9 ms·
Tesla, Rivian Put on Fake Show of Support for ‘Right to Repair’
- omgJustTest 3y agoYou can’t even jump another car with your Tesla, let alone do repairs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cj 3y agoAdding to that, you also can't jump start another Tesla with your Tesla (according to the manual) Edit: link to jumpstarting in manual: https://www.tesla.com/ownersmanual/model3/en_au/GUID-3567D5F4-A5F4-4323-8BE0-023D5438FFC6.html https://www.tesla.com/ownersmanual/model3/en_au/GUID-3567D5F...
- fipar 3y agoQuestion out of ignorance: what does it mean to jump start an EV? I know what it is for an ICE (and I have a jump-starter-battery always in the trunk, with usb ports it doubles as a phone charger if you’re somewhere without power), but for an EV, I’d guess you either have enough battery charge for it to run, or you need to charge, right?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- giancarlostoro 3y agoIf you need to jump start an EV you need to charge it basically. I cant think of a case where it would be needed with an otherwise filled battery.
- raisedbyninjas 3y agoI just learned that my ICE vehicle can drain the 12v battery overnight if it fails to turn off the accessories circuit. No lights or infotainment etc. were left on. In my case, it was the switch on the park gear flaked out. I imagine a variety of similar faults could cause the same issue in an EV.
- zerocrates 3y agoMy car (a hybrid) has a long-standing bug in the radio system that can make it "freeze" and stay on forever. Only way out once it's frozen is to pull the right fuse (or wait for it to drain your battery all the way).
- cj 3y agoReminds me of renting a zipcar for a few days and parking it in an underground parking lot. When I went to use the car after a couple days, the battery was drained. This happened on multiple occasions with different vehicles parked in the same garage. My best guess is Zipcar has cellular comms to phone home, which enter some weird “always trying to connect” state when cut off from cellular signal underground. Zipcar’s response was to ban me from renting on their platform ever again for too many disabled vehicles.
- falcolas 3y agoAn EV has two power systems, 12V (typically) for the car accessories, and 120V for the drive motors. And if the 12V system is down, you can’t drive the car (can’t close the contactor that connects the 120V batteries to the system). So, in theory, you could jump the 12V system so you can engage the 120V system.
- scotty79 3y agoThe design that allows 12V to completely discharge while there's charge in high voltage batteries is idiotic. I ran into that in Toyota hybrid. Why there's no manual override that enables charging of 12V battery? It could be under the hood and turn off automatically when the voltage in 12V battery is high enough.
- rnk 3y agoThis same problem happens in evs where due to some problem the 12v discharges. When everything is working the 12v is charged up from the main battery bank. Tesla in the early days sometimes ran down the 12v and it wasn't that uncommon, there were problems with runs of batteries yielding poor ones; I think they had messed up software that wasn't charging the 12v enough, but they made changes to address that long ago. On my second ev, a rivian, I just had to have my 12 battery replaced. They said sometimes the 12v batteries just die on them.
- sgerenser 3y agoSome Hyundai hybrids and PHEVs have this (I saw it in the original Ioniq). It's a button you press that temporarily charges the 12V battery through the high-voltage system rather than being always enabled, but it seems like a great idea.
- anaganisk 3y agoJump start? Pfft. The stupid car, got stuck with AC stuck on full heat, with a blacked out screen. Unresponsive to resets. I couldn't even open the damm frunk to remove the fuses, yeah okay I don't carry a 12v battery around with me to jump the frunk.(how difficult is it to give damm manual overrides for critical stuff) It was a rental so no access to Tesla app. Tesla Customer service refused to help, since it's a rental Tesla is a smart phone with wheels that can't make calls. It's great while it works but it is as dangerous as it can be once things go wrong. This car must be banned. It scarred me enough to keep me away from other EVs too which put all the controls in a screen. There is no excuse for EVs to have everything electrically controlled.
- rnk 3y agoI agree these situations can be dangerous and frustrating. There is a manual trunk release on the tesla, here's a video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b1bJ0F3R0Nc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b1bJ0F3R0Nc. I have a rivian and the 12v battery died on it while I had it plugged in charging at home. In the manual I found the emergency trunk release (access from underneath the car), and then there was a manual release for the charging port inside the frunk. My gas cars have died with some electrical problem before, out in the boonies where there was no one to help. But that was back when all my cars had a key, so I could at least open the door with physical key.
- bdcravens 3y agoMany EVs still have a physical key to open the car (my EV6 and my wife's ID.4 both do for example)
- rnk 3y agoWell that's great, my Tesla and my rivian do not have physical keys, and I wish they did.
- anaganisk 3y agoNot the trunk, the frunk. That's where the fuses are located on the Tesla Model Y isn't it? Or were the videos I watched were wrong?
- blamazon 3y agoSmall nit: I can 'jump' (read: charge the battery of) other cars with my model X, as long as the other car is an ICE car. In the frunk there is a panel that pops off and underneath there are (unlabeled) 12V and ground terminals that I can put jumper cables on. However, I have had to get my car towed a mile to a charging station before, I really deeply wish I could have received a jump then.
- omgJustTest 3y agoHave you tried it? My Tesla doesn’t keep the terminals charged unless the car has recently been in motion and shuts down in a few minutes. Also Tesla says not to do this, jumping in the conventional sense is more as you describe, charging the other battery and may require more than 20min to do it.
- blamazon 3y agoYes, I have an unfortunate habit of leaving the lights on in my ICE vehicle, and I've used it to run an inverter many times in a camping type of scenario. My memory is that there's two 12v terminals in my frunk, one that turns off and one that does not. My car is older though, pre facelift.
- Retric 3y agoThat is the exact use case where solar roofs on EV’s become very useful. However you can “jump” EV’s, supply power to their 12v system and then charge off of another cars 120v plug, or a portable generator etc.
- blamazon 3y agoSimilarly, I've always thought it's a no brainer for any ICE car to have a solar roof. At a minimum it can keep a 12v battery from dying over long parking durations or high parasitic drain, and at best it could like, keep a container refrigerated or something.
- 3y ago
- 1970-01-01 3y agoTaking this literally, it would be a massive publicity stunt. Have a stock Model 3 jump 20 school buses, and then see how the competition goes.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoBecause they are apples and oranges and Tesla is using 48v! Jumping a 12v lead acid battery with 48v is a fantastic way to completely fry the ICE vehicle.
- masklinn 3y agoAFAIK Teslas use 12V like everyone else, do you have a source for 48V? However EVs (and hybrids) do tend to have pretty small 12V batteries and I think some of them have switched off of lead-acid: they only need the 12V to boot up the electronics, not to power a starter engine.
- diebeforei485 3y agoTesla has future plans for 48V, but they're still on 12V today.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoSorry, it's 16v (15.5v) 48v is coming later this year.
- bad_alloc 3y agoWell, most EVs have weak 12V batteries to power computers, lights etc. They are not designed to output the amps needed to turn an engine. That makes sense for the EV since it saves a lot of weight. And the main batteries are usually 400V to 800V, which you can't use to jump another car (or you can use it once, at most).
- masklinn 3y ago> You can’t even jump another car with your Tesla That's pretty common for EVs (and hybrids), since they don't have (or need) a traditional starter engine and only use the 12V to boot up the car they downsize the 12V and / or switch to lithium chemistries.
- esjeon 3y agoYeah, it's just a tiny compatibility issue, but it's really a bummer that you're sitting on enough electricity to power a house for days and can't even jump a car. It's gonna be great if we can utilize all the juice in our cars...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jayd16 3y agoYou can get a small jumper battery and leave it in the car. You can easily charge it with the EV. It'll be smaller than a full set of jumper cables, even.
- javajosh 3y agoRather than us fighting for the right to repair, shouldn't manufacturers be fighting for the right to limit our ability to repair? Isn't "right to repair" the default state? The right to repair, modify, disassemble, recombine your own property is a key component of capitalism, is it not?
- xg15 3y agoI think in the current flavor of capitalism, the key component is "fuck you, I got mine".
- circuit10 3y agoRight to repair is about making sure manufacturers can’t intentionally block repair. Also there have been some cases of people getting into legal trouble for doing things like using aftermarket (“counterfeit”) parts, I remember hearing about a repair shop having to destroy iPhone screens
- MoreSEMI 3y agoAgree, the language is problematic. But unfortunately companies sometimes use the law to take away that right. Additionally, right to repair sometimes means going beyond the default state and requiring companies to go the extra mile, so that is where the langauge may also stem from.
- SenAnder 3y agoIn addition to all the legal restrictions on "reverse engineering" (i.e. examining how stuff works) and circumventing DRM, as technology advances, using technical means to restrict otherwise legal end-user activities is becoming a big problem. That you're legally allowed to repair your tractor doesn't help much if the on-board secure TPM chip flags your replacement parts as counterfeit, locks the engine, and reports you to the manufacturer so they refuse to sell you parts in the future.
- MostlyStable 3y agoThis is something I've wondered about. For cars there is a bunch of regulatory stuff that might preven you from doing this, but I believe the regulatory burden on tractors is much less. Why has no one just built a full on control system swap for tractors? Yeah, the OEM control board won't recognize your replacement part. Or it won't tell you whats actually wrong. Etc. Etc. But if you just replace it with an entirely OSS control system, that problem goes away. I know that this probably not a trivial task, but, given the amount of money at stake, it feels worthwhile, but maybe I'm just underestimating the degree of integration of the current control system into the parts. If everything down the internal engine sensors is running priprietary, encrypted software and you basically have to tear it down and replace every single electronic component on the tractor, then yeah it probably won't ever make sense.
- echelon 3y agoSince EVs are mechanically simpler, I'd really like to see a return to kit cars. Perhaps you could buy the preassembled chassis and modify the rest of the car as you'd like. Maybe you could tear down the whole thing and rebuild it. In theory this should be super accessible. You might see a whole community spring up over it. It's potentially a huge market ranging from teenagers to retirees. Lots of people love cars and modifying them. There might be lots of companies that get in on the action and build a full ecosystem of compatible parts. It'd be really neat.
- adolph 3y agoFramework car
- extraduder_ire 3y agoWould be nice, but the economics would be kinda wack with how much of the cost is in the battery pack. Especially when companies like tesla put the same pack in all their cars and determine your "capacity" in software. I'd imagine that would either change, or people would start buying up the lowest-cost EVs just to pull the battery out of them (like "shucking" external drives) and resell all the other parts.
- echelon 3y ago> or people would start buying up the lowest-cost EVs just to pull the battery out of them (like "shucking" external drives) and resell all the other parts. That sounds amazing.
- 1970-01-01 3y ago>Among the auto blogs that covered the announcement, few pointed out the hollowness... Regurgitation via a Google news search link cites absolutely nothing. Its the sloppiest journalism I have ever seen on any tech website.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dundarious 3y agoWhat makes you think looking at that google news search was the extent of the research they did to justify that assertion? Journalists typically do not show all their workings (though they could always show more). To me, the link is obviously just a moderately useful stepping stone/prompt for people to research the point themselves.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoI didn't say that. I'm saying the hyperlink used to cite their sources is dynamic by design and therefore extremely sloppy.
- Transpire7487 3y agoNo normal person can repair a Tesla, it’s basically a trade secret. My brother is a mechanic and servicing Teslas are a non starter due to the complexity. The notion that I can just download a manual, buy some parts and DIY my own repairs is absolutey ludicrous. The only reason for Tesla to support right to repair is to increase regulatory burden on competitors, stunt innovation and raise costs for their competition. Shame on this anticompetitive behaviour.
- omgJustTest 3y agoNo normal person can cast an ICE header. Same logic.
- esjeon 3y agoIt's not the best example unfortunately. People do build custom headers by cutting and welding various pipes using off-the-shelf tools. Welp, ICE is an old tech (from 18c), so it doesn't take dark magic to fix a whole ICE car mechanically. The real deal breaker is electric controllers w/ proprietary software.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThat's assuming you need the controller to do the exact same thing in the exact same way as the OEM one. But in many cases people are replacing it because they want it to do something different anyway. And these functions are in many cases quite simple. You replace the controller for the door locks. It operates a solenoid that locks and unlocks the doors. Maybe they no longer function by calling the call center to have them unlock your car, but maybe you don't want that anyway. They still function if you press a button on your key fob.
- api 3y agoEVs could be a gigantic step down in complexity but that doesn’t benefit their manufacturers. It would risk making them a commodity that can be assembled from parts like an old school PC. Instead the industry is looking at the EV transition as a way to increase costs and decrease customer freedom. This is absolutely artificial and in no way mandated by the technology. A similar case in computing is what happened with mobile and tablets where a change in form factor allowed lock down to be smuggled in without people asking too many questions. A Mac is now a big overgrown tablet in terms of its CPU and innards but you can install your own OS on a Mac but not an iPad. Why? No technical reason at all. Right to repair is good but it’s actually less than what we need. We need a huge rebirth of DIY technology and less centralized supplier ecosystems. This may require some regulation but it also requires consumers to stop being so passive and prioritizing shininess and laziness over every single other thing. The “millennial minimalism” era needs to end both as an aesthetic and a framework for consumer-producer relations. (The two are related.)
- marak830 3y agoI'm sorry I have seen the thread leads, and I cannot agree with them and think the replies do not get enough notice. Right to repair should be a full set of instructions for "everything" are available. That's it. Give the full specs for everything. If it's code reliant(which wtf), what does it require to work? That's. Fucking. It. We give you rules to say peeps cannot sell what you made, you make it so we can repair it. If you don't like it, sell fucking service.
- bagels 3y agoI think the biggest problem with Tesla is access to parts, much of the process (minus the computer bits) are easy to reverse engineer.
- naremu 3y agoEven the need to "reverse engineer" something that you paid for and ostensibly own, though, is overwhelmingly insulting and in some ways (though obviously not technically legally, ethically) is basically directly challenging public perception of property ownership. It's not even like it's say, a watch that I might actually need specialist equipment or knowledge to repair/maintain. It's actually something I'm expected to at some point, be required of me, but is tactically not provided to me as to benefit a private entity. And arguments can be made about who's ethical and economical burden it is to make documentation, but the fact is it'd just save an overall immense amount of societal time and productivity for those who already have the potential to provide documentation, to do so. And so the expectation that we are left to our own devices on various forums and social media websites that may or may not be SEO'd by google to be brought to our attention with the right combination of keywords. Is kind of baffling, to be honest. If it's easy for us, it should be even easier and quicker for them. Especially when most in many countries are unfortunately reliant on such things, many of them may not be reverse engineerers, or even versed in google-fu.
- charcircuit 3y ago>It's not even like it's say, a watch that I might actually need specialist equipment or knowledge to repair/maintain. If it doesn't need specialist knowledge then why are you asking for people to release their knowledge on how it works? Just use your general knowledge on how it works then.
- photochemsyn 3y agoRepairability is like online security: if companies really cared about it, they'd have built it into the product beginning at the design stage. With most products these days, repairability is actively discouraged at many different levels: components are inaccessible, soldered or glued on, specifications are unavailable, replacement parts are not sold direct to the public, etc. This is all done to shorten product lifetimes such that consumers have to purchase new products more frequently, that's clear enough. Some companies might realize that there's a market for repairable products and shift tactics, there seem to be a few out there, though not many.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- subhro 3y agoIn the other news, BMW has "stopped" selling service manuals for motorcycles showing a damn middle finger to everyone including law makers (in Europe even). That is absolutely rubbish, but somehow they can do it legally.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]