6 ms·
Court rules in Pornhub’s favor: Age-verification law violates First Amendment
- valianteffort 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- boringuser2 3y ago[flagged]
- woodruffw 3y agoIt seems to be entirely possible that someone can simultaneously believe that porn is bad and that the government should have no particular insight into whether you watch it.
- boringuser2 3y ago[flagged]
- bigbillheck 3y ago> most former ones have since moved on Oh if only.
- woodruffw 3y agoI'm not a libertarian. It's just a pointless, wasteful, and manifestly stifling incursion on something that needs social education (much like booze, you're never going to kill porn).
- boringuser2 3y ago[flagged]
- woodruffw 3y agoPlease read comments charitably. This site has rules to that effect. Social education means that the government should commit funds and other resources to educating the public (especially young men) about the un-reality of pornography and its insufficiency as a substitute for normal human intimacy. This is what other developed countries do[1]. Edit: and note: this is an obviously non-libertarian position to hold. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQKPWq38cVY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQKPWq38cVY
- orwin 3y agoI don't watch that much porn anymore, but we still sometimes put a Dorcel (or any 'porn with plot' movie) to get in the mood, especially in winter. I think it's a positive in my sexual life. Anyway, this is clearly government overreach. I'm not against age verification but it has to be an anonymous system. Privacy is worth fighting for.
- woodruffw 3y agoPeople are ostensibly downvoting you because you're baselessly linking porn to "population collapse." Plenty of people think that porn is bad or, more weakly, that it's a mild social ill that requires counter-education to help (mostly) young men understand that porn isn't the same thing as a healthy adult relationship. You can believe these things without catastrophizing.
- valianteffort 3y ago[dead]
- pphysch 3y ago[flagged]
- tennisflyi 3y agoPray tell?
- throwaway5959 3y agoSome people think that because they don’t like the speech of others that those others aren’t entitled to speak. They are wrong.
- prasadjoglekar 3y agoAu contraire, it was Hustler mag that actually pushed the boundaries of what is free speech and defended it all the way to the Supreme Court. This issue is not quite the same, but it's people like these that test and re test free speech limits. https://www.oyez.org/cases/1987/86-1278 https://www.oyez.org/cases/1987/86-1278
- smoldesu 3y agoWhy isn't porn speech?
- pphysch 3y agoWho said that? The issue is that the "Free Speech Coalition" isn't actually about free speech broadly, but has a single-issue focus on empowering the notoriously exploitative pornography industry.
- martin8412 3y agoOn the opposing side you have evangelist Christians claiming to protect children, while they consistently refuse to acknowledge the large amounts of child abuse and exploitation within churches. If you want to protect children, ban them from the churches.
- sashenka 3y ago[dead]
- StevePerkins 3y agoLove wins!
- thaumasiotes 3y agohttps://satwcomic.com/children-will-love-it https://satwcomic.com/children-will-love-it
- zakariya_og 3y ago[flagged]
- woodruffw 3y agoPornhub is a pretty disgusting company[1]. At the same time, this law was manifestly meant to serve as a foot in the door towards increased online surveillance (there is no such thing as "online age verification" for just minors) with the obvious aim of stifling constitutionally protected speech. Seems like a reasonable (and very straightforward) ruling. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornhub#Non-consensual_pornography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornhub#Non-consensual_pornogr...
- darkclouds 3y agoSurely its just publicly documenting criminal acts for law enforcement purposes when looking at data privacy laws like EU GDPR? Mind you, when will the legal system admit it non-consensually forces itself onto people from the day one is born? I wonder who does more harm especially as we are supposed to live in a democracy where we can pick and choose our politicians and thus legislators, and yet the state doesn't teach law to people in a tldr way. The legal system is certainly dictatorial in a fascist dictator way, so does that make law abiding citizens little fascist dictators, who use a mere transgression of the law, to unload their pent up frustration of violence on those around them? I will say this, the US constitution is so vague, its barely worth repeating let along harping back to for court cases. Time to update the constitution for the 21st century, unless it should be viewed simply as a tldr in todays modern times?
- deprecative 3y agoIf we updated the constitution then we'd have slavery back in effect and there would be no separation of church and state.
- hnfong 3y agoWithout "updates" you wouldn't even have the First Amendment...
- deprecative 3y agoThe processes via which we update that Constitution. I wasn't speaking to historically I mean now. We cannot get amendments ratified through the normal Congress + States approach. We'd have to do the whole Constitutional Convention thing. That opens the entire Constitution up for changing. If that happens, because land means more than people, we'd have the chucklefuck brother-husbands in charge of the process.
- thsksbd 3y agoIf the state can impose tough restrictions on a right, including criminal and age limitations for one enumerated constitutional right (the second) why can't it impose it for the first?
- tzs 3y agoIt can impose limits for the First. This particular attempt to do so was found to be unconstitutional because the details of the limits it imposed were, according to the court, much too broad. Generally to impose limits on a Constitutional right there has to be some legitimate compelling state interest to justify it and the limits have to be narrowly tailored to avoid limiting the right more than is necessary for that. More details in the court's decision, which is linked to in the article. The court goes into great detail to explain what is allowed and how the Texas law goes beyond that.
- thsksbd 3y agoI don't see why the same restrictions to buy a firearm shouldn't apply to pornography, namely: - ID required - a half hour or more background check by a licensed dealer - while it can be purchased online, said dealer must physically be present to hand possession of the material - A prohibition to certain material, country wide - individual states impose further restrictions on the material. Im sorry, but just as I see no reason why an 11 year old should walk out of a store with a firearm, I also dont see a compelling reason why an 11 year old (the average age of a first time porn user) should freely be allowed to watch a woman be savagely sodomized by a group of men as is the case on a typical porn site's homepage. EDIT: Oh, and states should be allowed to make databases of porn consumer's preferences and habitually leak them for their neighbors to know, just like NY did
- voakbasda 3y agoGiven your edit, I can’t quite tell if the rest of your comment is meant to be satirical or not. Anyway, I would argue that many of those sorts of restrictions on the second amendment are themselves grossly unconstitutional and should be overturned by the courts.
- playday 3y ago[flagged]
- zakariya_og 3y ago[flagged]
- f33d5173 3y ago>There are viable and constitutional means to achieve Texas’s goal What do they have in mind, I wonder?
- defrost 3y agoWhy wonder when the full statement by the court is linked? https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172751222/gov.uscourts.txwd.1172751222.36.0.pdf https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.11... eg: One alternative the court discusses (page 43) is: Plaintiffs propose adult controls on children’s devices, many of which already exist and can be readily set up. This “content filtering” is effectively the modern version of “blocking and filtering software” that the Supreme Court proposed as a viable alternative in Ashcroft v. ACLU. 542 U.S. at 666–73. Blocking and filtering software is less restrictive because adults may access information without having to identify themselves. And the Court agreed with the finding that “filters are more effective than age-verification requirements.”
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- yieldcrv 3y ago> There are viable and constitutional means to achieve Texas’s goal, and nothing in this order prevents the state from pursuing those means. This is the correct way to appeal to authority. Being willing to notice that the authority, or a different authority, can achieve the same goals in a different way, no matter how it makes you feel to have that discussion or train of thought.
- oblib 3y agoThe article reports the Texas law said "pornography sites would have been forced to display a “Texas Health and Human Services Warning” in at least 14-point font — one such warning was specified to read, “Pornography increases the demand for prostitution, child exploitation, and child pornography” I not sure I can believe all that. I do believe porm can be addictive for some folks because I knew a guy who had barrels full of hard core porn magazines at his metal fabrication shop in Hollywood when I was young teen in the 70s. He must've had 1000s of them. I'm not at all convinced that it "increases the demand for prostitution, child exploitation, and child pornography” though. With the few exceptions for prostitution all of that is already illegal in most places here in the U.S. and has been long before porn on the web became a thing, and "child pornography" has always been a crime. I don't think a "warning" like that on porn sites will change any of that at all. It's nothing more than political bullshit.
- jstarfish 3y ago> I not sure I can believe all that. I do believe porm can be addictive for some folks because I knew a guy who had barrels full of hard core porn magazines at his metal fabrication shop in Hollywood when I was young teen in the 70s. He must've had 1000s of them. There is a massive difference in the content and consumption rate of your guy with the barrels versus the average 18 year old. It took him years to amass that much, and I doubt he consumed them all. Each one cost a few bucks, and he had to physically go to some seedy adult shop to buy them. There was friction involved in his "addiction" (if it's even that; some people are just collectors/hoarders). Today, you can pull up infinite-scrolling pages and HD video of just about anything without leaving the house, for free. Your consumption ability is limited only by your penis not being torn to bloody shreds. Porn exists that breaks the fourth wall and directs the viewer to do everything from watching more porn, to consuming your own effluent, all the way to conditioning you to renounce your sexual orientation and getting a sex change. Something is different these days, and it doesn't appear to be a net positive, considering the suicide statistics. Recovering and reviewing browser histories is a function of my day job; in my experience, escalation is real, but I do have to admit bias in that the instances I see are almost always suspected to be exploitation cases to begin with. It sounds absurd that someone could start with Playboy and end at CSAM but it does happen over the course of years, to people who consume porn like the rest of us eat, drink, socialize with friends and converse with our families. It becomes an entire lifestyle unto itself. One case literally saw the guy progress from porn to nudism to swinging with his wife, then to him looking for rub-and-tugs (post-divorce), gay, then trans escorts (not judgment-- neither were available during his swinging phase due to known intolerance of both within that community), and then he was outed by a Chris Hansen-type when he attempted to meet a child for sex. Depression and a hypersexual lifestyle don't lend themselves to rational thought. This guy wasn't even gay or a pedophile (no previous history by any account, nor any CSAM artifacts I discovered), but as his timeline documented his downfall, it screamed desperation (at one point he did seek mental health treatment, failed to find it, and consoled himself with...porn. A therapist will see you for an hour next month. Porn is always there for you.). The "child" in this case, he didn't even seek out-- they approached him on a popular hookup app; he was desperate enough that he attempted to pursue the opportunity. (Yes, this was entrapment; no, he wasn't prosecuted-- but his family and friends were blasted with the footage.) You may deny the possibility because you haven't walked that path and never will-- good for you and godspeed. Inasmuch as porn can be an addiction (apparently this is up for debate?), there are high-functioning users, and there are total fucking trainwrecks. The latter are prone to progressively-increasing usage, at higher doses, escalating to eventual "overdose" when nothing does the job anymore. I'd attest the same thing with drug users happens here, because it's less about the vice itself and more about chasing diminishing returns of dopamine and the methods by which they are obtained. This isn't a porn-exclusive problem, but I do think in the context of porn there are some unfortunate side effects because of its private nature and low cost of consumption-- you can only hide gambling losses or excessive drug use for so long. With porn, there's an unusual danger in that it may take an arrest involving public humiliation, harassment and battery before you even know you have a problem-- because insight into your porn usage is necessarily concealed from anyone inclined to help you. Someone could have helped the guy above...if they knew he was struggling, and what with. That said, I don't agree with Texas' approach--they're being too extreme--but try to keep an open mind. Porn obviously doesn't lead to these outcomes for most users, and it's fucked for Texas to assert that it does. The truth is found somewhere in the middle, between your own opinion and that of the state of Texas. In my experience, for some people, it really can be as bad as Texas claims.
- zakariya_og 3y ago[flagged]
- kashunstva 3y agoIt’s unlikely there are many here are advocating for porn per se; instead, they are advocating for a particular right in the US Constitution. Even there, it’s a nuanced discussion. But it’s one that is completely short-circuited by ad hominem comments such as this. Say what you will about the state of the judiciary in the US but there remains a rule of law; and restrictions to rights have to be based in something more than preferences, no matter how sincerely held.
- decremental 3y ago[flagged]
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]