5 ms·
NYPD will use drones to monitor backyard parties this weekend
- iAMkenough 3y agoWhat are the legal implications for taking down an unidentified drone hovering over your private property?
- bozhark 3y agoWonder how much they differ for physical and non-physical intervention
- sp332 3y agoIf you cause interference that crashes a drone, you'll have the FCC and the FAA up your ass.
- teeray 3y agoWell, since it’s legally an aircraft, it’s a felony
- NoZebra120vClip 3y ago> What are the legal implications https://xkcd.com/1523/ https://xkcd.com/1523/
- officialchicken 3y agoThere are no legal means to take down a drone in NYC. And the implied assumption that the same rules and laws apply to NYPD as the citizens is ridiculous at best.
- lacrimacida 3y agoWhat are the consequence of taking them down though? If they fly low enough even an arrow could do so. If they’re high enough in the air some sort of firearm could do away with it Im thinking… I guess that would equate to shooting at NYPD propery but would a costly investigation be worth it?
- chomp5977 3y agoFiring a weapon in the air is a supremely bad idea. Especially in a city. ESPECIALLY in NYC.
- psunavy03 3y agoIf you're willing to shoot a firearm in the air to take out a drone in a crowded city, you have no business being within arm's reach of any firearm unsupervised, regardless of how old you are.
- lacrimacida 3y agoIm not willing to do so but someone will, and an ingenious person could use a silncer or something that obfuscates their location. While Im impressed with the development of drone tech I don’t think suddently they’re invincible in any way…
- atmavatar 3y ago"I might get caught if I don't use a silencer" is hardly GP's point. Short of using a rail gun, your projectile is unlikely to reach escape velocity.
- omniglottal 3y agoYou don't need "escape velocity", and a suitable PCP can be mail-ordered.
- Nifty3929 3y agoThe penalty is that your life will be turned over, you will give all your money to lawyers, and then you will spend a lot of time in jail.
- jakelazaroff 3y agoHi! I live in NYC too. Please don’t fire a gun into the air! As much as I dislike NYPD surveillance, it’s better than being killed by a falling bullet!
- rolph 3y agolets go fly a kite,,,with a good bit of monofilament in the tail so its sturdy.
- yogurthewise 3y agolol what if you have one of these? Or something equivalent? https://www.thisiswhyimbroke.com/tactical-drone-jammer-gun/ https://www.thisiswhyimbroke.com/tactical-drone-jammer-gun/
- dhx 3y agoI don't think the 50 hawks bred in your backyard can be prosecuted?
- jstarfish 3y agoTraining a bald eagle to take them down would certainly cause some chaos.
- lacrimacida 3y agoI havent thought of that and it’s quite ingenious and hard to prove legally who’s behind it.
- Nifty3929 3y agoThey don’t need to prove anything. They will know it’s the local hawk guy. That person will then sped all his or her money on lawyers, and then spend a long time in jail.
- lacrimacida 3y agoWith this technology flourishing I wouldn’t be surprised seeing more and more hawks as ‘pets’ though. Don’t underestimate the reaction to any abusive tech, the achilles heel may be even easier than that to strike
- uptown 3y agoIt’s been done: https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-europe-35750816 https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-europe-35750816
- tzs 3y agoThere's probably no legal way to do that in the US. Bald eagles (and Golden eagles) have special protection under Federal law which essentially makes having anything to do with them a felony unless you are a zoo or are a Native American using the eagle for religious purposes, and even then you need to get a permit.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xwdv 3y agoYou will end up in Federal Prison with no chance of parole. It is a felony to shoot down aircraft. Do not do it, it’s not cool.
- flangola7 3y agoLegal or not I personally know a number of individuals who would down these without any hesitation. It is on their property and is not a human being: fair game as far as they are concerned.
- Ao7bei3s 3y agoIt is not, in fact, on their property. The airspace belongs to the public. It is ironic that they would deprive others of their property rights in the name of perceived property rights. I would certainly hope for a felony conviction in such a case. I have no sympathy for people who would use weapons to illegally enrich themselves at the expense of others. And by the way, as has been decided this year (though it might yet be appealed) in the Wyoming border crossing case, even using a ladder to cross through the airspace above private lands is not trespassing.
- flangola7 3y agoWho said anything about enrichment? We have a right to privacy and quiet enjoyment. Corporations aren't people, they don't have moral rights. If shooting/netting them down catches on they can't arrest everyone. "Father becomes imprisoned felon for taking down invasive corporate/government drone that spied on their home" will not be a headline that garners sympathy for the drone operator.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoSend in the autonomous bomb-defusing shotgun-wielding robot dogs
- h2odragon 3y agoPaintball rifles? What kinda range do we need? Release a bunch of helium balloons, each trailing as much thread as they can lift. Might just tie a bunch and do a barrage balloon thing as a canopy anyway.
- dmix 3y agoIf Russia<>Ukraine war taught us anything is that you will rarely see or hear the drone that kills you. And UA isn't usually using any high end gear like western police. The rare videos you see of soldiers shooting rifles at them they almost always miss.
- unethical_ban 3y agoI am disgusted by this and think all levers of society, legal and social, should be used to protest and fight against this panopticon evil. I also think it's absurd to think, just yet, that NYPD is going to be using kamikaze drone bombs to take out backyard pits. Where's the fun in that? Cops don't get to crack any heads.
- h2odragon 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1985_MOVE_bombing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1985_MOVE_bombing
- BearhatBeer 3y agoWelcome to City 17 whrrrrrr SNAP
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoAh, greetings fellow person of culture.
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoIt's safer here.
- 71a54xd 3y agoI'm never moving back to New York - this is beyond insane.
- lacrimacida 3y agoComing soon to your area too
- woodruffw 3y agoThe NYPD is a profoundly overfunded police agency[1], as these kinds of technical hijinks indicate. If there are noise complaints, why aren't they knocking on doors? (It's a rhetorical question: the answer is that the NYPD has abject contempt for the communities it ostensibly serves, and increasingly is made of people who don't even live in the city they police[2].) [1]: https://council.nyc.gov/budget/wp-content/uploads/sites/54/2021/03/056-NYPD.pdf https://council.nyc.gov/budget/wp-content/uploads/sites/54/2... [2]: https://nypost.com/2023/06/03/more-nypd-officers-are-opting-to-live-outside-nyc/ https://nypost.com/2023/06/03/more-nypd-officers-are-opting-...
- timcederman 3y agoIt's always fun to ask people how much they think the annual budget for the NYPD might be, and learn they're off by several orders of magnitude.
- khuey 3y agoIt's not really a fair comparison because much of the budget is the cost of labor, but the NYPD's budget is roughly equal to the budget of Ukraine's military (pre-February 2022).
- koonsolo 3y agoWell, NYC has about 8.5 million people. I'm from Flanders and we have about 6.5 million people. 8.5 is about the population of Austria or Switzerland. I think people underestimate how big NYC really is. It is basically a small country. So yeah, how much funds do the police of Austria or Switzerland get?
- Hello71 3y agoaccording to https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/DDN-20170816-1 https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/D..., in 2015, Austria spent €545 per inhabitant on "public order and safety", which includes "Police services; fire-protection services; law courts; prisons; R&D related to public order and safety; public order and safety n.e.c. ". about 9 million people live in Austria, so they spent about €5 million in total. according to https://cbcny.org/research/six-fast-facts-about-nypds-preliminary-fy2023-budget https://cbcny.org/research/six-fast-facts-about-nypds-prelim..., the NYPD budget in 2023 was $10.8 billion. so, NYC spent about twice as much on police as Austria spent on police plus fire protection, law courts, prisons, etc. even if they have the same population, it should cost more to police Austria than NYC because Austria has a larger area, so they need to have more police stations and cars.
- doodlebugging 3y ago>But as the technology proliferates, privacy advocates say regulations have not kept up, opening the door to intrusive surveillance that would be illegal if conducted by a human police officer. Since these drones don't fly themselves and there is a trained officer somewhere at the controls then this surveillance is in fact conducted by a human police officer and should be an illegal violation of privacy. Frankly if one of these things shows up over my backyard while I'm smoking a brisket for my family I'm gonna moon it and make lewd hand gestures.
- edrxty 3y agoThe FAA needs to stop regulating them as manned aircraft so it's not a felony to down them intentionally
- doodlebugging 3y agoI agree. A drone that stays over someone else's private property is their problem. If it is operated from neighboring property as a device to gather information about me when I am on my property then that changes everything. When it is purposely guided over mine then I should have the option to handle it in any way I deem appropriate. Looking into my back yard, which is enclosed by a fence and is therefore not open for public viewing should be a violation of my privacy.
- horsawlarway 3y agoI think the deciding factor is going to be how we define "observable to the public" now that flying cameras on are the table. My sad guess is that the general rule will change to accept things that can see your property from public airspace as "observable to the public", and that eventually building design and landscaping will change to give you private spaces outdoors if you have money and desire.
- doodlebugging 3y agoThis may be how it works out but anyone arguing that an observer flying in an airplane through public airspace has the same opportunity to peer into your private back yard or other areas of your private property is arguing apples and oranges. Most people flying in planes are passengers in transit between two locations with no opportunity to guide the plane to allow them to view specific locations. On the other hand a drone operator has full control of the path the drone takes and can operate it so that it peers into private spaces from public airspace. If a property is marked as private property then that privacy should offer protection from those who would trespass using public airspace.
- unethical_ban 3y agoTime to buy some green lasers, and elect city leaders who will make this more illegal than it already is under the 4th amendment.
- Arrath 3y agoBy all accounts the apparatus is already quite capable of (and practiced at) quickly locating and dispatching officers to the locations from which fools are shining laser pointers at aircraft, so I can't imagine the first part of your statement is a good idea.
- voytec 3y agoOfficer Alex Murphy reporting to duty.
- fny 3y agoCan a lawyer explain why this doesn’t violate unreasonable searches? Why is a warrant not required?
- woodruffw 3y agoIANAL, but it might. As the article mentions, it almost certainly violates NYC laws as well[1]. The NYPD has not historically shown an institutional interest in laws enforced on them, rather than by them. [1]: https://www.nyc.gov/site/nypd/about/about-nypd/policy/post-act.page https://www.nyc.gov/site/nypd/about/about-nypd/policy/post-a...
- robalfonso 3y agoMy feeling would be this does violate the law. The problem is new technology must often go through courts to actually establish the law. So it seems that while the NYPD could decide it’s a no-go, their worse case is to do it, get sued and then let a judge make the call.
- dgrin91 3y ago(1) it's not been tested in courts, so it might not be legal (2) the likely argument from the government would be that open backwards are but subject to the same expectation of privacy as other interior parts of the home. If the cops have a helicopter surveiling your back yard no one says that it's a warrantless search. Why is a drone different? The obvious answer there is levels of scale, but it's an open question if that will hold up to actual legal challenges
- enragedcacti 3y agoThe Supreme Court ruled in Florida v. Riley that the police do not need a warrant to observe an individual's property from public airspace. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_v._Riley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_v._Riley The 5-4 Podcast has an episode covering it and they are not light in their criticism of the court's decision: https://www.fivefourpod.com/episodes/florida-v-riley/ https://www.fivefourpod.com/episodes/florida-v-riley/
- psunavy03 3y agoThe arrogance of the NYC and New York State governments regarding the entire Bill of Rights apparently knows no bounds. This is a stereotypical example of a government which believes its citizens aren't constituents whom they serve, but stupid proles who have to be kept down by their alleged "betters."
- woodruffw 3y agoThere is an almost infinite amount of things to reasonably blame the NYC and NYS governments for, but this doesn't look like one of them (other than in the basic sense of enabling this behavior through budgeting): it's the act of a largely unaccountable police force, rather than a legislative order or rule.
- psunavy03 3y agoThe NYC government, at the very least, is ultimately accountable for the acts of its police department. My NYS comment was a more wide-ranging shot at what happens to individual rights when one political party (red or blue) gets to call the shots. But if the NYPD is really "unaccountable" to the NYC government, well, that seems like a ripe situation for the Feds to step in because the local government has lost control. A PD which isn't accountable to its elected government isn't a PD; it's an armed gang.
- woodruffw 3y ago> But if the NYPD is really "unaccountable" to the NYC government, well, that seems like a ripe situation for the Feds to step in because the local government has lost control. A PD which isn't accountable to its elected government isn't a PD; it's an armed gang. We're in agreement!
- hazmazlaz 3y agoPerhaps you should brush up on your constitutional law, because at least in this one instance the Bill of Rights is entirely being respected. Also consider that for every noise complaint to the police, there is a complainant - a citizen constituent - who is being bothered by a loud party. But let's forget about those people, their rights to reasonable peace and quiet don't matter? I don't agree with that stance.
- zer8k 3y agoStrangely everyone here is suggesting overt attacks on the drone. That will get you put in prison. Rules for thee but not for me is how the police operate. The drone will have an FAA number and it'll become a felony for "shooting down an aircraft". On second thought: Perhaps I should edit this post. LOL.
- foobarian 3y agoI doubt these drones wouldn't just fall back to safe mode and navigate back to base. It would be a lot more fun to build a drone that can drop a net over another drone.
- Ruq 3y agoHypothetically, of course.
- unethical_ban 3y agoI have wanted to learn more about the RF spectrum as it relates to drone control, and how susceptible various brands of drone would be to interference of those frequencies. For research purposes.
- Deprogrammer9 3y agoI'm guessing rich white New Yorkers wont have to worry about drones over their property spying on them. ಠ_ಠ
- mackaway 3y ago[flagged]
- Ancapistani 3y agoThe really abhorrent thing here is how absurdly difficult it is to fly a drone commercially in NYC - and the NYPD is going to fly them at night beyond line of sight.
- 7e 3y agoThe NYPD promises an officer will respond to a noise complaint within 8 hours, and only if there are no other emergencies. That’s a terrible SLA. A drone can probably respond to five calls an hour since it doesn’t get stuck in traffic. Recording a back yard in NYC, where there is no reasonable expectation of privacy (it’s visible from everywhere), from a drone which has probable cause (a complaint) seems perfectly reasonable.