8 ms·
Shorts risks cannibalising core YouTube business, say senior staff
- seydor 3y agothe youtube people who work on shorts should feel ashamed of themselves. They have a platform with a certain reputation and acclaim by users for providing - and supporting- all sorts of quality content, yet they push hard (very hard) an awfully trivial form of (not even) entertainment where you can't even seek the video back and forward. you should at least adjust your messaging to say how sorry you are for shoving shorts on our faces
- layer8 3y ago> you can't even seek the video back and forward For me that works with shorts, maybe it’s a recent change.
- commonlisp94 3y agoIt's also often sexual or suggestive content. inb4 it's just showing me what I like. In icognito mode go to YouTube and watch a single video that might suggest you are an 18-45 year old male, and then look at your suggested shorts.
- Nihilartikel 3y agoAgreed, though somehow a few of my accounts have escaped that recommendation minima in YouTube. Not so much on tiktok or any fb property. They really force the onlyfans market-funnel jiggle videos into your face..
- jacquesm 3y agoMore like 13 to 95...
- isanjay 3y ago> it's just showing me what I like This is a silly and stupid argument. I was searching for some programming tutorials and it showed suggestive content in search results in maybe you might also like section or something like that. WTF is that.
- pxoe 3y agolet's not pretend like youtube has some heights of quality it's upholding. "all sorts of quality" is really more like all sorts ranging from good to bad to awful. and short-form comedy is in there too, and was there all along, right on the regular youtube.
- seydor 3y agothe quality has gotten better over the years so they must have been doing something right
- pxoe 3y agothey're mostly doing nothing. they're sleeping on every emerging video category. they got a video podcasts section only this year. their gaming catalog remains barebones. it's like they just don't want to make any "controversial" content curation decisions, even if it means that the platform is stagnating. let's not confuse creators and creator communities progressing and evolving, with state of platforms they happen to be on.
- arlcode 3y agoWhat has gone down is my ability to even tell what a video is even about since YouTubes algorithm/metrics/ad distribution Encourages creators to make absolute garbage titles and thumbnails in order to be discovered. This has absolutely negatively affected my YouTube view time since I am annoyed at having to guess the topic and whether it is worth suffering an ad for it. I put this in YouTubes court since they control what is shown to users and what isn't.
- Findecanor 3y ago> you can't even seek the video back and forward. You can copy the video ID into the URL of the normal player and play it like any other video. There's a Tampermonkey script that changes the player automatically: <https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/439993-youtube-shorts-redirect https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/439993-youtube-shorts-redi...>
- esel2k 3y agoThe most awful thing that it defaults in shorts. I am so far that I am actually looking into feature phones as I am convinced my life would be better without social media and attention-seeking-lowcontent offer like shorts.
- eddieh 3y agoI keep clicking the "not interested" X button that closes the shorts section oh the homepage, but no matter what it just keeps coming back. Unkillable zombie style.
- mitthrowaway2 3y ago[X] -- "Ok. We'll hide this for 30 days." Is that your idea of consent, youtube?
- d1str0 3y agoConsent was you typing in “youtube.com” to go to a privately owned website.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoPerhaps, but that's the consent that they certainly don't want me to revoke. The part where my preferences are customizable is meant to be a mutually beneficial arrangement, because it prevents me from leaving.
- thiht 3y agoFun idea of consent. I hope you never walk on someone else's private property, even accidentally.
- Lammy 3y agohttps://www.mrfdev.com/enhancer-for-youtube https://www.mrfdev.com/enhancer-for-youtube can hide them for good
- sbarre 3y agoNot if you're on a device or a tablet, sadly.
- unforeseen9991 3y ago
- postmodest 3y agoI can only assume that shorts increase ad revenue by decreasing the time between ad views and that's why they push them on users and creators. The government needs to step in and regulate ads, because ads destroy content and at some point , quality content is a societal good that needs to be protected.
- collaborative 3y agoAds are a necessary outcome of users rejecting to pay for digital content 99.9% of the time
- littlestymaar 3y agoThe web started without ads nor payments. And it was not worse when it was run mostly not for profit, quite the opposite.
- sbarre 3y agoYeah but scale matters. The number of people who are on the Internet now, and therefore the cost to serve them (at least for major or popular platforms) is much higher than it was back in the early days of the web. I too long for those days, trust me, but it's just not a fair comparison.
- jabradoodle 3y agoMore users is likely not more expensive per user; especially not given how much cheaper compute is now compared to 20 years ago. Clearly market forces often lead to a horrible product many of us don't like.
- sbarre 3y agoYeah sorry I just don't agree with that reasoning. Even if cost per user hasn't gone up (which I would actually bet it has, if we had a way to measure it), the total cost has gone up, and for a distributed non-commercial Internet you need to have a total cost, not a per-user cost, that is affordable for lots of people, not just for large market leaders, like it is today.
- arbitrarian 3y agoAll the times I've watched a short, it's been an accident.
- coding123 3y agoAge we live in
- rabbits_2002 3y agoEvery time I have tried to watch shorts it ends up being videos of people getting killed or dying. I just went ahead and blocked them with adblock
- Ekaros 3y agoI would not hate them if they also appeared as regular videos. But they do not. So sometimes you even have massive discoverably problems wit them.
- callalex 3y agoFrom my perspective, it already has. Some of my favorite long form creators have switched to shorts for the money. As a result I just no longer bother going to YouTube anymore and just stick with podcasts.
- dageshi 3y agoI'm not sure shorts make much in the way of money vs regular videos. https://www.youtube.com/shorts/H6st2yl6jNE https://www.youtube.com/shorts/H6st2yl6jNE As they said, I think it might be good for discovery. My personal habits back that up, I'm aware of some channels I wouldn't otherwise be without shorts.
- sshine 3y agoShorts are more addictive. Shorts will capture your attention for longer and display ads in-between more frequently. I find musicians and naked ladies via shorts, but I rarely extend my science and programming channels via shorts.
- viraptor 3y agoIt seems to be mostly driven by what you click on. Like, my shorts will always include Hank Green, Vsauce, some entertainment like VLDL or dropout.tv. Just click "not interested" on stuff you don't care about.
- darth_avocado 3y agoI found the opposite true. Shorts lowers the barrier of entry and generates a large volume of garbage content. You’d have one original video, followed by thousands of other either lip syncing to the original or just nodding their head (aka reacting) to it. It is very easy to get annoyed by it and leave the platform.
- BuyMyBitcoins 3y agoPersonally, I can’t stand Shorts because they don’t let me scrub through the video. I actively avoid watching them because I feel like I’m being forced to watch the whole thing.
- dottjt 3y agoWhy all the hate for Shorts? I think they serve a purpose i.e. when I don't have time to watch a full video, I can just watch a Short. Basically when I'm on my computer, I don't watch Shorts. When I'm on my phone, and I have a few minutes to kill, but still want to learn something I'm interested in, I'll watch a Short.
- karaterobot 3y agoIn that context, what's the difference between a Short and a regular video, only shorter?
- UberFly 3y agoFrom my perspective they're mostly low effort noise.
- GuB-42 3y agoIt is the UI/UX. Shorts are not just videos that are short. It also come with a player where you can't go forwards and backwards, that autoplays through an algorithmically generated feed, optimized for retention. The system isn't designed for you to watch a short, in fact, it discourages it, it is designed so that you watch an endless stream of shorts.
- surgical_fire 3y ago> optimized for retention. Failed hard on me. Perhaps I am weird.
- GuB-42 3y agoDidn't work for me either. My first reaction when I saw the new interface was "help, I want to get out!", and I have avoided even potentially interesting shorts for that reason. I ended up installing an extension that plays shorts like regular videos. There are certainly many "weirdos" like us, but YouTube (and TikTok) don't care. As long as it turns on more people than it turns off, it is a win for them. If there are enough weirdos, some smaller company may get interested and cater to that niche. In fact, I think it is how current tech giants may fail, by only focusing on the majority and dropping the niches, they may open themselves to a more nimble competitor that use these niches as a starting point to eat away their market share. Privacy is one such niche, but I think it is already an overcrowded market, plus, Apple is on it, so you can't rely on that alone. Maybe there is a niche for an anti-tiktok that can be exploited.
- izacus 3y agoAnd I bet some veteran staff thinks that shorts should be all there is. People have opinons, what's this nothing burger?
- super256 3y agovsauce only uploads shorts these days, it makes me sad.
- arlcode 3y agoMake sense. That explains why he vanished from my perception a while ago. Didn't even notice until now.
- extraduder_ire 3y agoI don't think his time between videos has changed much, he's mostly reposting content from his tiktok account @corndogwilly IIRC. Better this than nothing, IMO.
- jacquesm 3y agoThey keep pushing them too, even if you keep disabling them.
- franczesko 3y ago"Shorts, may eat away at its long-form content, which has for almost two decades been its primary bread and butter" Long form content which is artificially long, because of what platform rewards. Those videos cold easily be 2min long or less, but how would they justify placing a 30s ads before it? Also - majority of streaming takes place on mobile. Short format is straight to the point and what Internet needs. No one has time to go through 10min of clickbaity spam chopped by sh*y YouTube ads.
- moribvndvs 3y agoThis comment reduces several different concerns into a single opinion that long is clickbait and short is just right. At the end of the day, videos should be as long as they need to be to suit the type of content, the creator’s style, and their target audience’s taste, and it’s offensive for content platforms to assume or countermand your preferences or tastes. The issue is that platforms are also forcing these reductive, drain-circling usage patterns motivated by competition and profitability, but it especially sucks when you do it to a well-established user base. Especially since it’s the easiest thing in the world to just let users decide if they want shorts or not. You are in your right to think that long form videos are bloated click bait. I’m in mine to think that shorts are predominantly attention deficit trivialities for memes, influencer trash, and also clickbait. What sucks is that I can’t get away from shorts, and worse than that, shorts circumvent YouTube’s neutered, paltry search and recommendation algos and are constantly pushing even lower quality and uninteresting if not completely irrelevant (and sometimes inappropriate) rubbish higher than things I’m actually looking for. You at least can go to TikTok. I will have to wait until a critical mass of my favorite content creators migrate to a less shitty platform.
- threeseed 3y ago> Short format is straight to the point and what Internet needs I would strongly disagree. Short form encourages TikTok style click-bait/outrage-farming content. I much prefer the much more thoughtful longer content you do find on Youtube.
- AlphaCerium 3y ago
- lawn 3y agoThey're horrible. Luckily you can use ublock origin and letsblockit, or other browser plugins, to completely erase them from YouTube. https://letsblock.it https://letsblock.it
- traspler 3y agoSadly not from the apps without sideloading modified versions. Not only is the quality absolutely garbage but I also noticed that my brain is susceptible to them and I tend to doomscroll if I ever land there. I really try so hard to excise all the short form content stuff from my life but even with extensions and everything, the web version is not great enough to replace the app completely.
- AlphaCerium 3y agoPersonally I use UnHook to completely hide all recommendations, merch/music/offers/etc. ads, replace the default homepage with the subscriptions page and generally clean the UI: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-recommended-videos/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-recom... In addition, I use the Stylus extension with a custom stylesheet to restore the UI to the roughly pre-2016 look. This has allowed me to essentially treat my Youtube experience as a RSS feed viewer, which I feel is a much healthier experience. However, by doing this you do lose out on the discovery factor that Youtube is known for.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoHas anyone tried using youtube without recommendations? I do not recommend, and shorts are an even worse plague on top of that.
- fma 3y ago"Senior YouTube staffers are reportedly worried that its TikTok competitor, Shorts, may eat away at its long-form content," They are different forms of content, just on the same platform. Seems like a a non-sensical article for the click of driving engagement on The Verge - and I guess it worked. Also, the Verge is just poorly summarizing a Financial Times article...in other words, The Verge is providing 'short-form content' of ft.com, except, ft.com isn't getting the ad revenue (not the same publisher, afaik). And for FT...their article does not cite a single person from YouTube. Just "a staffer in a meeting said..."...according to "YouTube staff". I honestly expected better....from both.
- zimpenfish 3y ago> They are different forms of content, just on the same platform. Sure but if someone uploads short trailing / covering something they also cover in a long-form video (and I have seen several creators I follow doing this), there's a non-zero percentage of people who aren't going to bother with the long-form version because they'll have got the gist from the short. That's eating away at the long-form, no?
- sam0x17 3y ago> They are different forms of content, just on the same platform No there really is something to what they are saying. My husband is a HUGE youtube user and now on most of his devices his feed is 50% shorts. It completely changes the experience of consuming youtube content.
- sbarre 3y agoI am in a similar boat, I pay for Premium and I don't want to see Shorts anywhere in my feed, but I can't not have them.. I can snooze them for 30 days or something (I mostly use an iPad) but that's not what I want. As a paying customer, it's infuriating.
- fma 3y agoI must have a different experience somehow? My feed & recommendationa only has Shorts in one spot...2nd from the top, and I can see more if I swipe. Besides that all other recommendations are long form.
- yosito 3y agoI really don't understand why so many apps have to try to converge and become the same thing. Apps seem to be having an identity crisis.
- crazygringo 3y agoBecause otherwise new apps replace older apps. The older ones go out of business and die. Obviously investors and employees don't like going out of business. So they try to hop on whatever's becoming popular so they don't get replaced. It may be confusing for consumers. But surely you can see the logic for app owners. And it also means competition is alive and well.
- sam0x17 3y agoEverything has been downhill since they let people upload custom thumbnails honestly. That shit should pick a random frame from the video and attempts to game that (like re-uploading 1000 times until it happens to select the portion of the video with the desired thumbnail) should be flaggable. The thumbnails, which used to be indicative of average content of the video, have just become visual clickbait. Oh how I miss the early days of youtube when these were just random frames from the video.
- jakeogh 3y agoIn Libretube, "settings > advanced > enable data saver" disables thumbnails. It's wonderful.
- AlphaCerium 3y agoSee DeArrow: https://dearrow.ajay.app/ https://dearrow.ajay.app/ Created by the same developer as the wonderful SponsorBlock extension. Replaces titles and thumbnails from videos with community-sourced, click-bait free versions.
- CM30 3y agoFunny enough, creators can't upload custom thumbnails on YouTube Shorts, at least not without a lot of trickery. So if you dislike thumbnails that much, Shorts would probably appeal more than normal videos.
- mkl95 3y agoA month or so ago I started watching a comedian I thought was pretty talented. Youtube then started spamming me her Shorts. I unsubscribed because my brain associates her content with that annoying pattern.
- TMWNN 3y agoWas it Taylor Tomlinson? A couple of months ago I suddenly got videos of her (both shorts and the longer 5-10 minute clips) recommended, and I'm normally not into standup at all. (I did enjoy them, but not enough to actively seek out more.)
- alborzb 3y agoWow that's wild, I'm not OP but I've also got this exact situation. I watched a couple of old Dave Chapelle clips and then suddenly had a bunch of videos from the Taylor Tomlinson all recommended to me repeatedly, even though I had never heard of her before...
- TMWNN 3y ago> even though I had never heard of her before Yes, that's the weird thing. I've heard of Dave Chapelle, but I can't remember the last time I watched a clip of his or any other standup comedian. I'd never heard of Taylor Tomlinson before.
- jorl17 3y agoSame thing happened to me. Taylor Tomlinson. Out of the blue.
- crorella 3y agoShorts have just downsides in my mind: - not enough time to provide quality content - dilution of engagement, because the lack of meaningful content you can produce and consume in a few seconds/minutes - further promote short span focus which is bad for long term development
- Havoc 3y agoIt's not the short themselves but youtube's clumsy attempt to ram them down everyone's throat that's the issue. It's a bit like news is now often luck of the draw as to whether you're getting an article, an audio clip or a video. It's jarring. If there was a simple toggle button between videos/short/both all this wouldn't be an issue.
- _dujt 3y agoSeriously. I can’t imagine how trivial it would be to just add a flag to my YouTube account permanently disabling shorts but they’d rather make it per device, per 30 days. Forget what we want to watch, we will use YouTube they way their PMs want.
- mvdwoord 3y agoin ublock origin I have: www.youtube.com##ytd-guide-renderer a.yt-simple-endpoint path[d^="M10 14.65v-5.3L15 12l-5 2.65zm7.77-4.33"]:upward(ytd-guide-entry-renderer) www.youtube.com##ytd-mini-guide-renderer a.yt-simple-endpoint path[d^="M10 14.65v-5.3L15 12l-5 2.65zm7.77-4.33"]:upward(ytd-mini-guide-entry-renderer) www.youtube.com##ytd-browse[page-subtype="home"] .ytd-thumbnail[href^="/shorts/"]:upward(ytd-rich-item-renderer) www.youtube.com##ytd-browse[page-subtype="subscriptions"] .ytd-thumbnail[href^="/shorts/"]:upward(ytd-grid-video-renderer,ytd-rich-item-renderer) www.youtube.com##ytd-search .ytd-thumbnail[href^="/shorts/"]:upward(ytd-video-renderer) www.youtube.com##ytd-browse[page-subtype="subscriptions"] ytd-video-renderer .ytd-thumbnail[href^="/shorts/"]:upward(ytd-item-section-renderer) www.youtube.com##ytd-browse[page-subtype="trending"] .ytd-thumbnail[href^="/shorts/"]:upward(ytd-video-renderer) www.youtube.com##ytd-search .ytd-thumbnail[href^="/shorts/"]:upward(ytd-video-renderer) www.youtube.com##ytd-rich-shelf-renderer[is-shorts] www.youtube.com##ytd-reel-shelf-renderer m.youtube.com##ytm-reel-shelf-renderer m.youtube.com##ytm-pivot-bar-renderer div.pivot-shorts:upward(ytm-pivot-bar-item-renderer) m.youtube.com##ytm-browse ytm-item-section-renderer ytm-thumbnail-overlay-time-status-renderer[data-style="SHORTS"]:upward(ytm-video-with-context-renderer) m.youtube.com##ytm-browse ytm-item-section-renderer ytm-thumbnail-overlay-time-status-renderer[data-style="SHORTS"]:upward(ytm-compact-video-renderer) m.youtube.com##ytm-search ytm-thumbnail-overlay-time-status-renderer[data-style="SHORTS"]:upward(ytm-compact-video-renderer,ytm-video-with-context-renderer) m.youtube.com##ytm-single-column-watch-next-results-renderer ytm-thumbnail-overlay-time-status-renderer span:has-text(/^(0:\d\d|1:0\d)$/):upward(ytm-video-with-context-renderer) youtube.com##ytd-rich-grid-row, #contents.ytd-rich-grid-row:style(display:contents !important;) which works a treat (for now, but sure will remain possible)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- neonate 3y agohttps://archive.ph/UJwY1 https://archive.ph/UJwY1
- codedokode 3y agoI watch Youtube on laptop and never watch Shorts. The videos I watch are usually in range of 5 to 30 minutes and cannot be shortened. Also, I don't like vertical format. I don't understand what's good in short videos. Would you prefer to read 1 page book, watch 1 minute movie or go to a 1 minute concert?
- lxgr 3y ago> I don't understand what's good in short videos. No attention span required.
- satvikpendem 3y agoThey're fun when you're out and about. They are usually comedic in nature. Sometimes, as it's often said, brevity is the soul of wit.
- CM30 3y agoShort videos work best when you want to show something that doesn't really need a lot of explanation, or justify a full length video. For instance, in the gaming world, a random glitch you encountered that sends your character falling through the floor, or an AI bug that causes an enemy or NPC to get stuck/repeat the same actions in a loop, or a really close finish at the end of a race could be great short material. It's amusing to watch out of context, but doesn't provide enough material for a full length production. Other examples in other genres could be a meme based on a particular funny clip, outtakes/bloopers from a longer stream or video, part of a TV show or film that's somewhat iconic and can be enjoyed out of context, etc. Could be treated like an ad for the longer production, in the same way Nintendo thought their mobile games were a gateway product to their console ones.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- throwawa14223 3y agoI don't get shorts. The UI seems awful. The aspect ratio is unpleasant, and for some reason it rapidly advances me to another short without giving me time to interact with the UI.
- palmer_fox 3y agoShorts are gross. A great example of the medium becoming the message.
- bentt 3y agoThere are some nice Chrome extensions which erase Youtube Shorts from the desktop experience. Highly recommended. I use "Youtube-shorts block"
- penjelly 3y agomight be just me but, on android i noticed the mobile app gets into a state where it fails to load/play standard video, no issue with shorts however. Considering unsubscribing if i cant find a fix
- AraceliHarker 3y agoIn fact, UUUM, the largest YouTuber firm in Japan, reported that its AdSense earnings deteriorated as the number of views on Shorts increased while the number of views on regular videos decreased.
- xnx 3y agoBetter to cannibalize yourself before someone else does it to you. YouTube already alienated many viewers by encouraging longer, more television-like, videos. TikTok showed that there was a huge demand for more concentrated/focus video content without a bunch of filler. Many TikTok videos I enjoy are shorter than common YouTube intros!
- CM30 3y agoAs someone who posts content on YouTube, I definitely agree Shorts have caused issues on the platform. They're the most promoted type of content hence they're super tempting for creators, yet if you end up making them it can kill your conversion rate for longer videos and drive off the people that prefer those instead. The biggest issue though is how they've tied them to the vertical video format. That's okay if your content is singing or saying stupid things on camera, but for pretty much anyone who covers tutorials or media or games, it basically mades the format a lose-lose situation for video quality. You either give up the reach Shorts bring by posting only normal content, which can at least be viewed in a decent aspect ratio without cutting anything off, or you try and make your shorter videos into Shorts, and end up with a nigh incomprehensible video due to not being able to fit important info on screen. So what could be a cool way to show interesting clips and things that happened that might not deserve a full length video is basically only usable for the most vapid, surface level content.
- expertentipp 3y agoMy nephews watch shorts like little robots. Probably by hit and miss they figured the optimal video form and length to melt the kids' brains.