3 ms·
The vast majority of people in Europe pays nowhere near half our salary in taxes. Only a few countries have total tax wedges (including employer payroll taxes)
by vidarh 3y ago
The vast majority of people in Europe pays nowhere near half our salary in taxes. Only a few countries have total tax wedges (including employer payroll taxes) that reach that level for more than small minorities of the population.
- anonzzzies 3y agoNot sure why you get downvoted; most taxes are scales and the highest is around 50%. That doesn't mean you pay 50%. Or even close to it.
- victorbjorklund 3y agoIn sweden we also have social insurance fee (which is a tax according to all def even if it is called a fee) and VAT. 50% is just one of many taxes. You should count all the taxes an individual pays.
- anonzzzies 3y agoSo then you would need, in other countries, count all the unemployment insurance, pension, school premiums and healthcare insurance also towards their tax. Then yes. When people outside more socialist countries say they pay far less tax, they never include any of this, so I don’t either.
- ekianjo 3y ago[flagged]
- vidarh 3y agoThe average earner in Sweden pays <25% combined in tax + social insurance fee according to OECD Taxing Wages.
- Try1275 3y agoI live in Austria. I pay 48% on everything above 60k € and 50% above 90k. Our VAT is 20%. Most people who can afford it pay for private doctors because it‘s almost impossible to get an appointment with one that‘s covered by normal health care. So I guess at least for my country the statement above is somewhat true.
- Shaanie 3y agoSweden: 24% payroll tax, >30% income tax = 47% tax. Then there's a 25% VAT on most non-food goods, and an extra 20% income tax on any income above $56k. To be fair, 17% of the payroll and income tax are pension contributions (up to earning around thr $56k, after that it's just a tax).
- vidarh 3y agoMarginal rates. Sweden reaches 50.3% for a single person earning 167% of average salary in total tax wedge (including employer payroll taxes) with no substantial deducations. An average earner has a total tax wedge of 42.4%. Sweden is one of the highest in Europe. The average earner pays 24.3% in income tax and employee social service contributions. The VAT adds up to less than you'd think, because for starters you won't buy anything VAT rates with the money you've already paid to tax, nor what you pay on housing, or food. Last time I added up what I actually paid in tax it was around 4%, both in Norway with similar tax levels to Sweden, and in the UK.
- dijit 3y agoeven if your top tax rate is >50% it is difficult for you to actually pay 50% in tax. For example, in Malmö, Sweden the top tax rate is 52% and starts at 45k, but even at 70k your actual tax load is something like 36% Not counting VAT of course.
- vidarh 3y agoIt's typical for these discussions that people assume marginal rates and never check the effective rates.
- 3y ago
- yardstick 3y agoIn the UK once you reach over ~120k GBP the total tax wedge is above 50% [1]. At 90k GBP you are paying 45%. I guess it depends on what “nowhere near half” means. 45% is close imo. Especially with VAT added in on purchases. Yes the average London wage is more like 50k GBP, but from that perspective it’s also only double the average wage before you hit 45%+ tax take. The top UK tax rate (including employers NI etc) is ~59%. 1. https://listentotaxman.com/?year=2022&taxregion=uk&age=0&time=1&ingr=120000 https://listentotaxman.com/?year=2022&taxregion=uk&age=0&tim...
- avianlyric 3y agoLess than 1% of the UK population earns above £120k. It think GPs qualifier: > for more than small minorities of the population. covers that situation. Simply put, only a small minority of people in the UK pay that much tax. Not to mention the classic error you’ve made > hit 45%+ tax take. that tax take only applies to persons income that’s above 120k. The actual total tax burden across their income is substantially lower, given everything below £120k is taxed at a much lower rate.
- yardstick 3y ago> Not to mention the classic error you’ve made Actually I didn’t error. This is the total tax paid expressed as a percentage. It is not the marginal tax rate. See the link I provided as evidence (add total deductions + employers NI together).
- avianlyric 3y ago> add total deductions + employers NI together Why would anyone do this? Employers NI is a business tax, why would consider that a tax paid by individuals? If you’re gonna start attributing employer taxes to individuals, then why not start including business rates and other random taxes, then you can gin up any level tax burden you want.
- yardstick 3y ago
- ekianjo 3y ago[flagged]
- vidarh 3y agoCheck OECD Taxing Wages before you throw out unfounded accusations of lying, and you can see for yourself what average earners and people earning 167% pay in the OECD countries. While that does not cover all of Europe, it covers the bulk of the European population.
- jiofj 3y agoTaxes on your salary, + VAT, + rest of taxes you pay for owning a car, a house, + taxes on petrol, etc amounts to at least half your salary in most European countries.
- _0ffh 3y agoBelgium and Germany are the worst, at about 70% total in taxes and dues.
- vidarh 3y agoIn most European countries you'd have to earn far above average to approach that. Have a look at the tables in OECD's Taxing Wages publications. Having earned far above average in several European countries, I've never paid more than half, despite for part of the time earning 5x+ the national average. That's not to say you can't. Some certainly do. And some countries are much higher. Belgium in the very significant outlier, with Germany not far behind.
- Detrytus 3y ago> total tax wedges (including employer payroll taxes) Those "employer payroll taxes" are still part of your salary. It's just an accounting trick to fool you.
- vidarh 3y agoThey are not part of what you negotiate, and if the rates change your take home pay doesn't change, but it was exactly in anticipation of arguments like this I pointed out that my claim holds even for total tax wedge.
- Detrytus 3y agoMaybe for you its not a part of what you negotiate, but it surely is for your employer. In my country it is a typical to work based on self-employment and you can see it quite clearly even in advertised salary ranges: the amount you can get when self employed is equal to the sum of salary offered for employees and payroll taxes.
- vidarh 3y agoWhat do you consider "typical"? In Europe, Greece is by far a massive outlier with about 30% self employed". No other European country comes close (I think Italy is second, about 10 percentage points lower, but not sure). In other words, in no European country is it anywhere close to being more typical to be self employed than being employed. The vast majority of people negotiate a salary, not a self-employed rate. That it is part of the calculation for the employer is irrelevant - so is office costs, admin overheads, software licenses, equipment, yet we don't consider those costs deductions from an employees salary and bump the "real" salary up accordingly.
- refurb 3y agoAre you sure? I mean, most European countries (there are exception) have a marginal rates of >30% at middle class incomes. Then add on top VAT rates of >20%. It wouldn't surprise me it hits 50% of income for an awful lot of Europeans.
- vidarh 3y agoYes, I'm sure, and you can't add up percentages like that. Effective rate is far lower, and you can't spend money you've paid in tax on VAT, nor money you've spent on housing, or the multitude of zero rated goods which usually includes food, so the proportion of your money you pay VAT on is usually small. Last time I actually did the math, I paid about 4% of my gross pay in VAT, and despite being in the top 1-2% or so in the UK my effective rate including VAT is still only just approaching the 50% mark.
- refurb 3y agoI never implied you just "add up percentages like that". The point is, if your effective income tax rate is 35%, you also need to add up all the taxes that aren't income tax, like the 20% VAT, gasoline taxes, alcohol taxes, property taxes, stamp duties, etc, etc. Add all that up and I wouldn't be surprised if many people had an effective tax rate >50%
- vidarh 3y agoI would be surprised if many people had an effective rate >50% that way. I've done the calculations in the past - the effective rate of VAT as a proportion of gross income added up to around 4% for me, because most of my money does not go towards VAT rated products. Nor does it for anyone. Because before you spend on VAT-rated products (or alcohol, gasoline etc.), you first pay income taxes, then you pay for housing, and food which most places is zero rated or at a discounted VAT rate, and debts. The higher you earn, the lower proportion of your income tends to go towards spending, partially because you tend to put aside a larger proportion for pensions, partly because you pay a higher rate of tax, so VAT contributes less to your overall tax burden - it's a deeply regressive tax. Most people don't have enough money to spend on highly taxed items for it to be possible for them to get to an effective tax rate of 50%+, and most of those of us who might be able to spends our money otherwise - bigger house, bigger pensions, more investments. I earn many times the UK national average, and so pay income tax and national insurance far closer to the 50% mark than the vast majority of the UK population. Despite that I still don't cross it when other taxes are added on. Including VAT, property taxes/council tax and similar. I'm in the top 1-2% income earners in the UK - people earning less than me are certainly getting nowhere near 50%. Even when I lived in Norway, which has wealth taxes, some of the highest gasoline and alcohol taxes in the world, and higher income tax, and high VAT (25%), did I reach 50%. In some of the highest tax countries in Europe, like Belgium (an extreme outlier) and Germany, higher proportions will cross the 50% line, but overall for Europe this applies to a vanishingly small proportion of people. UK is "low tax" for Europe, but closer to the average than e.g. Belgium and Germany. Which is why the "half goes to taxes" crowd almost always ends up forced to start bringing up the total tax wedge instead of other taxes. Even then most people will never hit 50%, though more do.