3 ms·
So you are saying GoDaddy should first audit and approve every business before selling them a domain? They are a domain registrar, and their only job is to sell
by paxys 3y ago
So you are saying GoDaddy should first audit and approve every business before selling them a domain? They are a domain registrar, and their only job is to sell a domain to whoever wants it in a few clicks, nothing more. There is nothing special about ".us" over anything else. Content problems are the business of the FBI and other law enforcement agencies.
- londons_explore 3y ago> Content problems are the business of the FBI and other law enforcement agencies. I've often wondered why the FBI don't have a website where I, a random citizen, can get hold of SSN's, credit cards, bank accounts etc. to give to any scammer who asks me. The FBI would then trace all uses of those numbers and use them like a honeypot.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoIt seems like a clever idea to me! The first problem that comes to mind (not necessarily insurmountable) is that some number of people will use the honeypot data in legitimate forms, either due to cluelessness or intentional fraud on their end. It's not immediately obvious to me what happens in that case.
- autoexec 3y agoMy first thought was that the numbers would end up being collected and screened for by bad actors and if the numbers were generated on demand, we'd eventually just run out of valid SSNs or credit card numbers. It might work on a small scale though. They could give a few of those numbers out to security researchers and internet abuse desks.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- miah_ 3y agoIt used to be that to get a SSL certificate you had to provide a Dun & Bradstreet ID, and go through a minor audit. Was the Internet safer then? Well I certainly wasn't being phished in the 90's because it wasn't really a thing yet. I enjoy what Letsencrypt brings us so I don't want to go back to that, but I do believe the registrars are certainly partially to blame here, look at Google and .zip, how many valid domains are registered with that TLD, and how many are malicious? We can make better decisions, it just requires not being so damned greedy.
- burnte 3y agoOnly some vendors did that, most didn't. And that was back in the days when we though SSL would be useful for ID verification, which it never was meant to be used for.
- kube-system 3y agoThose barriers to entry meant basically nobody hosted malicious sites with an SSL cert back then. "Look for the lock" was a valid security recommendation in those days.
- indymike 3y agoActually, we'd just see the web part of an attack on a hacked webserver, often with an wildcard EV cert. something.majorcorp.com/some/backwater/director/index.htm. The funny part is the phish would look like something at UPS and be hosted on some airline site, so the advice to check the link was the best defense.
- fullspectrumdev 3y agoI still see this pretty much daily. Usually you find the mailer script (for spamming), a web shell, and a few different phish kits all under some directory. Also usually the captured credentials, etc. Sloppy work from the crooks, but it works.
- nulbyte 3y ago> It used to be that to get a SSL certificate you had to provide a Dun & Bradstreet ID, and go through a minor audit. What kind of audit? And was it conducted by DNB? If so, some audit it must have been. I can't speak to the time before, but these days, DNB is a scam in and of itself. Just last year, the FTC finalized its order against them for deceptively selling a junk business credit monitoring service and failing to correct errors on business credit reports--even today, they'll tell you they don't know who provided the data that they themselves collected in the first place.
- 3y ago
- deathanatos 3y ago> There is nothing special about ".us" over anything else. No, .us is special; the OP sums it up well enough: > Under NTIA regulations, the administrator of the .US registry must take certain steps to verify that their customers actually reside in the United States, or own organizations based in the U.S. Such restrictions aren't unique to .us, and I've worked with other ccTLDs that have similar restrictions. Generally, AIUI, they're supposed to be for the people of that nation, who can then do as they see fit. Maybe that's free access to whoever pays for it, maybe that's "only our people", such as is closer to the case here. > Content problems are the business of the FBI and other law enforcement agencies. If GoDaddy actually did the job they were supposed to be doing here, it might actually be possible for that to happen, since there'd be a door on US soil to bust down, but if the bad actor is just in some far-away nation that was never supposed to have been permitted to register that domain in the first place, the bar goes up a bit.