I think that downplaying the benefits of the vaccines is somewhere between uninformed and irresponsible. I don’t care nearly as much about criticism of government commas and the tech industry.
- scarface_74 3y agoYou mean when I said in my original post > But, I think it was a disservice to call something a vaccine It was a severe disservice because it increased skepticism and reduced uptake > I think that downplaying the benefits of the vaccines is somewhere between uninformed and irresponsible What part do you disagree with? Even the pro-vaccine side which I’m one of says effectiveness declines to near zero after six to nine months without a booster. > I don’t care nearly as much about criticism of government commas and the tech industry. You should care because they are a major cause of the anti-vaxxers and causing people to die and be hospitalized unnecessarily because of ineffective messaging
- sunshinesnacks 3y agoI’m not sure we are having a productive conversation about the word “vaccine” or vaccine effectiveness, so I don’t have anything else to add there. When I said I don’t care as much about criticism of government comms (commas was a typo) and the tech industry, I meant I’m not too concerned that you are criticizing them. I don’t think I fully agree with you, but I don’t feel strongly enough that I would have replied to your comment if that was all it appeared to be about.
- csours 3y agoMaybe you should check the actual endpoints for the trials you mention.
- scarface_74 3y agoThe government repeatedly pressured tech companies to suppress information about the short term effects of the vaccine and that it didn’t prevent infection. It was only later on that they admitted as much. This led to many people not trusting anything the government said.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- csours 3y agoPeople don't like the answer "we don't know that", so they will ask experts until they get one who answers the question. People don't have time to understand the context of complicated subjects, so they ask experts who answer quickly. People can't test every statement for truth, so they ask experts who answer confidently. And then people feel like they've been lied to, because we don't know all the answers, the answers are complicated, and we need to change our minds sometimes because we were wrong. It's easy to blame "the media" or "the experts" or "the elite" for these problems, but there are a lot of hard problems in this world that need a lot of context to really understand in a meaningful way. Yes, media, experts, and elites abuse their position. Solving this problem requires more work than just replacing them. Your instinct that something is wrong with authority figures is correct, but I feel like you've gone down a narrow channel for the answers.
- scarface_74 3y ago> Your instinct that something is wrong with authority figures is correct, but I feel like you've gone down a narrow channel for the answers. I am not doubting the science or the statements that come from the CDC, DHHS, or the established respected medical community. I’m criticizing the government more for actively, denying and suppressing information that they admit now to be true. On another note almost everything that the government has done in handling Covid since the vaccines have come out has done more harm than good: 1. Vaccine mandates for a vaccine that has since been shown not to be effective long term without a booster. I for the J and J vaccine March 2021. I could show that as proof of vaccination and that alone and I would still be in compliance even though all of the science shows it doesn’t mean anything two years later without boosters (which I’ve done on schedule and still got Covid twice. It was mild each time) 2. Mask mandates after the vaccine was widely available - in practice mostly ineffective because people were wearing cloth masks and not wearing them correctly. At that point I had no sympathy for people who died from Covid who refused to get vaccinated. They made their choice using their own free will.
- jeromegv 3y ago> the effects of the vaccine completely disappeared within 6-9 months I don't know if you are anti-vax person disguising as a "just asking reasonable question" type of person (it's a common tactic), but I had to reply to be sure that anyone reading that understood this was absolutely false. The impact on the death rate and severe outcome of COVID is being seen even years later, so this is absolutely false this entirely disappear within 6-9 months, this is very well documented. This vaccine allowed us to move forward and make sure our hospitals and entire healthcare system stopped being overrun even when we had a 30-40% of the population contracting the virus, this is an absolute win.
- scarface_74 3y agoDid you even read my original post? “even if the “vaccines” did reduce the severity and number of deaths it was a win” I said in another reply that I have “virus induced asthma”. A simple cold will cause my immune system to overact and cause me severe difficultly breathing. I was first in line for the vaccines and I did an MRNA booster before it was recommended in the US because I read what I thought were credible studies from other countries about needing it after the J and J one shot. I’ve also said before that “I retired my wife” who was working as a school bus driver because I didn’t feel it was safe before the vaccine came out. > The impact on the death rate and severe outcome of COVID is being seen even years later I’m not disagreeing with that. You’re preaching to the choir. I am saying it was a messaging problem to call it a vaccine if it doesn’t prevent you from getting the disease.
- hedgehog 3y agoI'm not sure where this idea that vaccines 100% prevent disease (or infection) came from. The main reason previous vaccination programs like measles have worked so well is they allowed near eradication so most people never even get exposed, or just less exposed in cases like influenza where there is too much mutation or waning to get close to eradication. That's why immunization requirements at places like schools are useful, if you add too many unvaccinated kids to the mix then even some of the vaccinated kids are likely to get infected and sick. More to the point, lots of people get the flu vaccine and hit or miss whether you still get sick (probably less, but still a bit).
- sunshinesnacks 3y ago“didn’t seem to reduce the chance of you catching it” It absolutely did reduce chances of catching/testing positive for COVID early on, and that benefit shrank over time as the virus mutated. “the effects of the vaccine completely disappeared within 6-9 months” I’m not sure about odds of catching it, but reduced odds of hospitalization and death do persist beyond 9 months. Also, see the flu vaccine, as someone else has already referenced. Do you put quotes around “vaccine” when you refer to those?
- scarface_74 3y agoDid you even read where I said “ that even if the “vaccines” did reduce the severity and number of deaths it was a win” > I’m not sure about odds of catching it, but reduced odds of hospitalization and death do persist beyond 9 months. We don’t know that. Most people who cared enough to get the vaccine, also probably cared enough to get booster shots as recommended. Every study shows that the effectiveness completely disappears within 6-9 months without a booster. I am one of those who got the booster. And you arguing with me about the effectiveness when I’m arguing about the messaging shows how out of touch people are on HN with the significant number of Covid/anti-vaxxers.
- sunshinesnacks 3y ago“ Did you even read where I said…” I did. You said “if” as if maybe they didn’t. “We don’t know that.” Yes we do. Boosted vs not boosted is differentiated in case, hospitalization, and death data.
- scarface_74 3y agoIn the context of the entire post, how could you infer that I was arguing against vaccines when I explicitly said I’m not an anti-vaxxer?
- sunshinesnacks 3y agoWell, I don’t think I was the only one that had issues with your original comment. As someone else mentioned, unfortunately “I’m not anti-vax, but…” is a common anti-vax opening line. I believe you now, though.
- epistasis 3y agoYou should apply a bit more critical thinking to the lines you have been fed. We have to create new flu vaccines every single year, because flu is so varied. They don't see a ton of use, but they save a lot of lives. So thinking that we don't accept this definition of vaccine is just not based in reality. SARS-CoV-2 evolves, particularly under the pressure of resistant hosts, and even people that were infected once can get it many times! Secondly, the vaccines absolutely did reduce the chances of catching covid, by massive amounts. Take even a glance at any of the studies: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2035389 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2035389 I would beg you to look back at where you picked up these bits of misinformation, and completely eliminate those sources from your information diet. They can not be trusted, and will infect you again with bad info that puts your health at risk.
- scarface_74 3y agoYour link says > The mRNA-1273 vaccine showed 94.1% efficacy at preventing Covid-19 illness, including severe disease It prevented “severe illness”. I agree with that completely. I said as much. It didn’t say it prevented you from “getting in”. Preventing severe illness is a win. I’ve taken Covid shots every six months for that reason - especially since I have virus induced asthma. But the government originally marketed it as preventing Covid. This and going out of its way to pressure tech companies to suppress what we all agree is the truth now has led to Covid anti-vaxxers.
- epistasis 3y agoThe vaccine prevents illness, that's exactly what you are quoting. Thats what the trial was looking for. Look at the chart, about incidence. It absolutely did prevent getting Covid. I don't understand what you are trying to say. It doesn't merely prevent sever disease, it prevents all incidence of disease.
- scarface_74 3y agoI’m saying that the government claimed that getting the vaccine would “prevent Covid”. Traditionally, when people take “vaccines” that’s the expectation. When the government was suppressing information that now everyone agrees is true - that the vaccines don’t prevent Covid and that the effects were short lived, they lost credibility and the same people who didn’t fight traditional vaccines like we all took as kids became anti-vaxxers and now are railing against vaccines that do actually prevent you from getting diseases
- throw10920 3y ago> But, I think it was a disservice to call something a vaccine that didn’t seem to reduce the chance of you catching it, the effects of the vaccine completely disappeared within 6-9 months and it didn’t keep you from catching Covid. I think that that's because the public is used to super-effective vaccines that are so good at preventing you from getting the disease at all that they've started associating that term with that level of effectiveness. I don't think that's entirely fair, though - whenever we develop a new variant on any technology (e.g. Li-Ion batteries, after NiMh), the new technology usually has some initial performance deficits (e.g. lower capacity), so it seems reasonable to accept that in the case of vaccines as well. "Vaccine" was originally intended to be an indicator of what it was, not how effective it was. That doesn't excuse the poor and dishonest communication from many governments, though. They should have been very clear about the numbers: "This reduces your chance of contacting Covid by about 60%, and reduces your chance of severe illness by 80% if you do get it" or something. > We wouldn’t accept that definition for any of the other vaccines like Smallpox, measles, etc Well, the smallpox vaccine is only 95% effective - it doesn't completely prevent you from getting smallpox, either, and I suspect that that's the case for basically every vaccine in existence. > didn’t seem to reduce the chance of you catching it, the effects of the vaccine completely disappeared within 6-9 months and it didn’t keep you from catching Covid These claims seem a bit far-fetched, but I'm open to looking at the evidence if you'll bring it forth. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/smallpox/vaccine-basics/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/smallpox/vaccine-basics/index.html
- scarface_74 3y agoFrom your link. > The smallpox vaccine protects people from smallpox by helping their bodies develop immunity to smallpox. Do you see the term “immunity” anywhere on the CDCs sight today with regards to the Covid vaccine? Are you disagreeing that the Covid vaccine looses almost all effectiveness after 6 to 9 months? Again from the CDC. https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2022/s0901-covid-19-booster.html https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2022/s0901-covid-19-boost... > They can help restore protection that has waned since previous vaccination
- throw10920 3y ago
- nradov 3y agoThe CDC did actually change their definition of vaccination in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic. The updated definition is more scientifically accurate, but the timing of the change caused a lot of public confusion and the CDC did a bad job of communicating the reason for the change. https://apnews.com/article/fact-checking-976069264061 https://apnews.com/article/fact-checking-976069264061
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd this exactly the point I’ve been making, the incompetence of the CDCs messaging and even worse suppressing information that we all know to be true now based on the latest messaging of the CDC has done harm to vaccine programs that have been generally accepted by everyone.