40 ms·
As long as new supply is not being built, whether due to restrictive zoning, NIMBYism, or other such reasons, the bubble will not burst. Too many people simply
by satvikpendem 3y ago
As long as new supply is not being built, whether due to restrictive zoning, NIMBYism, or other such reasons, the bubble will not burst. Too many people simply want too few homes. The answer is to build high density housing in the places people want to live in, usually major cities.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoWhich will not happen because of the NIMBYism you describe. Local and state governments tend to have a high representation of property owners relative to the folks who really need this change to happen. It's "F you got mine" applied to housing policy.
- 0xParlay 3y agoAlso tragic is people without homes fighting a proxy war with “developers” because of their podcast centric understanding of economics. It’s more important that developers don’t make a profit than increasing the supply of homes and nothing will change their minds. If new housing supply has the word “luxury” in the name then lord help you. Gentrifying a community with new houses is like the worst thing a person could do.
- iamdamian 3y agoI'm very interested in the topic but skeptical of sweeping claims like this. What is the most definitive evidence (actual data plus analysis by economists) that you can point me to that proves this is true?
- jonhohle 3y agoIt’s not true (at least not for the past 20 years nationwide). New housing has grown faster than population growth. In 2000 there were 113 units per capita vs 145 per capita today.[0] The average number of people per household hasn’t changed significantly since then, so there is technically 30% more housing available in the US than 20 years ago. Not all of that housing is where people want it, investors are collecting properties like Pokémon, the vast majority of people can only afford a house half the price they could before interests rates rose, and those with mortgages are stuck with their low rates and little incentive to move (or at least sell). So it’s not the lack of units that’s the issue, but a market that (surprise!) favors the wealthy and entrenched. If you had cash, houses could be found at absurdly low prices 12 years ago. But as always, the climate favored the wealthy whose credit score wasn’t wrecked, who had excess capital to deploy, and were willing to tie it up in real estate for 5-10 years as the market recovered. 0 - https://twitter.com/Econimica/status/1686999658483314688 https://twitter.com/Econimica/status/1686999658483314688
- Xorakios 3y agoThere is a deficit of around 40 million units in the US. Desired household sizes keep decreasing due to ongoing drops in marriage and childbearing rates, which increases housing units out of historical proportions. This is compounded by the desire for vacation homes and the continuing opposition to increased housing in privileged areas such as the coastal cities. Here's a fun graph from the US Census Bureau: https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/54683a71e4b0768e168af8a5/1416118570700-0AL9F1GK5P4YTIQFYAPP/housing-2010-10-20-new-home-construction-sa-iacono.jpg?content-type=image%2Fjpeg https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/54683a71e4b0768e1...
- iamdamian 3y agoHow is 'deficit' measured, and what source are you using?
- vvpan 3y agoWell a lot of people who want homes are expecting to be getting short-term rental revenue that would cover their mortgage payments at least. If they fail to do that then they might not want the home. Also the numbers do not exactly support your statement: https://www.construction-physics.com/p/is-there-a-housing-shortage-or-not https://www.construction-physics.com/p/is-there-a-housing-sh...
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoThis is in turn dramatically impacts the price of the home. I bought a home last year during peak sales season in a great neighborhood in a major tourist town at a very reasonable price that had been on the market nearly a week before I made my offer. How? Because my HOA explicitly forbids me from using the home as a STVR, which kept most interested buyers away. The desire to capitalize the house in the future is a major factor in rising home prices. I can do a long term rental, but no Airbnb. Want to dramatically reduce upward pressure? Start passing laws that severely punish STVR activity and prices will come down.
- bredren 3y ago> Start passing laws that severely punish STVR activity and prices will come down. Enforcement, and aligning city incentives with enforcement is also needed. Airbnb landlords faking residency or other requirements but paying all fees and taxes may not get enough attention.
- the_gipsy 3y agoPopulation increase brings job-opportunity increase. Then we will need even more high density housing. This is a vicious cycle. "Just build more housing" is not the solution.
- satvikpendem 3y agoSounds like that's exactly the solution. Build more housing until supply meets demand, even if demand rises. It's not as if the population is infinite.
- the_gipsy 3y agoThe demand rises above above what's physically possible to offer. And it's not about population growth, but migration.
- satvikpendem 3y agoWhy would it? It doesn't happen today even in countries with cheap housing, like internal migration in Japan. People aren't going to suddenly flock to countries for cheap housing, otherwise we'd see a bunch of Americans moving to Thailand or something.
- the_gipsy 3y agoExactly, nobody flocks to housing on its own: people migrate to job opportunities. Which increase with population density. If you increase housing where there is already demand due to job opportunities, then you increase density there, and then you increase the job opportunities again, and thus you increase the demand even more than what you satisfied with the new housing. It's not as simple as "build more houses!".
- satvikpendem 3y agoI don't think you understand what I'm saying. The cycle you're talking about is not an infinite process, nor is it guaranteed that people will flock somewhere just because there is more housing, because it is also not guaranteed that job opportunities increase due to lowered housing. You have your causality incorrect there.
- carlosjobim 3y agoReal estate prices have been increasing more than any asset for decades in regions that have catastrophic depopulation. There is no shortage of housing. Abandoned houses are everywhere, I've seen them rot before my eyes through the years. Abandoned land is everywhere, I see it overgrown. Ask to purchase that abandoned property and you'll be hit with an outrageous price demanded. Is it sound to organize your economy in a way where the mere luck of owning real estate will net you the same income as what a specialized professional has to work decades to earn?
- ipaddr 3y agoPeople want detacted homes for afford prices in desirable locations like the core of major cities.
- araes 3y agoConsider that the market is no longer the 90%. Since real wages have not risen much since ~1980 [1], most of the consumers have no response when rates suddenly increase. Houses are simply not purchasable. Case study: Vancouver, BC, Canada (I looked in May 2023). House prices: ~$1.1M. Loan rate: ~5%. Month payment: $5900. Yearly: $71k. Avg Salary: 60k (before tax). Result: No normal worker can afford the loan, and the bank won't give you the loan. When interest rates sharply rise, suddenly all loans to normal humans based on existing prices look like failure, because there is no way to make the payments. "I'll give you a loan, so you can miss payments every month, owe me more every year, and then default. No." if( money_earned < monthly_payment) then { no_loan } Also, wealthy need somewhere to park their money. A bunch of really wealth folks made a bunch of enormous profits last year. [2] Frankly, if you're in the $10^9 club, there's not much to buy. Personal air craft carrier? Your own airforce? Build your own town? [3] Reconstruct all of Iraq? [4] [1] https://files.epi.org/2013/ib388-figurea.jpg https://files.epi.org/2013/ib388-figurea.jpg [2] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/big-oil-doubles-profits-blockbuster-2022-2023-02-08/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/big-oil-doubles-prof... [3] https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/4184337-california-forever-company-behind-land-purchases-near-travis-air-force-base-launches-website-details-plans/ https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/4184337-california-... [4] https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-1-d&q=reconstruction+budget+for+iraq https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-1-d&q=reconst...
- zer0tonin 3y ago> Frankly, if you're in the $10^9 club, there's not much to buy This is nonsense. The US treasury market is $10^13, it will have no issue accommodating a few buy orders from the $10^9 club
- red-iron-pine 3y agoVancouver is cheating; it's one of the most expensive cities in N. America. Not Canada -- all of North America. https://www.vancouverisawesome.com/local-news/vancouver-ranks-3rd-most-expensive-city-in-north-america-5490661 https://www.vancouverisawesome.com/local-news/vancouver-rank... Vancouver, especially, has not seen salary gains in keeping up with the housing market. It is explicitly, unambiguously, huge amounts of foreign money. The housing prices in greater YVR correlate to foreign issues in China like Xi's crackdowns, or MBS' takeover in Saudi. This is true for Greater Toronto as well, but very much less so over the rest of Canada.