12 ms·
Tech workers now doubting decision to move from California to Texas
- mdonahoe 3y agoMy friend just moved back to SF from Austin. He said Austin seemed alive when it was one of the only places open during COVID, but now it’s just another place with worse weather.
- whatsup7123 3y agoHomesickness is also possible here. For those that have lived in California for over 10 years, you can get very attached to this state even given its high costs and other problems. There is a lot of diversity, good restaurants, good weather, beaches, and a sense of belonging in Silicon Valley. Giving up those things is not easy even if it comes with other benefits.
- beanjuiceII 3y agoNice try low effort article...
- kurthr 3y agoIs this sarcasm from the king (prince... duke) of low effort comments?
- gojomo 3y agoOne quote, and one bit of 5-month USPS change-of-address data not specific to techies or those who'd recently moved-to-Austin? Not much to hang a trend story on. This kind of story is just pandering to some readers' desired headlines.
- viknesh 3y agoThis could basically have been written by ChatGPT with the prompt "write a story about USPS change of address data showing movement out of X as it relates to the tech industry"
- deaddodo 3y agoCalifornia partly took the tech industry from the old tech centers (Texas, Massachusetts, etc) due to regressive (or progressive, on California's part, if you choose to see it that way) policies regarding Non-Competes and other executive/corporate limits. It's become so entrenched in the economy now, with so many protective policies and huge VC centrality, that it's unlikely WFH and housing prices are going to dismantle that monopoly in a couple years. That's not to say it's a permanent monopoly, but if those other states want to actually take any of that influence, they need to morph their policies to at least match the kind of privileges California offers. There are other places that have actually been working to do this for a decade or two that have grown permanent economies in the tech realm (Boston rebuilding their tech economy, Colorado, Utah, Oregon). Texas is simply not one of them, despite Austin doing its best.
- hackernewds 3y agoCan replace all this with "beautiful weather, people, nature and H1B friendliness"
- shitlord 3y agoCalifornia has another advantage that is harder to beat: geographically, it is a nice place to live. Most of the state has a very high USDA natural amenity rating: https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/natural-amenities-scale/ https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/natural-amenities-sca...
- jeffbee 3y agoWhy, just because it's 110F every day and the electricity costs $50/kWh on weekdays from 6pm-8pm? SF paper had a longer treatment of the report 2 days ago https://www.sfgate.com/local/article/california-transplants-unhappy-exodus-austin-18343754.php https://www.sfgate.com/local/article/california-transplants-... and it links to the original, paywalled report.
- vel0city 3y agoNo consumer pays $50/kWh in Texas.
- jeffbee 3y agoYet. You can't expect the electricity resellers to absorb wholesale market shocks forever without passing it on to consumers. The ERCOT spot market has hit the ceiling of $5000/MWh every single day all summer long.
- gruez 3y agoIs that the spot price or price for all electricity consumed in the state? Depending on how the market is structured it's very possible that there's different prices paid depending on the type of contract. For instance the utility might be paying one generator a fixed price for base load, and gets the remainder on the spot market. On hot days the spot market might be $5000, but that's not the price the utility pays for all electricity at that moment, because it also has electricity supplied from lower priced contracts.
- vel0city 3y agoIt balances out for all those hours in the year where prices go negative and all those hours where it's not $50/kWh. Plus, youre talking spot markets, not day ahead. Most electricity is sold in the day ahead markets, which isn't anywhere near those prices. But hey, continue suggesting people are actually paying $50/kWh without sharing any additional context. Being truly genuine, I see. I did the math based on my usage last month. I pay $0.06/kWh for electricity cost (not including delivery, just energy). Most of my usage is after those peak hours, as my car charges and pool pumps run and we do our laundry and dishwasher and what not over the evening or early morning. Even at that rate my REP probably made money off me, as they would have still been ahead assuming they were properly buying in the day ahead markets. And in the fall when rates often go negative they'll make a lot of my usage getting paid both ways on the transaction. What do you pay for electricity? Oh yeah, and my plan is 100% renewable purchase. What mix is yours?
- classichasclass 3y agoLooked at a (non-tech-sector) job in Houston, we weren't especially bothered by the heat, and the people I would have worked with would have been great, but we just couldn't see ourselves there culturally. My wife also found hurricane season personally alarming.
- louislang 3y agoThe fact that I'm in Houston and have grown accustomed to the threat of yearly hurricanes is personally alarming.
- selimthegrim 3y agoHi from NOLA.
- muzaffarpur 3y agoThere is no information in the linked article. I would like to opinion of regular techies not some investor, not some vp or CEO or CTO or Mr Musk. Likes of Mr. Musk, lives in stratosphere. Regular techies at best live in rental apartment, paying 30-40% of his monthly income as rent, with no viable path to home ownership.
- xanth 3y agoThis article isn't a shining beacon of journalism but as a "tech worker" not having lived in either city but considering it I'd be interested in "transplants" anecdotes.
- jeffbee 3y agoThe real OP has tons of anecdotes. https://www.businessinsider.com/tech-workers-moved-to-austin-regrets-2023-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/tech-workers-moved-to-austin...
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoThere's many explanations for this: - SF tech companies recalling some workers for partial in-person work - laid off tech workers going out of TX in-person interviews - affordability pushing workers outside of TX to other states, which does not include CA Article doesn't bother to explore any.
- Racing0461 3y ago[flagged]
- dreamcompiler 3y agoTexas makes a big deal about not having income tax. What they don't tell you is how high the property taxes are. I live in a state with income tax, and if I lived in this same house in Austin (as if I could afford such a house in Austin) my total, overall tax bill in Texas would probably be $20k per year higher than I pay now.
- YeBanKo 3y agoProperty tax is much fairer than income tax imo.
- jeffbee 3y agoIf you think flat is fair, then yes. If you are coming from California it's quite shocking. People like Elon Musk and his enablers in the media talk about the marginal tax rates in California, but the median Californian owes no or trivial state income taxes. If you transplant that median household to Texas their tax burden is higher, and they are more exposed to housing market shocks than they would be in California where the state constitution limits tax assessment increases to 2% per year.
- saurik 3y agoA property tax isn't a flat tax, as the people who own the highest value assets--and are thereby able to use them to extract the highest rents from other people--are paying higher taxes for that continuing privilege. The reality is that homeowners can feel poor but they are ridiculously richer and more powerful than people at the same income level who are merely renting. If you want to limit property tax, but you don't have really really strict rent control laws (which California does not: some areas--including, notably, San Francisco--do have some minimal mechanisms, but they pale in comparison to the power of prop 13 for property owners) you end up with an extremely unfair tax system... ...which, though, does favor people with more money, and so this actually furthers the narrative of how the people who moved away from California because they wanted to not have so much tax on their income are now realizing they have a lot of assets and want to capitalize on that in California.
- afavour 3y agoThis just in: some very well compensated workers discover that affordability isn’t the biggest motivator in their lives. Maybe I’m too much of a cynic but when everyone was hyping up moving to Texas (or Miami before that) the only pitched seemed to be affordability. But more or less everywhere is more affordable, the question is why move to [destination state/city] specifically. And I never saw a hugely compelling reason. Off topic perhaps but personally I’m much more interested to know the future for things like the arts in the face of inaffordability. Like, if aspiring actors can’t afford to stay in LA long term waiting tables and going on auditions what might that mean for the film industry? Could we see other cities get some of that cultural cache?
- ternaryoperator 3y agoYou're not too much of a cynic. While the COL is high in the Bay Area, people still live here and come here because you get something for that money. The pleasant climate is certainly one factor, but there are certainly others.
- wolverine876 3y agoSomeone (who generally is more perceptive) said to me: I can buy a house in Austin that is X time bigger than in the Bay Area. Of course; but then why not move to South Dakota. The higher housing prices in CA reflect much greater demand - people want to live in CA, despite all the reactionary political media campaigns - and it's for good reason. When Austin prices match SF, then things have changed. I was surprised that so many people just followed a hot trend on such a long-term, high-impact decision.
- deltaomega 3y agoThis exactly. I tell people if they’re moving due to a desire for cheaper housing, there are many options (Ohio, Wisconsin, Nevada, Georgia, etc.) that make much more sense than Texas.
- bigyikes 3y agoThis is just wrong. You’re commenting on demand while ignoring supply. The Bay doesn’t have any more land (and nimbys tend to prevent new, denser development). This drives prices up. Texas has an absurd amount of empty land. This helps keep prices down. Making a comparison between the two and attributing the difference to desirability doesn’t make sense. (I don’t disagree that the Bay is desirable for many reasons or even that it does have higher demand.)
- chkaloon 3y agoMadison, WI. It's cheaper, good culture, nice folks. Come on up! Snow is much better than 110F for weeks on end.
- howenterprisey 3y agoAre there a lot of tech jobs besides Epic? (Seriously, when I was at the airport flying in for my on-site, I heard some of the workers behind the check-in desks talking about going to work there...)
- chkaloon 3y agoYes, consulting firms on Epic's coattails. Also biotech
- floren 3y agoWisconsin summers may not be 110F but they feel like it thanks to the humidity. Visits to Grandma were spent reading old comic books in the basement between trips to the lake -- besides the heat, there were also the skeeters, horseflies, deerflies, and ticks to deal with. I'd still probably pick Madison over Austin, though.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoSpun off a thread with the original source for the headlined claim here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37387870 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37387870
- deltaomega 3y agoI’m one of those that moved my family from CA to Austin during the pandemic. We wanted cheaper housing and more space, and told ourselves Texas is the future. We pretty quickly learned that Texas does not feel like the future. The traffic was surprisingly worse than where we moved from (Orange Co), we had an incident with some nut that harassed us at the grocery over wearing a mask, and the weather was absolutely unbearable. We don’t drink or watch sports so it felt like there was nothing to do besides sit inside our air conditioned home in a quiet neighborhood and occasionally get really good barbecue. We made it almost 3 years, but but the bullet and moved back. California has its shortcomings too, but we have a newfound appreciation for it and will probably never leave.
- igetspam 3y agoWe stayed 8. Moved just outside Austin in 2016. By 2018, the neighborhood doubled and traffic tripled. The pandemic absolutely destroyed the neighborly facade. Then the last few summers hit peak heat and that was it. Our 2.5 acres with a $12k playground castle was all but unusable most of the year. And the people were becoming more and more cruel. We left for New England. The weather is much better and so are the people. I won't go back to CA. I spent most of my life there but it's not the right home for my family. We're much happier here.
- wendyshu 3y agoCruel in what way?
- cvhashim04 3y agoTrading OC for Austin seems funny to me. I’m strongly considering moving there from my cold state if things fall into place. OC is one of the nicer areas of SoCal that’s also relatively affordable.
- deltaomega 3y agoI’ve never heard of someone refer to OC as “affordable”. It’s one of the least affordable counties in the US [0]. Travis county (Austin) homes are less than half the price [1]. [0] https://www.attomdata.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Top-10-Unaffordable-Counties-Q3-2022.png https://www.attomdata.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Top-10-... [1] https://www.redfin.com/county/2866/TX/Travis-County/housing-market https://www.redfin.com/county/2866/TX/Travis-County/housing-...
- blindriver 3y agoWe almost moved to Austin during the pandemic. Luckily my wife's potential job offer fell through so we stayed in the Bay Area. We've heard of friends of friends who sold their Bay Area house during the pandemic, moved to Austin, but now can't move back because they can't afford to sell their house and take a loss, and then come back and get a 7% mortgage on double the house price. I think we would have been okay in Austin, but the things I've heard from close friends from Texas are: 1) Austin is not like SF Bay Area at all. People around here seemed convinced by the myths that Austin was like a liberal oasis in a Republican desert but it's not like that at all. It's more liberal than rural Texas but it's still Texas. 2) There's only desert and rolling hills for 3+ hours around. No water, no mountains, etc unless you make a long road trip. It's not like the SF Bay Area where you have water, desert, mountains, etc all very close by.
- piotrkaminski 3y ago> It's not like the SF Bay Area where you have water, desert, mountains, etc all very close by. Wait, desert?!
- floren 3y agoI would say that e.g. Panoche Hills could be considered a desert environment and it's just a bit down I-5.
- gojomo 3y agoSF's not too far from some famous deserts - within 8h drive you can get to Death Valley, Mojave, or the home of Burning Man, Black Rock Desert. (From Austin, Big Bend's part of the Chihuahuan Desert is about 8h away, plus of course many other dry & dusty west Texas locales.)
- kibibu 3y agoI would definitely classify an 8hr drive as "far"
- 3y ago
- dylan604 3y agoI was born in TX, moved to LA for a few years, and then moved back to TX for family reasons. I can't wait to not live in TX again. As the article suggests, the government will never represent me in this state, and the things they are doing are reprehensible to me. However, I have a few obligations preventing me from just picking up for something more fitting. The first is lack of firm decision on where to land. Every place will have pros/cons. I hate hate hate moving, so the pros must significantly outweigh the cons to make moving across country (let's face it that moving out of texas is equal to across the country in sheer miles).
- soderfoo 3y agoTook a big leap and landed in Europe from TX. Pay is lower, but is offset by being able to walk to work, reduced stress, and a sane work life balance. I still make enough and feel like I've been able to save more due to not owning a car. Overall, my quality of life increased greatly and I hope you find your place to (not to sound cliché) live your best life. Our time is so limited and living in limbo is no fun.
- cvhashim04 3y agoParis?
- wolverine876 3y agoThe CBRE study linked from the OP gives an idea of the scale of Bay Area tech relative to other places: Labor force in tech: Total Change 2017-22 SF Bay Area 407,810 23% New York Metro 371,030 11% Toronto 285,700 29% Washington, D.C. 265,240 7% L.A./Orange County 249,620 17% Dallas/Ft. Worth 205,920 28% ... Austin 96,610 39% Elsewhere it says 75,020 tech professionals moved into the Bay Area in that time (net, if I understand correctly). Avg Wage SF Bay Area $185,425 Seattle $172,009 Boston $121,794 Baltimore $113,544 Washington, D.C. $105,808 Austin $105,495 https://www.cbre.com/insights/books/scoring-tech-talent-2023/which-are-the-top-ranked-tech-talent-markets https://www.cbre.com/insights/books/scoring-tech-talent-2023...
- tibbydudeza 3y agoWhy live in the middle of a desert when you can be close to the coast ???. All the money in the world would not get my to change that.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoDisclaimer: I live next to downtown by I-35. Did move during the pandemic from NorCal to TX. (Have family in TX.) Many issues: The charm is gone with too many highrises like San Jose downtown. It's hot AF. 110 F for 3 months every day. 100 F every day for another 2 months on either side of that. In winter, it can randomly freeze down to 11 F, and say "hello" to no power and no water for 2-3 weeks. The housing is slapped together and lacks architectural design. The new apartments are tiny and expensive, and not very good. There's just as many homeless as SF, including rampant retail theft. The costs are just as bad as the Bay Area. The roads are worse than those in Bay Area, and I didn't think that was possible without snow and ice. Lots of tourists, which could be a negative for some people. The schools are so-so. It's Texas and abortion is illegal. Fewer batshit insane people than LA but more than Denver. And anyone can CCW or open carry without any documentation. If you have no criminal record, you can buy a handgun over at Academy without any waiting period at all. Property taxes are absurd. If you think Palo Alto is bad... APD is critically underfunded, understaffed by 200-250 officers, morale is terrible, and non-life-threatening calls have a 48 hour backlog. If you have an AirTag on an item, it's stolen, and the location is known, the police won't lift a finger. There is zero routine traffic enforcement. Crowded with 2nd- and 3rd-tier school tech bros, corporate clones, and dumb money lazy people... people who are simultaneously uncool and boring. Don't go to Whole Foods because it screams conspicuous consumption. The HQ is unimpressive. There isn't much of a tech scene compared to the Bay Area. On positive notes: Even though TX-35 is a national gerrymandering joke reaching from downtown Austin to downtown San Antonio by an "umbilical cord" along I-35, Greg Casar is one of the most reasonable, ballsy, sharp, empathetic, and progressive reps in Congress. H-E-B. There are a few used bookstores still in operation. Plenty of vinyl shops, although none compares to Discogs. Absurd number of tall people compared to anywhere else in the US and the world, including Oslo.
- kthejoker2 3y agoRather than read this low-effort bait piece, I recommend "Town mouse and country mouse" by Aesop. This phenomenon was well understood 2500 years ago.
- nunez 3y ago(x/post) The comedy writes itself. All of the complaints listed here (hot weather, shit-tier public transit, etc) were true of Austin prior to the Great Migration. Everyone wanted in though because Austin is the first place people think of when they think of Texas, it's the only major city in Texas with rolling hills, it's perceived as the only non-conservative city in Texas (it is not), 6th St and Barton Springs are fun, and Texas has no income tax and cheap real estate. Now that real estate prices in Austin are significantly higher than they were in the past, a self-induced problem BTW!, and the Real Texas Heat™ has finally come, folks want to move back. (Property tax rates in Texas have always been high, and they only go up every year.) Austin was always a small town with Texas government and a huge school with a huge American football team (UT Austin). I don't think it was designed with the explosive growth that it has seen in the last 15 years. Its road design is proof of this. US Interstate 35 cuts right through town and it only has one partial ring road (TX-130). It also has the MoPAC (TX-1), though that expanded and, consequently, became a partial toll road. Compare this with Houston, where I live. It has three huge interstates going through it (US I-10 east-west; US-45 north-south; Texas I-69/US Hwy 59 SW-NE), one huge and constantly problematic interstate beltway (US I-610) and two state ring roads (TX-8; TX-99). It is designed to accommodate and move a significant population (or significant freight, which it does also). Austin has always been overrated IMO. Houston is way bigger, more liberal and diverse (in every dimension, not just race, but it is extremely racially-integrated) than Austin has ever been and has a world-class food scene but gets 1/10th of the hype because...actually, I have no idea why? Dallas is also way bigger than Austin and actually has a tech scene of sorts (though it is old and enterprise-y) along with more moderate (but still hot) weather but didn't boom like Austin did. Why?