6 ms·
Poverty is linked to poorer brain development but reading can help counteract it
- d_sem 3y agoI would recommends the Youtube rabbit hole of Neil Postman lectures from the early 1990's that outlines this very observation. ( I don't expect you to subscribe to all his opinions, but he does attempt to analyze the impact of different media) I won't go as far as to say reading is the only medium for self-development but I will challenge you, dear reader, to take a photo of a page of a book, then a photo of any modern website and compare the design elements. Books are less distracting, and are not designed to steal your personal agency with the strength super computers. Books allow for greater introspective focus on complex ideas. In fact, some concepts worth learning require several hundred words to describe. Practicing the ability to singularly focus on long form thought is a great skill to have. It is a form of deep work/thinking.
- blueridge 3y ago+1 for anything by Neil Postman.
- akomtu 3y agoIt occured to me that a broken mirror is a good metaphor of what the modern web does to our attention. Instead of a whole smooth surface clearly reflecting the reality, our attention becomes shattered into many pieces, each reflecting something different. Books, due to a long continuous context, let us polish this mirror. For a similar reason, I guess, a typical exercise in the eastern tradition is to keep all your attention on one thing for a few minutes at least, and all the time, ideally. HN is, unfortunately, not very different: a stream of tiny disconnected comments shatter our attention if we read it too much.
- free_energy_min 3y ago“The dataset contained measures of young adolescents ages nine to 13 and how many years they had spent reading for pleasure during their early childhood. It also included data on their cognitive, mental health and brain health. About half of the group of adolescents starting reading early in childhood, whereas the other, approximately half, had never read in early childhood, or had begun reading late on. We discovered that reading for pleasure in early childhood was linked with better scores on comprehensive cognition assessments and better educational attainment in young adolescence.” Seems like classic correlation not causation
- WolfeReader 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observational_study https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observational_study
- jonny_eh 3y agoAt what age is "early childhood"? My son is turning 5 but isn't reading yet. Should getting him to read asap be my top priority?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pjmorris 3y agoAnecdata based on a sample of two: If you find things he's interested in and read to him, he'll eventually take off on his own. At least, that's how it worked for me. After my mom had read to me who knows how many times, I can still remember the thrill of realizing I was reading the book (about a rocket trip to the moon, late 60's) myself. The habit has sustained me in many ways since then, but it didn't feel forced at the start, which helped, IMO. My own son is having difficulty with reading, among other things. The thing that gets him going is recognizing he needs to be able to read to serve some of his other goals. So, again, interest.
- hooverd 3y agoReading for pleasure will make your child a nerd. It happened to me. Have your son read for business- get him on the hustle grindset early.
- slothtrop 3y agoI just read age appropriate books to my kids and figure they'll eventually read on their own. The strongest predictor of whether or not a child will go on to read for pleasure is just having books around. If they don't want to, well, whatever.
- jostylr 3y agoAt Sudbury schools, reading naturally occurs for students, but the age ranges from 4-12, with typical being 7-9. There seems to be little correlation to early reading and a love of reading, anecdotally from these schools. In fact, often the ones who learn to read later seem to love reading more than the ones who read earlier. The first books, of any kind, my daughter read were Harry Potter books. She went from not reading at age 8, to reading chats with her friends at age 9 (pandemic time), to having read the entire 7 book series by the end of age 10. No one taught her how to read. Writing, using devices, arithmetic, she largely acquired them all on her own as she matured. While I am biased, she seems well-adjusted and quite bright. I have no doubt that she is capable of mastering whatever she would like to master. Note that the article was looking at a cohort study. It was not based on randomly assigning "pleasure reading in early childhood" which means cause and effect cannot be ascertained. My guess is that if they were to measure lifelong Sudbury students they would find well-developed cortical areas regardless of early childhood reading or not. The development probably relates to constructing complex understanding of the world (or fictional worlds) which independent play as well as reading can do, but conventional teaching cannot.
- jmacklin308 3y agoGrowing up I never really got into reading for fun, mostly due because the school I went too didn't understand reading comprehension issues and "incentivized" reading. They set a limit of reading 5 books within some time frame in order to go to recess this one special day and/or attend this party they were having. I wanted to go, but really couldn't catch up. I felt left behind. The reward should be the reading, not some external source or something a child should be getting by default. I know this was a little part of my life, but It really stuck with me and still to this day don't enjoy reading fiction for fun due to the negative implications growing up. Occasionally I start to read some fiction but end up getting it on audible to listen too.
- barcode_feeder 3y agoI don't have children yet, but I expect to in the coming years. I wish to instill a love of reading in them, but I worry about how to go about doing so. I spent so much time reading as a child that I'd get grounded from it, forbidden from reading at the dinner table, that sort of thing. But that love came partially from a lack of alternatives; we only had local TV channels and no video games or other comparable distractions. I worry how, to a child, a book can be as effective a lure as a screen when I, as an adult, often find myself taken by the latter.
- SoftTalker 3y agoRead to your child, and provide books and opportunity once he starts learning to read. He'll either be drawn to it or not. I've had three kids and their interests and things that motivate them are all wildly different. So a lot of it just boils down to "if he likes reading, he'll read." Do the same with music, and sports/physical activity, and other things.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoJust to note: their child might not be a boy. Feels a bit disconcerting to see the male default used here.
- patrickdavey 3y agoI'm actually sorry to see this down voted. I have a daughter, and it is just crazy once you start reading books how much is needlessly male focussed. From the first farmyard books where the boy is driving the tractor and the girl is in the cart on the back. To fantastic Mr fox and his four small foxes (all male) etc etc. It's just extremely unbalanced. In our community, there's every reason not to use a male default everywhere. It would not have changed the original commenters meaning at all to have said "they" instead of "him" and would have been more inclusive. Surely that's a good default?
- theonething 3y ago
- uberdru 3y agoA point often left out of this discussion is that a love of reading is usually engendered by a single book. Not by reading 10 books over the summer, though, of course, that's something all kids should do. You can't really predict when it will happen, or what book will be the catalyst.
- stanrivers 3y agoThe other thing that is important about reading beyond brain development is the learning of lessons / history / culture. I can't remember who the quote is from, but something like "He who does not read lives but one life. He who reads can live thousands." There is also something about forming your own identity that is important too - like understanding history tells you something about who you are and who you can become. Stealing from David McCullough [1]: "History is philosophy taught with examples... First of all we have to get across the idea that we have to know who we were if we’re to know who we are and where we’re headed." "The Greeks said that character is destiny, and the more I read and understand of history, the more convinced I am that they were right... It is not in the still calm of life or the repose of a pacific station that great characters are formed." And so reading is much more than just developing skills around reading and focus, it is about learning and growing as an individual. [1] https://www.butwhatfor.com/p/takeaway-tuesday-knowing-history-knowing https://www.butwhatfor.com/p/takeaway-tuesday-knowing-histor...
- autoexec 3y ago> The other thing that is important about reading beyond brain development is the learning of lessons / history / culture. I can't remember who the quote is from, but something like "He who does not read lives but one life. He who reads can live thousands." You could say the same today about video games, movies, television, or even youtubers. Exposure to culture enriches the mind.
- tnel77 3y agoNot to imply playing video games is as intellectually stimulating as reading, but I feel like some games really challenge you in a positive manner. The ability to manage your inventory, interact with characters, make choices and deal with the consequences are all great for expanding your mind. Essentially, playing some RPGs (I feel) can make you a slightly better person whereas I have a hard time seeing the intellectual value in something like Fortnite.
- autoexec 3y ago
- Workaccount2 3y agoI'll be the one to bring up the taboo: It's totally possible that intelligent people have well paying careers and give birth to intelligence advantaged children. Mother nature loves bestowing fortune to the fortunate. There is the pervasive "blank slate" approach to cognition, when there is plenty of evidence that your brain is not in fact a blank slate at birth. I mean people just passively accept that some people are just born physically stronger, or with a more athletic build. Especially if their parents are athletes, or it runs in the family. But bring up intelligence along with genetic factors and everyone recoils and tenses up. It seems so plainly true, there is plenty of evidence to back it, yet its article after article, discussion after discussion of "Kids who read books end up being more successful" and never "Naturally smart kids enjoy reading books".
- ajuc 3y agoNobody believes 100% blank state. The debate is about the percentage. Also intelligence (as measured by IQ) is not linearly correlated with success. After a certain point the higher IQ you have the less likely you are to be successful.
- david-gpu 3y ago> After a certain point the higher IQ you have the less likely you are to be successful Being much smarter than the people around you must feel very isolating. The expectations placed on you since you are a child can't be easy to deal with either. Thankfully I'm too stupid to have any of those problems.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoKids who grow up in a household with a mother and father who read are more successful.
- dakial1 3y agoIt seems that the article/study does not disagree with your point: > Our results showed that reading for pleasure in early childhood can be beneficial regardless of socioeconomic status. It may also be helpful regardless of the children’s initial intelligence level.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zlg_codes 3y agoThere are too many variables at work here to deduce something as droll, and frankly, offensive as "poor people are stupid". Poor outcomes from disadvantaged families are due to more than educational opportunity. Children make fun of each other for superficial things, including how expensive their clothes are. The social element, and the feeling of being left out of activities because you cannot afford them, I would say contributes more to poor outcomes than just the lack of money. It's everything else that gets triggered or worsened from a lack of money that creates the outcome. And typically, nobody cares unless that person is female or they grow up to create trouble for others. Then they start having conversations about how we can "improve outcomes". As usual, any effort to care comes after problems become too large to handle. People who discuss this need to either live it or go get exposed to its realities before they can start making definitive statements on it. There are plenty of intelligent people who were simply handed the short end of the stick economically, and it's a failing of our societies that these people fall through cracks to begin with.