3 ms·
That's the doomerism we all got to welcome. The talk is about how the path is clear, so we should start to look at those bottlenecks and remove them. But well,
by marcosdumay 3y ago
That's the doomerism we all got to welcome.
The talk is about how the path is clear, so we should start to look at those bottlenecks and remove them. But well, the path has been patently clear for more than a decade. It was only propaganda trying to obscure it.
Whoever manages to abandon doomerism and walk the path, instead of resisting being dragged through it will get the first mover advantage over well, the entire future.
- PaulHoule 3y agoBoosterism is the close partner of doomerism. If I were facing a bunch of boosters I'd probably sound a lot like Noah in comparison to how I sound now. I read a lot of literature on the energy situation 20 years ago because I got concerned about this long before a lot of other people did and the assumption back then was that we needed at least 10x the energy storage than many people seem to think we need now. Newer literature doesn't confront the old literature and explain why it's different today, it just seems that people are more optimistic. Sure batteries are around in the world but at 100x the cost and 1/100 times the scale. Could an exponential curve continue, yes it could. But "things that can't continue forever won't" and we are seeing that happen in the semiconductor industry right now where new generations of chips are not cheaper per transistor than old chips which will bring progress to an absolute halt. What I see is a lot of quoting very low prices that are a bird in the bush not a bird in the hand and no mention of error bars or "the probability of this is 70%" or, more likely, "there are four events that have to happen to realize this that each have a 50% probability of occurring" so the result is that people react like they do when they get assaulted by a friend (soon to be ex-friend) who wants them to join Amway or by a crypto bro at a party. That is, people like Noah have to sound a bit less optimistic if they want to be taken seriously.
- marcosdumay 3y ago> but at 100x the cost and 1/100 times the scale That exactly what people were saying about solar 10 years ago. Hell, some people are still saying that about solar today, but it's what people were correctly saying 10 years ago. Do you have any reason for why batteries will stop improving before they are mainstream? (As somebody pointed out, your numbers are a bit off, and they are already viable. They just aren't the cheapest option in isolation, so we have natural gas plants and batteries are niche. Do you have a good reason why they will stop improving before they dethrone natural gas?) Because, just like solar, the physical constraints puts a floor on their price that is much lower than what we need.
- PaulHoule 3y agoIn general you need some miracle to get a factor of X, for instance progress in semiconductors has required a few miracles a decade. For a long time we got those miracles until we didn't. (It's not an accident that people are complaining that this year's GPUs aren't cheaper than last year's GPUs because transistors are not longer getting cheaper with die shrinks which is the real end of "Moore's law") In a lot of cases you get a few miracles then you run out of miracles. Like aviation. That's the normal case in technology in fact, cases like semiconductors where the miracles keep coming are really unusual.
- marcosdumay 3y agoOh, yeah, it's magic! Let's just forget that people had a pretty good idea on how far one could push the semiconductors industry since a few years after the transistor was invented. Let's not look at the physical possibilities at all, because in what way could that help? I really think you are trying to say that people will have to work hard to gain the battery improvements. But, yeah, of course they will. Nobody on the entire thread said those gains will be free. What I simply don't understand is why you insist the process of optimizing batteries will stop orders of magnitude away from the optimum, without any reasoning behind it.