4 ms·
> Even though Apple is the largest company on the planet an entity that has a small fraction of the budget is apparently able to do a better job. NSO Group is
by mschuster91 3y ago
> Even though Apple is the largest company on the planet an entity that has a small fraction of the budget is apparently able to do a better job.
NSO Group is Israeli and (most likely) filled to the brim with former Unit 8200 staff. About the best of the best what the IDF has to offer - they've been said to match the NSA in quality.
> I don't see why Apple couldn't make those people an offer they can't refuse.
For all that can be guessed, they're a semi-private company, deeply connected with the Israeli government [1]. No one can pay these guys enough. If you want them to stop, you'll have to get the Israeli government to agree, and they won't give up any asset that gives them an edge over Iran or its numerous other enemies.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSO_Group#Relationship_with_the_Israeli_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSO_Group#Relationship_with_th...
- jacquesm 3y agoSo stop shipping iPhones to Israel until they play ball. If they're that smart they can roll their own phones. These companies do immense damage and endanger lives the world over. Given enough time and budget there is nothing that can't be cracked and it's the very worst actors that have access to this stuff.
- mschuster91 3y agoAs much as I agree with you... I think it's most likely that the US NSA, UK's MI(whatever), Israel's Mossad and a bunch of other secret services all cooperate with each other. No way these guys get taken down, and no way that the sanctions that have been nominally announced actually get enforced at the murky, intransparent bottom layer of the secret services. Someone has to crack open the phones of drug kingpins, terrorists etc. after all.
- hot_gril 3y ago? They'll just buy iPhones in some other country.
- jacquesm 3y agoGPS is a thing. iPhones have GPS.
- saagarjha 3y agoOk, and these companies develop zero-day exploits for a living. You think region-locking is going to work?
- callalex 3y agoEnough to make the company politically unpopular in its home country, yes.
- bigbillheck 3y agoGPS is trivially blockable.
- jacquesm 3y agoVoters would notice.
- nerdbert 3y agoSo tourists (or people visiting for family or work) who own iPhones wouldn't be able to use them in Israel? You can probably see how that's a tough sell.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, that's exactly it: you harbor this sort of company you will not be able to pretend it's business as usual on other fronts. After the 500,000th Facebook post of tourists linking NSO to 'my holiday in Israel was spoiled and I won't be going back there' I'm pretty sure they'd get the message. I'm ok with whitehat hackers but this shit has to stop. Mind you, I have an old Nokia so it's not as if I'm affected, the only thing I have to worry about is the baseband processor and my telco. But there are plenty of people who need a smartphone for their work and their opsec is pretty much as good as their phones' security.
- lmm 3y agoGood luck finding politicians willing to play hardball with Israel. Most won't even cut off arms sales to them.
- thrashh 3y agoThere’s very few candidates in that region for good allies so Israel has a stronghold in US politics. If we had made Iraq a powerful ally, it would have weakened support for Israel but that whole area of the world is too embroiled in conflict.
- sho 3y agoThat would be an extraordinary act of political activism which is never, ever going to happen. I'd argue it's not a corporation's place to take such an action in the first place. This is, if anything, a diplomatic matter and should be left to the state. I mean what next, stop selling to the KSA because of their gay rights issues? Iran? Russia? Where does that end? Well, it won't even begin, and rightly so. This is a state matter and they should stay in their lane. They're doing all they can, and should. BTW, I bet there's more than a few USA organisations who are quietly very annoyed about Apple's relentless bug-fixing. Organisations like NSO are tolerated for a reason.
- nebula8804 3y agoHa! Thats some nice fan fiction. Look at how Elon is torpedoing himself even further trying to take on ADL(lets be frank they clearly have ties to Israel). It took far right wing people + Elon bringing the issue up to even have a discussion on pushing back against ADL (and now ADL can just say thats just clearly anti-semetic people being anti-semetic) so the issue is already dead. Apple being a public company with many institutional portfolios holding their stock would not survive these portfolios dumping their shares due to pressure if they announced this. This could even be enough to force remove Tim Cook from his role. Why would he take such a drastic position? This rot is at all layers of the western world(UK, Canada, AUS, NZ, France at least). All the way from state governments passing laws saying you cannot boycott Israel or else you'll be barred from contracts(Anti-BDS laws) to congress removing members from their committees if they criticize Israel(eg. Illhan Omar) and signing loyalty pledges to Israel. When ANY new resistance appears against Israel, multiple groups in all of these countries move at light speed to enact a response. The downsides of having these exploits is clearly acceptable to all the people that make the decisions. And it's not like a regular person can use these exploits against members of congress to make them feel the pain. They'll just 'Julian Assange' you. What you are proposing requires massive reform at ALL level of government and across the western world as this is not only a US problem. Good luck with that. This requires changing fundamental beliefs of the majority of people who vote in these governments. They have a special "bond" with Israel and they wont willingly let go of that. You'll be better off just reverse engineering the complete iOS binary and finding every possible exploit. [1]:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-BDS_laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-BDS_laws [2]:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilhan_Omar#Remarks_on_AIPAC_and_American_support_for_Israel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilhan_Omar#Remarks_on_AIPAC_an... [3]:https://apnews.com/article/israel-republican-vote-pramila-jayapal-racist-state-congress-isaac-herzog-b591b1063e955f22176a22cbef3f6667 https://apnews.com/article/israel-republican-vote-pramila-ja...
- doktrin 3y ago> It took far right wing people + Elon bringing the issue up to even have a discussion on pushing back against ADL (and now ADL can just say thats just clearly anti-semetic people being anti-semetic) so the issue is already dead. The issue is dead because Elon's grievance is patently absurd. He's accusing the ADL of singlehandedly engineering a 60% drop in Twitter ad sales. It would be genuine comedy were it not for the fact he's handing a megaphone to the worst-of-the-worst groyper kindernazis.
- gruturo 3y ago> So stop shipping iPhones to Israel until they play ball. For what purpose? They would still procure iPhones through gray channels and hack them because that's what their victims use. Should Apple also stop selling phones in every other country, because that's where many of NSO's exploits are actually used? What other purpose? Annoy the local population? Create a grey/black market where you're even more likely to be given a "pre-hacked" unit?
- acdha 3y ago> No one can pay these guys enough I’m sure there are a lot of committed patriots there but I doubt it’s the whole company. Tim Cook could drop 1% of their cash on hand and see how many of them would turn down a million or two as a signing bonus, and if that didn’t work he could escalate to 10% or toss in some stock. I find it unlikely that wouldn’t tempt a lot of people, especially since the U.S. is one of Israel’s staunchest allies so it’d be pretty easy to tell yourself that pile of cash isn’t selling out. The real reason they don’t do that is trust: how could you ever be confident that someone wasn’t passing information back to Unit 8200 or even helping them out?
- lazide 3y agoI think you’re misunderstanding. Mossad likely wouldn’t let anyone pay enough. Or let NSO accept. Unless they were already friends enough to not need to worry much about cost.
- acdha 3y agoI understood but am skeptical of that - they'd block sale of the entire company but I think it'd be a surprise if they prevented a bunch of Israeli nationals from accepting prestigious jobs with an American company.
- lazide 3y ago1) of course they would. Or worse (see Gerald bull). 2) any company doing that would have to be insanely naive or reckless.
- Scoundreller 3y agoNSO seems more like a business. If Israel wanted to, they could pay NSO to keep their software internal/private, no? The more devices that get exploited, the more exploits that get closed. That's how you lose your edge against your enemies. Unless they're so confident in their stream of exploits that it's worth burning a few. Or these nation states are buying the devices to operate these exploits and operating them in their security labs...hrmmmmm...
- saagarjha 3y agoThe business of these companies is to develop a continual stream of exploits to counteract them being eventually patched, yes.
- not2b 3y agoIt appears that the Israeli government operates the same way as the Russian government with respect to their private black/gray hat companies and groups: hacking other people is OK, just don't hack our nationals or our institutions, and we're cool. And if they hack companies or people seen as hostile, so much the better.