7 ms·
Why Is .US Being Used to Phish So Many of Us?
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoSo GoDaddy is the registrar responsible for the ccTLD, but who is responsible for the 50+ second-level domains? Are those all under GoDaddy's control too? I mean, I assume that most people registering a .US domain are not registering it at the top level. Do individual states have no control over how their second-level domains are administered and delegated? Furthermore, there are so many sub-sub-domains under all that. Any one of those could be vulnerable to someone entering unauthorized DNS information and getting a host within the domain without any need to register anything at all.
- tuckerman 3y agoStates usually control a top level domain under .gov (e.g there is labor.ca.gov for California’s department of labor). .us on the other hand is freely available for anyone to use (and in my experience is usually quite cheap)
- Dwedit 3y agoStates being part of .gov is relatively new. There was a very long period where .gov was exclusively for the federal government. The state governments were under the domain (abbreviation of state).us, and everything was a subdomain of that.
- wavemode 3y agoyeah I still remember my grade school website's domain ended in ".k12.<state abbrev>.us" Seems ripe for abuse if such registrations aren't being securely controlled
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoBut you don't get it. No registration is necessary. All an attacker needs is access to the authoritative DNS servers. They can get a delegation or insert their own resource records. Why go through a registry and give up a credit card and personal details?
- anamexis 3y agoI think they're referring to <state>.us registrations
- tuckerman 3y agoI think at this point it’s been allowed for over 20 years but I’m sure there is a mixture still. I was mostly trying to point out that registering under .us is pretty trivial. There is no need to try and sneak something into some states’s dns records, anyone can just go on any registrar and purchase something directly under .us
- ciabattabread 3y agoNew York City, a municipal government, used to have its website at www.ci.nyc.ny.us, now it’s at nyc.gov. But NYC still has a bunch of active websites hosted at *.nyc.ny.us.
- kube-system 3y agoNYC also has a TLD of their own. e.g: https://www.archives.nyc/ https://www.archives.nyc/
- davchana 3y agoThat's privately controlled, not like .gov. But yes.
- ArchOversight 3y ago> I mean, I assume that most people registering a .US domain are not registering it at the top level. No, 99% of the people are registering at the top-level. It's not like .uk where there is second-level domains that each domain falls under.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoWell except for k12.xx.us, which used to be standard in every state. Some of these domains are still alive, so there are definitely third- and fourth-level domains available for hijacking and malicious injections.
- loeg 3y agoThey might exist, but it is a far cry from “most people registering a .US domain are not registering it at the top level,” which is mistaken.
- kube-system 3y agoThese namespaces are controlled differently. You can't just go to godaddy.com and register "phishingdomain.k12.ny.us"
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoYes, that's exactly what I mean. The subdomains are administered by the autonomous IT departments and administrators who run their delegated, authoritative name servers. Therefore, they are rather more vulnerable than a centralized registry that has the resources to scrutinize every application for veracity.
- kube-system 3y agoThe article is about how GoDaddy doesn't even bother scrutinizing second level registrations. Nobody is bothering to hack local governments to set up phishing domains. It's a lot easier to navigate to godaddy.com with 5 dollars and a fake address to grab a second-level domain.
- kube-system 3y agoIn 2002 the .us TLD started allowing others to register second-level domains as they wish, and those types of registrations became the majority that same year. Locality namespacing in .us is mostly a historical thing now. Some still exist, and their management is delegated to other managers other than GoDaddy.
- davchana 3y agoI did get my firstname.us yesterday (for legitimate purposes, maybe a blog post sometime in next decade). One can absolutely register.us at top level. Many institutions like school, counties, departments get countyname.us & then provide sub domains to others. Many in California has switched over to .gov by using .ca.gov at least at state government level.
- roughly 3y agoUS citizens getting screwed over because the government outsourced management of a national resource to the biggest company it could find, that company’s proving to be totally incompetent, and oversight is basically nonexistent? Say it ain’t so!
- 0xDEF 3y agoPlenty of countries outsource their ccTLD management to the private sector. It's GoDaddy that is the problem.
- kube-system 3y agoHell, the root zone is controlled by the private sector.
- roughly 3y agoI agree. It’s not the outsourcing, it’s that we picked an incompetent company and then didn’t provide any oversight.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- strbean 3y agoIn this case it isn't incompetence, it's immorality. Which sucks, but is to be expected from the private sector when there is no oversight.
- asu_thomas 3y ago[flagged]
- roughly 3y agoTo be clear, that’s not what I’m saying at all. Plenty of other governments manage to do this fine; the US government, on the other hand, has been shaped by 40 years of anti-government, pro-business philosophy to both favor the largest institutional partners it can find (very often rewarding size and prior government contracts over any actual competency) and to effectively lack the staff and ability to provide proper oversight. We regularly hand over government functions to partners with no actual incentive to provide more than their bare contractually obligated service while extracting the absolute most from users of those services and wind up getting shitty outcomes and high prices, and somehow this is used to _further_ drive the narrative that government is the problem and we should outsource even more.
- autoexec 3y agoGoDaddy is making a ton of money by allowing spammers and scammers to abuse .US domains. They have a massive incentive to turn a blind eye to it because cutting these bad actors off would mean they lose out on all that money. It doesn't matter to them if the money they're getting is likely stolen to begin with or that the domains will be used to rip off countless others. Amoral monsters who will do anything for money can't be trusted to do anything other than make money. It's bad enough they're able to register domains with other TLDs, but we should probably not allow them to manage .US at all given their track record.
- paxys 3y agoSo you are saying GoDaddy should first audit and approve every business before selling them a domain? They are a domain registrar, and their only job is to sell a domain to whoever wants it in a few clicks, nothing more. There is nothing special about ".us" over anything else. Content problems are the business of the FBI and other law enforcement agencies.
- londons_explore 3y ago> Content problems are the business of the FBI and other law enforcement agencies. I've often wondered why the FBI don't have a website where I, a random citizen, can get hold of SSN's, credit cards, bank accounts etc. to give to any scammer who asks me. The FBI would then trace all uses of those numbers and use them like a honeypot.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoIt seems like a clever idea to me! The first problem that comes to mind (not necessarily insurmountable) is that some number of people will use the honeypot data in legitimate forms, either due to cluelessness or intentional fraud on their end. It's not immediately obvious to me what happens in that case.
- autoexec 3y agoMy first thought was that the numbers would end up being collected and screened for by bad actors and if the numbers were generated on demand, we'd eventually just run out of valid SSNs or credit card numbers. It might work on a small scale though. They could give a few of those numbers out to security researchers and internet abuse desks.
- throw0101b 3y agoCan anyone on the planet register in .us, or are there residency requirements (like with .ca)?
- kagevf 3y agoIn TFA: "Also, .US domains are only supposed to be available to U.S. citizens and to those who can demonstrate that they have a physical presence in the United States." ... and ... "Under NTIA regulations, the administrator of the .US registry must take certain steps to verify that their customers actually reside in the United States, or own organizations based in the U.S. But Interisle found that whatever GoDaddy was doing to manage that vetting process wasn’t working."
- davchana 3y agoavailable to citizens "&& residents". Not every resident is citizen.
- stOneskull 3y agoevery resident has a physical presence
- nottorp 3y agoBecause it's handled by a for profit company whose aim is to sell as many domain names as possible?
- dogcow 3y agoIt's a shame that the .us locality namespace and delegated manager infrastructure has been allowed to languish. GoDaddy (and Neustar previously) have intentionally made it difficult or impossible to register new locality domains under namespaces managed by them (read: the majority of namespaces). The delegated manager system truly represented the distributed, decentralized nature of the old Internet. That said, it is not completely dead; there are still a handful of delegated managers out there, and you can even convince some of them to "register" a new domain for you in the locality namespace!
- Thomashuet 3y agoAs Wikipedia puts it: Most registrants in the U.S. have registered for .com, .net, .org and other gTLDs, instead of .us, which has primarily been used by state and local governments, even though private entities may also register .us domains. This makes .us a prime target for attackers because victims tend to trust .us more than .com. Nothing GoDaddy can do will change that.
- phendrenad2 3y agoThis is HN so let's go beyond shallow outrage and actually think about what a solution would look like. I'm sure some here are involved in KYC and fraud prevention. What could GoDaddy do to prevent this kind of abuse?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TheRealPomax 3y agoGonna need some graphs that show "phishing volume per domain" here, because just saying that this is "according to The Interisle Consulting Group, which gathers phishing data from multiple industry sources and publishes an annual report on the latest trends" doesn't actually anyone anything, it's just an appeal to authority when no one has any reason to trust a consulting group to actually be authoritative. Show the numbers.
- brianpan 3y agoThe report is linked at the end of the article. Most phishing comes from .com (expected due to its size). The report says about .us: ".US is the ccTLD of the United States and had a very large number of its domains used for phishing -- almost 30,000 domains, more than 20,000 of which were registered maliciously by phishers." Also, it seems doubtful that krebsonsecurity would be appealing to some authority without a good cause.
- jeroenhd 3y ago> Also, it seems doubtful that krebsonsecurity would be appealing to some authority without a good cause. Ever since the false accusations accident, I've stopped trusting Krebs when he's making statements like these. .US has a high percentage of phishing domains, but in terms of raw numbers .com, .cn, and .pw are still much bigger than .us. I do wonder about these statistics, though; I don't know where domaintools.com gets their statistics from, but that's the only source for these "total domains registered" number. TLDs like .rest and .live also have much higher phishing percentages. The assertion that .us is unusually phishy is backed by numbers that don't seem to have a clear, verifiable source. I don't know who Interisle are, but I don't think they run any TLDs, so I wonder where they got their data from. They say they've collected their data from through https://www.cybercrimeinfocenter.org/ https://www.cybercrimeinfocenter.org/ but that's hardly an authoritative source of domain statistics.
- xNeil 3y agoOT, but I find it interesting that one wrong move can erase hundreds of good moves (one mistake can erase 20 years of goodwill).
- tacticalturtle 3y agoFor legitimate use cases - I think the .us domain was doomed when the US government forbid using anonymizing proxies for the domain registrant’s contact information. If you register one - you need to provide complete contact information, and that will be publicly available via Whois. I still get spam calls offering “Web Design” services for the .us domain I naively bought 8 year ago, even though it’s 7 years expired.
- everybodyknows 3y agoApparently at least this problem is being addressed by the NTIA: > The NTIA recently published a proposal that would allow GoDaddy to redact registrant data from WHOIS registration records. The current charter for .US specifies that all .US registration records be public.
- tacticalturtle 3y agoYes - Contrary to the quoted source in the piece, this is a good thing. Clearly if all this fraud exists with the requirement in place - it’s not an effective prevention measure.
- benlivengood 3y agoIt's not terribly difficult to find mules in a country to do the (totally legal) work of registering a domain name which is then credentials-transferred or has NS records pointed at DNS under scammers' control. Passkeys are probably the solution to most phishing attempts.
- barryrandall 3y agoBecause the contract awarding administration of the .us ccTLD to Neustar (acquired by GoDaddy) specifies the certification/spot check process: https://www.ntia.doc.gov/files/ntia/publications/ustld2007_34_apph_nexus.pdf https://www.ntia.doc.gov/files/ntia/publications/ustld2007_3.... NTIA could amend the contract to require or allow a different process that doesn't so readily enable phishing. So, bribe your local legislator if you'd like to see the process changed.
- distantsounds 3y agobecause a domain extension based off of a country is more reputable (and likely more available) than its .com equivalent? I love Kreb's work but this article title is complete garbage. It has nothing to do with the domain extension and more about godaddy turning a blind eye to their customers' nefarious doings. This can happen with _any_ domain.
- goldinfra 3y agoWhat steps would be reasonable to "verify that their customers actually reside in the United States, or own organizations based in the U.S." and wouldn't be very easily subverted by bad actors? I would object much more strongly to registrars being heavy-handed about verification for .us domains than being overly-loose about it. Phishing/spam problems aren't going to be solved by verifying .us domains.