4 ms·
> I think we do have a factual disagreement though, because this is really rare and is largely an access issue. No, it’s a moral dispute because the factual is
by rayiner 3y ago
> I think we do have a factual disagreement though, because this is really rare and is largely an access issue.
No, it’s a moral dispute because the factual issue is immaterial under the other side’s moral view. The fact that it’s hard or expensive to get an abortion doesn’t justify killing a fetus that has a face and can feel pain. Likewise, it doesn’t matter how rare it is. Infanticide in general is rare, that’s not a reason to legalize it at the discretion of the mother.
When it comes to ending human life, we just don’t entertain the kinds of arguments you’re making about “access.” It doesn’t matter. So the crux of the dispute is what you think about the act of killing a fetus at different stages of development. The weight of any reasons for doing so looks completely different depending on that starting point.
> Whenever I find myself in conversation with members of the pro-life community I'm just depressed by the amount of misinformation they labor under
I find myself in the same position when talking with pro-abortion people who think a fetus is a “clump of cells.” I was floored when my wife got pregnant with our first child and I realized how many weeks there were between when the fetus looks human and when Roe allowed states to stop doctors from killing it. Growing up in a pro-abortion area I had never been taught that information.
> in particular the prevailing belief that there are significant numbers of women having abortions in the 2nd and 3rd trimesters "for no good reason".
No, the fundamental issue is that we disagree about what constitutes a “good reason” for a killing a fetus at an advanced stage of development.
> You're even trying to show here that it is the case by pointing out a discrepancy between Canada and Denmark and inferring, but we have clear evidence it isn't.
If you think that the only “good reason” to kill a fetus in the second or third trimester is that the mother’s health is in jeopardy, or that the baby will not live, then the comparison of Denmark and Canada is extremely illuminating. Both countries have widespread abortion access in the first trimester, and both countries allow abortions after 12 weeks for medical reasons. But Canada allows abortions after the first trimester because the woman no longer wishes to be pregnant, while Denmark does not. Canada this has 17% of abortions occurring after the first trimester, while in Denmark it’s just 4%. From the perspective of Danish law, most of the second and third trimester abortions in Canada are not happening for “good reasons” (assuming the probability of later stage medical issues is similar in both countries).
And the “compulsive demagoguery” comment is just bizarre. The scientific fact is that each human individual starts out as a cell that has a good chance of being spontaneously aborted, and develops into a baby that everyone agrees is entitled to all the protections of any other human. Drawing a line where it’s okay to kill an alive, biologically human organism is fraught and is the subject of disputes all over the world. Even countries that have legal abortion don’t agree on the reasons (individual rights in the west, population control in Asia). In my home country it’s illegal except to save the life of the mother. But it’s tacitly accepted as population control for poor people up to 10 weeks. An effort to legalize it for population control reasons failed in 1976. It’s not something the GOP ginned up to get votes FFS.
- camgunz 3y agoYou're saying it's immoral to abort a fetus after the 1st trimester outside of the typical exceptions (assault, life of the birthing person, etc.). I'm saying that almost never happens, and you're saying even so it should still be illegal. I think what you're missing is that it's probably impossible to craft such a prohibition bill that still protects the birthing person, because again the cases where abortions occur after the 1st trimester are innumerable. You can say you don't care, or that you value the fetus more than the birthing person, but I don't think it's useful to equate it with "infanticide... at the discretion of the mother". That's wildly out of bounds here. It's an extremely high stakes, complex issue and both sides deserve respect. I think you need to think through exactly what that regime would look like because, and I'll say it again, we already had it. For some reason you really want there to be a law, but that law wouldn't change the numbers, and it wouldn't have many important exceptions. As a result, women would still seek abortions in unexempted cases (both "good" and "bad"), the same number of overall abortions would happen, all that would change is that more desperate women/girls and caregivers would go to prison, and more desperate women/girls would hurt themselves seeking unsafe abortions. > When it comes to ending human life, we just don’t entertain the kinds of arguments you’re making about “access.” You're missing my point. If you're serious about your position ("we want as many abortions as possible to happen only in the 1st trimester") then you need to dramatically increase the access to abortion in the 1st trimester. That's what you should be all over HN posting about. A draconian abortion ban won't do what you want. > From the perspective of Danish law, most of the second and third trimester abortions in Canada are not happening for “good reasons” Again you're not responding to the facts I've laid out for you. There are lots of other potential reasons for this (access, primarily), and your only evidence for this is your inference, which is no evidence at all. This is a classic post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy, which you're stubbornly making even in the face of other more parsimonious explanations. I don't know why you insist on believing there's a significant population of women out there that are doing this, but you've yet to show any evidence for it.
- camgunz 3y ago> It’s not something the GOP ginned up to get votes FFS. You're wrong on this one. The GOP is unbelievably craven and corrupt. Paul Weyrich (founder of the super successful conservative think tank The Heritage Foundation) explicitly demagogued the abortion issue to activate evangelical voters and create a large conservative voting bloc (with the ultimate end of creating segregated Christian schools) [0]. He wrote about it himself; he's proud of it. [0]: https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/05/religious-right-real-origins-107133/ https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/05/religious-ri...