19 ms·
Chicago’s parking meter disaster
- decremental 3y ago[dead]
- mcpackieh 3y agoJust spitballing: Defund the meter maids to de facto legalize ignoring the meters. Or tell the cops to look the other way while everybody smashes the meters up with sledgehammers. Or ban street parking to screw the meter company.
- asu_thomas 3y agoWho? Who is supposed to do these things and why?
- rapsey 3y ago> Under the contract, the city must maintain at least 30,000 meters in any given year
- randomdata 3y agoIf the people think the above is a good idea, they can also ignore the contract. It is not like there is some kind of supernatural power that enforces contracts.
- zoky 3y agoNo, it’s a very natural power—the courts. If Chicago ignores the contract, they’ll get sued and have to pay even more.
- randomdata 3y agoThat natural power is just people. Ignoring the contract is only significant if people choose to stand by the contract. But if the people believe what's contained in the original comment is a good idea, why would they stand by the contract? Without a supernatural power to uphold the contract, and without people to uphold the contract, there is nothing.
- FredPret 3y agoTrue but there are many other contracts that are critical to our daily functioning. If the city honors this terrible beast of a contract according to the rule of law, that bodes well for all the good contracts the entire government of the States has.
- randomdata 3y agoSmashing parking meters in some "clever" attempt to evade the contract already doesn't bode well for other contracts. Once you've gone that far down the rabbit hole, the contract already means nothing. Obviously in the real world it is unlikely that the people would think that the above is a good idea, but if they did then the contract is only as worth as much as the paper it is written on. It can simply be ignored. It is not like there is some kind of supernatural power that enforces contracts.
- FredPret 3y agoVery true - that's why some places are much easier to do business in. The USA is very good for this
- Sharlin 3y agoBecause of the rule of law? A court does not have the power to annul a contract simply because they think it was a really bad idea. Although I guess there ought to be some sort of a escape hatch for forced renegotiating of contracts that are as detrimental to the society at large (ie. the taxpayers) as this one. I have no idea whether there is one.
- BeFlatXIII 3y ago…and if the voters refuse to raise enough taxes to pay the fines?
- econnors 3y agodetroit says hello
- stevage 3y agoDoesn't the article begin by talking about how the courts are siding with the corporation?
- randomdata 3y ago”If” does not imply that the people do believe the above is a good idea. It is merely hypothetical.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoOne of the US’s biggest assets is its trust-ability. People around the world clamor to do business in the US, and creating outsize demand for the US’s currency because of it. Obviously, the people of the US can choose to reduce that perception, but there are tradeoffs. See Somalia and their currency’s purchasing power at the other other end of the spectrum.
- randomdata 3y agoObviously the people wouldn't actually think that smashing parking meters to renege on a contract is a good idea, but, as we said, if they thought it was a good idea then it wouldn't matter if the contract states something about not smashing meters. There would be nothing to enforce the contract. It is not upheld by a supernatural force.
- pmontra 3y agoCan't they be creative and put all of them in some place where they won't be used? Example, the emergency lane of highways, roads where nobody parks, etc.
- blamazon 3y agoLower Wacker Drive waves hello! But actually I think the contract accounts for this though, my memory is there's some kind of year-over-year value promise. (Plus inflation!) If true, moving the parking meters to a low demand location means the city would have to pay the difference in potential revenue, on top of the relocation costs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Sharlin 3y agoThe parking meter company would have had to employ some astonishingly incompetent lawyers if they had left such an obvious loophole in the contract text. It's the exact same thing as with scientists. Any time some lay person on HN or Reddit or wherever asks about some research or a new phenomenon or whatever (textbook example: dark matter) a question of the form "but have they considered <some very obvious idea>?" the answer is "yes, they have because that's their job and they're not stupid!"
- mminer237 3y agoYes, and if revenue goes down because of where they places them, the city itself has to make up the difference.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoI've skimmed through the contract. The city is contractually obligated to have the meter maids but I think they could tell them to stop writing tickets. Problem is the city needs the money. There's a parking app now so smashing the boxes won't work. Anyway no matter what you come up with there's a clause that basically says "if the city does anything that causes us to lose money they have to reimburse us" so we are well and truly fucked.
- gonzo41 3y agoThe city can get out of it. They could just flake out of the contract. The company is actually holding the risk because they think they can debt trap the city. They are holding the dragon by the tail and think they are in control. If the city just flakes on the contract and lets parking be free. Then everyone will be happy. The company will fight back in the courts and the city can just grind down that process for as long as possible. It doesn't have to settle, it can investigate back and do all sorts of things to cause trouble.
- mminer237 3y agoIf the city just ignores the contract, it will be sued. You can't delay a court hearing forever. Eventually it would have to pay all the lost revenue plus interest plus court fees. That's a terrible idea.
- kodt 3y agoI believe the contract guarantees a certain level of income. The city would no doubt have to pay for this if attempted.
- jimt1234 3y agoSorta related: A community near me recently experimented with "automated" parking enforcement. Basically, cameras around a parking space detected if the same car was parked longer than was paid for, and if so, the system fired off a ticket to the registered owner of the vehicle (by OCR'ing the license plate). I heard a few rumors regarding why the experiment stopped: - people were really PO'ed for getting parking tickets in the mail, days or weeks later. - cheating husbands were getting caught by their wives: "What's up with this parking ticket from downtown when you told me you were visiting your mother in Big Bear?" - vandals (heroes?) were spray painting the cameras, then parking for free.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago>vandals (heroes?) were spray painting the cameras, then parking for free. Why would they be heroes for unfairly preventing others from using the parking spaces?
- asu_thomas 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20230515004534/https://www.chicagotribune.com/opinion/editorials/ct-editorial-parking-meters-chicago-daley-20230430-fau3wymdevf7vknog5osrge5e4-story.html https://web.archive.org/web/20230515004534/https://www.chica...
- Baader-Meinhof 3y agoThis is clearly presented with a slant. I'm curious if there is a more neutral reporting on this? Like the article points to the 10x returns over 75 years as an example of the city being fleeced... But that sounds kinda like normal returns to me?
- scarface_74 3y agoI first heard about the story on this podcast episode of “Cautionary Tales”. I thought that an article would be a better post. https://overcast.fm/+5K6ZISYMc https://overcast.fm/+5K6ZISYMc
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoThat explains why this appeared on HN the day after I'd listened to it! The book "Paved Paradise" by Henry Gubar that was the source of the podcast, looks an interesting read: https://www.amazon.com/Paved-Paradise-Parking-Explains-World/dp/1984881132?ref_=ast_author_mpb https://www.amazon.com/Paved-Paradise-Parking-Explains-World...
- gxqoz 3y agoI read this over the summer, it's a great read.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jonathankoren 3y agoI remember when this stunt was pulled. It was loudly reported on all sides an obvious fleece for a quick buck. No one in the city supported this except Daley and the aldermen. Daley avoided having to actually deal with a budget shortfall, and then got a job with the firm that negotiated the deal. As for “normal returns”, it was sold well below value, and the whole enterprise is literally just rent seeking.
- scheme271 3y ago
- AlbertCory 3y agoAs a Chicago native, this gives me no end of amusement. Richie Daley's father would never have fallen for this. He'd send the Building inspectors to that company's offices every 4 hours, finding a new and very serious violation each time. Or something.
- scheme271 3y agoDaley didn't get fleeced. It was a sweetheart deal since he and his allies got a bunch of stuff from CPM and friends. It was the taxpayers that got fleeced. A few weeks after the deal went down, Daley got a job at the law firm that negotiated the deal: http://theexpiredmeter.com/2011/06/daley-takes-job-with-parking-meter-deal-law-firm/ http://theexpiredmeter.com/2011/06/daley-takes-job-with-park...
- bhickey 3y agoYou're talking about a guy who was so corrupt he destroyed an airport in the middle of the night.
- isuckatcoding 3y agoPlease be more vague
- helsinkiandrew 3y agohttps://jalopnik.com/chicagos-former-mayor-once-destroyed-an-airport-under-t-1848789654 https://jalopnik.com/chicagos-former-mayor-once-destroyed-an...
- bhickey 3y agoHuh? I'm not being vague in the slightest. Daley bulldozed the runway at Meigs Airfield in the dead of night. https://chicago.suntimes.com/2023/3/31/23662485/miegs-field-airport-mayor-richard-daley-bulldozed-notherly-island-plane-march-2003 https://chicago.suntimes.com/2023/3/31/23662485/miegs-field-...
- HDThoreaun 3y ago
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoI have a new phrase du jour: "Let governments be governments". This is pretty much the exact situation. A mistake (corrupt or incompetent) was made. Admit it. Then end the contract. Now governments should honour contracts negotiated earlier in good faith, but there has to be a level of "oh come on" about that honouring. Here everyone's reputations would be enhanced if a meeting occurred where the CEO of Goldman? / Abu Dabi and the Mayor plus maybe a federal rep (pretty high up maybe White House Chief staff) sit down and basically threaten the investors with no more deals in USA unless they hand back the meters. Everyone gets to look like winners - the government looks like real government and the investors get a profit and look like the kind of big shots only white house can deal with. And then we learn to actually scrutinise these deals that happen every day across towns across the west and ask - why? Don't sell the family silver, build strong towns, tax sensible levels, and trust in your city.
- behringer 3y agoAgreed. And next in Chicago we need to cancel or renegotiate pensions with all government employees in the county over the age of 60 for having been personally responsible for putting the county in a deficit to begin with.
- derekp7 3y agoPensions are a tricky subject. In cases where a pension job paid less than prevailing wages, that pension is in reality deferred payment for time already worked. So taking away the pension is wage theft. It would be similar to if an organization decided to take back a large portion of your 401K because they retroactively deleted the company matching benefit. In reality, that deferred pay should have been properly invested / managed from the beginning, but that would mean higher taxes or lower spending on other programs at the time the wages were earned.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoDefined benefit pensions have a simple fix. They should be illegal (along with all other deferred compensation schemes) for taxpayer funded entities. The moral hazard of letting today’s voters and today’s politicians and today’s senior government employees (the union leaders) steal from taxpayers 30 years in the future is obvious. Not to mention it is all going into the same SP500 anyway, so just cut out the middleman and moral hazard, and give everyone a Fidelity/Vanguard/Schwab 401k and let them buy the SP500/target date retirement fund they want. Having a lien on future taxpayers is literally the only difference between taxpayer funded defined benefit pension funds and 401K/IRA.
- ajdude 3y agoHalf as interesting did a really nice video on the subject a couple weeks ago: https://youtube.com/watch?v=HG6KA6V4T7w https://youtube.com/watch?v=HG6KA6V4T7w It is absolutely bonkers how one-sided the deal was and seems to be costing the city billions
- loosescrews 3y agoHalf as Interesting had a good video on this topic a few weeks ago: https://youtu.be/HG6KA6V4T7w?si=TXh71B1xoHGGID84 https://youtu.be/HG6KA6V4T7w?si=TXh71B1xoHGGID84
- theshrike79 3y agoFYI: the "si=xxxxx" bit in the end of Youtube share urls is an unique identifier that points to your specific user account and most likely contains specific metadata on how and when it was shared. You can, and should, remove it when sharing Youtube links. For that link the correct format would be: https://youtu.be/HG6KA6V4T7w https://youtu.be/HG6KA6V4T7w
- stevage 3y agoRegardless of the specifics of the deal, signing a 75 year deal with a single company is anti competitive. How did it get up? Weren't all the other parking companies outraged? Around here, deals like that never last more than years. They have to be re-tendered frequently.
- Simulacra 3y agoChicago doesn't stand for corruption, they demand it, yet voters continue to approve and send the same people back, so Chicagoans must also approve of the corruption.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoUnless the alternative is even more corrupt? Could be the lesser of two evils.
- scarface_74 3y agoI hate to get political. But the candidate leading in the polls by a wide margin for one of the major political parties has 91 indictments hanging over his head and loved by the “Christian right”. People don’t care about the ethics of their politicians.
- jacobsenscott 3y agoPeople vote for party, not person. But that's the only thing that really makes sense in a 2 party system.
- bluGill 3y agoYou can see examples of this in all parties over many years. In a few cases you can find an example of people who decide to care, but overall if the corrupt person is mostly on their side humans will ignore corruption as "just a minor thing", while corruption on a different side is a major problem. I hope you take the above and examine everything closely to make sure you are not falling for it. Fight corruption where ever it is found, even if it is on your side.
- gretch 3y agoAny government based contract that is 75 year is unethical in my opinion. 75 years is something like ~3 human generation. 3 whole generations that don’t get to decide how to govern themselves because their grandparents signed away their future in an iron clad contract.
- szundi 3y agoExactly, and these are not projects to like move mountains what requires enormous investments
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoA 75 year lease is pretty standard in lots of these kinds of government contracts, and I'll explain why. I work with a nonprofit that is negotiating a (standard length) 75 year lease for a piece of parkland. The nonprofit will have to invest many millions of dollars into buildings and improvements on this land (all publicly accessible). Without the 75 year lease, there is no way the nonprofit could run a capital campaign to raise money for the improvements - nobody would be willing to donate money if in a couple years the government could choose to change their minds and rip up the contract. This type of dynamic exists (someone else needs to make a huge upfront capital expenditure, and they need some sort of guarantee that they won't get "rug pulled") all over the place. Case in point, in 2017 Austin leased part of the airport for another company to run as the "South Austin Terminal". The original lease was for 40 years, and then only a couple years later the city changed their mind and decided they wanted that land back to do a major overhaul of the airport, and they tried to get it back with some extremely shady eminent domain tactics (and they basically got their ass handed to them in court). I actually hate the South Terminal (it's confusing and not connected in any way to the major Austin airport), I'm glad to see it go, but I'm also glad the city can't weasel their way out of a bad decision just because they changed their mind: https://communityimpact.com/austin/cedar-park-leander/transportation/2023/02/07/austin-ordered-to-pay-90m-to-acquire-south-terminal/ https://communityimpact.com/austin/cedar-park-leander/transp... I agree that there needs to be some way to hold previous office holders accountable for decisions that affect a locale long after the original signers are gone, but just saying we can only have leases for 20 years or so isn't the right way to do it.
- Apreche 3y agoThere is still a possible, but very difficult and improbable, way out of this. The appropriate legislature can change contract law. This may be difficult if it’s federal law that needs changing, but it’s still possible. If necessary, new judges can be appointed/elected who will decide in the city’s favor. Then they can take a new case to court and have the contract voided.
- gok 3y agoWhat people miss about this deal is that the city was literally losing money on parking meters before the deal because it was so incompetently managed. Chicago retains all the revenue from tickets, which are much more frequent now, so overall the city is making a lot more money from street parking today than it used to. Now, ideally the meters would have been run correctly with municipal ownership, but that was apparently not within their capabilities.
- dharmab 3y agoBut the city also has to guarantee the company lost revenue if the city removes meters. So any efforts to redesign streets with less cars and parking can't proceed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mortenjorck 3y agoIt is, in a word, awful. A perfect example of this is on Chicago Avenue, where the city added dedicated bus lanes… except they aren’t really, because even though you can’t drive in them unless you’re a bus, you can still park in them. Absolute Kafkaesque urban planning.
- idbehold 3y agoI'm sure there's something in the contract to prevent this, but couldn't they keep the meters and then post a "No Parking" or "Bus Parking Only" or even "Parking from 11:59PM-12:00AM"?
- matthewowen 3y agoKeep the parking, but make the entire street bus only. Good luck getting to that parking spot!
- 3y ago
- justin66 3y agoThat is some really bad writing.
- linuxftw 3y agoI don't know if the term is as long, but the toll roads being constructed today also include a 'minimum revenue' guarantee by the state governments. It's not just Chicago that's robbing tax payers blind, they've just done it long enough to be effectively insolvent.
- alistairSH 3y agoYep. The “Lexus Lanes” around DC are like this. Usually they’re international companies, so in some ways worse than just “Wall St”. I know we get the government we deserve, but holt shot it’s infuriating for roads to be outsourced this way.
- one_level_deep2 3y agoPlease explain how Chicago is "effectively insolvent."
- pchristensen 3y agoThe taxes are already high, the population is decreasing, and that's not counting enormous pension underfunding at the city and state level. There has been lots written about this for decades, during which the problems got worse. See e.g. https://www.chicagofed.org/publications/chicago-fed-letter/2017/379 https://www.chicagofed.org/publications/chicago-fed-letter/2...
- one_level_deep2 3y agoNone of those prove “effectively insolvent” and most are false, anyways. Chicago population grew according to 2020 census. Then the Census Bureau acknowledged that was undercounted. Any "news" on this is likely using the admittedly bad calculations to push a narrative. [1] Taxes aren’t particularly high for a city. There is no city income tax and property taxes aren’t in the top 10. [2] The pensions are absolutely an issue, but huge progress has been made in the past 5 years and they are making actuarial payments as of now. They got a bond rating upgrade recently and are solidly investment grade. "On October 21, 2022, Fitch Ratings upgraded the City of Chicago's general obligation bonds from BBB- to BBB. This was Fitch's first upgrade of Chicago general obligation bonds in 25 years due to the City's improved financial condition, rather than a change in the rating agency's methodology." [3] [1] https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/illinois-undercounted-in-2020-census-actually-grew-to-13-million-the-states-largest-population-ever/2837753/ https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/illinois-undercounted-... [2] https://learn.roofstock.com/blog/cities-with-highest-property-taxes https://learn.roofstock.com/blog/cities-with-highest-propert... [3] https://www.civicfed.org/civic-federation/blog/chicagos-recent-rating-upgrades#:~:text=On%20October%2021%2C%202022%2C%20Fitch,in%20the%20rating%20agency's%20methodology https://www.civicfed.org/civic-federation/blog/chicagos-rece....
- didgeoridoo 3y ago> Way back in 2009, Chicago’s inspector general confirmed that the city had sold out for far less than the lease’s value. A report by Bloomberg Business said CPM stood to earn about 10 times what it paid over the life of the contract. Any way you slice it financially, Chicago got taken to the cleaners. That’s approximately a 3% annualized return on investment (1.03^75 ~= 10). EDIT: Nope. See downthread. That’s really not bad at all, especially if the vendor has to pay to administer, maintain, and update the meters. I wonder how the IG got the idea that effectively selling a $10B 75-year taxable bond for $1B (in a year when high-grade muni bonds were yielding over 7%) was remotely a bad deal. Unless I’m missing something, this is a fantastic deal for Chicago and its taxpayers.
- sharedbeans 3y agoMaybe the report already discounted the future cash flows? I agree it would be pretty ridiculous if they didn’t.
- didgeoridoo 3y agoSo when the report says “10 times what they paid”, it means “10 times the amount the $1B would be worth in 75 years at the currently-forecasted risk-free rate of return”? I can’t imagine that’s true, but who knows I guess.
- Retric 3y ago10 times the inflation adjusted number seems to be the implication. However, the company receives money every year not a single lump sum at the end. If I lend you 10$ and you agree to pay me an inflation adjusted 1$/year for 100 years that’s vastly better than getting an inflation adjusted 100$ in 100 years. In the initial example the first dollar is discounted X%, the second X%^2, the third X%^3… Where getting paid an inflation adjusted 100$ after 100 years is fully discounted X%^100. The first case is equivalent to a bond paying nearly 10% + inflation with annual payments where the second is closer to 4.7% + inflation without annual payouts. PS: Further it’s ~zero risk as the contract states the city is responsible if revenues fall below projections.
- who-shot-jr 3y agoThere is a podcast about this - "The City That Sold Itself To Wall Street": https://www.pushkin.fm/podcasts/cautionary-tales/the-city-that-sold-itself-to-wall-street https://www.pushkin.fm/podcasts/cautionary-tales/the-city-th...
- JshWright 3y agoIt's always interesting to me when topics like this pop up in several places at once. I wonder what the common prompt was. Cautionary Tales (a great podcast, BTW, if folks aren't already familiar) published that episode last week. Half as Interesting also published a video about it a couple weeks before that. 99% Invisible brought it up in a parking related episode back in May (I wouldn't be shocked if that's what prompted HAI and CT to look into it), around the same time as this Chicago Tribune piece.
- rossdavidh 3y ago"Fortunately" for Chicago, there's a decent chance they will, in fact, declare bankruptcy well before the 75 years are up. Whether the parking meter situation would actually be better run or less exploitative under Chicago's city government is, of course, debatable.
- primitivesuave 3y agoThe mayor who sold Chicago’s parking meters had a father by the same name (Richard Daley) who was also a corrupt mayor of Chicago, and who infamously reneged on a desegregation deal with Martin Luther King Jr. https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/how-mayor-daley-outfoxed-martin-luther-king/1902225/?amp=1 https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/how-mayor-daley-outfox...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwawaymanbot 3y ago[dead]
- SoftTalker 3y ago"corrupt mayor of Chicago" Is there another kind?
- H12 3y agoLaughably incompetent.
- saalweachter 3y ago"unpopular", "one term", etc.
- vlark 3y ago"former"
- projectazorian 3y agoThe Daley machine has been very effective at building infrastructure, adding housing stock, and attracting investment to the city. It turns out that a lot of people are willing to overlook some corruption in exchange for results. (It helped that the Daley family always kept things relatively clean when it came to their own affairs. Most of the serious corruption happened one or two levels below them.)
- koolba 3y agoThis is the city that invented the idea of selling 99-year leases of public land and infrastructure. Every time there’s a budget issue, they sell off a piece of the city rather than addressing the actual budgetary problems (ie spending too much damn money!). It’s also unsurprisingly a single party city, and State too, with the Democrat party being in continuous control of the city for 85+ years.
- neaden 3y agoCity yes but Illinois' last governor before Pritzker was a Republican and had a Republican governor from 1976-2002.
- tigerBL00D 3y agoSo... what if these meters suddenly started breaking all over the place? Who's contractually liable to keep them operational?
- Kon-Peki 3y agoThe lessee. Early on a lot of unhappy people damaged the meters - you don't have to pay if the meter is broken. They learned from this and the current meters are very robust.
- HelloMcFly 3y agoIt only takes a can of spray paint, one need not bring a hammer. But now that it's all mobile-enabled all that doesn't help as much as it once did.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoPoint taken :) It appears that spray paint is still illegal to sell in Chicago - obviously nobody has it. Right? https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/chicago/latest/chicago_il/0-0-0-2609206 https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/chicago/latest/chicago...
- patrickmay 3y agoRobust to thermite? Asking for a friend.
- papa0101 3y ago[flagged]
- MetaWhirledPeas 3y agoMove unwanted meters into abandoned parking lots. Maybe there's an old run-down airport somewhere? Put parking spots on the tarmac.
- neaden 3y agoUnfortunately by the terms of the contract the city has to pay a penalty for doing things like that to make up for lost revenue.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoIf you're more of a numbers guy or gal, it's probably worth pointing out that the audited financial statements are available here [1]. I see that they have five lease deals going on and the reporting is only about the one (the worst deal???). A counterpoint is the deal in which Chicago leased the underground parking garages two years prior. Looking at those financial statements show that the deal was absolutely terrible for the bank(s) that financed the investment company - the original "owner" went bankrupt and the new "owner" has lost tens of millions over the last few years. I have to wonder whether the aggregate of all the deals is a "disaster", "a little bit bad", or maybe "a little bit good" (lowest probability?) [1] https://www.chicago.gov/city/en/depts/fin/supp_info/public_private_partnerships/asset_lease_agreements.html https://www.chicago.gov/city/en/depts/fin/supp_info/public_p...
- throwawaymanbot 3y ago[dead]
- scarface_74 3y agoFor some reason this reply below the parent comment was marked as dead. Am I missing something? Why was it killed? > Part of the deal is that if their yearly returns are not high or met, the city has to make up the shortfall. Which is absolutely disgusting and insane for tax payers.
- smsm42 3y agoI'm not sure why it's insane. It makes it more like a loan than a risky investment, and with 3.2% return one must be crazy to take the deal without some kind of guarantees. I mean if you are promised a 3.2% APY investment and then told "but we can actually decide at any time to mess with your income or do anything that breaks it completely, and you'd have to trust us not to do that for 75 years" would you take that? Would you buy an annuity which pays less than a savings account, but the holder can at any time restructure it in ways that makes it return even less? No sane investor would do that. At least not with 3.2% APY - that'd require much higher income, commensurate with the risk.
- 3y ago
- renewiltord 3y agoPrincipal-agent problem, no? Daley's job was to help out some buddies at CPM. He did it successfully. Chicago is the principal. He was the agent. But you can't align a city's objectives with that of the guy running it because he's essentially managing something that has the potential comp on the (black) market equivalent to a high-end hedge fund manager for the pay of a chump. If you put someone in charge of something, they will extract all the surplus from it that they can. The idea of governance that rests upon electing the incorruptible is a bit silly. Hard to manage, though. Do you say that every city deal over 5 years must go to a proposition? That no deal can exceed 10 years? In a nation with massive state power, the state would renege on the deal and CPM would be left up shit creek. In the US, individuals and groups of them negotiate as equals often. The state occasionally strikes back, but it's not privileged in any sense. Some pluses, some minuses.
- gilbetron 3y agoThe revenue is guaranteed, not the profit, so just require like 10 times the number of meters throughout the city, but make the cost per meter cheap. So the company gets the revenue, but their costs go through the roof. Make them beg to come back to the table ;) (This probably wouldn't work because there are probably other nefarious terms in the contract)
- tiffanyh 3y agoIs this a "disaster" because this private company is making money from their investment? or Is this a "disaster" because they are making more money than expected?
- alanbernstein 3y agoIs it reasonable to describe purchasing parking meter rights and raising the rates as "making money"? Who did the "making" of anything here? If you rewrite your question with "taking" instead of "making", does that make a certain answer more obvious?
- cryptonector 3y agoIt's a disaster because the city government is granting one company a monopoly by delegating to it a government power, and the contract is too difficult to renegotiate, and it fleeces the city's citizens in ways that they can't petition to redress (the city can't lower parking fees, and it can't even remove the meters from streets where maybe now there should be no paid parking). This sort of deal is very suspicious. One wonders if there's been kickbacks of any sort. Chicago is famous for its corruption after all.
- hamburga 3y agoNot sure if it's related to this specific parking meter deal, but I'll share my worst Chicago parking horror story: It's Black Friday, maybe 2010. My siblings and I go out for a drink somewhere downtownish. Street parking is tight. So we pull into parking for a corner business center (anchored by a bank, with a few other retail stores, all closed for the evening). There's some tiny "no parking here unless you're a business patron" sign that we genuinely don't see. After our very happy evening drinking reasonably-priced Chicago beverages, we return to the car. It's got a boot on it. The guy who installed the boot is just sitting there in his truck, waiting for us to get back. He tells us that we parked illegally and need to pay $150 (maybe more? at least that) to get the boot off. Something about it felt like society was eating itself alive. Just funneling money into some cynical investors' bank accounts while restricting us from making use of totally available, no-cost resources (an empty lot) that are themselves supported by ux taxpayers. Why do we do this to ourselves?
- pfannkuchen 3y agoI had this happen at a smaller city in NY state, except they had the car towed instead of booting it. In retrospect I’m not sure it’s totally unreasonable, since running a night time public parking lot could bring different risks and costs than a daytime lot. There is definitely a cash grab component though.
- monksy 3y agoParking in most of the city is incredibly tight, and there is a land and maintenance cost to having it. You shouldn't be looking for using that space for free. Even in the suburbs there are situations where parking is for that business and that business only.
- ourmandave 3y agoYeah, we parked in the wrong place and they towed our car. Had to take a taxi down to the impound and pay $100+. That was over 20 years ago.
- qingcharles 3y agoThis is very, very common in Chicago. Many business parking lots have a guy parked there all through the day to just boot you immediately and then take your money when you return.
- mattmaroon 3y ago"A report by Bloomberg Business said CPM stood to earn about 10 times what it paid over the life of the contract." Umm, is that really that much over a 75 yr contract? $1 invested in the stock market 75 years ago would be worth $172 today and that's adjusted for inflation, which I don't think the 10x figure is. To get to where we end up with 11x after 75 years in nominal dollars we're looking at just north of 3.2% interest. So basically Chicago got a 75 yr loan at just over 3.2%. Currently 30 yr muni bonds average almost 4%. They'd have been lower back then, and I'm not even aware of 75 yr bonds existing, but what works out to a 3.2% interest rate on a 75 year loan is far from a disaster. This article was not written by someone who understands finance, so I may be taking too much from that one quote. But if all they're getting over 75 yrs is a 10x return, it's hardly abusive! The investors would have been much better off just buying ETFs.
- bobthepanda 3y agoThe thing that sticks people’s craw is that it has more or less solidified the current allocation of street space to parking, and any attempt to change it (bus lanes, bike lanes, a COVID outdoor eating area, etc.) now cost the city substantial amounts of money. At least with a normal loan if your priorities change you can shuffle your budget accordingly.
- projectazorian 3y agoAlso, normally when you pay for street parking the blow is softened by the belief that - at least in theory - the money might go to infrastructure maintenance or some other publicly beneficial cause. Not so in Chicago, it's just going to line the pockets of rent seekers.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoStreet parking in the US is almost universally, and massively, subsidized. The money doesn't "go toward" anything except an infinitesimal reduction in that subsidization. To see this in action, stroll into a popular part of town, check the rate for parking on the street for a few hours, then check the rate for doing the same in a private lot on the same block. Metering is purely in the interests of the business owners on the block, who don't want people parking for more than a few hours - ie anyone except their customers.
- dventimi 3y agoThe city could just tear up the deal. What're the investors gonna do? Sue? Ok. Let 'em. At this level, this is a matter of politics, not law. You can bend or break or make the law do whatever you want if you have the will to do it and the political muscle to back you up.
- jimnotgym 3y agoThere are many people here calling the mayor corrupt. If a business bribed a public official to get a contract, and the city could prove it, then the deal would be void, wouldn't it?
- effnorwood 3y ago[dead]
- spullara 3y ago10x the investment over 75 years kind of sucks.
- stretchwithme 3y agoSounds like "substantial penalties for early withdrawal". Buyer beware.
- glonq 3y agoI worked in the parking biz for a decade. It's an industry that attracts a lot of scumminess because a lot of money passes through it and controls are lax. We had more than one customer unhappy with our system because it generated tight, accurate audit reports which meant that nobody could skim. I also recall an effort to put all parking meters in San Francisco under the purview of the department of weights and measures, but IDK if that was successful.