5 ms·
At the risk of being boring: software liability would go a long way towards getting companies to do this work themselves. Even though Apple is the largest compa
by jacquesm 3y ago
At the risk of being boring: software liability would go a long way towards getting companies to do this work themselves. Even though Apple is the largest company on the planet an entity that has a small fraction of the budget is apparently able to do a better job. I don't see why Apple couldn't make those people an offer they can't refuse. That takes them off the market and has them doing something productive.
- phendrenad2 3y agoSoftware liability would effectively crush smaller companies, unable to keep up with the lawsuits, because they don't have billions in the bank.
- jacquesm 3y agoIf your software can cause billions of damage and you don't have billions in the bank you are in the wrong business, or acting very irresponsibly.
- RhodesianHunter 3y agoSmall companies can't cause billions in damage though...
- jacquesm 3y agoThe argument wasn't mine.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoYes they can? It's totally possible for a small, well connected, group to be writing small pieces of custom code in very critical applications, like core reactor controls system for navy submarines.
- RhodesianHunter 3y agoThose may be small teams, but they are most definitely not small companies.
- tonyarkles 3y agoSQLite and OpenSSL are prime examples. Both have exceptionally small teams behind them writing software that literally is in everything.
- acdha 3y agoOr you’d have separate rules, similar to how you can make kit cars or ultralight airplanes without being held to the same scrutiny as Boeing or GM.
- salawat 3y ago...implying the scrutiny Boeing is held to does anything beneficial. The regulatory capture resulted in a pathological operating module that put over 346 in an early grave because they couldn't be arsed to not cut corners; then on top of ot all, there's no substantive finding of liability or wrongdoing. Laws that are ultimately unenforced due to 2B2F might as well not exist at all.
- acdha 3y agoI don't want to defend Boeing's management but even with the worst failure in, what, half a century? it's still much safer to fly than drive so I wouldn't be so quick to throw aviation security culture under the bus.
- thfuran 3y agoI think you should really think about what you're saying. Would you cut makers of physical artifacts the same slack, say a small prepared food producer who just can't afford to vet their supply chain or final product to make sure it's not contaminated?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- phendrenad2 3y agoThis has already played out. Most consumer software specifies that it cannot be used in medical devices, or for nuclear energy production. So some version of this already exists. But should this apply to video games? Horoscope websites? Random number generators? I'm just pointing out that it isn't a universal argument.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Even though Apple is the largest company on the planet an entity that has a small fraction of the budget is apparently able to do a better job. NSO Group is Israeli and (most likely) filled to the brim with former Unit 8200 staff. About the best of the best what the IDF has to offer - they've been said to match the NSA in quality. > I don't see why Apple couldn't make those people an offer they can't refuse. For all that can be guessed, they're a semi-private company, deeply connected with the Israeli government [1]. No one can pay these guys enough. If you want them to stop, you'll have to get the Israeli government to agree, and they won't give up any asset that gives them an edge over Iran or its numerous other enemies. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSO_Group#Relationship_with_the_Israeli_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSO_Group#Relationship_with_th...
- jacquesm 3y agoSo stop shipping iPhones to Israel until they play ball. If they're that smart they can roll their own phones. These companies do immense damage and endanger lives the world over. Given enough time and budget there is nothing that can't be cracked and it's the very worst actors that have access to this stuff.
- mschuster91 3y agoAs much as I agree with you... I think it's most likely that the US NSA, UK's MI(whatever), Israel's Mossad and a bunch of other secret services all cooperate with each other. No way these guys get taken down, and no way that the sanctions that have been nominally announced actually get enforced at the murky, intransparent bottom layer of the secret services. Someone has to crack open the phones of drug kingpins, terrorists etc. after all.
- jcampbell1 3y agoI don’t understand your comment. Are you saying that involving trial lawyers and US juries to collect big settlements from Apple is going to stop the NSO Group? Or is it that the NSO Group should be liable for the actions of their clients?
- jacquesm 3y agoI don't understand your comment either. You say you don't understand and then you give a choice between two narrow interpretations neither of which seems to cover what I wrote. To make this a bit more productive: If Apple were liable for their defective products then they might decide not to ship them at all until they can be sure enough that the risk of the lawsuits putting them out of business is small enough that they can absorb it. This worked wonders for other industries (notably: automotive, airlines, medicine). It may slow them down a bit, you may have a wait a bit longer for the next iteration of some gadget. But that's a small price to pay in my opinion. As for the NSO group: I'm suggesting that Apple use their well filled cash coffers to buy these guys out, and failing that that they use some of that money to sue them for all of the damages that Apple incurs as a result of their actions as well as any criminal charges that they might get to stick. See 'Skylarov'. It wouldn't be the first time that a US judge finds fault with a foreign company. At a minimum it would slow them and their employees down to the point that they will be in a US jail the next time they visit Disneyland. If it works against illegal gambling operations I see no reason why that sort of mechanism can't be brought to bear against state sponsored hacking groups and their employees.
- bawolff 3y ago> If Apple were liable for their defective products then they might decide not to ship them at all until they can be sure enough that the risk of the lawsuits putting them out of business is small enough that they can absorb it. > This worked wonders for other industries (notably: automotive, airlines, medicine). It may slow them down a bit, you may have a wait a bit longer for the next iteration of some gadget. But that's a small price to pay in my opinion. That's quite a big price for non life-critical equipment that is a billion times more complex than a pacemaker or the safety-critical parts of an airplane or car.
- saagarjha 3y agoNSO Group is just one vendor; there are many more: Variston, Dataflow, Azimuth, Cytrox, …
- forcedmaddie 3y agoYet you forgot to mention that you entertain relationships with employees of those companies and go to their conferences. Hypocrisy much?
- saagarjha 3y agoThat's true, but I'm not entirely sure why this would be relevant to include in my comment? It's just pointing out that other vendors exist in this space other than NSO Group. I don't even see the hypocrisy if I had posted that while working at one of the places I mentioned? How would you rephrase it? (It seems like you know me, are you someone I've met before?)
- hollerith 3y agoIf Apple buys NSO Group and shuts it down, other firms are incentivized to enter the market especially because of the prospect of a nice payday if Apple buys the new firm, too.
- mise_en_place 3y ago[flagged]
- jamiek88 3y agoEdited. Decided not to engage.