3 ms·
It would be great if we lived in a world where "please don't" was an effective security strategy, but we do not, and Apple needs to fix this problem before it g
by paxys 3y ago
It would be great if we lived in a world where "please don't" was an effective security strategy, but we do not, and Apple needs to fix this problem before it goes viral.
- utunga 3y agoI dunno.. if we just assume everyone around us is gonna be an asshole then we can never have nice things. In order to be able to take the subway I'm willing to assume that not every person in the car is gonna blast their personal music preference at max volume. Yes it is possible for them to do that but that doesn't mean it's on me to invent super smart headphones to block that out. At some point, in some cases, "please don't" is in fact a valid security response.
- failuser 3y agoWireless communications are inherently jammable. Where is the border between this and a bunch of microwaves jamming cell reception? I’m not saying Apple should not have done a better job in anti-spam measures, but “please don’t” is a basis for many nice things we have.
- smoldesu 3y ago> Where is the border between this and a bunch of microwaves jamming cell reception? One is hardware-based Denial-of-Service, and the other is software-based?
- failuser 3y agoThe main difference is the power requirement. Jamming wide band signals requires more power.
- IshKebab 3y agoJamming does not require much power. There are plenty of battery powered jammers available.
- smoldesu 3y agoIt's also generally against FCC regulations. Airdrop is not a regulated standard; it is entirely up to the implementing party to anticipate and mitigate abuse. The problems you're conflating are not the same, this Flipper Zero attack is entirely enabled by bad design. The explicit issue listed in the article is not inherent to the technology, it is inherent to Apple's vision for the Airdrop user story.
- IshKebab 3y agoThis isn't a security issue though. It's just annoying. It also requires physical proximity. We do live in a world where expecting people around you to not be arseholes is a reasonable strategy. The only real difference here between this and people playing loud shitty music on their phones or whatever is that it's harder to locate the source.