4 ms·
Nah, "waterfall" means exactly what people think it means. For one reason, because that's how language works. But on a more impactful way, because what people
by marcosdumay 3y ago
Nah, "waterfall" means exactly what people think it means.
For one reason, because that's how language works. But on a more impactful way, because what people think about it is exactly what was widely practiced at the time the paper was posted.
Corporations did hire some requirements gathering consultant. That consultant would make a lot of documents, sign them down and go to another client. Then the corporation would do an auction and get a "supplier" based on the requirements docs, make a contract and sign down that the docs completely described what they expected and was exactly what should be delivered. Then an administrator would test the received software against the contract, and shove it in a shelf where the software wouldn't get in anybody's way, because nobody would want that thing.
This is exactly how large corporations developed software.
Of course, the researcher that coined the name was so out of touch with the industry that he thought he was creating a strawmen. That makes his description not very useful, even though it doesn't detract anything from the paper's quality.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoDeveloped past-tense? Large corporations and organizations still do this to an unfortunate degree.
- rawgabbit 3y agoI agree large corporations still RFP and contract out this way. The vendors are now “agile” but deadlines and hard requirements are still baked into modern contracts. I can’t tell the difference between now and the bad old days.
- throwbadubadu 3y agoAnd to be realistic, also owed to their size also some things need to go that way? And it is also wrong, because even those corps don't throw the product away, but start iterating then usually. And unfortunately on the other hand "modern", scrum becomes just smaller waterfalls. It all seems to be just a spectrum of sprint length and size of your feedback loops? But I'd encourage everybody to not just bitch about it but try to live that situation, a big tanker is just much different steering than a speedboat. Unlimited scrum trainers and agile mindsets won't help that. In this sense I'm not sure what neither waterfall nor modern agile in its many variation means, just certainly it is always easy to laugh from the outside.
- marcosdumay 3y agoPersonally, I haven't seen this for a while. Everybody I know that use contractors migrated into "let's measure the software after the fact, iterate the design, and auction on the measurement unity" that, of course, also fails all the time, but works much better. It's basically the "Scrum" people tend to use in-house with some added nonalignment of incentives to spice things up. But I don't doubt a lot of places are still auctioning requirements. I just haven't seen them lately.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]