7 ms·
Lidl Product Recall [pdf]
- rickdeckard 3y agoTerrible.......so what's the URL and what was on it?
- DonaldFisk 3y agoHere's a Reddit discussion about the recall: https://old.reddit.com/r/unitedkingdom/comments/1662ylp/lidl_recalls_popular_paw_patrol_snacks_over/ https://old.reddit.com/r/unitedkingdom/comments/1662ylp/lidl...
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoOops. Looks like someone ignored the domain expiration emails. I see that constantly, especially where there's high turnover.
- jjgreen 3y agoThe wayback captures page (SFW, but links to recent captures rather not) https://web.archive.org/web/20230815000000*/https://www.appykidsco.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230815000000*/https://www.appy...
- levidos 3y agoThank you
- jandrese 3y agoIt's a domain parking page full of ads for Chinese porn apps. The company closed shop and some squatters took over their domain. A recall seems unnecessary to me, but I'm guessing they got complaints and figured this was just safer.
- padjo 3y agoHardly anyone will actually return anything but they get to cover their asses by doing this.
- yorwba 3y agoEat the cookies, return the packaging? After all, it's an issue with the packaging that resulted in the recall.
- mcguire 3y agoOdds are, if a consumer asked they would tell the consumer to just throw the packaging away. In fact, that's probably what they would tell a retailer.
- anon____ 3y agoConsumers won't return it, but the stores will, in bulk. That's a lot of lost food because they can't repack or relabel it.
- bombcar 3y agoThe recall could instruct the stores to cover the offending URL with a sticker. But they’ll just say “toss ‘em”.
- imp0cat 3y agoOh, Chinese hackers attacking Paw Patrol, what's next? Bing Bunny gets turned into The "Big" Bunny? ;)
- bombcar 3y agoBing Bunny sounds like some misplaced Microsoft promotion.
- bspammer 3y agoIt's not just porn, it's actively malicious. The site tries to install a configuration profile (iOS) if you click through, presumably to install a root CA or something.
- whalesalad 3y agothe url was appykidsco.com
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoIt still is. Open in mobile view and you'll see.
- lioeters 3y agoQuoted below to save you a click. Sounds like it's not a problem with the products themselves, but their website got hacked. --- Important Notice: Product Recall Paw Patrol All Butter Mini Biscotti Biscuits x 5 Paw Patrol Choc Chip Mini Biscotti Biscuits x 5 Paw Patrol Yummy Bake Bars Raspberry Flavour x 5 Paw Patrol Yummy Bake Bars Apple Flavour x 5 Batch affected: All stock • Lidl GB is recalling the above-mentioned branded product as we have been made aware that the URL of the supplier which is featured on the back of the packaging has been compromised and is being directed to a site that is not suitable for child consumption. • We recommend that customers refrain from viewing the URL and return this product to the nearest store where a full refund will be given. We apologise for any inconvenience caused and thank you for your cooperation.
- Otek 3y ago> Quoted below to save you a click I hope not many people are reading a comment section before article.
- Greenpants 3y agoI, for one, often glance at the comments first to check if an article is valid. If not, there's probably a highly rated comment explaining what's wrong with an article's facts or reasoning. Saves me not just a click, but lots of time reading lesser quality articles too.
- gruturo 3y agoI always check out the HN comments first. The HN comments don't assault my browsers with popups, ads, awful styling and who knows what else. I may learn what the article is about (not always clear from the title of the submission) and be warned of other people's reactions (like "WOW that giant flashing thing on page 2 can trigger a seizure!" or "Site hijacks back button!" or even more importantly, "Article is a waste of time, author has it all wrong. Here's an authoritative source which explains why"). I may or may not risk a click at all if there are no comments. I do read the article before commenting though. (Well.... not this time, but it's kind of a meta topic)
- 3y ago
- siva7 3y agoI can't even tell if this product is meant for dog or human consumption.
- CTOSian 3y agobutter/chocolate for sure not for dogs...
- Karellen 3y agoIf you don't have kids, or none of your close family do, there's no reason you would be aware of the brand, but if you do they're astonishingly popular and almost impossible not to be aware of :-) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PAW_Patrol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PAW_Patrol > PAW Patrol is a Canadian computer-animated children's television series > The series has been sold to TV networks in over 160 countries. > In 2016, the season two episode "Pups Save a Mer-Pup" was nominated for Best Animated Television/Broadcast Production for Preschool Children in the 43rd Annie Awards. As of 2023, PAW Patrol has received twenty five Canadian Screen Award nominations with twenty wins.
- drcongo 3y agoIt's known as Piss Poor Patrol in this house.
- weekay 3y agoThis is very common in retail. What tends to happen is that a retail buyer would work with a supplier and order a product in . That product packaging will have a promotional or information site it will link to & is printed as a QR code. From a buyers perspective they are doing this as it’s a way to provide value or information to their customer and supplier fronts the cost of this. The IT teams within retail aren’t kept in the loop and neither are they aware of a site that is hosting any of this content. All the content and marketing of this is done by a agency who are hired and managed by the category or merchandising teams in the head office . Product sells for a quarter or maybe 6 months at the most . Products get rotated and goes back to warehouse until such time in a year they need to liquidate the stock and do promotional discount pricing as part of back to school or Black Friday etc., By then the agency that fronted this and created the site has lost its domain or the site isn’t maintained/ gets compromised etc., At that point the product is on the shelf , domain is hijacked or the hosting provider / host gets taken over by a malicious actor. Then the IT / security teams in the retail organisation are asked to step in and support their business colleagues. Every major retail corporation will have this happen to them at least once a year. IT teams will have a laugh about this and nothing ever changes as a process as it doesn’t really affect the share value or damage the reputation of the retailer as such
- b3lvedere 3y agoOne of my customers found out someone copied their website almost to perfection under a different domain name and started advertising their products for way less prices. They wanted the website gone of course. So now i had to explain our company doesn't have any jurisdiction on some website hosted on the other side of this planet.
- dazc 3y agoI have recently received a subpoena from 'the other side of the world' regarding a domain I registered recently. It seems the domain in question was one of many involved in IP infringement against a global fashion brand long before I came along. A simple check of registrar data would confirm I have f all to do with this. Either some big law firm knows different from you or are just scamming their client? Surely this can not be the case?
- seabass-labrax 3y agoI can completely understand the concern with a compromised promotional website listed on the packaging, but a full product recall seems to me extremely wasteful. Presumably, all those bags (which look to me like they're made of plastic) will have to be disposed of, if not the actual biscuits themselves. This is just one factor in a multitude of reasons why single-use plastics are wasteful, but I believe that if a company is not responsible enough to look after a URL they should not be plastering it all over consumer products. A URL is for life, not just for Christmas. Not sure whether to link to the Dogs Trust or the W3C here!
- kypro 3y agoRealistically is anyone actually going to return these products because of the URL though? I'd assume it's more damage control in the event someone actually does visit the URL because then they can say, "well we have recalled these products, sir".
- londons_explore 3y agoAll of the product still in stock in the shop or warehouse will be chucked out at the suppliers expense.
- Paianni 3y agoWell, our expense since we impose a system that makes this possible.
- jcul 3y agoYeah I don't think anyone will.
- krisoft 3y ago> all those bags will have to be disposed of, if not the actual biscuits themselves. Nobody will repackage the biscuits. That is not a thing any manufacturer or merchant would seriously consider. Of course it will be disposed of. Just imagine the liability of selling a food product which already come back from a costumer.
- harvie 3y agoInsert http cookie joke
- qingcharles 3y agoThere is nothing wrong with the food, so I hope they at least show up at a food bank so poor people like me can get some value from them.
- Freak_NL 3y agoThe sad thing is that they won't. Lidl can't risk sending these out with the compromised URL on the packaging, and covering the URL would take a lot of people in the chain cooperating and donating resources to arrange that. It is cheaper for Lidl just to donate a new batch without the URL and destroy the affected batch… The best thing one can hope for is that these end up on the break room table at Lidl shops, but there are probably rules that prevent that too.
- NullPrefix 3y agoSo you want to use those bad QR codes to hurt poor people?
- mikey_p 3y ago"Cool URIs don't change" from 1998 is as relevant as ever :( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23865484 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23865484
- selectnull 3y agoLet's all hope w3.org doesn't forget to renew their domain. Because if they do, all these links to "Cool URIs don't change" will suddenly become extremely ironic. We're safe at least up to 2029...
- dredmorbius 3y agoIf URIs aren't permitted to change, they require inalterable time and/or content elements to them. Probably ownership/authorship as well. Because otherwise, this becomes an increasingly futile (and frustrating) Quixotic quest.
- schnable 3y agoMy Chevy had a recall out to replace one of the pages in the manual.
- nneonneo 3y agoCheck the whois on the site (appykidsco.com): it's registered to someone in Jiangsu, China, and they seem to own a lot of other domains: https://website.informer.com/email/muskseo1971@gmail.com https://website.informer.com/email/muskseo1971@gmail.com Seems like one of these automated domain-takeover attacks: watch for expiring domains, snap them up the moment they expire, replace them with porn ads, profit.
- colejohnson66 3y agoThe email address is even using Elon Musk's name and birth year