3 ms·
I tend to agree. I consider myself an environmentalist, and I've also come to recognize that these issues can be complicated. Progress is made iteratively and
by freedomben 3y ago
I tend to agree. I consider myself an environmentalist, and I've also come to recognize that these issues can be complicated. Progress is made iteratively and sometimes gradually. While I would love to drop a hammer on the over-fishing of Pacific Salmon for example, when you meet a person who lives in Homer Alaska and lives off of their fishing and you realize that if we completely shut down fishing for a year or two, that person would be economically destroyed. That's just one person in the equation. There are many thousands more. There are ways to improve the salmon population without wiping people out or causing major havoc, but it requires people to learn a whole lot more about the issues than what can be reduced to sound bytes.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoThe flip side of this is easily illustrated: Look up the North Atlantic Cod Fishery. We failed to tell fishermen to stop fishing, and as a result the entire ecosystem collapsed and has never returned. They had to stop fishing anyway, and their way of life collapsed too. Its a tricky reality to balance, but the fishing industry have historically always gotten this wrong. At a certain point you have to be willing to tell people that their way of life is unsustainable. Of course, then we have to recognize that most of us live an unsustainable way of life, fishermen just happen to be living unsustainably in a shorter term than the rest of us.
- freedomben 3y agoAbsolutely, completely agree. The fishing industry has demonstrated extensively that they can't be trusted to self-manage (North Atlantic Cod, and Pacific Salmon are great examples). The appeal of over-fishing for short term gains at the cost of long-term is just too good for them to refuse, and they will take what they can. Normalcy bias[1] (which they come by honestly as humans) will do it's thing and convince them that a little bit won't hurt, or it will never disappear, or whatever it needs to. Whatever the solution is, it will definitely include reductions in fishing allowances, and that's going to hurt for producers and consumers alike, but it still has to be done. If we don't, in 5 to 10 years they'll be changing jobs anyway cause the fish will be gone and the ecosystem devastated. The trick isn't to avoid all suffering, that's just not possible. The trick is (IMHO) to first understand it, then minimize it. Homer Alaska guy will have to accept reduced income for at least a few years until the population rebounds. In the end, at least his business, home, and way of life aren't completely destroyed. I don't know how we establish/create an independent and reasonable regulator to manage limits, but that's what we need to figure out. The existing entities are too corrupt and have proven that they can't be trusted. On the flip side, some environmental groups are too extreme and also not trustworthy regulators. It's a very hard and complex problem. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normalcy_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normalcy_bias
- rob74 3y agoYour sentence can be generalized: "The appeal of [over-exploiting natural resources] for short term gains at the cost of long-term is just too good [...] to refuse". But, as with overfishing, the bill is eventually coming...
- poulsbohemian 3y agoI may regret making this comparison, but bear with me here... the thinking person realizes that the terms "pro-life" and "pro-choice" are in no way an accurate reflection of two camps on that issue. In the same way, what's clear to me is that dams are not anti-salmon, despite the common political portrayal that dams == dead salmon, no dams == return of the salmon. Could the fish (not just salmon, but also lampreys, sturgeon, trout, etc...) do better without dams? Sure, possibly, but let's not overlook that these dams also employ technology to cool the water to counter climate effects. And, the rate of fish through the dams is pretty darn amazing -- 95+% will survive their up /down journey. So I'm with you - we all have to study and look at the big picture and try to reign in the various political forces that may not be acting with cool heads (on all sides of the equation).
- bobthepanda 3y agoThe issue with fish ladders is not that they kill fishes, actively. The issue is that fish just don't really go back up fish ladders at dam, with the rates estimated as low as 3%. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fish_ladder#Effectiveness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fish_ladder#Effectiveness
- tlow 3y agoAnother issue with dams and ladders for that matter is that they significantly lengthen the journey time. Additionally protected marine mammals take advantage of the backlog of these blockages and consume significantly more fish as they have no quick escape.
- briffle 3y agoThese dams don’t have fish ladders, and retrofitting them would cost astronomical amounts more than they could recover by selling the power.
- deepfriedchokes 3y agoJobs should not come before the environment. Humans can easily adapt. The environment less so.
- WJW 3y agoYou say "humans can easily adapt", but some of these families have been in the fishery trade for generations and would rather give up their religion than being forced to live on land like a normie. This is absolutely not something they will willingly do. If you've ever tried telling an Evangelical that taking this whole Jesus thing so seriously is maybe not the best idea for humanity then you know what I mean.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThat’s a weird statement. The environment does easily adapt, but in ways that humans might not be able to adapt to. When we talk about ecosystems and climate and such, we talk about maintaining them for our own interests (so not shooting ourselves in the foot making a bad trade off). At the end of the day, the Earth will adapt to anything, and a few million years after humans have gone extinct, there will hardly be any trace that we ever existed.
- sneak 3y agoI have no dog in this race, but couldn't you make the same argument for whaling?