7 ms·
Apple to Launch 'Low-Cost' MacBook Series Next Year to Rival Chromebooks
- jonfw 3y agoI'm curious if this will run on a full-fledged version of MacOS or if we'll finally start to see the ipad-ification of a laptop from apple
- WillPostForFood 3y agoThey really should just enable mac apps on the iPad, and let that be the low-cost MacBook.
- robnado 3y agoThere is something to be said about the laptop form factor and macOS enabling productivity. That said, I would definitely see the guts of an iPad being put in the frame of a laptop with macOS.
- bpye 3y agoThe Air and 2 port Pro are very close to being the guts of an iPad Pro in a laptop chassis with macOS anyway.
- hx8 3y agoMacOS generally needs more ram than iPadOS because iPadOS can be more aggressive about pausing and closing applications to free up more ram than MacOS can be. I think some modern iPads are still at 4GB when that's too low for modern MacOS.
- kube-system 3y agoDifferent input devices really do need different UI controls, if you want a comfortable and polished experience. You can just do it anyway and expect the user to 'deal with it', but you end up with experiences that people just don't really like: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Tablet_PC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Tablet_PC
- WillPostForFood 3y agoan iPad with the Apple keyboard brings input parity, so really nothing holding back running Mac apps.
- kube-system 3y agoAn ipad with a keyboard would still have an issue with the control design disparity between touch input vs pointer input.
- Wingman4l7 3y agoWe already have... they've destroyed reparability by soldering in the SSD and the RAM, and they turn into soft-bricked e-waste every time someone donates one and doesn't remove their Apple cloud account first.
- gumby 3y agoThey reduced the need to repair due to disk or RAM failure by getting rid of the connectors. I am not claiming they did this out of the sweetness of their hearts, but I do challenge your first point. I believe apple could fix the “didn’t log out of iCloud” problem if they want, even if only through through some special apple-only refurb process. They would have to have some way to figure out n if it were stolen or legitimately discarded. But they have no incentive to do this.
- helf 3y ago[dead]
- Wingman4l7 3y agoI've never seen a disk connector failure, but I've constantly seen disk failures. Soldering your disk to your mainboard also makes the cost (and odds of failure) of data recovery much higher.
- wnorris 3y agoI assume this will be lower cost through plastic casing, M1, and low RAM/storage. Currently the M1 is sufficient for 90%+ of the population (IMO), it is the RAM/storage that will outdate most Apple computers. If Apple sells this in the $599-799 range with 8GBs of RAM that would be a solid offering for most K-12 schools.
- nvm0n2 3y agoObvious strategy for price segmentation: it runs full macOS but can only install/run apps from the app store, and has no Terminal.app. At a stroke that partitions the market so developers and admin UNIX lover types can't buy them. Pro media users can't either because not enough RAM. But it runs Safari and iLife.
- superkuh 3y agoBuying a low end Apple product is a terrible idea. They cannot be upgraded. So you'll just be stuck with 8GB of RAM and 256GB internal storage... meaning lots of problems with getting all the dozen dongles and external devices you have to attach to it staying working. And don't even think about trying to open Photoshop and a browser. The only decent apple computers start at about $2k and up.
- wredue 3y agoAs opposed to the 4 gig of ram and 128g of storage on the Chromebooks which cannot be upgraded that this is meant to compete with?
- superkuh 3y agoYes. Those are terrible computers too but at least they advertise they aren't full computers.
- wredue 3y agoAll you know at this point is that these are low cost computers, and there appears to be a target of grade school use. Chromebooks are not meant for photoshop. I don’t know what you mean by “not full computers”.
- maleldil 3y ago> I don’t know what you mean by “not full computers” Chromebooks are sold as laptops that run (only) Chrome. It's in the name. Most people don't expect to able to run full-blown desktop applications on them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hotstickyballs 3y agoMost apps are web apps these days. No need for good hardware. Just dedicated js and video player functionality is good enough
- ksec 3y agoAs stated since 2017, as soon as Apple move to their own Silicon now known as Apple Silicon, there is no reason why they cant have a MacBook SE for $699 all while keeping the same margin. ( Edit: Although in typical Apple fashion, low cost probably mean $799, which still would allow them to claim this is a historical new low cost MacBook, as the previous was $899 MacBook Air 11". Probably worth pointing out in case anyone dont know, Apple already sell an M1 MacBook Air with 128GB storage at $799, but it is only to education only. ) I am just surprised it took them this long. Although the sales of Mac were so good I guess they had zero reason to play this card until now.
- packetlost 3y agoI thought I heard sales of Macs were way below expected over the last year?
- NhanH 3y agoAlmost everything is way below expectation over the last year due to 2022 with whiplash effect and abnormal growth + this year recession.
- jasonjmcghee 3y agoMaybe they pulled an instapot and made a great product that lasts (with only incremental improvements in the next gen). I got an M1 Air when it came out and an M2 Pro for work, and other than the 16 vs 32 GB, it’s very similar in terms of performance. I assume it’d be more apparent if i did 3d modeling or video production, but it works very well as a dev machine.
- gumby 3y ago> Maybe they pulled an instapot and made a great product that lasts This is a longstanding position by apple since ~ the iMac.* The long lifetime (hw quality + software support) means higher resale value and pays off for companies like Apple and Toyota. Why didn’t it help instapot? Resale value means the investment for a buyer of a new device is (conceptually) lower and signals quality, so you can charge more. And the resold devices serve a customer who can’t pay full retail, keeping the, from giving their money to a competitor. Now this works bc the new buyer values the new features (else they’d just hang on to the equipment for longer, as I do). Instapot’s problem was they lacked a “killer feature upgrade”: the 2023 model is basically the 2017 model. * dunno before but I somehow can’t believe a company that shipped the Performa line had the same attitude. Edit: I had a brain fart and said BMW had a high resale value, while actually they are notorious the other way (since I’ve owned one myself, I shouldn’t have made this mistake). Thanks to Our_Benefactors for pointing this out.
- CobaltFire 3y agoI really hope they bring back the fun styles, more like the old G3’s! I know my kids would love that.
- throwaway154 3y agoAn international perspective, related to cited educational use - iPads are huge in Asia for private schools. Chromebooks barely register. An additional $500 over 3 years won't register much in terms of total private education costs; I can see a role where the demand for total Apple products (applebook+iPhone+iPad+iStuff) is complimented, not substituted.
- kayodelycaon 3y agoA lot of Apple-related rumors turn out to just be wishful thinking or internal prototypes that never got released. I have no doubt Apple has or is working on something like this but it would really surprise me if they target the low end for their devices.
- xhkkffbf 3y agoIt's not so much the chromebooks that won over education. It's the Google Docs workspace which is relatively simple for schools to use.
- phpisthebest 3y agoLowCost MacBook + Office 365 for Education...
- tapoxi 3y agoI've actually come to love Chromebooks. We keep one in the kitchen as a general recipe machine/need to pay a bill or whatever. It's cheap, it upgrades itself, the battery is really good, and there's no need for my wife or I to run anything on it outside of a browser. I don't know why I'd pay a premium for a Mac with that use case. Garageband? I'm certainly not going to be playing games on it.
- kube-system 3y agoWould these even be targeted at your use case? Aren't the majority of Chromebook sales institutional in nature?
- tapoxi 3y agoMy brother is a public high school teacher, so I'm somewhat familiar. They're to schools, where the objective is to have something that's cheap, easy to administer, and locked down. They also tie into Google Classroom/GSuite and have limited local storage. Many Chromebooks aren't given to a specific student, but rolled out in carts and handed out during a "computer lab" time. While a Mac would work, a cart full of Macs is radically more expensive than a cart full of Chromebooks. A family friend is a music teacher that uses Logic, so maybe that's a use case, or iOS development.
- gwbas1c 3y agoWell, I think it all depends on why someone is buying a Chromebook. Is it because they want a cheap clamshell with a keyboard? (Tablets adjust poorly to this use case.) Is it because they want a cheap general-purpose computer? I've seen enough non-institutional users of Chromebooks to see that there is a market for them. (I had one of the original demo units and really liked it.) I can see why Apple would want to get a piece of that market.
- Vermyndax 3y agoDid you know that it has a three-year lifespan mandated by Google, and after that it will not receive upgrades?
- Vermyndax 3y agoThe only thing people are missing here is that it's not just about the hardware, it's about Chrome in particular. Our school system "requires" the use of the Chrome browser because of the third-party plugins that only support Chrome. The school board thinks the best way to do that is... of course... to buy Chromebooks. They're awful. Terribly slow, constantly breaking, and a total disaster. I'd love to see MacBooks come into use here, but sadly it's not just about the hardware. The school board has to stop being lured by shitty software vendors. Yes, I'd love to vote them out.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> The school board thinks the best way to do that is... of course... to buy Chromebooks. I wouldn't be surprised if the school were sold on these plugins on the basis that you can use them using only a Chromebook.
- daft_pink 3y agowill they have 2gb of ram and cost $200 to upgrade the memory to 8gb?
- mwint 3y agoNo, but if they did people would still buy them because the 2GB version would outperform an 8GB Chromebook in daily tasks. Apple isn’t going to ship something that doesn’t beat the pants off a Chromebook.
- daft_pink 3y agoSure, but it's going to start out at double the price. Then the upgrades that most users need will raise the price to the point where you might as well buy that Macbook Air anyways similar to the base iPad lineup and the iPad Pro.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoI'm not sure I believe this rumor.
- jeffbee 3y agoMaking the laptop cheaper will not solve any of the usability and manageability issues with macOS. If I was going to rank my wishlist, at the top would be the protracted outage that accompanies every OS update. ChromeOS updates itself in seconds and you barely notice. macOS grinds for several minutes before the reboot and 10-20 minutes during the reboot. It sucks!
- ankurdhama 3y agoChromeOS uses A/B partition scheme, so it essentially downloads the updates in background and apply them to the non-active partition and then notifies the user to restart which is essentially just switching to the other partition.
- thisisauserid 3y agoI've never been a fan of Apple, but the Macbook trackpad keeps me from switching. Whose is second best?
- aa_is_op 3y agoGreat.... more e-waste
- gumby 3y agoJobs scorned the “Chromebook” segment (I can’t even recall what the jargon was... “netbook”?) when the analysts were crying that apple would die without it. There’s a different team on board now but I’d bet the logic is unchanged. But they aren’t ignoring this segment, rather they’ve differentiated the iPad instead. For you (I assume) and me this is absurd, but then again the Chromebook is pretty useless for most HN readers too.
- etempleton 3y agoI recently purchased a new M1 Macbook Air 2020 model) on Amazon for $750 and it is great. I had previously owned this same model but with 16GB of ram instead of 8GB so I was a bit nervous, but it has been a non-issue. I suspect Apple is using Amazon to test selling the Macbook Air at a significantly lower price than you can get on their website. The only thing I think they could do to make it cheaper would be to make it out of plastic instead of aluminum.
- bdcravens 3y agoBorderline clickbait, as the title is written to be more definitive than the actual article, especially from a site called MacRUMORS. "... claims a new report out of Taiwan." "This is the first rumor we have heard that Apple is actively developing a new MacBook series that the company will price below its more premium MacBook offerings, so expectations should remain guarded until we receive corroboration from other sources."
- runjake 3y ago1. Keep in mind this rumor is weak. It's from someone without a track record. 2. I don't believe this a market for Apple. To compete in the Chromebook market, largely education, it's about all about volume and cost (How many Chromebooks can I get per $1,000 I spend?). And the current per-unit cost is about $250. 3. Education institutions could get M1 MacBook Airs for $699, but they don't for two main reasons: 1. they're over twice as much as a $250 Chromebook, and 2. they're far less durable than a $250 Chromebook. And replacement rates are very high in the education markets. 4. One possible way Apple might be able to compete is to make durable, cheap ($499 or less) MacBooks and then commit to ~7 year OS updates. A little more upfront cost, but customers would probably save on long-term hardware and staffing costs. Right now, we're throwing away perfectly usable Chromebooks because they are on something like a 4 year OS lifecycle.
- ulfw 3y agoMaybe a way to bring the beloved 12" Macbook back, but this time with an M3 instead of underpowered intel M series chip
- gwbas1c 3y agoI wonder if Apple is going to make an iPad with a clamshell keyboard? I see so many people use them like laptops now.
- ylee 3y agoWhen I covered IT hardware companies on Wall Street, I heard Apple's CFO say that his company could release a $799 computer "but we don't want to". Around the same time, at an investor dinner with the Dell CFO, an attendee asked how sales were of a $299 computer on Dell's print catalog cover. The CFO replied, "the problem with advertising a $299 computer is that people want to buy it".