5 ms·
Where did the QWERTY keyboard come from?
- llm_nerd 3y agoTangentially related but there is a recent Radiolabs podcast about "The Wubi Effect" and it's a very interesting listen. The Chinese market also uses QWERTY (which surprised me), and they enter text using a variety of coding tactics. The government pushed method is called pinyin and is basically phonetic and was a way to try to standardize pronunciation. The Wubi method is basically building the shape components of the character set. Anyways, fascinating to learn. Somehow didn't realize that so much of the world also uses QWERTY.
- School-Cotton 3y agoPinyin is not just an input method, it’s also the standard way to write Mandarin in the Latin alphabet. Virtually all the spellings of names from mainland China that you’re familiar with (e.g., Xi Jinping) are written in Pinyin.
- hoppyhoppy2 3y agohttps://radiolab.org/podcast/wubi-effect https://radiolab.org/podcast/wubi-effect
- sho_hn 3y agoThe essential read: https://sino-platonic.org/complete/spp171_chinese_writing_reform.pdf https://sino-platonic.org/complete/spp171_chinese_writing_re...
- TheBlight 3y agoCame for the why but at least got the where as advertised.
- yboris 3y agoOne fun theory is that layout purposefully included letters for the word "Typewriter" in the top row (even when fingers are on the home row). This made it an easy selling point: "see how easy it is to type the name of the object?"
- eimrine 3y agoThe qwerty came from idiots.
- AprilArcus 3y agoYes! And the home row is mostly in disemvoweled alphabetical order: "d_fgh_jkl", another hint at the layout's origins.
- navels 3y agoWhat a useless article, especially given the title. Here's all they have to say about the layout: There’s some dispute over how and why Sholes and Glidden arrived at the QWERTY layout. Some historians have argued that it solved a jamming problem by spacing out the most common letters in English; others, particularly more recent historians, hold that it was designed specifically to help telegraphists avoid common errors when transcribing Morse code. Regardless, after around 30 test models, Sholes and Glidden settled on QWERTY—and changed the world.
- happytoexplain 3y agoI disagree. When I have a question, I am prepared for the answer to have some amount of ambiguity, especially when it comes to historical questions of the format "why is X", "how did X originate", etc. If I were trying to choose a descriptive name for an article, the question that it researches is a reasonable choice. Combined then, I am happy with the article's content given its title, and I am happy with the information it delivered to me without my having to do my own research. I don't feel that this is clickbait, nor do I feel qualified to assert that their conclusion is wrong.
- ghaff 3y agoYes, and like many I've heard the anti-jamming explanation (contra the slow typists down one), so I actually find it interesting that this is a somewhat unsettled question.
- mavhc 3y agoStarting with a piano keyboard where A-L were on the black notes and M-Z on the white below them in reverse order Then the vowels were moved to the top row These letters still fit that pattern eyuio adfghjkl mnvxz I and O were near 9 and 8 because they were also used as 1 and 0 to save keys, and people wanted to type 1870 etc easily. A was swapped back to the middle row for ease of use, everything else was pretty much to avoid patents of other layouts QWERTY stuck because typing classes were invented and they first used QWERTY
- phkahler 3y ago
- javier_e06 3y agoI learned to type on a Corona typewriter and it would jam when the key metal arms (or whatever the name was) came from the opposite side. The arm coming from the left side leaving too slow and bam! the arm from the right side comes smashing the other arm. My guess then was that the letters were put in some fashion that the group of letters coming from the right side seldom where adjacent from the group of letters coming from the left side. The closer the arms where to the center of the typewriter the less they would travel hence faster going in and out and beneficial for the letters to be adjacent, for the English language of course. ETAOIN SHRDLU The 10 most common letters in the English language. With exception of the A, all towards the center of keyboard.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoL is the opposite position to A, so also an edge letter. I too learnt to type in part on a mechanical typewriter keyboard -- there was a TV kids show about journalists and I wanted to mimic them I think. IME (a long time ago) you wanted to have consecutive keys on opposite hands because it took the whole hand moving to provide a good force to move the key and impact the ribbon hard enough to make a good print of the letter. But then, as you said, you would occassionally get the type arms locking up. I definitely couldn't use my pinky to type on that keyboard. TH, ER, ON, AN are the most common letter pairs [in British English]; TH is good on a QWERTY but the other pairs are not particularly well placed I think.
- fanf2 3y agoThe Linotype keyboard has ETAOIN SHRDLU as the leftmost two columns of each block of letters (separate keys for lower and upper case!) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Linotype_keyboard_with_Star_Quadder_attachment.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Linotype_keyboard_wi...
- robertlagrant 3y agoI wouldn't count L, O or S as particularly central either.
- lsmeducation 3y agoIt’s interesting how we play the most advanced video games on a peripheral from 1870. Zero innovation on that front, and worse, we’re going even further backward with the mechanical keyboard obsession.
- Phrodo_00 3y agoThe reason we had to go backwards to mechanical keyboards is that modern keyboards were being built just for lower prices with no regard to feel or longevity. Sometimes things don't need innovation. If you don't want to play with a keyboard there's always controllers (that also seem to have found a pretty stable form the last years)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 3y agoI have a mechanical keyboard on my main desktop system. But I have to admit that, given the amount of typing I do on short-throw (non-butterfly) MacBook keyboards, I'm not sure I really have a clear preference at this point. (And there's something to be said more generally for the keyboards you use day to day not being radically different from most other keyboards you'll encounter.)
- qball 3y ago>we’re going even further backward with the mechanical keyboard obsession Well, not quite; single-stage/two-stage trigger technology, as well as progressive triggers, have some benefits when applied to keyboards. First, single-stage/two-stage triggers give you (with single-stage) a single smooth press with activation point somewhere in the middle, or (with two-stage) a consistent amount of takeup then a wall that you have to break through to activate the mechanism. So you can have the key pressed and resting on the activation point, and then press it the rest of the way when you want the input to register (for instance, if you're in a game and are waiting for someone to peek around the corner). Second, progressive triggers, where pressing a little way registers a single input and pressing it all the way down/back types something fully-automatically. They're still mostly useless because the manufacturers refuse to put properly heavy springs in the switches, but the technology itself is ready for this. It's certainly strange that it took 70 years from the implementations of these ideas in firearms to today's keyboards given the advantages of each mechanism are equally applicable to both, but that's the way it happened.
- loicd 3y agoThe QWERTY layout has a funny difference with for instance the french AZERTY layout. On an AZERTY keyboard, the parentheses () are directly accessible whereas the square brackets [] are not. On a QWERTY keyboard, this is the opposite : you need SHIFT for the parentheses () but not for the square brackets []. I've always wondered why the QWERTY layout favored the square brackets over the parentheses. Naively, parentheses are more common and should be more easily accessible...
- yunruse 3y agoI’ve always set up a custom keyboard for exactly that! () on their own keys, [] on shift and {} above 0 and 9. It always struck me as the most natural alignment for prose and programming. Thankfully between Ukelele [0] and MSKLC [1] it’s pleasantly simple to do [0] for macOS: https://software.sil.org/ukelele/ https://software.sil.org/ukelele/ [1] for Windows: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=102134 https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=102...
- rantallion 3y agoAnd if anyone wants to go really custom, it's worth checking out the QMK firmware supported by many mechanical keyboards. Aside from the level of customisation made possible by QMK, another benefit is that everything lives on the keyboard - no need to install keyboard profiles on each machine you might connect the keyboard to.
- jaclaz 3y agoNot really-really. You are comparing your English QWERTY, with the French AZERTY, but there are many more languages QWERTY. On the Italian keyboard (which is also QWERTY) the round brackets need Shift, but the square ones need AltGR.
- speedbird 3y agoAs it happens I’ve always found the American Querty keyboard much better for C programming than the English one due to bracket / punctuation layout.
- edpichler 3y agoI quitted QWERTY 10 years ago. Since then, the chronic pain I had in my hands disappeared. I also created a layout to use my old Dvorak keyboard on Windows: https://github.com/edpichler/Apple-Dvorak-on-Windows https://github.com/edpichler/Apple-Dvorak-on-Windows It works with my mechanical keychron and, I believe, with any other similar Dvorak keyboard.
- CollinEMac 3y agoI've never understood the Morse code explanation. How does QWERTY help avoid Morse code errors?
- gabetax 3y agoThe best research I've seen on this is the paper "On the Prehistory of QWERTY" [1] which has a great figure on the fourth page with the presumable original prototype showing all the consonants wrapping around alphabetically and the vowels on the top row. [1] https://repository.kulib.kyoto-u.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2433/139379/1/42_161.pdf https://repository.kulib.kyoto-u.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2433...