8 ms·
Are self-driving cars already safer than human drivers?
- shmde 3y agoNo.
- Marazan 3y agoIt was an easy question this time.
- Gys 3y agoDownvoted because the article does a really good effort to analyze all data and adds other considerations. A simple 'no' without arguments does not add anything to the discussion. > With all that said, it seems that Waymo cars get into serious crashes at a significantly lower rate than human-driven cars.
- roomey 3y agoSo they say 1 crash every 60k miles (or about 5 years worth of driving). I really doubt humans have one crash every 5 years on average. Then they say 1 fatal crash every 100 million miles.... And then make it sound like we have to have self driven cars drive 100 million miles before we can tell if they are safer. That article is all over the place.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- variants 3y agoYeah it sounds like they are using weird averages and applying them to a small fleet of self driving cars and saying they are safer because they have had less accidents than the millions of people on the road
- elif 3y agoThere is a big gap between scraped a shopping cart and head on collision. This is why Tesla reports 'miles between accidents resulting in airbag deployment.' The national average is 600k miles. For FSD (which has over 300M miles driven) it is 3.2M miles between accidents.
- adgjlsfhk1 3y agowhile this methodology makes sense, it's hard to get the thought out of my head of the Tesla self driving car intentionally not deploying the airbag because it will bring down it's stats
- elif 3y agoThen get into your head that Tesla engineers use the fact that the entire fleet has video and telemetry data in order to fine tune the use of airbags for the exact opposite purpose: to reduce injury caused by both excessive and insufficient airbag deployment.
- adgjlsfhk1 3y agotwo things: 1 most crashes are very minor (e.g. getting into or out of a parking space) and also most crashes are from people who are some combination of under 20, over 80, drunk, or just atrocious at driving. most people's crash rate is a lot lower
- tialaramex 3y ago> So they say 1 crash every 60k miles (or about 5 years worth of driving). I really doubt humans have one crash every 5 years on average. Oh not humans. Americans. Most developed countries are much safer. America has found a lot of exciting ways to make this worse, whether its choosing more dangerous technology, not prioritising safety in design, or just obvious stuff like oops we made it crucial for everybody to drive so now we have to let everybody drive even though that's unsafe.
- ulizzle 3y agoAmericans don't have an average of one car crash every five years.
- Closi 3y agoI don't think those facts are incompatible. 1) You would need self driven cars to drive over 100 million miles to validate that, assuming that there have been no deaths from full 'self driving' (i.e. Cruise/Waymo rather than Tesla, which isn't level 4) 2) Depends what you call a crash - 1 impact per 5 years might not be entirely wrong... According to this link: https://1800lionlaw.com/how-many-times-will-your-crash-you-car-in-your-lifetime/ https://1800lionlaw.com/how-many-times-will-your-crash-you-c... > The car insurance industry estimates that the average driver will file a claim for a collision about once every 17.9 years. This matches me - I've had 1 crash in 15 years of driving which resulted in a claim (someone drove into the side of me), but there have been at least 2 other impacts which have not resulted in a claim (1 person bumped into the back of my car on a motorway and impacted but but no damage, and there was one incident where I accidentally scraped a car when parking and I agreed to pay the driver for repainting directly without going through insurance).
- linuxftw 3y agoAt the end of the article, the author makes the appeal that self-driving development should continue and increase on public roads because the companies can't develop their products otherwise. The companies can absolutely develop their products outside of public streets. A few thousand acres and some purpose built infrastructure would do it. If that's not cost effective, well that's their problem.
- shiftpgdn 3y ago“Why are there still bugs in our software the developers have a dev environment and a test suite”
- fhd2 3y agoIf you invest (significantly) into a test suite that realistically mirrors the real world, that argument doesn't fly. Think Chaos Monkey squared. But it's neither cheap nor fast. Sure, some rare edge cases are probably impossible to model even with great care. But that's not the stage self driving is at, they struggle with pretty common and predictable problems.
- shiftpgdn 3y agoYou’re talking out of both sides of your mouth here. Even the greatest test suite on the planet will miss edge cases in the real world. Self driving cars are already 99.999% successful and effectively perfect in simulation.
- lukev 3y agoThis also doesn't account for non-safety related risks of self-driving cars, relative to human drivers. For example, it's quite common for an autonomous vehicle to slow down or stop in a way that disrupts traffic. This isn't "unsafe", per-se, and in fact it's probably the car's safety protocols functioning correctly. But (depending how frequently it happens) it's still a strong argument against deploying these things on public roads. We need vehicles that are not only safer than human drivers, but less disruptive and more competent overall.
- jackcviers3 3y agoPerhaps it's an indication that humans are far more acceptable of risk in cars than they should be.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- konschubert 3y agoOf course there is a limit. But if the self driving vehicles are being a bit slower than human-driven cars, that’s a very small price to pay for the huge safety benefits. In fact, as a pedestrian and cyclist, I could not care less.
- bee_rider 3y agoThe issue isn’t that they are too slow, it is that they are too erratic. Slamming the brakes for no reason is unexpected behavior, which makes it more likely that a crash will occur.
- HWR_14 3y ago> as a pedestrian and cyclist, I could not care less. I mean, if you don't use something, you don't care about downsides that apply to it. That's not a great argument, unless you also only want to convince other people who don't use cars to not use Waymos.
- konschubert 3y ago
- bhouston 3y agoSo Waymo is pretty decent - generally if Waymo was equal to human performance, the number of times it caused an accident would similar to the number of times other drives caused accidents it was involved in but that isn't the case. Humans drivers are hitting Waymo cars way more. "First, other vehicles ran into Waymos 28 times, compared to just four times a Waymo ran into another vehicle (and Waymo says its vehicle got cut off in two of these cases). Second, Waymo was only involved in three or four “serious” crashes, and none of them appear to have been Waymo’s fault." This suggests that if we were to replace all humans with Waymo, at least in the nice temperate snow-less/ice-less cities they are currently driving in, accidents would possibly be cut by 4x. Very interesting.
- skywhopper 3y agoI’d be suspect about how little the Waymos are at fault. Erratic or unpredictable driving behavior can cause accidents even if it would technically be ruled as the other driver’s “fault”. Also, replacing all human drivers with Waymos isn’t possible. Waymos can’t do everything drivers need to do and don’t operate in all conditions, in all places, at all times. Until they do, these stats are not really meaningful.
- bhouston 3y agoI wouldn't be surprised as Waymos and similar become more popular, humans will actually get worse at driving collectively as we have less practice.
- ryathal 3y agoWith collisions that out of sync it suggests Waymo is behaving in an uncharacteristic way compared to most drivers and is causing accidents.
- resoluteteeth 3y agoTwo major issues I see with this are: 1) It's very important to do an apples to apples to comparison when you're looking at accident rates, and you can't just do that by looking at averages for the US for all miles traveled. There have been issues with numbers for Tesla autopilot before where it looked like autopilot was safer than it was because Tesla compare autopilot against the average accident rates for all miles driven but in reality for the types of situations where autopilot was used, human drivers actually had fewer accidents on average. 2) Waymo has a low accident rate because its vehicles are operating very conservatively right now. If it could scale up and still operate the same way, that wouldn't be an issue, but its vehicles are already causing problems by getting stuck which suggests that it wouldn't be practical for them to operate a significantly larger number of vehicles the way they are operating right now. To scale up, they would need to drive less conservatively, and in that case they very likely would not be safe in their current state. IMO, this means it isn't really meaningful to say that they're "already safer" than human drivers.
- ilyt 3y agoOne example: Bad weather/road conditions where human might have problems but autonomic cars currently will go "no, you drive it".
- jansan 3y agoThis. Once autonomic cars can safely and with confidence steer through a crowded IKEA parking lot on Saturday morning when it's raining we can say they are ready.
- bhouston 3y agoEven if they can do that, they cannot drive in most of Canada almost half the year -- we have snow and icy roads 3-6 months a year.
- danielbln 3y agoSince human drivers can do this, what's missing from autonomous systems to perform here as well? More training data? Different optical or radar systems? Assuming our ability to drive isn't some God given gift, there shouldn't be a hard limit on what autonomous cars can do, yes?
- davidktr 3y agoWallStreetMillenial on Youtube just had a nice explanation why comparing risk for self driving cars and human drivers is not that simple. At least for Tesla, the answer is "hell no". https://youtu.be/wCJ7fNoEUsY?t=287 https://youtu.be/wCJ7fNoEUsY?t=287
- kingcobraninja 3y agoDepends on the conditions. Freshly paved interstate with clear lane markers, light traffic, daytime overcast skies with no rain? Maybe. Driving through a construction zones with painted-over lane markers at night, traffic cones knocked into the road, power out, and a police officer directing traffic at an intersection? No.
- Gys 3y ago> Freshly paved interstate The article is specifically about driving in SF. It also states SF is one of US more difficult cities to drive.
- zirgs 3y agoDoes it snow in SF?
- lillecarl 3y agoDo self driving cars have to drive in snowy conditions yet?
- Ekaros 3y agoAbsolutely they do, if they want to be at all usable.
- cwillu 3y agoThere are cities that are not in california, and some of them get snow. Self-driving cars don't have to drive in snowy conditions; indeed, they don't have to drive in any conditions at all. It'd be nice if they could though.
- aworks 3y agoYes, and it was glorious... https://www.sfchronicle.com/projects/san-francisco-snow/ https://www.sfchronicle.com/projects/san-francisco-snow/
- 3y ago
- globular-toast 3y agoThis question seems very dependent on the country in question. The article seems to be about the US. I suspect it is very different in a country which features well-designed road layouts and driver training, like the UK.
- d0liver 3y agoThis definitely feels like a very hopeful and intentionally narrow sited analysis. Like, we're saying that Waymo's accidents were primarily low-speed collisions but also they were only allowed to go 35mph max and drive in off peak hours when accidents are far less likely to begin with. If we're doing a comparative analysis then we'd need to compare to humans driving unimpaired during off hours at 35mph at most. And, it's also definitely worth considering how predictable and consistent the failures are; a human might miss someone backing out and hit them once because they are distracted. A computer missing the same means that there's a set of conditions that will trigger failure every single time they occur. So, if those conditions are repeated heavily in any place then the likelihood of catastrophic failure increases substantially.
- brianwawok 3y agoThe fact that humans don’t follow the speed limit is part of the math though. Just compare the same roads at the same times.
- jabradoodle 3y agoIt depends on whether the argument is that I should use an autonomous vehicle or that everyone else should. If it's a worse driver than me but better than average; I'd still be safer driving myself. I'd be safer if I could force the idiots into a self driving car.
- pipo234 3y agoFor sure there is some cherry picking going on. And for sure it depends. And for sure we're missing the big numbers to do a meaningful statistic analysis at this point. What I think is most interesting about your way of looking at this is whether we'll find those sub-domains where autonomous driving makes sense versus where manual driving will remain safer. And what those domains will be.
- ghaff 3y agoI still wonder if we end up in a place--perhaps for a significant period--where you end up with AVs on a subset of roads perhaps in a subset of conditions. I don't live in a city so I have different use cases than those who do live in a city may have, but being able to be driven on the highway in most conditions seems like a much easier task than the general case, applies to conditions where an accident can be serious, and would actually be really useful for a lot of people.
- zirgs 3y agoDid they try those cars during winter? In typical spring conditions where you have wet ice and wet snow on the road and road markings aren't visible. Oh right - those don't happen in California.
- resolutebat 3y agoThe article is not asserting that self-driving cars are always better than humans, but simply that in controlled conditions in SF/Phoenix, they seem to be doing a better job than humans. This is already pretty amazing. Yes, many places are harder to drive in than SF and Phoenix, but they're harder for humans too, and Waymo & co will continue to get better as they get more training data, better sensors, and bugs get fixed.
- aworks 3y ago1976 was the last time it snowed in San Francisco. I wonder if the Waymo software has logic for precipitation/temperature i.e. shut it down. I'm guessing it requires human intervention although hopefully in a timely manner.
- ghaff 3y ago>Oh right - those don't happen in California. It does actually. You just have to go into the mountains.
- zirgs 3y agoDid they test those cars in those mountains?
- giantg2 3y agoCurious comment about driverless vehicles. How does insurance work? How are the rates set (high due to ambiguity now?)? How do you exchange information? How do you clear the roadway while also not fleeing the scene? How does the vehicle know if it makes contact at very low speeds (no real shock of impact but enough to scratch/dent/run over a foot etc?
- atoav 3y agoI think the big issue with self driving cars isn't that anybody doubts that they are safer in standard situations. The issue is, that I can totally see a self driving car fuck a rare obscure situation up in the worst way — where even the worst drivers would probably do okay. E.g. let's say you are in a tunnel and there is a fire, you car blocks the fire truck. The normal line of thinking would be to throw all existing rules of traffic out of the window and so totally illegal maneuvers that might even damage your or other peoples cars. A self driving car might be able to do that, but it cannot make the judgement needed to know when to throw all rules out of the window. Now in that example the driver (if they exist) could take over, but there are similar examples where there is less time to decide and/or a switch to manual might not be feasible. Think of all situations where multiple dangers have to be weighed against each other, for example a rock slide where a street is partly blocked (enough for the AI to stop) but there is still rock coming down the mountain. A situation where a criminal gang blocks the road, in order to make you stop and rob you — this being a thing that could become easy game when self driving is wide spread enough. The problem with self driving cars is that even if you statistically manage to be safer over the typical journey today, people still wanna know that it keeps them safe in very atypical conditions as well. And that as of now is not the case.
- xoa 3y ago>The issue is, that I can totally see a self driving car fuck a rare obscure situation up in the worst way — where even the worst drivers would probably do okay. So? Unlike with humans, self driving networks of cars can learn from a rare obscure situation, then the entire network can be updated to handle it going forward, forever. Whereas "the worst drivers" (drunk speeder road ragers say) will just cheerfully plow into students in front of their schools yet again. >The problem with self driving cars is that even if you statistically manage to be safer over the typical journey today, people still wanna know that it keeps them safe in very atypical conditions as well. Meh. This is just a typical argument from incredulity/unfamiliarity. People have zero issue accepting significant risk given solid benefits and most people's driving most of the time is short and boring. That'll be Good Enough to get the ball rolling, and it'll only ever improve. >And that as of now is not the case. Where is the suggestion in the article that the current cars are ready to handle absolutely everything everywhere today? It's about incremental gains and safety in one particular very high population location.
- Barrin92 3y agoNo because the cars are self-selected to only drive on roads that the companies consider safe to begin with. Self driving tech currently operates on probably less than 1% of American roads, and that's a fraction of roads on the planet. >Waymo and Cruise have driven a combined total of 8 million driverless miles For context, the average American drives about 13k miles per year, so this is about as much as much data as a village of a thousand people produces annually. The actual experiment that would produce relevant data: A substantial mass of driverless cars on a random set of roads under random conditions, including with a high enough concentration that the cars need to interact with each other the way humans need to interact with other drivers. (obviously we know how this would end, which is why nobody attempts it)
- PopAlongKid 3y agoOver ten years ago, this article pointed out that "The Ethics of Saving Lives With Autonomous Cars Is Far Murkier Than You Think".[0] >"Let’s say that autonomous cars slash overall traffic-fatality rates by half. So instead of 32,000 drivers, passengers, and pedestrians killed every year, robotic vehicles save 16,000 lives per year and prevent many more injuries. >"But here’s the thing. Those 16,000 lives are unlikely to all be the same ones lost in an alternate world without robot cars. When we say autonomous cars can slash fatality rates by half, we really mean that they can save a net total of 16,000 lives a year: for example, saving 20,000 people but still being implicated in 4,000 new deaths." [0]https://www.wired.com/2013/07/the-surprising-ethics-of-robot-cars/ https://www.wired.com/2013/07/the-surprising-ethics-of-robot...
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe]
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoMore discussion over here yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37344991 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37344991
- ttfkam 3y agoEver walk around in a crowd in a foreign country? I mean one quite distant and distinct from your own? You bump, cut off, and get off frequently due to having a different rhythm and patterns than everyone else. It doesn't matter how conscientious you were in crowds back home. Self-driving cars are the foreigners. In isolation they may be safer and more predictable. But they have driving patterns that "the locals" simply don't. There are bound to be more bumps and cutoffs as these two groups interact, only at high speeds with tons of weight. It may not matter how conscientious their algorithms are if the locals keep bumping into them or get continually inconvenienced. The locals aren't going anywhere, for better or for worse. FSD needs to drive like a local, only better. That's a much harder nut for FSD to crack.
- bigfryo 3y agoSeeing how there are tons of young males in big trucks driving around asserting territorial dominance, I suppose self-driving cars that are not really that good are indeed more safe, comparatively speaking